Forward the Internet connection to a second router for network management (Bridge vs DMZ)


Recommended Posts

Hi,

For optical fiber, a particular ISP I'm interested in, installs a ONT+Router all-in-one device (Huawei) which does not support bridge mode (maybe the router itself supports it but the functionality was probably removed by the ISP). But I don't like this router, I want to use my own (Asus AC68U) to manage my whole LAN. Usually, one would connect the Huawei to the Asus in bridge mode and have the Asus manage everything. But like I said, there's no bridge mode in the Huawei.

I believe the Huawei supports DMZ and I can redirect all the traffic from the Huawei to the Asus and still have the Asus manage everything. However, my question is, in practical terms, what exactly is the difference between redirecting all the traffic with bridge mode and redirecting all the traffic with DMZ. I'm really looking for practical pros and cons. Like "in mode X you can do this but not that".

Would I be able to achieve what I want - have the Asus manage the Internet connection to my LAN (like NAT, Firewall, Port Forwardin, DDNS, VPN, etc...) - with DMZ? Or is there anything that would only be possible in bridge mode?

What model of Huawei is it? Usually when ISP's do things like this, you find the MAC and clone it onto your own device. That's what I have done in the past with an ISP over here in the UK.

The problem with double nat.. For one is a performance hit, be it slight - it still a hit. You prob could have issues with isakmp since this a static port and headers prob going to get messed up in the double nat.  This is used in IKE which is IPSEC vpn connections mostly.. Do you do any of that?  That can make it more complicated, but should still be able to get around it.

Normally you would avoid a double nat as much as possible..  If not in the dmz of the first router it becomes a real pain to control port forwarding, stuff like UPnP would not work.  But if in the dmz you should not have all that many issues other than the slight performance hit of a double nat.  You could have issues with ftp for sure depending on the routers and ftp helpers, if no helper trying to do active or run a ftp server behind could be broken..  Passive could even be a problem if 1st router doesn't have a helper for ftp..  I wouldn't worry about that too much, unless you run a ftp server to the public.. Or use it all the time - its really a deprecated protocol and sftp should be used anyway.

Normally a DMZ is not a bridge, depending on the router it might not forward specific traffic or might do something weird with some ports being listened on the 1st router and not forwarding correctly.  Like I said should be avoided!!!!  But if you have to do it, its not the end of the freaking world.. More than likely you can get everything to work..

Is this a business line or home connection.  Business I would think you could demand bridge mode..Do you plan on playing lots of say console games behind this setup?  Stuff that does with UPnP and or likes static source ports could have problems, but since dmz in first router you should be ok.. For example if console game says via UPnP hey make sure you use source port X on when you nat because who I am connecting too expects that but then outside router just nats it to some random port that is open in its state table.  Where you connecting might say hey that is wrong source port.

Dmz is not the same as actual public IP, the router is doing forwards and napt and ports are going to get changed twice, this could cause issues since while it only done once and depending on the router you could have control over this When you do your specific forwards.  But since its being done twice and outer one is just in auto mode with everything being forwarded to first router..

I would really push for bridge mode on the isp device.  But if a no go, its a slight performance hit..  Why exactly do you want your own router?  To run your wifi, just use it as access point and just use the isp to control forwards, now only 1 nat.  Do you run multiple network segments?  Why do you feel you can not just use the isp device as your edge router?

Another issue that can happen, is just crappy device given by isp and when its doing nat and having to keep track of a lot of connections (p2p for example - especially if multiple users of it) the isp device nat falls down.. But if it was just bridging the connection the user could use a better device that can handle the number of states and not have an issue, etc..

 

 

Edited by BudMan
  On 10/11/2015 at 08:35, John Teacake said:

What model of Huawei is it? Usually when ISP's do things like this, you find the MAC and clone it onto your own device. That's what I have done in the past with an ISP over here in the UK.

Huawei HG8247H. If by cloning the MAC you mean you'd only use my own device, that will not work. I still need to use the ISP's device for IPTV and VoIP. Also, I believe my credentials are builtin in the device, not sure about this though.

  On 10/11/2015 at 13:02, BudMan said:

The problem with double nat.. For one is a performance hit, be it slight - it still a hit. You prob could have issues with isakmp since this a static port and headers prob going to get messed up in the double nat.  This is used in IKE which is IPSEC vpn connections mostly.. Do you do any of that?  That can make it more complicated, but should still be able to get around it.

I'm not sure... I want to have the VPN service on the Asus turned on so I can connect to my LAN and access my internal services. I do not want VPN to forward all my traffic through my home connection. I'd like to have the possibility though, but I probably won't use it.

  On 10/11/2015 at 13:02, BudMan said:

Normally you would avoid a double nat as much as possible..  If not in the dmz of the first router it becomes a real pain to control port forwarding, stuff like UPnP would not work.

For security purposes I usually turn UPnP off and open the required ports as necessary for any games I play (which are not that many to be honest).

  On 10/11/2015 at 13:02, BudMan said:

But if you have to do it, its not the end of the freaking world.. More than likely you can get everything to work..

I'm afraid I do because the bridge functionality is disabled and I'm not sure anybody has yet found a way to enable it (if the router supports it, I believe it does).

  On 10/11/2015 at 13:02, BudMan said:

Is this a business line or home connection.  Business I would think you could demand bridge mode..Do you plan on playing lots of say console games behind this setup?  Stuff that does with UPnP and or likes static source ports could have problems, but since dmz in first router you should be ok.. For example if console game says via UPnP hey make sure you use source port X on when you nat because who I am connecting too expects that but then outside router just nats it to some random port that is open in its state table.  Where you connecting might say hey that is wrong source port.

Home. I'm not in a position to demand anything. And the only way to request something is after signing the contract, which makes it worse. AFAIK, they no longer have the old ONT+Router combo available anymore, they install the new Huawei for all new clients. Like I previously said, I prefer to disable UPnP and forward all the needed ports. Do you see any issues with this setup?

  On 10/11/2015 at 13:02, BudMan said:

I would really push for bridge mode on the isp device.  But if a no go, its a slight performance hit..  Why exactly do you want your own router?  To run your wifi, just use it as access point and just use the isp to control forwards, now only 1 nat.  Do you run multiple network segments?  Why do you feel you can not just use the isp device as your edge router?

Because the ISP router sucks and doesn't have all the features I want. I've read many reviews on the Asus routers and they have exactly what I want and like in a router. It's not just the wifi, it's everything. To name a few, VPN Server, DDNS, dual wireless, QoS and proper IP/MAC management (they usually suck on those ISP routers). Also, the Asus has constant firmware development and there's the excellent Merlin firmware with extra features that I need (for one, DDNS to run a custom script so I can have my own custom domain). I just wanted to delegate the Internet/LAN management to the Asus as much as possible and leave the ISP router for IPTV and VoIP only.

Thanks for the long and descriptive post, that's exactly the kind of answer I was looking for :)

"proper IP/MAC management"

What is this exactly - setting a reservation?  While I agree with you some very limited dhcp servers in many soho routers...  I don't recall seeing one that doesn't do a reservation.  What I have seen is the lack of setting any other options like changing the gateway or dns, or other options you can set with dhcp, etc.

Again double nat would not be the preferred setup, but it is a very workable solution if you don't have the choice.

I have a modem with Time Warner that I couldn't get bridged (hidden menu and nothing I could find would get me into it).  I just called them up, asked to be transferred to Tier 2 support, and them accessed it and bridged it for me.  Then I connected my own gear.  Try giving them a call if you haven't.

  On 16/11/2015 at 12:59, BudMan said:

"proper IP/MAC management"

Like, machine A has MAC A:B:C:D and static IP 1.2.3.4 and it's named "My Personal Device (on the router itself) than I can forward ports, control network access and stuff like that per machine identified by the name I previously selected instead of trying to identify the device I want by MAC or IP address. It's very basic but a lot of devices fail having a good interface to manage stuff like this.

  On 16/11/2015 at 13:12, farmeunit said:

I have a modem with Time Warner that I couldn't get bridged (hidden menu and nothing I could find would get me into it).  I just called them up, asked to be transferred to Tier 2 support, and them accessed it and bridged it for me.  Then I connected my own gear.  Try giving them a call if you haven't.

Yeah, I'm gonna try that but unfortunately the kind of technical support we get around here is not very good, they are not very comprehensive. In other words, they really don't care.

So that is simple dhcp server reservation..  And then ability to use an alias in firewall rules, etc. That would not really be a reason to use one device over another if you ask me..   . But sure if you like that feature of a firmware then ok..

You asked me why I wanted to use my own device and I gave you a few reasons, that's just one of them. But it's certainly not the most important. I wouldn't buy and use my own device just for that.

This topic is now closed to further replies.
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Posts

    • I have two Tab S9 FEs and two Tab A9+ tablets. While the Tab A9+ is not as powerful as the Tab S9 FE, I like the much cheaper Tab A9+ better. It has a slightly more Landscapish display for those who use the Landscape mode. I haven't noticed much difference in the speakers. The S9 FE does better on battery drainage at around 7% an hour vs 9% an hour for the Tab A9+. I don't use Fast Charging because it is not good for the battery and I haven't really compared the charge time between the two. One thing for sure is the Tab A9+ does a lot better at handling memory under Android 15 UI 7 than it did under Android 14, UI 6.1. The Tab A10+ has yet to be released and as I understand it, it has major chipset and charging upgrades. It expected to be released late this summer or early fall, but with all Samsung hardware releases, I imagine this one will be same where the U.S. is not among the early markets to see a new device.
    • As such, about 30,000 government sector computers would be switching by 2027 or so. I have been there and done it though probably not with as many as 30,000 computers. i worked on a Bank of America conversion project and it was a mess, a complete mess. Computer system conversions are never as easy as they sound in the media or even the Corporate Boardroom or Government high-up offfices. One may ask, what MIcrosoft hardware and sofware the government of Denmark is using in addition to desktop computers and Office?. One thing for sure. We know that they aren't using Windows 10 Mobile.
    • WTF? I can't believe you are surprised it's not an option or it should be. 
    • Yes, if the PCs aren’t upgraded, they’ll lack features like TPM and remain vulnerable to driver and hardware-level exploits. That includes CPU flaws, RAM vulnerabilities, boot and BIOS attacks, and so on. Realistically, there should have been a steady programme of hardware refreshes rather than allowing systems to age well past their practical and secure lifespan. Are we seriously entertaining the idea of running Linux on machines that are over a decade old as a long-term solution instead of upgrading? Would you entrust your financial data or medical records to a box from the early 2000s, with Windows XP removed and Linux installed in its place? Performance degradation is not just an inconvenience. It affects productivity. Slow machines cost time, and time costs money. Security flaws do too. Hardware and software upgrades should be part of a rolling, responsible IT strategy. They should not be treated as an afterthought. This kind of complacency is precisely the issue we’ve seen before. Just look at how that played out in the UK. We readily replace construction tools such as drills, saws, and other equipment on a regular basis, and many of those cost more than a standard desktop PC. Yet when it comes to computers, we’re still stuck in the mindset of "if it isn’t broken, don’t fix it." Just because something powers on doesn’t mean it is fit for purpose. The horse and cart did the job at one point too, but that didn’t mean it was wise to stick with it when something better came along.
    • Freshly released Samsung Galaxy Tab S10 FE is already discounted by Fiza Ali The Samsung Galaxy Tab S10 FE is already available at a discount, just two months after its debut, so you may want to check it out. The device is powered by the Samsung Exynos 1580 processor and equipped with 12GB of RAM and 256GB of internal storage, which can be expanded by up to 1TB via microSD. It features a 10.9‑inch LCD display with a resolution of 2,304 x 1,440 pixels and a 90 Hz refresh rate. Photography and video calls are handled by a 13MP rear camera and a 12MP ultra‑wide front‑facing camera. The device further includes dual AKG‑tuned speakers for immersive audio. The Galaxy Tab S10 FE offers Sub‑6 5G, dual‑band Wi‑Fi 6 with Wi‑Fi Direct support, and Bluetooth 5.3 for low‑latency wireless connections. Moreover, it incorporates S Pen functionality with handwriting assist, a Circle to Search feature for instant Google look‑ups, and Math Solver for converting handwritten equations into editable text and step‑by‑step solutions. The tablet comes pre‑loaded with a suite of creative and productivity apps, including LumaFusion, GoodNotes, Clip Studio Paint, Noteshelf, Sketchbook and PicsArt. The Galaxy Tab S10 FE is water‑resistant, safeguarding against spills, splashes, and brief immersion, and includes a dedicated AI hot‑key on its keyboard for quick access to on‑device artificial intelligence tools. Finally, the tablet houses an 8,000 mAh lithium‑ion battery (29.95Wh) that is said to deliver up to 20 hours of continuous use and supports Super Fast Charging. Samsung Galaxy Tab S10 FE: $519.99 (Amazon US) 9% off This Amazon deal is US-specific and not available in other regions unless specified. If you don't like it or want to look at more options, check out the Amazon US deals page here. Get Prime (SNAP), Prime Video, Audible Plus or Kindle / Music Unlimited. Free for 30 days. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
  • Recent Achievements

    • Explorer
      Case_f went up a rank
      Explorer
    • Conversation Starter
      Jamie Smith earned a badge
      Conversation Starter
    • First Post
      NeoToad777 earned a badge
      First Post
    • Week One Done
      JoeV earned a badge
      Week One Done
    • One Month Later
      VAT Services in UAE earned a badge
      One Month Later
  • Popular Contributors

    1. 1
      +primortal
      549
    2. 2
      ATLien_0
      240
    3. 3
      +Edouard
      160
    4. 4
      +FloatingFatMan
      147
    5. 5
      Michael Scrip
      112
  • Tell a friend

    Love Neowin? Tell a friend!