Remove the Start button in Windows 8.1 with StartIsGone

By Sergey "hb860"
in Microsoft (Windows)

 Share

Recommended Posts

Veteran

ZakO

Posted
Posted

Nice app, thanks. Don't see the point of a start button when there's a Windows key on the majority of keyboards, I understand why they put it back, but it should have been an option.

  • DConnell and WAQT
  • Like 2
Experienced

DJGM

Posted
Posted

For those wondering what's the point of this, especially after so many calls to bring the Start button back, it's for when

you're using a 3rd party add-on like Classic Shell, that brings back the full traditional Start menu, the new Start button

is redundant, as it appears underneath the 3rd party Start button, and can be clicked on accidentally.

Grand Master

LittleNeutrino Veteran

Posted
  • Veteran
Posted

I will probably use this when 8.1 is officially released as I agree the button is useless, not sure why they put it back, it wasn't the start button people wanted back it was the old manu they wanted.

Veteran

siah1214

Posted
Posted

So, here's a thought, and forgive me if this too far out or crazy,

But what if the people asking for the start button back, and the people asking for the start button to be gone, are DIFFERENT PEOPLE?

 

*GASP!*

 

It's almost as though there's a diverse group of people in the world with different likes and preferences. 

 

But no, no that's just TOO crazy........

Veteran

Darrian

Posted
Posted
  On 11/09/2013 at 21:50, Lone Wanderer Chicken said:

I am doing a major face palm at this. People want the start button back and demand start button software programs. Now Microsoft puts a start button back in Windows 8 and now people want to gone and software to remove?

 

Because people didn't want the "button" back so much as the "menu."  Microsoft put the button back, but it still just redirects you to the start screen, which apparently most people can't seem to adapt to, so putting the button back was pretty much pointless.

  • insanelyapple and oliver182
  • Like 2
Grand Master

Denis W. Veteran

Posted
  • Veteran
Posted
  On 11/09/2013 at 22:19, Nik Louch said:

**** me, what's wrong with everyone?

 

* Some people wanted the start button back, not all

* Some people wanted the start menu back, not all

* Some people want the new start menu gone, not all

 

This guy has given people an app - for those who want it.

 

/ End of thread.  Really...

 

Well said. (Y) Be a bit more grateful folks, the OP has provided an utility some may find useful, and if you don't, there are plenty other threads to take up this debate on instead of this one.

  • WAQT, Calum and +Nik Louch
  • Like 3
Proficient

insanelyapple

Posted
Posted
  On 12/09/2013 at 02:03, Darrian said:

Because people didn't want the "button" back so much as the "menu."  Microsoft put the button back, but it still just redirects you to the start screen, which apparently most people can't seem to adapt to, so putting the button back was pretty much pointless.

 

I would say that with Start button in 8.1 most people doesn't feel so handicapped like in 8.0 with Start tooltip - the key element of UI of past OS versions, the most recognizable element is back. But this is also just a rotten compromise from Microsoft...

Grand Master

HawkMan

Posted
Posted
  On 12/09/2013 at 11:17, Neobond said:

I lol'd.

Maybe instead, you should make sure that developers who post their work on your site isn't met with such hostility and stupid arguments ?

Honestly, this thread is a pretty bad example of how people are met when coming here showing of their work that many would find useful.

  • +Nik Louch, oliver182 and WAQT
  • Like 3
Experienced

WAQT

Posted
Posted
  On 12/09/2013 at 11:21, Sergey "hb860" said:

I have no desire to argue with anyone.

I just provided the choice for everyone who need it.

 

Thank YOU for providing this option.

 

I have not tried it yet, still waiting for 8.1 to roll out officially.

 

A question, when we run the app and set it to run at startup, will it be possible to remove the icon from the notification area? ... I just don't like apps showing up there, if we click the original downloaded file we can have it pop up again?

Grand Master

Calum Veteran

Posted
  • Veteran
Posted

Thank you for this utility, Sergey "hb860"! I'll probably leave the Start button there, personally, but as I find it to be an ugly, unneeded UI element, I'm glad to know I have this option available to me if I decide I'd like to remove it :)

Grand Master

Steven P. Administrators

Posted
  • Administrators
Posted
  On 12/09/2013 at 11:34, HawkMan said:

Maybe instead, you should make sure that developers who post their work on your site isn't met with such hostility and stupid arguments ?

Honestly, this thread is a pretty bad example of how people are met when coming here showing of their work that many would find useful.

People are passionate about the subject. I was merely lol'ing because of the repeated coverage of articles we did on adding back the button and now we have this. Our support is obvious by the coverage on the front page just now.

 

Sergey is a hero to some, and I applaud that :)

  • Sergey "hb860"
  • Like 1
Proficient

Sergey "hb860"

Posted
  • Author
Posted

^^Thank you guys!

  On 12/09/2013 at 11:36, Blueclub said:

A question, when we run the app and set it to run at startup, will it be possible to remove the icon from the notification area? ... I just don't like apps showing up there, if we click the original downloaded file we can have it pop up again?

I will implement this behavior.
  • Steven P., WAQT and Brandon H
  • Like 3
Veteran

FaiKee

Posted
Posted

lmao, now when we see a windows with start button, it could be a win8 with StartIsBack(or ClassicShell, or whatever),

when we see a windows without start button, it could be win8.1 with StartIsGone. :laugh:

 

It's a good job, hb860 and Tihiy!! :) 

  • Sergey "hb860"
  • Like 1
Mentor

Anthony Tosie Veteran

Posted
  • Veteran
Posted

Always good to have options for those who want it. Nice job, Sergey -- can't say I'll use it, but I may give it a shot to see if I prefer it (I just press the Windows key anyway).

  • Sergey "hb860"
  • Like 1
Apprentice

Sicarius123

Posted
Posted

Excellent, will be installing this when I install 8.1. I have a few programs pinned to my taskbar and don't want to lose the real estate to a useless start button I wont click. I have a start button on my keyboard and built into my screen (Helix), and haven't missed the taskbar button even on desktops for a second.

Proficient

Sergey "hb860"

Posted
  • Author
Posted
  On 12/09/2013 at 12:06, Sergey said:

^^Thank you guys!

I will implement this behavior.

Guys, as I promise, here is an update.

StartIsGone v2.0

Added multiple monitors support :)

Added tray context menu option to hide the tray icon.

GS7e883.png

Download link is the same: click

  • +Nik Louch, WAQT and DConnell
  • Like 3
This topic is now closed to further replies.
 Share
Go to topic listing

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.

  • Posts

    • Apple introduces macOS Tahoe with a new Phone app, revamped Spotlight, and more

      By derekaw · Posted

      I'm running OS 26 on all my devices; it's nice. The windows on iPad is a great move.
    • How to watch Apple's WWDC 2025 event online happening from June 9 to 13

      By Yonah · Posted

      Neowin does not have that problem.
    • YouTube comments are not displaying correctly for some users

      By John K · Posted

      That newest first/top comments first issue has been around for years. Only ever encountered it on videos that were slightly edgy, so to speak.
    • How to watch Apple's WWDC 2025 event online happening from June 9 to 13

      By +MrElectrifyer · Posted

      That was a great presentation. Loved everything about the Aero Glass design upgrade, and how they're even making it easy for devs to create stunning app icons that fit in with the design with a new Icon Composer app. Very well executed Apple 👏🏽 Unfortunately though, they only took a mere baby step with iPadOS bringing aincient resizable windows to iPadOS, still no way to run full-fledged macOS apps on it. So, it's still a no go for me, and I simply can't settle for ANY mono device again having experienced the Surface Pro line...
    • Windows 11 finally gets redesigned Start menu and more in builds 26200.5641 and 26120.4250

      By TarasBuria · Posted

      Windows 11 finally gets redesigned Start menu and more in builds 26200.5641 and 26120.4250 by Taras Buria Apple is not the only company with big software announcements today. Microsoft is dropping two preview builds for Windows 11 users, which introduce major changes to the Start menu. Those in the Dev Channel can download build 26200.5641 (KB5060824) and try the much-improved Start menu and other changes. Windows Insiders in the Beta Channel receive build 26120.4250 with the same changelog. The new Start menu features several changes that make it easier to launch your favorite app. It no longer uses a two-page view, focusing on a single scrollable view instead. At the top, you have your pins, then the Recommended section (you can now turn it off completely), and a list of all apps presented as a grid or categories. Also, the Start menu is now more adaptive, which means users with bigger displays will have a larger Start menu to display more apps (up to eight columns of pinned apps, six recommendations, and four category columns). Finally, it has a new button that lets you expand or collapse the Phone Link pane. By the way, you can check out this article if you want to take a look at other Start menu variants that Microsoft considered when working on the new Start menu. Other changes in build 26200.5641 include the ability to select what widgets appear on the lock screen and the so-called Screen Curtain for Narrator. The latter blacks out the display, keeping the content of the screen available only to those using the Narrator. You can turn on or off the Screen curtain by pressing Caps Lock + Ctrl + C. Also, Narrator now has a new welcome experience that guides users through its features and recent changes. The Settings page is getting two sections fused into one: Searching in Windows and Search Permissions are now just Search in the Privacy & Security section. The gamepad keyboard now has improved navigation and improved focus handling for child keys, flyout menus, word suggestions, language switching, settings, etc. It also works on the lock screen when you have to enter your PIN. Here are other fixes that Microsoft is rolling out gradually to Windows Insiders: [General] This build should fix an underlying issue in the previous flight which was causing input to not work for some Insiders, including when typing into Search, and with the Chinese pinyin IME candidate window, clipboard history, and the emoji panel. [Recall (Preview)] The following fixes are rolling out for Recall on Copilot+ PCs: Fixed an issue causing Recall to crash for some Insiders in the last couple flights. [Taskbar] Fixed an issue where in some cases taskbar icons might appear small even though the setting to show smaller taskbar buttons was configured as “never”. [File Explorer] Fixed an issue where restoring a File Explorer search result from Recall would open File Explorer but not show your search string. [Windowing] Fixed an issue where ALT + Tabbing out of a full screen game could lead to other windows freezing (like Windows Terminal). [Login and lock] Fixed an issue causing the lock screen to crash for some Insiders in the previous flight. [Graphics] Fixed an issue causing some displays to be unexpectedly green after the latest flights. [Settings] Fixed an underlying issue which could lead to the Settings window hanging and no longer responding to input or resizing unless you closed and reopened it. Fixed an issue in System > Display, where if UAC was set to Always Notify and you tried to click the button to do color calibration for your display and cancelled, it would crash Settings. Fixed an issue in System > Display, where a chevron might display for Brightness even if there were no additional settings to display. Fixed an issue where if you changed to a custom mouse cursor in Accessibility > Mouse pointer and touch, it could make Settings crash. There is also a single fix that is rolling out to everyone right here, right now: [General] We fixed the issue where you might see severe discoloration when connecting your PC to some older Dolby Vision displays. Here are the known bugs in both Dev and Beta Channels: After you do a PC reset under Settings > System > Recovery, your build version may incorrectly show as Build 26100 instead of Build 26120. This will not prevent you from getting future Beta Channel updates, which will resolve this issue. [NEW] Some Windows Insiders may experience a rollback trying to install this update with a 0x80070005 in Windows Update. We’re working on a fix for the next flight. [Start menu] The following are known issues for Windows Insiders with the new Start menu: [NEW] Using touch to navigate the new Start menu may not work reliably. For example, it currently does not support the swipe-up gesture. [NEW] Drag and drop capabilities are limited from “All” to “Pinned.” [NEW] In some cases, duplicate entries may appear in folders on the Start menu. [Xbox Controllers] Some Insiders are experiencing an issue where using their Xbox Controller via Bluetooth is causing their PC to bugcheck. Here is how to resolve the issue. Open Device Manager by searching for it via the search box on your taskbar. Once Device Manager is open, click on “View” and then “Devices by Driver”. Find the driver named “oemXXX.inf (XboxGameControllerDriver.inf)” where the “XXX” will be a specific number on your PC. Right-click on that driver and click “Uninstall”. [Click to Do (Preview)] The following known issues will be fixed in future updates to Windows Insiders: Windows Insiders on AMD or Intel-powered Copilot+ PCs may experience long wait times on the first attempt to perform intelligent text actions in Click to Do after a new build or model update. [Improved Windows Search] [REMINDER] For improved Windows Search on Copilot+ PCs, it is recommended that you plug in your Copilot+ PC for the initial search indexing to get completed. You can check your search indexing status under Settings > Privacy & security > Searching Windows. [File Explorer] The following are known issues for AI actions in File Explorer: Narrator scan mode may not work properly in the action result canvas window for the Summarize AI action for Microsoft 365 files when reading bulleted lists. As a workaround, you can use Caps + Right key to navigate. [Widgets] Until we complete support for pinning in the new widgets board experience, pinning reverts you back to the previous experience Note that the Dev build has two more known issues: The option to reset your PC under Settings > System > Recovery will not work on this build. We’re investigating an issue causing a small number of Insiders to experience repeated bugchecks with KERNEL_SECURITY_CHECK_FAILURE after upgrading to most current Dev Channel builds. You can find the official announcement for the Dev build here and for the Beta build here.

  • Recent Achievements

    • Rookie
      CHUNWEI went up a rank
      Rookie
    • Enthusiast
      the420kid went up a rank
      Enthusiast
    • Conversation Starter
      NeoToad777 earned a badge
      Conversation Starter
    • Week One Done
      VicByrd earned a badge
      Week One Done
    • Reacting Well
      NeoToad777 earned a badge
      Reacting Well

  • Popular Contributors

    1. 1
      +primortal
      486
    2. 2
      +FloatingFatMan
      267
    3. 3
      ATLien_0
      261
    4. 4
      Edouard
      201
    5. 5
      snowy owl
      178
    Show More

  • Tell a friend

    Love Neowin? Tell a friend!