• 0

Technical drawbacks of using a VM ? Are there any ?


Question

Hi all, I have a bunch of Linux Distros Im wanting to test out, and also the CP of Windows 8. I know its not practical to Partition and its Time Costly using Live CDs; so, my question is, if I was to run VBox or VMWare to run the ISOs in, what are the drawbacks of not using "native" hardware ? I understand that there may be speed issues but what other quirks should I know about before I begin ? Also, as I said, Im planning on using VBox and the 30day Trial of VMWare, is there any Distro ( and Win8 ) that will run better in one and not the other ?

Many Thanks in advance for your wise words :)

11 answers to this question

Recommended Posts

  • 0

I had no luck running the W8 preview with VirtualBox, although apparently others have had no problems. Anyway, if you'll just be testing operating systems you don't need any VMWare trial, VMWare Player is free and enough for what you need.

Drawbacks? Well, just bear in mind that what the guest OS sees is not the real hardware. After installing the VMWare/VBox guest tools everything should work fine, but you'll likely still find that HW acceleration performance is a bit crappy and sound might not work great.

  • 0

There aren't any "quirks" in virtualization hence it's widespread use everywhere from data centers to small business. Certainly while demo'ing software, virtualization shines. The only drawbacks you'd encounter are with older processors that don't have the latest virtualization instructions. Also, dedicated graphics support is very limited still in any virtulization software but VMware Workstation is best.

  • 0
  On 08/05/2012 at 16:28, TW.4T said:

Hi all, I have a bunch of Linux Distros Im wanting to test out, and also the CP of Windows 8. I know its not practical to Partition and its Time Costly using Live CDs; so, my question is, if I was to run VBox or VMWare to run the ISOs in, what are the drawbacks of not using "native" hardware ?

Live CDs are great, but they can be limited still. If you're using a virtual machine, it'd be better to install the actual OS and check for updates. Sounds more like you don't want to reboot and be without Windows/internet while you play around with them rather then needing a VM.

  On 08/05/2012 at 16:28, TW.4T said:

I understand that there may be speed issues but what other quirks should I know about before I begin ?

If your CPU supports virtualisation, the guest OS should run at near full speed. What you really need to be aware of is the lack of hardware support from the guest OS. ie Drivers, and that'll be your biggest issue with speed.

  On 08/05/2012 at 16:28, TW.4T said:

Also, as I said, Im planning on using VBox and the 30day Trial of VMWare, is there any Distro ( and Win8 ) that will run better in one and not the other ?

VMware is better supported across more Guest OS, however, vbox, if it works for what you want is just as good. I'd try to go with VMWare if you can.. but it really depends what you want to do with them after you've played around with the OSs.

  • 0

There is no 3d graphics acceleration available as of now in both VMware and virtualbox for Linux distros! So, that's the foremost problem you are going to face if you need to test or run graphic intensive applications!

Other than that, everything should run fine and dandy!

  • 0

The main drawbacks...That I have seen.

Limitations are based upon the Host OS (speed and number of processors), amount of memory you can spare to the VM.

VM does not have direct access to special features of hardware (such as video cards)- most use a generic video render (some use the S-3 trident) So basically it is software based render which is a bit slower. (but then again it would be just like using an onboard video and only limit is how much memory you can spare from the allotment for the VM to use for video memory.)

Bottom line -- only drawback is if you like a lot of eye-candy and would want to play a game it may have a big drawback. For what they are designed for they work perfectly.

  • 0

There aren't any disadvantage apart from the performance at least for personal use.

One thing i Have noticed is if you use laptop your battery capacity goes down drastically when using linux(with Ubuntu).

Maybe it was just me but wanted to give a heads up.

This topic is now closed to further replies.
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Posts

    • AS data is written to 1 disk its also written to the other disk in the raid pool. RAID - Wikipedia
    • Its still there, but annoyingly you have to left click the word now and not right click as many millions of peoples muscle memory are quickly finding out.
    • Their initial offerings (AV) were fine, but then there was just absolute stagnation and they had no idea what to do with themselves so they created solutions to problems that really didn't exist, convinced users they did but then realised nobody was buying into it, so bundled their bloated crap with OEM builds. Arguably, the whole AV market got a bad name with end consumers for a period because of companies such as Norton.
    • Windows Server 2025 security baseline to get more frequent updates, streamlines settings by Paul Hill Microsoft has announced the release of the June 2025 revision of its security baseline package for Windows Server 2025 (v2506), it is now available to download from the Microsoft Security Compliance Toolkit. After downloading it, you can test the recommended configurations in your environment and customize or implement them as you see fit. To deal with the evolving threat landscape, new Windows features, and community feedback, Microsoft is planning to revise the Windows Server baseline more frequently in the future. Windows Server security baselines are a collection of Microsoft-recommended configuration settings that help administrators establish secure and consistent Windows Server environments. This is the first security baseline update for Windows Server 2025 since January, a summary of the changes is presented in this table: Security Policy Change Summary Deny log on through Remote Desktop Services Allow remote logon for non-admin local accounts on MS and add “BUILTIN\Guests” to both DC and MS. WDigest Authentication Remove from the baseline Allow Windows Ink Workspace Remove from the baseline Audit Authorization Policy Change Set to “Success” in both DC and MS Include command line in process creation events Enable in both DC and MS Control whether exclusions are visible to local users Moved to Not Configured as it is overridden by the parent setting. Of these changes, the removal of WDigest Authentication and the addition of Include command line in process creation events are significant. Microsoft said it removed WDigest Authentication from the security baseline because it is no longer necessary for Windows Server 2025. The policy was originally enforced so that WDigest couldn’t store plaintext passwords in memory, which was a significant theft risk. Since the 24H2 update in Windows Server 2022, the policy has been deprecated, so there’s no need to enforce this setting. The update also adds Include command line in process creation events to improve the visibility of how processes are executed across the system. By capturing the command-line arguments, it makes it easier to detect and investigate malicious activity that may otherwise seem legitimate. If you want to learn more about the other changes in a bit more depth, refer to Microsoft’s announcement of this security baseline update.
  • Recent Achievements

    • One Month Later
      Leonard grant earned a badge
      One Month Later
    • Week One Done
      pcdoctorsnet earned a badge
      Week One Done
    • Rising Star
      Phillip0web went up a rank
      Rising Star
    • One Month Later
      Epaminombas earned a badge
      One Month Later
    • One Year In
      Bert Fershner earned a badge
      One Year In
  • Popular Contributors

    1. 1
      +primortal
      537
    2. 2
      ATLien_0
      205
    3. 3
      +FloatingFatMan
      167
    4. 4
      Michael Scrip
      151
    5. 5
      Som
      127
  • Tell a friend

    Love Neowin? Tell a friend!