Is my new HDD dying/defective?


Recommended Posts

One month ago I bought WD60EFPX disk and installed it into UGREEN US222 enclosure, ran SMARTS test + read/write test with Victoria. Everything was looking good so I started filling it up with content till I had 1.5 TB free space left.

Two days ago on a quiet night I noticed that it sounds a bit too loud for my liking and as if it's working harder just to read files, as in I'd just open a folder/file and would hear HDD clacking. I redid the SMART tests and Victoria read test (all came back great), the disk itself also seems to be working perfectly fine, but I'm somewhat paranoid (and very nervous since it's my only storage and I can't just backup the files willy nilly) and maybe it was always sounding like that and I just didn't notice, so I'd really appreciate if someone could tell me if it the sounds are normal or not.

Recorded during unpacking a zip file on said HDD - please turn up the sound (sorry for bad mic)

And this was recorded while running a short SMART self-test with Kitfox, this is definitely not normal, right? What is causing these sounds?

 

Link to comment
https://www.neowin.net/forum/topic/1465365-is-my-new-hdd-dyingdefective/
Share on other sites

I think you're just being paranoid. HDDs always make sounds, as they have moving parts. That doesn't sound like a bad sound.

As long as SMART isn't seeing any faults, I wouldn't worry about it.

As I was always taught, have your files always in 3 places. In your system, and a backup on separate drive stocked up on the shelf, and one away from your house, cloud or a friends house.

  • Like 3
On 12/04/2026 at 02:29, Mindovermaster said:

I think you're just being paranoid. HDDs always make sounds, as they have moving parts. That doesn't sound like a bad sound.

As long as SMART isn't seeing any faults, I wouldn't worry about it.

As I was always taught, have your files always in 3 places. In your system, and a backup on separate drive stocked up on the shelf, and one away from your house, cloud or a friends house.

Even the second video's sound? It sounds like a grinder, I don't even know what could possibly make that sound normally.

On 11/04/2026 at 18:57, Doomsayeragain said:

Even the second video's sound? It sounds like a grinder, I don't even know what could possibly make that sound normally.

Your stomach? :laugh: 

I think it has more to do with the enclosure if it is too loud. I can't see in the second video if the HDD is in the enclosure or not (too dark).

Outside of the enclosure is also going to be loud, normally HDDs are built inside computers or an enclosure which absorbs some of the sound HDDs make.

If the S.M.A.R.T test passed, then it is not dying.

  • Like 3
Posted (edited)
On 12/04/2026 at 13:03, Steven P. said:

I think it has more to do with the enclosure if it is too loud. I can't see in the second video if the HDD is in the enclosure or not (too dark).

Outside of the enclosure is also going to be loud, normally HDDs are built inside computers or an enclosure which absorbs some of the sound HDDs make.

If the S.M.A.R.T test passed, then it is not dying.

Yeah, sorry, forgot to add - it's in UGREEN US222 enclosure always.
I don't mind the noise itself or the loudness of NAS drives, I'm just afraid that it shouldn't be making THOSE particular noises, it sounds like a grindstone and not like the usual popcorn machine.

SMART is seeing no faults, neither short nor extended, but I was told that SMART is VERY unreliable when it comes to predicting failure so that's why I'm panicking.

On 12/04/2026 at 14:45, Doomsayeragain said:

SMART is seeing no faults, neither short nor extended, but I was told that SMART is VERY unreliable when it comes to predicting failure so that's why I'm panicking.

I am pretty sure WD has their own disk checking tool, yeah they do here: https://support-en.wd.com/app/answers/detailweb/a_id/51537/~/download%2C-install%2C-test-drive-and-erase-using-western-digital-kitfox

Can't get better than that 😛 

On 12/04/2026 at 19:55, Steven P. said:

I am pretty sure WD has their own disk checking tool, yeah they do here: https://support-en.wd.com/app/answers/detailweb/a_id/51537/~/download%2C-install%2C-test-drive-and-erase-using-western-digital-kitfox

Can't get better than that 😛 

Yeah I know, the sound I linked was happening during short SMART test using that very same tool you linked.

Hello,


Can you attach the hard disk drive directly to your computer via SATA and then re-run the tests without the intervening USB enclosure?  Are the results any different if you perform the test that way?

Regards,

Aryeh Goretsky
 

  • Like 1

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Posts

    • A coalition of publishers sued OpenAI and Microsoft over scraping content without consent by Hamid Ganji Image via Depositphotos.com AI companies often rely on readily available internet content to train their chatbots and provide users with instant answers. This method of AI training is fast and relatively inexpensive, but using a website’s content without permission or compensation is not something publishers like to see, and this is exactly why Microsoft and OpenAI are now being sued. As reported by Bloomberg, a group of publishers that collectively own nearly 400 newspapers has filed a lawsuit against OpenAI and Microsoft. The coalition argues that the two companies scraped their content to build AI chatbots like ChatGPT and Copilot without paying any compensation. The complaint, filed in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York, argues that while AI products have generated billions of dollars in market value using publishers’ work, none of that value has been shared with the publishers. The plaintiffs are seeking statutory damages and injunctive relief for alleged copyright infringement and violations of the Digital Millennium Copyright Act. “Defendants systematically and secretly crawled the Publishers’ websites—including content behind paywalls and other access restrictions—and copied the Publishers’ articles, stories, and other original works onto their own servers without authorization,” the complaint states. The publishers also described the AI boom as a “death knell for local journalism” if AI companies that scrape content for free are not held accountable. Former New Jersey Attorney General Matthew Platkin and his law firm, Platkin LLP, are representing the publishers. “Our models empower innovation, are trained on publicly available data, and are grounded in fair use,” OpenAI spokesperson Drew Pusateri told Bloomberg. This is not the first lawsuit involving the unauthorized use of publishers’ content by AI firms, but it is one of the largest coalitions ever formed against the free use of content by AI chatbots. In 2024, OpenAI and Microsoft also faced a similar lawsuit from eight newspapers that claimed AI products were benefiting from their content without permission.
    • Rufus alternative Ventoy now supports Windows 11's mandatory update, fixes major boot bug by Sayan Sen While Microsoft has its own official Media Creation Tool used for making bootable USB media, there are some popular third-party utilities as well which offer additional options like bypassing system requirements, Microsoft Account creation, and more. One of these is Ventoy, and the software has received its latest update today. In fact, the app actually got a slew of updates over the last couple of days, three version releases in total, to be specific. The first release, version 1.1.13, was pulled as there was some unspecified error in the update, and as such, the corrected version 1.1.14 was pushed out. Following that on very short notice, 1.1.15 was published as well. For those unfamiliar, Ventoy is an open-source utility that lets users create a bootable USB drive once and then simply copy ISO, WIM, IMG, VHD, or EFI files onto it without repeatedly formatting the drive. It supports both legacy BIOS and UEFI boot modes, Secure Boot, and a wide range of operating systems, making it one of the most versatile tools in the category. The biggest change in version 1.1.14 is an updated Secure Boot shim file aimed at resolving the UEFI CA 2023 issue, which is basically a compatibility problem that has affected Secure Boot environments on some systems. If you recall, we reported about severe boot issues on HP devices following the release of updated Secure Boot 2023 keys. For anyone who may not be aware, back in early 2024, Microsoft announced that it was updating Secure Boot keys as they were going to become 15 years old in 2026, which is also when they are set to expire. As such, the new 2023 certificates have been rolling out with the newest Windows 11 updates. Updated boot manager and Secure Boot certificates are crucial for protection against malware like bootkits. These are mandatory updates. Alongside that, the VentoyPlugson graphical plugin configurator was updated in sync with the release. The update also introduces a new VTOY_SECURE_BOOT_POLICY option within the Global Control plugin, giving users more flexibility in managing Secure Boot behavior. Ventoy has also received a fix for a startup issue when Secure Boot was disabled. Microsoft does officially allow users to boot systems without Secure Boot as long as the PC is Secure Boot capable. The full changelog is given below: Update secure boot shim file to solve the UEFI CA 2023 issue. The new release use a new CA, so you need to enroll the new key for the first boot time. VentoyPlugson update synchronously. Global control plugin add a VTOY_SECURE_BOOT_POLICY option. Fix the boot issue when Secure Boot is disabled in the UEFI firmware. You can download the latest version of the app here on Ventoy's official GitHub repo or from Neowin software stories.
    • Windows 11 is fine, no issues on any of the machines I've run it on since release. The stricter security requirements are a good thing, sometimes the baseline needs to change and people will winge, but it is what it is. Happened with the move from 9x to NT - broke compatability Happened with XP SP2 when security started to become a serious consideration Certainly happend with Vista that brought in UAC, the concept of not running as admin (something that has been the norm in Linux/Unix from pretty much the start) and a completely new driver stack. Windows 11 will probably get looked back at as the point where even consumer and SMB IT was dragged kicking and screaming into a somewhat secure by default configuration.
    • Bluestacks has been emulating Android on Windows for fifteen years. It's janky and riddled with ads though, so WSA looked like it was going to be a huge improvement over the emulator experience. Too bad Microsoft dropped the ball on that.
    • Classic. China would be nothing without Western, Japanese, and South Korean technology.
  • Recent Achievements

    • Rookie
      krychek57 went up a rank
      Rookie
    • Grand Master
      Jaybonaut went up a rank
      Grand Master
    • One Year In
      Philsl earned a badge
      One Year In
    • Dedicated
      Scoobystu earned a badge
      Dedicated
    • First Post
      Tom Schmidt earned a badge
      First Post
  • Popular Contributors

    1. 1
      +primortal
      441
    2. 2
      +Edouard
      172
    3. 3
      PsYcHoKiLLa
      134
    4. 4
      Michael Scrip
      78
    5. 5
      Xenon
      77
  • Tell a friend

    Love Neowin? Tell a friend!