Better NTFS Support Under Linux


Recommended Posts

Just noticed this on Slashdot:

Using the Real ntfs.sys Driver Under Linux

"A very neat hack uses the real ntfs.sys driver (obtained from your own windows XP partition and used via a wine-like layer (borrowed from ReactOS) to mount an ntfs partion with full read/write access. While not an ideal solution and certainly not free as in speech, this is an ideal stop-gap measure for many people trying out linux. I think that we'll probably see this in Knoppix pretty soon."

While write support in the kernel exists already, you can only use it on NON-system drives because of the second NTFS Journal that is present on system drives (or is it just the system partition? reguardless, I wouldn't touch my system DRIVE period with "NTFS write" under Linux). This appears to be a MUCH safer way, as it's actually using Microsoft's own driver rather than a "built from scratch" system!

Link to comment
https://www.neowin.net/forum/topic/120290-better-ntfs-support-under-linux/
Share on other sites

I saw this too. Pretty interesting idea. I know Knppoix et.al. will use it eventually (maybe), but I don't really see any of the big commercial distros using it since it uses MS property ( see the Web TTF core issues). Then again, most non-US distros don't have to worry about the insane US copyright rules.

I'm going to give this a shot on my laptop. Since I haven't used the XP partition in awhile anyway, no harm done if it does get nuked! :D

i believe the ntfs ppl had thought of doing that but gave a nice list of reasons why its bad. Personally i don't care atm too much. Would be nice to write to my windows drive.

Integrating that into knoppix would be great. Especially since windows users would use it to recover fscked windows. I know ppl who still use it regarldess, but have non ntfs drives.

I don't really see why people would want to have write support for NTFS in Linux anyway. I mean, there are isolated uses where it might be useful (eg. repairing a borked Windows install), but there's already better tools for that (eg. recovery console). And if you want to share storage space for say.. MP3's or DIVX's, you can do so with FAT32 or using Linux's native filesystem and picking up Paragon's software which allows you to read/write to Linux filesystems in Windows (came free with a computer magazine for me).

Yes FAT32 is a solution (I use it personally). On the other hand I had been cursing the whole world for a year before I switched to FAT32 (just after my hdd died). And I'm sure millions of people have NTFS partitions, and before swithing to linux they do all ask: what if need to write on ntfs drive?

  BananaMan said:
...if you want to share storage space for say.. MP3's or DIVX's, you can do so with FAT32 or using Linux's native filesystem and picking up Paragon's software which allows you to read/write to Linux filesystems in Windows (came free with a computer magazine for me).

Using FAT32, if you created the partition under Windows, it is crippled as you cannot make FAT32 partitions larger than 40GB AFAIK (to force movement away from the archaic filesystem). Yes, FAT32 supports larger partitions, but you need to use Partition Magic or some other 3rd party partition manager. And you loose the security features built into other filesystems. By default, Windows will definately not create a 120GB FAT32 partition. It forces NTFS on you.

For the casual user or for the newcomer, this would be helpful in allowing them to still access and modify their files if they are on an NTFS partition. I also know enough people who prefer to use ResierFS or XFS for their installs. Paragon's software is a good solution if you are using ext2/3, but if you're using XFS or ReiserFS (which is what SuSE defaults to; don't know about others), then you're SOL.

  FBody24 said:
...I don't really see any of the big commercial distros using it since it uses MS property ( see the Web TTF core issues).

The legal thing here, that I think will help push this into being adopted more, is that ntfs.sys is already on an NTFS-based system. This takes into account that you already installed a legal Windows operating system (you did, right?). There isn't any distribution of ntfs.sys that would need to happen, with such things as the Windows Fonts (which doesn't require you to have purchased Windows software), because you alreayd have the file on your drives. And if you don't have Windows installed, then what's the point of using NTFS?

This topic is now closed to further replies.
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Posts

    • Microsoft 365 Word gets SharePoint eSignature, now you can ditch third-party signing tools by Paul Hill Microsoft has just announced that it will be rolling out an extremely convenient feature for Microsoft 365 customers who use Word throughout this year. The Redmond giant said that you’ll now be able to use SharePoint’s native eSignature service directly in Microsoft Word. The new feature allows customers to request electronic signatures without converting the documents to a PDF or leaving the Word interface, significantly speeding up workflows. Microsoft’s integration of eSignatures also allows you to create eSignature templates which will speed up document approvals, eliminate physical signing steps, and help with compliance and security in the Microsoft 365 environment. This change has the potential to significantly improve the quality-of-life for those in work finding themselves adding lots of signatures to documents as they will no longer have to export PDFs from Word and apply the signature outside of Word. It’s also key to point out that this feature is integrated natively and is not an extension. The move is quite clever from Microsoft, if businesses were using third-party tools to sign their documents, they would no longer need to use these as it’s easier to do it in Word. Not only does it reduce reliance on other tools, it also makes Microsoft’s products more competitive against other office suites such as Google Workspace. Streamlined, secure, and compliant The new eSignature feature is tightly integrated into Word. It lets you insert signature fields seamlessly into documents and request other people’s signatures, all while remaining in Word. The eSignature feature can be accessed in Word by going to the Insert ribbon. When you send a signature request to someone from Word, the recipient will get an automatically generated PDF copy of the Word document to sign. The signed PDF will then be kept in the same SharePoint location as the original Word file. To ensure end-to-end security and compliance, the document never leaves the Microsoft 365 trust boundary. For anyone with a repetitive signing process, this integration allows you to turn Word documents into eSignature templates so they can be reused. Another feature that Microsoft has built in is audit trail and notifications. Both the senders and signers will get email notifications throughout the entire signing process. Additionally, you can view the activity history (audit trail) in the signed PDF to check who signed it and when. Finally, Microsoft said that administrators will be able to control how the feature is used in Word throughout the organization. They can decide to enable it for specific users via an Office group policy or limit it to particular SharePoint sites. The company said that SharePoint eSignature also lets admins log activities in the Purview Audit log. A key security measure included by Microsoft, which was mentioned above, was the Microsoft 365 trust boundary. By keeping documents in this boundary, Microsoft ensures that all organizations can use this feature without worry. The inclusion of automatic PDF creation is all a huge benefit to users as it will cut out the step of manual PDF creation. While creating a PDF isn’t complicated, it can be time consuming. The eSignature feature looks like a win-win-win for organizations that rely on digital signatures. Not only does it speed things along and remain secure, but it’s also packed with features like tracking, making it really useful and comprehensive. When and how your organization gets it SharePoint eSignature has started rolling out to Word on the M365 Beta and Current Channels in the United States, Canada, the United Kingdom, Europe, and Australia-Pacific. This phase of the rollout is expected to be completed by early July. People in the rest of the world will also be gaining this time-saving feature but it will not reach everyone right away, though Microsoft promises to reach everybody by the end of the year. To use the feature, it will need to be enabled by administrators. If you’re an admin who needs to enable this, just go to the M365 Admin Center and enable SharePoint eSignature, ensuring the Word checkbox is selected. Once the service is enabled, apply the “Allow the use of SharePoint eSignature for Microsoft Word” policy. The policy can be enabled via Intune, Group Policy manager, or the Cloud Policy service for Microsoft 365 Assuming the admins have given permission to use the feature, users will be able to access SharePoint eSignatures on Word Desktop using the Microsoft 365 Current Channel or Beta Channel. The main caveats include that the rollout is phased, so you might not get it right away, and it requires IT admins to enable the feature - in which case, it may never get enabled at all. Overall, this feature stands to benefit users who sign documents a lot as it can save huge amounts of time cumulatively. It’s also good for Microsoft who increase organizations’ dependence on Word.
    • It's always good to have an option to secure your stuff to another medium. I did that with DVD/CD collection, and run my own media server now. It's more convenient that way and no need for separate players anymore.
    • Google Search AI Mode gets support for data visualization and custom charts by Aditya Tiwari Google announced it is rolling out support for data visualizations and graphs for finance-related queries in Google Search's AI Mode. Introduced last month at the Google I/O 2025 keynote, the feature lets you analyze complex datasets and create custom charts simply using natural language prompts. The updated AI Mode lets you compare and analyze information over a specific period, Google explained. It generates interactive graphs and provides a comprehensive explanation for your questions. AI Mode utilizes Gemini's multimodal capabilities and multi-step reasoning approach to comprehend the question's intent while accessing historical and real-time information relevant to the question. For instance, instead of manually researching individual companies and their stock prices, you can use AI Mode to compare the stock performance of different companies for a specific year. Once the graph is generated, you can choose the desired time period using the mouse cursor and ask follow-up questions based on the data presented. These new data visualizations for finance queries are available to users who have enabled the AI Mode experiment in Labs. AI Mode was introduced earlier this year as an experimental feature in the US. The feature is an upgraded version of AI Overviews, and Google closely worked with AI power users through the initial development process. It uses the “query fan-out” technique to perform multiple related searches across subtopics and different data sources, then combines them to come up with a comprehensive response. Google updated AI Mode last month to use a custom version of the latest Gemini 2.5 model. It added several new features, including Deep Search, live capabilities, agentic capabilities of Project Mariner, a new shopping experience, and the ability to add personal context by linking Google apps. The search giant is planning to turn AI Mode into its bread and butter. It has begun testing ads for the feature, which will appear below and be integrated into AI Mode responses where relevant.
    • Guys, you should find another way to promote your deals... It's the third article in the last months that promote this deal for an upgrade from 10. Considering that upgrade from 10 to 11 is free it's a total non-sense.
    • Store should be a shrine of useful applications, vetted and verified. Easily sorted by publisher. Windows should start with not much installed and have things as options in the store. Not the wild west mess that it is. You could delete 95%+ of the crap on there and no one would notice. They need to add a better UI to the updates, it's awful right now.
  • Recent Achievements

    • Week One Done
      luxoxfurniture earned a badge
      Week One Done
    • First Post
      Uranus_enjoyer earned a badge
      First Post
    • Week One Done
      Uranus_enjoyer earned a badge
      Week One Done
    • Week One Done
      jfam earned a badge
      Week One Done
    • First Post
      survivor303 earned a badge
      First Post
  • Popular Contributors

    1. 1
      +primortal
      432
    2. 2
      +FloatingFatMan
      239
    3. 3
      snowy owl
      213
    4. 4
      ATLien_0
      211
    5. 5
      Xenon
      157
  • Tell a friend

    Love Neowin? Tell a friend!