• 0

Technical drawbacks of using a VM ? Are there any ?


Question

Hi all, I have a bunch of Linux Distros Im wanting to test out, and also the CP of Windows 8. I know its not practical to Partition and its Time Costly using Live CDs; so, my question is, if I was to run VBox or VMWare to run the ISOs in, what are the drawbacks of not using "native" hardware ? I understand that there may be speed issues but what other quirks should I know about before I begin ? Also, as I said, Im planning on using VBox and the 30day Trial of VMWare, is there any Distro ( and Win8 ) that will run better in one and not the other ?

Many Thanks in advance for your wise words :)

11 answers to this question

Recommended Posts

  • 0

I had no luck running the W8 preview with VirtualBox, although apparently others have had no problems. Anyway, if you'll just be testing operating systems you don't need any VMWare trial, VMWare Player is free and enough for what you need.

Drawbacks? Well, just bear in mind that what the guest OS sees is not the real hardware. After installing the VMWare/VBox guest tools everything should work fine, but you'll likely still find that HW acceleration performance is a bit crappy and sound might not work great.

  • 0

There aren't any "quirks" in virtualization hence it's widespread use everywhere from data centers to small business. Certainly while demo'ing software, virtualization shines. The only drawbacks you'd encounter are with older processors that don't have the latest virtualization instructions. Also, dedicated graphics support is very limited still in any virtulization software but VMware Workstation is best.

  • 0
  On 08/05/2012 at 16:28, TW.4T said:

Hi all, I have a bunch of Linux Distros Im wanting to test out, and also the CP of Windows 8. I know its not practical to Partition and its Time Costly using Live CDs; so, my question is, if I was to run VBox or VMWare to run the ISOs in, what are the drawbacks of not using "native" hardware ?

Live CDs are great, but they can be limited still. If you're using a virtual machine, it'd be better to install the actual OS and check for updates. Sounds more like you don't want to reboot and be without Windows/internet while you play around with them rather then needing a VM.

  On 08/05/2012 at 16:28, TW.4T said:

I understand that there may be speed issues but what other quirks should I know about before I begin ?

If your CPU supports virtualisation, the guest OS should run at near full speed. What you really need to be aware of is the lack of hardware support from the guest OS. ie Drivers, and that'll be your biggest issue with speed.

  On 08/05/2012 at 16:28, TW.4T said:

Also, as I said, Im planning on using VBox and the 30day Trial of VMWare, is there any Distro ( and Win8 ) that will run better in one and not the other ?

VMware is better supported across more Guest OS, however, vbox, if it works for what you want is just as good. I'd try to go with VMWare if you can.. but it really depends what you want to do with them after you've played around with the OSs.

  • 0

There is no 3d graphics acceleration available as of now in both VMware and virtualbox for Linux distros! So, that's the foremost problem you are going to face if you need to test or run graphic intensive applications!

Other than that, everything should run fine and dandy!

  • 0

The main drawbacks...That I have seen.

Limitations are based upon the Host OS (speed and number of processors), amount of memory you can spare to the VM.

VM does not have direct access to special features of hardware (such as video cards)- most use a generic video render (some use the S-3 trident) So basically it is software based render which is a bit slower. (but then again it would be just like using an onboard video and only limit is how much memory you can spare from the allotment for the VM to use for video memory.)

Bottom line -- only drawback is if you like a lot of eye-candy and would want to play a game it may have a big drawback. For what they are designed for they work perfectly.

  • 0

There aren't any disadvantage apart from the performance at least for personal use.

One thing i Have noticed is if you use laptop your battery capacity goes down drastically when using linux(with Ubuntu).

Maybe it was just me but wanted to give a heads up.

This topic is now closed to further replies.
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Posts

    • UK considers forcing Google to add competitor search options by David Uzondu Regulators are not playing around with Google this year. Just this April, we saw Japan take formal action against the company over Android phones, accusing the tech giant of forcing manufacturers to preinstall its search and browser apps. Now, the United Kingdom's antitrust watchdog is adding to the pressure with its own set of demands that could significantly alter how people use Google's products. The UK's Competition and Markets Authority, or CMA, wants to let users in the UK decide for themselves which search engine to use. This would come in the form of so-called "choice screens" that would appear when someone uses the Chrome browser or an Android device for the first time. In practice, this means offering a menu of different search providers, potentially even including AI assistants like ChatGPT, giving people a real opportunity to switch away from Google's default setting. To make this happen, the watchdog plans to slap Google with a special "strategic market status" designation, which means the agency gets new powers to impose very specific changes on how Google operates. The CMA is proposing this under new digital market rules designed specifically to rein in the power of large tech companies. A final decision on whether to officially give Google this label is expected by October 13. This fight over search and browser defaults is arguably more intense back home in the US, where the company is facing the possibility of having to sell off Chrome entirely after a landmark court ruling on monopoly grounds. You can bet OpenAI is very interested in that outcome, as its executives have said they would consider buying the browser if Google were ever forced to part with it. The CMA also has a few other changes in mind if its new status for Google goes through. The agency wants to ensure the company's search rankings are fair and do not unfairly penalize rivals. It also wants to give news publishers more transparency and control over how Google uses their articles and other content to train its AI models and generate those AI summaries you now see at the top of search results. Finally, the CMA is pushing for rules that would let people easily transfer their personal data, like their entire search history, to another company if they choose. According to AP News, Google sees the CMA's announcement as presenting "clear challenges" to its business in the UK. Oliver Bethell, a competition director at the company, also hinted that such strict regulations could even lead Google to delay the release of new products and features in the UK.
    • The Tick Tock of development, Hire, Fire, Rehire, Fire. Keeps the wages low and allows contract changes. I expect with AI here that will replace a tone of R&D with things like art concepts. Coding also will take a hit when the human will be the AI code checker and prompt basher. Instead of 100 programmers you can just have 2 overlooking generated code and tweaking if needed.
    • That will be an interesting comparison. My guess is that the B580 will be the more powerful card, but due to less mature game support, may be slower in some titles. Right now, the B580 is a great budget option, but when it is the same price as the RTX 5050, I suspect many users will opt for the NVidia option if it is their choice. However, a lot of OEM systems are using the B580, so users who barely understand what a dGPU is, are probably going to be using the B580.
    • Google Earth is now 20 years old, brings historical Street View imagery by Aditya Tiwari Google is no longer a young company, and many of its products have been in existence for over two decades. Its "not an April Fools joke" email service turned 21 earlier this year, and now, Google Earth is celebrating its 20th birthday. The search giant announced that Google Earth is getting historical Street View imagery to celebrate the milestone. "Now, you can access historical Street View imagery right from Google Earth — and if you use Google Earth in a professional capacity, you can easily access new datasets, like tree canopy coverage for cities, land temperatures and more," Google said in a blog post. Google Earth is well-known for offering many internet users an interactive bird's-eye view of the world at a time when mapping apps weren't as advanced. It was launched in June 2005 and features 3D buildings across major US cities, integrated local search, and 3D terrains showing mountains, valleys, and canyons around the world. Users could activate, tilt, and rotate 3D terrain for a different perspective of a location. It was an instant hit after launch, with over 100 million downloads in its first week. Just months later, Google worked with the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) to make updated imagery available to first responders battling Hurricane Katrina. However, the tech that powers Google Earth is a bit older than that. It was initially developed as Earth Viewer by Keyhole Inc., which Google acquired in 2004 and later rebranded. Now accessible via web browsers and mobile apps, Google Earth was initially available as free-to-download desktop software for Windows, Mac, and Linux. The company also offered Google Earth Pro for $399 per year, but it was later made available for free. Google Earth in 2005 Google Earth differs from Google Maps, which also debuted in 2005. While Google Earth is more focused on exploration and research, its sibling is inclined towards finding real-time information and navigation. Google Earth is known for the flying animation that appears when you go from one place to another. Not just the Earth's surface, you can also explore the ocean floor, the Moon, and Mars (via desktop app). The virtual globe app has been used to discover a rare type of coral reef off the west coast of Australia, often referred to as "the rainforest of the sea." The 2016 movie Lion told the story of a man who used Google Earth to reunite with his mother 25 years after he got separated from his family. Google Earth has seen several new features over the past two decades, including VR support, distance measuring support, the ability to create virtual tours, and Timelapse. In 2017, the 'new Google Earth' added the "I'm Feeling Lucky" button and a discovery-focused feature called Voyager. Another redesign introduced in 2023 allows professionals to evaluate building and solar design options. A feature introduced last year allows users to view historical aerial imagery of places dating back up to 80 years.
  • Recent Achievements

    • Week One Done
      Sharon dixon earned a badge
      Week One Done
    • Dedicated
      Parallax Abstraction earned a badge
      Dedicated
    • First Post
      956400 earned a badge
      First Post
    • Week One Done
      davidfegan earned a badge
      Week One Done
    • First Post
      Ainajohn earned a badge
      First Post
  • Popular Contributors

    1. 1
      +primortal
      595
    2. 2
      ATLien_0
      223
    3. 3
      Michael Scrip
      169
    4. 4
      +FloatingFatMan
      151
    5. 5
      Som
      136
  • Tell a friend

    Love Neowin? Tell a friend!