Recommended Posts

I feel Microsoft may be shooting themselves in the foot with Surface. Whilst I think the product itself is pretty awesome, the marketing decisions behind it so far have been abysmal. First the idea to only sell it in Microsoft stores even in Europe, that failed. Then they got an exclusive with John Lewis, again fail.

Now with the Surface Pro, they're releasing it in the US & Canada for sale today. How about if they released it worldwide today, how about if they didn't release it today but released it a month on from now and they were able to release it worldwide? How many more sales would that get? I'd say a few million more because the marketing can be targeted everywhere, at the same time.

Are we going to see another Zune? Good product, fail marketing? Perhaps.

Link to comment
https://www.neowin.net/forum/topic/1135620-surface-doomed/
Share on other sites

It's going to be a bumpy start for Microsoft, I think, and that isn't going to help them try to win the crowd's support of Windows 8. But is the Surface doomed because of that? I don't think so.

It's doomed because it's marketed by Microsoft. The only thing they've nailed are Windows and Office. Both of which lately have also been suffering from an abysmal marketing campaign. Surface and Windows Phone are only held in high regard by geeks or people that know geeks. The general public couldn't care less.

I think the Surface Pro is an amazing device that in time with better battery, will be almost perfect. I'd love to use one of them when on a photoshoot for example and I'd like to see my shots and use Bulb exposures with my SLR tethered

It's going to be a bumpy start for Microsoft, I think, and that isn't going to help them try to win the crowd's support of Windows 8. But is the Surface doomed because of that? I don't think so.

Surface Pro is going to do very well in the Enterprise. I think in the consumer space, Microsoft's ridiculously bad Music App, lack of syncing middleware (iTunes/Zune equivalent), have already doomed it with consumers. In the Enterprise it may actually help drive Windows 8 deployment. One area that may cause issues in the Enterprise, is the Modern UI search. That back and forth from Modern UI to Desktop environment when using search results plus it's overall clumsiness is not going to be a positive enterprise experience IMO. But the Surface Pro will do well as should form factors like the Yoga. They will be a successful Enterprise products where laptops were once purchased.

I'm on the fence about the Surface. It's an amazing product but Microsoft has shot themselves in the foot every way they turn with this product, and it's really pricey for the average user. It probably isn't doomed but I can't see it being a major seller.

there also Microsoft mis-campaign that keep telling to the masses:

"Tablet = PC and PC = Tablet"

With current Surface (pro) pricing masses will compare Surface (pro) with Laptop (PC),

and will find the fact that Laptop (PC) is:

- more powerful,

- flexible,

- can do anything that Surface Pro can do,

- AND cheaper than Surface (pro).

  • Like 2

A lot of times these days they used "sold out" as a marketing ploy.

you have zero proof. people seem to make stuff up to suit whatever it is theyre trying to portray.

retailers sold out. Microsoft stores sold out. Microsoft online sold out, and there were long lines up outsides the stores. thats fact. Doomed?

you have zero proof. people seem to make stuff up to suit whatever it is theyre trying to portray.

retailers sold out. Microsoft stores sold out. Microsoft online sold out, and there were long lines up outsides the stores. thats fact. Doomed?

Oh, I'm done said I didn't think it was doomed in a post above. I've said it was a amazing product. I am not a hater. But you have no proof of how many they had on the shelves to sell. Wal-Mart has 5 or 10 of each product they have to sell on Black Friday for major sales attraction and they sell out too. That means nothing to me. Give me some sales figures Microsoft.

you have zero proof. people seem to make stuff up to suit whatever it is theyre trying to portray.

retailers sold out. Microsoft stores sold out. Microsoft online sold out, and there were long lines up outsides the stores. thats fact. Doomed?

How would anyone ever have proof of this? Company use every tactic they can to draw attention to their products and not having a sell out on launch will get you less press coverage in the days immediately following launch. With that pressure in place it is reasonable to assume that MS shipped a small number at launch to ensure this could happen.

It would be reasonable for the inverse to be proven, which is what people usually expect. The rebuttal to this is usually with confirmed sales numbers that show they shipped more than expected and still sold out.

How would anyone ever have proof of this?

exactly, therefore don't use it as a possible explanation for why things aren't going your way. its like also saying maybe Steve Ballmer bought all those tablets himself to make the sales look good. Or all those people in line were paid to stand in line.

And you want sales figures? So people can do the same with their BS exaplanations like when they got the windows 8 sales figures?

This is a first gen release of a new piece of hardware from MS it was always going to be a bumpy start - as any first gen device usually is - but the era of the Tablet PC has returned, windows and Tablet PCs arent going anywhere. I have a good feeling MS will take the lessons learned from the this launch, development and teaming that up with the power of Haswell or (a third way) Bayfield / Temash we are going to have some great gen 2 surface products.

Point being, this is just the start of the surface story. Click in and stay tuned.

Surface Pro is going to do very well in the Enterprise. I think in the consumer space, Microsoft's ridiculously bad Music App, lack of syncing middleware (iTunes/Zune equivalent), have already doomed it with consumers. In the Enterprise it may actually help drive Windows 8 deployment. One area that may cause issues in the Enterprise, is the Modern UI search. That back and forth from Modern UI to Desktop environment when using search results plus it's overall clumsiness is not going to be a positive enterprise experience IMO. But the Surface Pro will do well as should form factors like the Yoga. They will be a successful Enterprise products where laptops were once purchased.

This.

I happen to know the mobility division of my IT department at work, which is an enterprise customer with over 10,000 employees (this is just one division of the entire corporation), had a full day meeting with Microsoft directly two weeks ago in New York City. The meeting was all about the Surface Pro. The rumors from that meeting are Surface Pro's are going to be picked up for a pilot over the next couple of months.

Although the home office also uses them, currently the sales force of approximately 2600 salesmen use the iPad. I know our IT department would love for nothing more then to be able to switch to a Microsoft based tablet. The Surface Pro could be that tablet. So could the Lenevo IdeaPad. Or maybe there is something else out there. The bottom line is the iPad has infiltrated WIndows based infrastructures in corporate america as they are appealing for mobile sales forces, and although many IT departments have done what they have needed to do in order to implement the iPad into their networks and systems, they are not happy about it. So once a capable Windows based tablet comes out and proves itself, I believe they will be adopted.

I happen to know the mobility division of my IT department at work, which is an enterprise customer with over 10,000 employees (this is just one division of the entire corporation), had a full day meeting with Microsoft directly two weeks ago in New York City. The meeting was all about the Surface Pro. The rumors from that meeting are Surface Pro's are going to be picked up for a pilot over the next couple of months.

No surprise there - the geeks in your company want to get a free surface pro to play with.

Next big "no" surprise, they will find it is no benefit in the enterprise and won't be considered for deployment.

I'm not a hater, but it's hard to argue counterpoints that I totally agree with from the consumers. I understand why Microsoft is making certain moves, but customers have rolled their eyes when they find out they're paying more for the Surface "Pro" which doesn't include Office or a keyboard.

Just my input from what I've seen at work today.

Incorrect. The lack of a start menu works great on a tablet.

man...I hate this argument. there is a start menu, it's just now it takes up the whole screen. I know this wasn't what you were saying, just hate hearing it continuously.

anyhoo, I'm replying to this on a surface RT, and I have to say I love it. really not interested in taking x86 on the go with me. battery life, and the office apps, plus a citrix receiver suit me just fine.

personally I don't think surface I doomed at all, think they'll do just fine.

This topic is now closed to further replies.
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Posts

    • I'm fine with a little reasonable promotion of Edge, but the degree which they do it right now I consider extremely unreasonable. 
    • Microsoft AI boss no longer believes that AI will replace human workers by David Uzondu Mustafa Suleyman, the head of Microsoft AI, recently took back his statements concerning white-collar jobs that he gave to the Financial Times in an interview made back in February, where he claimed that AI would replace office workers within 12 to 18 months. On Monday's episode of The Verge's Decoder, Suleyman recast the technology as more like a helpmate than a tool designed to take over your job. He explained that smaller office duties will "increasingly become digitized, automated" as people generate more digital materials. During the discussion, Suleyman emphasized a "very important distinction" between "tasks" and "jobs" to clarify his previous claims. He argued that his earlier comments only referred to individual actions that people perform at their desks. Suleyman used to work for DeepMind, the research lab he co-founded in 2010 alongside Demis Hassabis and Shane Legg, before he left in 2022 to establish Inflection AI and build an empathetic digital assistant. Microsoft hired him in March 2024 to lead its newly formed "Microsoft AI" division, placing him in charge of consumer products like Copilot, Bing, and Edge. His February comments also detailed plans for Microsoft to achieve self-sufficiency with a $140 billion infrastructure budget to train frontier models, predicting that creating a customized AI will soon feel like creating a podcast or a new blog: The 41-year-old is not the only AI executive who's softened his "AI will replace you" stance. OpenAI's CEO, Sam Altman, last month used X to push back against employment panic by arguing that his startup builds tools to assist humans rather than build replacements. He had previously garnered backlash by suggesting that many modern office roles that AI might replace did not qualify as "real work" in the first place, at least when you compare desk jobs to physical, historical labor like farming.
    • Adobe Acrobat Reader DC 2026.001.21662 by Razvan Serea Adobe Acrobat Reader DC software is the free, trusted standard for viewing, printing, signing, and annotating PDFs. Its the only PDF viewer that can open and interact with all types of PDF content – including forms and multimedia. It’s connected to Adobe Document Cloud – so you can work with PDFs on computers and mobile devices. Adobe Document Cloud is a revolutionary, modern and efficient way to get work done with documents in the office, at home or on-the-go. At the heart of Document Cloud is the all-new Adobe Acrobat DC, which will take e-signatures mainstream by delivering free e-signing with every individual subscription. Document Cloud includes a set of integrated services that use a consistent online profile and personal document hub. With Adobe Document Cloud, people will be able to create, review, approve, sign and track documents whether on a desktop or mobile device. Businesses will be able to take advantage of Document Cloud for enterprise which provides enterprise-class document services that integrate into systems of record such as CRM, HCM, CLM, and CMS, adding speed, efficiency and transparency to getting business done with documents. Adobe Acrobat Reader DC new feature highlights: Work with PDFs from anywhere with the new, free Acrobat DC mobile app for Android or iOS. Select functionality is also available on Windows Phone. Use the new Fill & Sign tool in your desktop software to complete PDF forms fast with smart autofill. Download the free Adobe Fill & Sign mobile app to add the same option to your iPad or Android tablet device. Save money on ink and toner when printing from your Windows PC. Store and access files in Adobe Document Cloud with 5GB of free storage. Get instant access to recent files across desktop, web, and mobile devices with Mobile Link. Sync your Fill & Sign autofill collection across desktop, web, and iPad devices. Adobe PDF Pack premium features includes: Convert documents and images to PDF files. Use your mobile device camera to take a picture of a paper document or form and convert it to PDF. Turn PDFs into editable Microsoft Word, Excel, PowerPoint, or RTF files. Combine multiple files into a single PDF (web only). Get signatures from others with a complete e-signature service. Send, track, and confirm delivery of documents electronically instead of using fax or overnight services (tracking not available on mobile). Store and access files online with 20GB of storage. Download: Adobe Acrobat Reader DC 64-bit | 719.0 MB (Freeware) Link: Adobe Acrobat Reader DC Home Page | Release Notes | Screenshot Get alerted to all of our Software updates on Twitter at @NeowinSoftware
    • Meta will now use data from outside businesses to personalize AI responses by David Uzondu In an update that's rolling out globally (except in a handful of countries), Meta will use your data from outside businesses to personalize your AI responses and your primary feeds. Meta already utilizes your shopping activity to target ads, but the company now plans to expand this tracking to personalize other "parts of your experience" like feed algorithms and AI assistant chats. The company is replacing the two settings ("Your activity off Meta technologies" and "Activity from other businesses") that currently let you disconnect off-platform activity with a single, renamed setting called Activity from other businesses. If you don't want Meta to manipulate your feed and AI responses using your outside history, you can just turn the Activity from other businesses setting off in your account settings. This toggle resides within your Accounts Center, applying your choice to every connected profile. Turning this off will not stop companies from sending your data to Meta. The company will still collect your web interactions, but it only uses them to train products, while still accessing external accounts you connect. When The Verge spoke to Meta spokesperson, Emil Vazquez, the representative said that this update will exclude several locations at launch including the European region, the UK, Brazil, Thailand, South Africa, Turkey, South Korea, Ecuador, Nigeria, and Kenya. The new update comes at a time when the social media giant is recovering from a major PR disaster involving generative AI. Last week, there was a huge security issue on Instagram where attackers figured out a way to exploit a prompt injection vulnerability. Hackers managed to trick Meta AI into handing over account ownership (even if the victim had 2FA enabled). Some of the affected accounts include the dormant Obama White House profile, cosmetics brand Sephora, the Chief Master Sergeant of the Space Force, and security researcher Jane Manchun Wong. Internally, the company also had to scale back plans on its Model Capability Initiative (MCI), an employee-monitoring program designed to train corporate AI models by recording worker keystrokes and screen activity, after employees raised privacy concerns and complained about severe battery life drain.
    • JetBrains is working to cut false positives in RustRover 2026.2 by David Uzondu Recently, JetBrains released the fifth EAP build of its dedicated IDE, RustRover 2026.2, bringing improvements like a Run gutter icon for criterion_main! macro benchmarking and a feature that alerts you when there are unused traits in your current scope. Now, the company is out with a blog post addressing one of the "most common" complaints from users: false positives. In RustRover, a false positive occurs when the editor incorrectly highlights something as an error even though the project compiles and runs successfully. This mismatch flags a gap between the IDE's internal intelligence and the actual compiler. When the editor flashes red warnings over perfectly valid code, developers lose trust in the tool, which stalls momentum. Traditionally, RustRover runs cargo check to detect compiler errors and warnings, but it also relies on its own code analysis engine to power real-time features. To provide quick feedback, this engine parses your source code into a syntax tree while inferring types and resolving names as you type. Because this engine must work on broken, half-written code and react instantly, its logic sometimes diverges from the compiler's, producing false positives that do not exist in the compiler's eyes. JetBrains said that it has a "dedicated task force" focused specifically on identifying and fixing false positives by analyzing user reports and examining large-scale open-source projects. To speed up this process, the team built an internal system modeled after Crater, the famous Rust project that compiles and runs tests for every single crate published on crates.io. This automated pipeline compares the diagnostics from RustRover's analysis with actual compiler output to catch discrepancies before they reach users, ensuring smoother workflows. RustRover, for those who're unaware, is a dedicated IDE designed specifically for Rust developers. It's been around for a couple of years now, providing features like built-in debugging via LLDB, seamless cargo integration, advanced macro expansion, and HTML support. JetBrains distributes the app under two licensing models: a paid commercial subscription and a free option for non-commercial use.
  • Recent Achievements

    • One Year In
      Primer1st earned a badge
      One Year In
    • Experienced
      JayZJay went up a rank
      Experienced
    • Reacting Well
      Sir_Timbit earned a badge
      Reacting Well
    • Week One Done
      rubentuben8 earned a badge
      Week One Done
    • Week One Done
      ARaclen earned a badge
      Week One Done
  • Popular Contributors

    1. 1
      +primortal
      512
    2. 2
      PsYcHoKiLLa
      229
    3. 3
      Edouard
      134
    4. 4
      ATLien_0
      87
    5. 5
      Steven P.
      80
  • Tell a friend

    Love Neowin? Tell a friend!