Is my new HDD dying/defective?

By Doomsayeragain
in Hardware Hangout

 Share

Recommended Posts

Neowinian

Doomsayeragain

Posted
Posted

One month ago I bought WD60EFPX disk and installed it into UGREEN US222 enclosure, ran SMARTS test + read/write test with Victoria. Everything was looking good so I started filling it up with content till I had 1.5 TB free space left.

Two days ago on a quiet night I noticed that it sounds a bit too loud for my liking and as if it's working harder just to read files, as in I'd just open a folder/file and would hear HDD clacking. I redid the SMART tests and Victoria read test (all came back great), the disk itself also seems to be working perfectly fine, but I'm somewhat paranoid (and very nervous since it's my only storage and I can't just backup the files willy nilly) and maybe it was always sounding like that and I just didn't notice, so I'd really appreciate if someone could tell me if it the sounds are normal or not.

Recorded during unpacking a zip file on said HDD - please turn up the sound (sorry for bad mic)

And this was recorded while running a short SMART self-test with Kitfox, this is definitely not normal, right? What is causing these sounds?

 

Link to comment
https://www.neowin.net/forum/topic/1465365-is-my-new-hdd-dyingdefective/
Share on other sites
Grand Master

Mindovermaster Global Moderator

Posted
  • Global Moderator
Posted

I think you're just being paranoid. HDDs always make sounds, as they have moving parts. That doesn't sound like a bad sound.

As long as SMART isn't seeing any faults, I wouldn't worry about it.

As I was always taught, have your files always in 3 places. In your system, and a backup on separate drive stocked up on the shelf, and one away from your house, cloud or a friends house.

  • Doomsayeragain, xrobwx71 and Steven P.
  • Like 3
Neowinian

Doomsayeragain

Posted
  • Author
Posted
On 12/04/2026 at 02:29, Mindovermaster said:

I think you're just being paranoid. HDDs always make sounds, as they have moving parts. That doesn't sound like a bad sound.

As long as SMART isn't seeing any faults, I wouldn't worry about it.

As I was always taught, have your files always in 3 places. In your system, and a backup on separate drive stocked up on the shelf, and one away from your house, cloud or a friends house.

Even the second video's sound? It sounds like a grinder, I don't even know what could possibly make that sound normally.

Grand Master

Mindovermaster Global Moderator

Posted
  • Global Moderator
Posted
On 11/04/2026 at 18:57, Doomsayeragain said:

Even the second video's sound? It sounds like a grinder, I don't even know what could possibly make that sound normally.

Your stomach? :laugh: 

Grand Master

Steven P. Administrators

Posted
  • Administrators
Posted

I think it has more to do with the enclosure if it is too loud. I can't see in the second video if the HDD is in the enclosure or not (too dark).

Outside of the enclosure is also going to be loud, normally HDDs are built inside computers or an enclosure which absorbs some of the sound HDDs make.

If the S.M.A.R.T test passed, then it is not dying.

  • xrobwx71, Rigby and Doomsayeragain
  • Like 3
Neowinian

Doomsayeragain

Posted
  • Author
Posted (edited)
On 12/04/2026 at 13:03, Steven P. said:

I think it has more to do with the enclosure if it is too loud. I can't see in the second video if the HDD is in the enclosure or not (too dark).

Outside of the enclosure is also going to be loud, normally HDDs are built inside computers or an enclosure which absorbs some of the sound HDDs make.

If the S.M.A.R.T test passed, then it is not dying.

Yeah, sorry, forgot to add - it's in UGREEN US222 enclosure always.
I don't mind the noise itself or the loudness of NAS drives, I'm just afraid that it shouldn't be making THOSE particular noises, it sounds like a grindstone and not like the usual popcorn machine.

SMART is seeing no faults, neither short nor extended, but I was told that SMART is VERY unreliable when it comes to predicting failure so that's why I'm panicking.

Grand Master

Steven P. Administrators

Posted
  • Administrators
Posted
On 12/04/2026 at 14:45, Doomsayeragain said:

SMART is seeing no faults, neither short nor extended, but I was told that SMART is VERY unreliable when it comes to predicting failure so that's why I'm panicking.

I am pretty sure WD has their own disk checking tool, yeah they do here: https://support-en.wd.com/app/answers/detailweb/a_id/51537/~/download%2C-install%2C-test-drive-and-erase-using-western-digital-kitfox

Can't get better than that 😛 

Neowinian

Doomsayeragain

Posted
  • Author
Posted
On 12/04/2026 at 19:55, Steven P. said:

I am pretty sure WD has their own disk checking tool, yeah they do here: https://support-en.wd.com/app/answers/detailweb/a_id/51537/~/download%2C-install%2C-test-drive-and-erase-using-western-digital-kitfox

Can't get better than that 😛 

Yeah I know, the sound I linked was happening during short SMART test using that very same tool you linked.

Grand Master

goretsky Supervisor

Posted
  • Supervisor
Posted

Hello,


Can you attach the hard disk drive directly to your computer via SATA and then re-run the tests without the intervening USB enclosure?  Are the results any different if you perform the test that way?

Regards,

Aryeh Goretsky
 

  • Doomsayeragain
  • Like 1

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share
Go to topic listing

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.

  • Posts

    • PowerToys is getting a new window management utility

      By TarasBuria · Posted

      PowerToys is getting a new window management utility by Taras Buria If you use PowerToys on Windows 11 or 10, you probably know that the app has quite a few utilities for window management. Fancy Zones, Always on Top, Crop and Lock, just to name a few. Soon, Microsoft will add another one, and fans of Alt + Tab should be excited. Proposed by Clint Rutkas, the module has a very simple idea: use a keyboard shortcut to toggle between windows within one app. For example, if you have four browser windows open, Alt + ` will let you switch between them just like Alt + Tab switches between all running apps. Here is the utility description from its GitHub pull request: Like other PowerToys utilities, Alt Window Cycle will offer shortcut customization. You will be able to use default shortcuts (Alt + ` for the next window or Alt + Shift + ` for the previous one) or remap them to something else. For now, there is no information on when Alt Window Cycle will arrive, so we will have to wait for the next PowerToys feature update (Microsoft usually pushes them on a monthly basis). Recently, Microsoft released version 0.100, which reworked the shortcuts guide, introduced an extension gallery for Command Palette, and more. Shortly after, version 0.100.1 arrived as a bug-fixing update. PowerToys is available on Windows 10 and 11, and you can get the app from the official GitHub repository, the Microsoft Store, or winget. Although Windows 10 is no longer supported, PowerToys developers currently do not plan to drop the now-unsupported operating system. And with Microsoft giving Windows 10 one more year in the Extended Security Update, you can expect PowerToys to remain available on Windows 10 for quite a while.
    • Politically funny images of the World

      By +primortal · Posted

    • The official Funny Pictures thread

      By +primortal · Posted

    • Sony announces Bungie layoffs that will affect "significant number of employees"

      By daryld · Posted

      This is sadly what happens when a company tries to become political and focus on agendas outside gaming, the constant push of inclusivity and whatever the current thing was and box ticking, instead of simply focusing on what was a great game to many myself included, massive let down that a once great game company has ended up this way hopefully this will be a lesson to game devs from here on in to leave politics and agendas out of gaming
    • Microsoft raises Xbox console prices by up to $150, discontinues 2TB version

      By Figure 8 Dash · Posted

      Prices for consumer electronic stink and will continue to stink for quite some time. If you're at all hesitant, just buy now because it's not getting better. (or buy used and save even more cash)

  • Recent Achievements

    • First Post
      kinowa earned a badge
      First Post
    • Rookie
      krychek57 went up a rank
      Rookie
    • Grand Master
      Jaybonaut went up a rank
      Grand Master
    • One Year In
      Philsl earned a badge
      One Year In
    • Dedicated
      Scoobystu earned a badge
      Dedicated

  • Popular Contributors

    1. 1
      +primortal
      409
    2. 2
      +Edouard
      168
    3. 3
      PsYcHoKiLLa
      132
    4. 4
      Xenon
      73
    5. 5
      Michael Scrip
      73
    Show More

  • Tell a friend

    Love Neowin? Tell a friend!