VLAN configuration on a "smart" switch for a guest WiFi network


Recommended Posts

So I finally got round to buying a proper access point (Unifi nanoHD), which is capable of having multiple SSIDs, mapped to VLANs.  I have a "smart" switch (TP-Link TL-SG2008), and a PFSense based firewall (SG2220).

 

Assuming that:

1) The AP is connected to the switch on port 1

2) The firewall is connected to port 8

3) There a bunch of other "trusted" devices on the other 6 ports.

4) I want my "trusted" network to run on VLAN 11.

5) I want my "untrusted" network to run on VLAN 99.

 

Is it right that I?

Set up a "trusted" SSID on the AP, which is on VLAN 11.

Set up an "untrusted" SSID on the AP, which is on VLAN 99.

Set up port 1 on my switch to preserve VLANs

Set up port 8 on my switch to preserve VLANs

Set up ports 2 through 6 to tag packets on entry with VLAN 11 and strip VLANs on the way out

 

Does anyone know how to achieve the configuration on my particular switch?

Also what changes do I need to make to pfSense to treat the VLANs as logical interfaces, each with their own subnet, DHCP ranges, internet access and prevent any routing between them?

 

Is there a specific sequence I need to do this all in so I don't lose connectivity to the various components whilst I make the changes?

In your pfsense config, you will want to create your vlans.  What you will do is create a rule to block traffic coming from your guest vlan to your private vlan, it will be able to communicate with all other networks.  

 

You will trunk your vlans on a port (usually you just have to enable trunking, but you can tell it to include those vlans on that trunk port) to the switch.  You will probably have to configure the switch port that is coming from pfsense to trunk.  You will have to configure the switch with the vlan id's that are coming from the pfsense router.  Then you can assign those vlans to ports.  

 

If you have a AP that is vlan capable (**cough** ubiquiti **cough**), you would trunk all of the vlans to that and make your AP default to the private vlan or a management vlan of some sort (so add another vlan for management of devices that can only have source traffic come from your private vlan, another pfsense access control list) to manage networking devices.  Then you can have your AP host both the Guest VLan via a Guest SSID and your Private vlan via Private SSID.

 

 

Draw it out on paper first on how you want things to work.  It will then become clear to you what you have to do and if you will or will not experience an outage.  Understand that you will probably have 1 lan  for internet traffic to go across, 1 lan for house, 1 lan for guest, if any guest or house will need to share devices like printers, another for printers/shared devices, and maybe for the hell of it one for IoT devices.  (fyi, I don't see a way to not have an outage of some sort...you can create the networks and test, but when you move devices over to the new LANs they may have to reboot).

 

  On 24/05/2019 at 19:33, sc302 said:

Draw it out on paper first on how you want things to work.

Expand  

This is very good advice... This will allow you to understand exactly what has to be done, and where.

  On 28/05/2019 at 11:57, sc302 said:

And vlan 2 (or whatever vlan....could be vlan1 but that is just lazy) going between modem and router. Internet traffic isolated on its own vlan to not mix secured from unsecured devices

Expand  

Can you explain that?  Given that the modem is ISP provided, with no control whatsoever in terms of VLANs, how would I achieve this?

The isp goes into the router. Whatever that is it is a Vlan or untrusted network.  This would be an untagged port. If we are treating this as an outside/untrusted network on a firewall/router nothing else is needed to be done.  

  On 28/05/2019 at 15:14, BudMan said:

So both of those vlans are tagged or is one native (untagged) and the other tagged? 

Expand  

Is one of these choices better than the other? If I choose to leave one untagged, would it be the trusted or guest one?

 

  On 28/05/2019 at 15:14, BudMan said:

At the switch and router? 

Expand  

Don't understand this question.

 

The picture is meant to be of what I want to end up with, not what I have right now (single SSID, no tagging at all anywhere)

  On 28/05/2019 at 15:48, Fahim S. said:

The picture is meant to be of what I want to end up with, not what I have right now (single SSID, no tagging at all anywhere)

Expand  

tagging/untagging is how switches work.  an untagged port is an access port.  An access port is an endpoint port where a device on the other end is essentially dumb and doesn't know the difference between tagged and untagged traffic.

 

Tagged is how a trunk works, this allows the port to encapsulate all of the vlans you choose on a single port.  You can have a native vlan (untagged) and several encapsulated vlans (tagged) on a single port that connects to a switch that can decipher this type of traffic (known also as 802.1Q).  

 

For your ap to work, it will have one port.  That one port can support all of the vlans you want to send over to the AP.  You can have the AP on both a tagged and untagged port...the tagged vlan will be the guest vlan and the tagged/untagged vlan will be your secured vlan.  just like in your picture.  

 

You need to understand the terminology, that is all.  If you don't know ask, don't assume that you aren't tagging anywhere, you have to tag for vlans to function across a single port.

 

edit: so you don't get confused, and being that budman has more time with helping, I will let him work with you.  If you get stuck or need simpler explanation please ask.

As to tagged or untagged doesn't matter which... Its just how you set it up.. Its normally more intuitive on say your router where the actual physical interface network is left untagged.  Vs not putting any network on the physical interface, and only enabling vlans that run on that phy interface.

 

As to switch and router, this is where native or untagged vlan will come in to play. For example out of the box on a switch the vlan 1 is untagged. 

 

On your AP if you do not set a vlan for an SSID, then it would be native untagged... And that would be need to be set on the switch port the AP is connected too.  If you tag both SSIDs on AP with vlan IDs then you would have to set them as tagged on the switch port the AP is connected too.

 

On the interface to the router same thing - if you set both as tagged vlans on your router, then they would both have to be tagged on the switch port that connected to your router.

 

On a port that carries more than 1 vlan, only 1 could be untagged (native) all other vlans would have to be TAGGED... Or all of them could be TAGGED... All depends on the device your connecting to that switch port and how its configured for native or all tagged, etc.

 

To be honest I think tag and untagged is what confuses the most new users to vlans.

  On 28/05/2019 at 16:03, sc302 said:

edit: so you don't get confused, and being that budman has more time with helping, I will let him work with you.  If you get stuck or need simpler explanation please ask.

Expand  

Thanks for the offer (I genuinely am grateful), but with the very greatest respect I never find your explanations very "simple".

 

  On 28/05/2019 at 16:21, Fahim S. said:

Thanks for the offer (I genuinely am grateful), but with the very greatest respect I never find your explanations very "simple".

 

Expand  

Interesting, but ok.  I do take great pride to simplify things, but completely understandable.  Everyone has different understanding levels, some people require many different approaches until they finally understand (or think they do). 

  On 28/05/2019 at 16:04, BudMan said:

As to tagged or untagged doesn't matter which... Its just how you set it up.. Its normally more intuitive on say your router where the actual physical interface network is left untagged.  Vs not putting any network on the physical interface, and only enabling vlans that run on that phy interface.

 

As to switch and router, this is where native or untagged vlan will come in to play. For example out of the box on a switch the vlan 1 is untagged. 

 

On your AP if you do not set a vlan for an SSID, then it would be native untagged... And that would be need to be set on the switch port the AP is connected too.  If you tag both SSIDs on AP with vlan IDs then you would have to set them as tagged on the switch port the AP is connected too.

 

On the interface to the router same thing - if you set both as tagged vlans on your router, then they would both have to be tagged on the switch port that connected to your router.

 

On a port that carries more than 1 vlan, only 1 could be untagged (native) all other vlans would have to be TAGGED... Or all of them could be TAGGED... All depends on the device your connecting to that switch port and how its configured for native or all tagged, etc.

 

To be honest I think tag and untagged is what confuses the most new users to vlans.

Expand  

OK... but in my switch I can set a port (on a per VLAN basis) as Untagged, Tagged, or Not Member. I can also give a port a PVID.  The switch doesn't have an option to set a port as an access port or trunk as such. 

 

I am pretty sure that for VLAN 99 I want to set port 1 and 8 as tagged and the others as Not Member. 

 

But what do I do for VLAN 11? Set them all to Tagged? What PVID should they have?

 

 

So if you put a port in vlan 11, and your going to connect a computer to it then that would be untagged 11 with pvid set to 11... This tells the switch when it sees untagged traffic coming into that port that its vlan 11.

 

When you connect say your router that is using untagged (native interface on the router) and you want that as 11, then same thing untagged 11, pvid 11

 

For the vlan 99 which you run on top of that physical interface, on the switch port it would add tagged 99.

 

For your access point same sort of thing.. if you do not put a vlan ID on one of your SSID that would be the untagged and pvid setting, with the other vlan set to tagged.

 

Your running pfsense as your router?  I can show you some screenshots of what I mean by native and vlan on pfsense.

got it.. thank you!

I decided to keep my trusted network untagged and decided that VLAN 100 would be a better choice for guest.

 

OK.. now the pfSense set up...

I set up a VLAN for 100, and then a (sub)-interface for this VLAN

I then set the interface with a static IP (I used 192.168.100.1 /32).  Kept everything else as default.

When I go to add a DHCP server, I don't even see the tab for my Guest network. 

 

Have I done something wrong?

 

  On 28/05/2019 at 17:47, Fahim S. said:

/32).

Expand  

that is wrong!  You prob want /24 which would be 192.168.100.1-254 would be valid IPs on that network.

 

/32 is all 32 bits.. so 192.168.100.1 is the ONLY address.  So can not run a dhcp server on that ;)

  On 28/05/2019 at 17:49, BudMan said:

that is wrong!  You prob want /24 which would be 192.168.100.1-254 would be valid IPs on that network.

Expand  

this is because /32 is a single IP Address and /24 would be a block of IP addresses? I don't understand how that works..

 

OK.. so now I have a DHCP server, giving out addresses 192.168.100.10 through 192.168.100.100.

Now no matter which WiFi network I get on, I can get out to the internet, which is good, but both networks can see devices in the trusted network.

 

How do I stop this?

Ooops...Completely forgot the firewall rules.

 

I added 2 rules.. an allow all, and a deny access to the trusted network, both to the Guest interface.

Do I need to add a similar deny rule to stop the trusted network being able to access the Guest network?

I can reach the pfSense administrative interface through both networks.  192.168.0.1 on the trusted network and 192.168.100.1 on the guest network.

Is there a way to stop access to this UI from the guest network?

Yeah put in a firewall rule to block it ;)

 

Normally on a guest network it would be pretty locked down..

 

Rules are evaluated top down, first rule to trigger wins, no other rules are evaluated... Post up our rules on our guest vlan interface and we can discuss

 

So what do you want to allow and what do you want to block?  If you just don't want clients to access gui.. Then put a rule above the any rule that says block dest lan address port XYZ, where xyz is the ports (or ports) via an alias that your gui is listening on.

 

example, if your gui just running on 80 (http)

example.thumb.png.7803110dc3e73282ac1f4b02f3583b23.png

 

Keep in mind that such rules would allow guest to actually hit your gui via your wan IP..

 

You could do something like this

otherblocks.thumb.png.51b83a10b4f6cb4e0fc82f1f32c02b86.png

 

So you allow guest to "ping" pfsense guest address. So client can validate they have connectivity to the gateway.

 

But then any other access to firewall is blocked - all IPs, lan, guest, optX, wan, etc.. "this firewall" is a drop down option for dest.

 

This would require clients to be using some outside dns - which is what you normally hand "guest" clients anyway - say 8.8.8.8 for example.

 

Or you could allow clients to use pfsense guest IP for dns and ping - but block all other access

icmpdnswlabels.thumb.png.1ae6bbf33a892c38c2084204340339a9.png

 

Given that when I show "test" on my screenshots you would use your "guest" ;)

 

Since this is local network and not public internet you might want to use "reject" vs just block.. This will tell the client F Off!! Vs letting the client keep trying with retrans, waiting and retrans again.. Client will get told instantly sorry blocked!

reject.thumb.png.37dfce04439b8e59d7d29d33953c019a.png

 

While reject is normally good for your local networks.. You would normally not want to reject any blocks you do from the internet.. Just block (drop) them.. Vs sending any sort of response.

 

This topic is now closed to further replies.
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Posts

    • First thing I wondered as well. I miss the old color. I always thought it was nice how each app had its own color. Then they go and take 2 of the most commonly used apps and give them the same color.
    • We humans have to pass tests and get licenses to be considered safe to drive a car, but Tesla can just go "Trust me bro". Gotta' love it. ]
    • Last Chance to download The Inclusion Equation: Leveraging Data & AI (worth $21) for free by Steven Parker Claim your complimentary eBook worth $21 for free, before the offer ends today on June 24. The Inclusion Equation is a comprehensive, one-of-a-kind guide to merging DEI and employee wellbeing concepts with data analytics and AI. In this book, renowned thought leader and professional keynote speaker Dr. Serena Huang explains exactly how to quantify the effectiveness of new talent strategies by connecting them to a firm ROI estimate, enabling readers to approach and win the favor of higher-ups in any organization with the same effectiveness that marketing and financial departments do. This book is written in a style that is appealing and accessible to all readers regardless of technical background, but with enough depth to provide real insight and strategies. Dr. Serena H. Huang distills her 10 years of Fortune 500 people analytics leadership experience into tools and framework you can leverage to measure and improve DEI and wellbeing in your workplace. Some of the topics explored in this book include: Attract and retain top talent, including Gen Z and Millennials, with tailored DEI and wellbeing strategies Quantifying not only a talent strategy's perceived initial effect on an organization, but also its improvement and expansion over time Turning DEI and wellbeing from illusive corporate concepts to quantifiable metrics Harness the power of AI to create synchronized DEI and wellbeing strategies that maximize ROI Getting serious attention from your CEO and CFO by quantifying HR initiatives Using data storytelling to demonstrate the business impact of DEI and wellbeing Preparing for the future by understanding the role of AI in creating an inclusive and healthy workplace The Inclusion Equation is a complete guide for DEI and wellbeing, covering getting started in measurement to using storytelling to influence leadership. This is the contemporary playbook for any organization intending to substantially improve their diversity, equity, inclusion, and employee wellbeing by leveraging data & AI. This book is also perfect for any data analytics professionals who want to understand how to apply analytics to issues that keep their CEOs up at night. Whether you are a data expert or data novice, as long as you are serious about improving DEI and wellbeing, this book is for you. This free to download offer expires June 24. How to get it Please ensure you read the terms and conditions to claim this offer. Complete and verifiable information is required in order to receive this free offer. If you have previously made use of these free offers, you will not need to re-register. While supplies last! Download The Inclusion Equation: Leveraging Data & AI (worth $21) for free Offered by Wiley, view other free resources The below offers are also available for free in exchange for your (work) email: Last Chance: Excel Quick and Easy ($12 Value) FREE – Expires 6/24 Last Chance: The Inclusion Equation: Leveraging Data & AI ($21 Value) FREE – Expires 6/24 Microsoft 365 Copilot At Work ($60 Value) FREE – Expires 6/25 Natural Language Processing with Python ($39.99 Value) FREE – Expires 6/25 How to Engage Buyers and Drive Growth in the Age of AI ($22.95 Value) FREE – Expires 7/1 Using Artificial Intelligence to Save the World ($30.00 Value) FREE – Expires 7/1 Essential: How Distributed Teams, Generative AI, [...] ($18.00 Value) FREE – Expires 7/2 The Chief AI Officer's Handbook: Master AI leadership with strategies to innovate, overcome challenges, and drive business growth ($9.99 Value) FREE for a Limited Time – Expires 7/2 The Ultimate Linux Newbie Guide – Featured Free content Python Notes for Professionals – Featured Free content Learn Linux in 5 Days – Featured Free content Quick Reference Guide for Cybersecurity – Featured Free content We post these because we earn commission on each lead so as not to rely solely on advertising, which many of our readers block. It all helps toward paying staff reporters, servers and hosting costs. Other ways to support Neowin The above deal not doing it for you, but still want to help? Check out the links below. Check out our partner software in the Neowin Store Buy a T-shirt at Neowin's Threadsquad Subscribe to Neowin - for $14 a year, or $28 a year for an ad-free experience Disclosure: An account at Neowin Deals is required to participate in any deals powered by our affiliate, StackCommerce. For a full description of StackCommerce's privacy guidelines, go here. Neowin benefits from shared revenue of each sale made through the branded deals site.
    • I knew it had to be fan art because it actually looked pretty cool.
  • Recent Achievements

    • Dedicated
      Parallax Abstraction earned a badge
      Dedicated
    • First Post
      956400 earned a badge
      First Post
    • Week One Done
      davidfegan earned a badge
      Week One Done
    • First Post
      Ainajohn earned a badge
      First Post
    • Conversation Starter
      sophiaisabella32 earned a badge
      Conversation Starter
  • Popular Contributors

    1. 1
      +primortal
      593
    2. 2
      ATLien_0
      223
    3. 3
      Michael Scrip
      170
    4. 4
      +FloatingFatMan
      152
    5. 5
      Som
      135
  • Tell a friend

    Love Neowin? Tell a friend!