Fragmaster from PHL has quit

[LOC Veteran]

Unbelievable

I have a feeling Valve, or hell even Gamespy may take it down fairly quickly. I saved a local copy so if they do, just ask here.

Here's an small portion:

Now, I could go on and on, talking about Steam, all the screw-ups with Counter-Strike: Condition Zero (I mean, JESUS, how do you declare a game GOLD, say it's FINISHED, and then not ship it until NEARLY SIX MONTHS LATER?), how Valve has messed up their relationships with Ritual, Gearbox, Vivendi (do you think Vivendi is a big fan of Steam?), and ATI... I could point out all the things Valve said they'd do but didn't, like releasing the HL2 benchmark or the SDK. I could whine on and on about how maddening it is to get flooded by mails from people complaining about how people can't play Half-Life anymore thanks to Steam or how Valve's customer support is non-existent. But the bottom line is this: I am not a fan of Valve anymore. I don't believe a damn thing they say and I'm sick of their bull****.

[Paganash]

Read that post about an hour ago - it is hands-down the greatest disgruntled employee letter I've ever read. I wrote a similarly toned resignation letter to Books*A*Million a few years ago, so I know how he feels. More power to ya, Fragmaster! :woot:

[b3njo]

nice read, and shocking too!

[Maxious]

omfg valve is going down for that. for those who are yet to read it, fragmaster breaks the nda he had with valve, and confirms that (quote) " a lot of the things Valve showed in the E3 demo were misrepresented. "

absolutely shocking, the repercusions for gamespy as a company are going to be interesting....

[HappyCar]

whoa! WHOA! stupid valve

good find, nice read

But still, where's HL2?

[LOC Veteran]

Well no, he didn't break the NDA with Valve, he had an NDA with Prima for a strategy guide they were working on for HL2. But since he quit that, and Gamespy he isn't bound by it anymore and can say what he wants. He certainly did heh.

[Prophecy]

Ya know? Im not a huge fan of HL however I do keep up with the news and I must say I honestly applaud this man for standing up and speaking the truth rather than feeding the public Valves BS. I have been dissapointed by Valves PR and the way they just lie to people.

Its sad that big companies like that could care less because in the end people will still buy that damn game so they dont care. They wont ever apologize, they will just make up another execuse.

Proph

[Chode]

I just logged on to post that exact same thing....

This makes me sad....a man who is pretty much "Half Life Fan #1" losing the faith.

:cry:

I hope his reservations are misplaced....but I'm a doubting Thomas :(

The editorial reads:

--------------------------------

Now that I'm leaving PlanetHalfLife and resigning as Site Director, I'd like to be a drama queen, burn a bridge or two, and possibly maybe explain a few things. I apologize in advance the incoherence of this babbling, but it's not like you're being forced to read this crap.

I started PHL in 1998, just after Half-Life hit store shelves. Half-Life: Day One absolutely blew me away. It was incredible. The full game was even better. I loved everything about Half-Life and I threw myself into the community. I made maps, I wrote horrible fan fiction (Walter's World), I spent hours playing HLDM (mostly on Gasworks). Half-Life is easily one of the best games of all-time (well, IMHO, at least) and nothing will ever change that.

I reluctantly left PHL in 1999 due to my increasing workload. During my first stint at PHL, I was mildly irked by things like the TFC delay, PowerPlay, and the confusion over TF2 (it's an expansion pack! Oh wait, it's not!), but these were just minor inconveniences and as whole I liked the way Valve did business. Their support of the mod community in those early days is the reason why Half-Life is still so popular today.

I quit GameSpy in 2000 and came back in mid-2002. When I took over PHL again, things had changed. Half-Life was clearly past its prime. Valve clearly wasn't the same company it once was.

In early April 2003, Half-Life 2 rumors started to leak out. Print magazines were given the exclusive on all Half-Life 2 information and online sites weren't allowed to post screenshots or previews until 5/8/03. I felt this was a pretty stupid thing to do -- forcing people to jump through hoops and hunt down low-quality, blurry magazine scans to get a glimpse of the sequel they've been waiting five years for -- but hey, that's just my opinion and I'm obviously biased about the viability of the print medium. Valve's doing essentially the same thing again this year; print mags saw HL2 awhile back and that information will start trickling out shortly.

I sat in on the first demonstration of HL2 at E3 2003 and was pretty damn impressed. When Gabe said that the game was coming out 9/30/03, I totally believed it. My interest in Half-Life had begun to wane, but that demo rekindled my interest in PHL in a huge way.

Two months later, things started to get complicated. In mid-July I heard from multiple reliable sources that Half-Life 2 wasn't going to make 9/30/03. Then I got hold of pretty conclusive evidence that Valve's Doug Lombardi had flat out told print magazines (off the record, of course) to plan on pushing their reviews of Half-Life 2 back to the Holiday issues. Then in late July, Vivendi announced that Half-Life 2 would be delayed to the holidays. Since I knew the delay was coming, I jumped right on this and confidently reported it as fact.

Unfortunately Valve -- for whatever reason -- refused to own up to the fact that Half-Life 2 was going to be delayed. Gabe made that ridiculous "First time I've heard about this" response, and other sites overreacted and assumed that this meant that Vivendi's announcement was a mistake. This situation was further complicated by Vivendi's backtracking: after Valve essentially refused to confirm the delay news, Vivendi was forced to (kind of) retract their original delay announcement. So tons of people incorrectly assumed this meant HL2 was still coming out on time.

At this point, I was stuck: I knew Half-Life 2 was going to be delayed, and instead of backing down and keeping my mouth shut, I kept (loudly) proclaiming that HL2 was going to miss 9/30 while other sites kept reporting the exact opposite, This was very frustrating, and if you were around during this period of time, you'll recall that I was acting like a real jerk. And to be fair to these other sites, they were being fed rather misleading information.

Most of the above stuff I already talked about in this editorial from September, but there's one key piece of information I left out: In August, I made a mistake. I was recruited to work on Prima's Half-Life 2 Behind the Scenes book and signed an NDA. Now I was privy to all sorts of Half-Life 2 information and quickly became 100% sure the game was going to slip, but thanks to the NDA, I couldn't say a damn thing about any of it. This was INCREDIBLY frustrating. I haven't even mentioned I was (emphasis on was) working on the book until now, and even then I only mention it because word leaked out on some other forums recently and there's no point in denying it.

In late August at ECTS, Valve's Doug Lombardi and Greg Coomer were both quoted as saying that the 9/30 release date was still happening. Lombardi told a co-worker of mine, to his face, that the game was still coming out September 30th worldwide. Some would call this marketing, but I'd call it lying.

I visited Valve in early September to conduct interviews for the Behind the Scenes book. It was quite a bit of fun, but I was a little disturbed by a few things. I won't get into the specifics, but information wasn't matching up. Things said during the E3 demo turned out to be either misleading or untrue, for example. I don't want to say exactly what kind of state the game was in when I was there, but you'll recall that when other fan sites visited Valve later that month (BEFORE the source code leak, even), they were unable to see the game. Now, if the game was in a playable state and supposedly ready to go gold within a couple of days, don't you think they would have shown it off?

Then the source code leak happened. I feel sorry for Valve that this happened because there's a possibility this could have a slightly negative on HL2 once it's finally released, but they really should have taken more precautions in the network security department. At first, Valve claimed that only 1/3rd of the source code was stolen, but once people compiled working versions of the game, well...

The Anonymous Leaker, despite being an ###### such as myself, was basically correct. HL2 wasn't nearly as far along as Valve was hinting at, and a lot of the things Valve showed in the E3 demo were misrepresented. Did he really release all the work Valve had done on HL2? To be honest, I don't know for sure. It's a possibility. Valve certainly made little effort to dispute his claims.

Valve didn't announce that Half-Life 2 would be delayed until 9/23. This, to me, was inexcusable. It takes ten minutes to send out an email.

OK, now you may be saying, "so what, why are you still crying about things that happened last year?" I think it's important to reiterate this story because it shows what kind of company Valve is. I don't feel they respect the community. If they did, they would have just confirmed Vivendi's delay announcement in July instead of stringing people along.

Where is Half-Life 2 now? Beats me. I haven't kept up with the past 5-6 months of development and E3 is coming up anyway, so you'll see for yourself. I do know that content has been cut from the game in an attempt to get it to ship sooner. Will it ship this year? I guess there's a 50/50 chance, but keep in mind that this is the same company that took three years to add bots to a mod they didn't even make and slap it in a box.

Now, I could go on and on, talking about Steam, all the screw-ups with Counter-Strike: Condition Zero (I mean, JESUS, how do you declare a game GOLD, say it's FINISHED, and then not ship it until NEARLY SIX MONTHS LATER?), how Valve has messed up their relationships with Ritual, Gearbox, Vivendi (do you think Vivendi is a big fan of Steam?), and ATI... I could point out all the things Valve said they'd do but didn't, like releasing the HL2 benchmark or the SDK. I could whine on and on about how maddening it is to get flooded by mails from people complaining about how people can't play Half-Life anymore thanks to Steam or how Valve's customer support is non-existent. But the bottom line is this: I am not a fan of Valve anymore. I don't believe a damn thing they say and I'm sick of their bull****.

Valve needs to learn how to properly communicate with their online fan base and treat their fans with respect. That means not telling your fans 7 days before the ship date that HL2 is delayed. That means not giving out vague "oh HL2 will be released this summer and by the way we didn't say summer of what year and it's always summer somewhere in the world so who knows LOL we'll see!" answers to direct questions. That means not streaming a couple hundred megs of cache files to Steam user's hard drives without their permission or knowledge.

I feel most of the problems at Valve are due to the ineptitude of one individual in particular. I'm not going to name names, but you can probably guess who I'm talking about. This person is easily the worst person I've ever met during my time within the "video game industry," and that's saying a lot, considering that this business is filled with superstar jerkwads like... well... me. I don't feel that he does his job properly, and he isn't what I'd consider to be a decent, trustworthy, or moral human being.

Plus, Valve has gone over my head a couple of times and interfered (or attempted to interfere) with the content of this site, which I think is pretty sad. Forum posts of mine have been deleted on their orders and I've been forced to edit news posts because Valve didn't care for the information or opinions I was sharing. I'm sure they'll complain about this post and attempt to get it yanked, but I don't care.

Don't get me wrong, Valve has some of the most talented developers in the industry. Some really great people who I respect immensely work there. It's a shame that most of these guys have been working hard for years on projects that have yet to see the light of day. There are just a few bad apples spoiling the soup. Or something.

Oh man, this is possibly the most scary, convoluted thing I've ever written. ANYWAYS, it's obvious that I have no business running a site like PlanetHalfLife when it's obvious this crap has made me CRAZY INSANE, so it's time to give up my silly little crusade of constantly telling people that they're wrong and turn the site over to more professional management with a better attitude and perspective than myself. Jabberwocky will be taking over PHL and I'm sure you'll see plenty of other new faces on the site as well.

A few more things: First, I'd like to publicly apologize to Pratt for a comment I made in the forums which seemed to imply that he wasn't reporting news properly. I was wrong, and he has the right idea. Secondly, I'd like to thank the HL2.net forums for their... enthusiasm... and some of the most hilarious things I've ever read. I'll never forget that thread where somebody compared me to Hitler for saying that Half-Life 2 would be delayed last year. Lastly, I'd like to thank all the PHL readers who have put up with the peculiar brand of garbage I've been dishing out the past couple years and for suffering through those "funny" flash movies of mine.

Half-Life 2 will almost certainly be a great game once it's released and I can't wait to play it. Be patient, don't believe everything you read, think for yourself, and remember that history has a habit of repeating itself. Repeating itself. Repeating itself. THE END.

- Fragmaster

Chode - I emphasise that I am not revelling/finding enjoyment in this. I truly find it sad.... this is comparable to Neobond/Redmak saying we are a bunch of n00bs and leaving here forever :(

[Lingwo]

I think everyone is losing faith in Valve as the only time they ever speak about HL2 is either to repeat themselves or hit us with a disapointment, I think fragmaster shoulda held on cause end of month a few UK Magazines are going to have big features on HL2 and playtests (well PC Zone anyway).

Its nice to see a big name in the Half-Life Community to speak his mind, which most us would like to say but not get noticed.

[machima]

Fragmaster has always been a whining idiot, even before HL2.

[Toxicfume Veteran]

Like I have said before and been flamed for by the members here on Neowin itself: Valve has been messing things up since release of that stupid pile of crap called Steam. Worst software ever.

I bet those people finally understand me now. :rolleyes:

Applauds to the man. (Y)

[machima]

Like I have said before and been flamed for by the members here on Neowin itself: Valve has been messing things up since release of that stupid pile of crap called Steam. Worst software ever.

I bet those people finally understand me now. :rolleyes:

Applauds to the man. (Y)

There is alot worse stuff than Steam. It's worked almost flawlessly for me since the day of the 1.0 release.

[Chode]

I think everyone is losing faith in Valve as the only time they ever speak about HL2 is either to repeat themselves or hit us with a disapointment, I think fragmaster shoulda held on cause end of month a few UK Magazines are going to have big features on HL2 and playtests (well PC Zone anyway).

Its nice to see a big name in the Half-Life Community to speak his mind, which most us would like to say but not get noticed.

Good points,

although I will extend this news with another recent news item.

The editor of PC Gamer UK recently made a post on the magazine's forums regarding their forthcoming Half Life 2 article.

Seems a lot of magazines are been given a hands on look at Half Life 2. I know PC Powerplay here in Australia is one of them. The "price" for these articles is that Half Life 2 is the magazine's cover article, and also an NDA that forces them to keep quiet until April 29.

The editor of PC Gamer UK indicates that what will be new is some exclusive screenshots, which he comments on as "I don't believe they show any new levels. The levels we played are levels you've already seen in screenshots but they were great fun."

Here is the forum post in question.

- Some people are translating these comments as meaning they only played a polished version of the leaked beta.

- Some are viewing it as only been shown the same things, just new camera angles.

- Some are of the opinion that these are the only levels VALVE wanna show the public pre-release.

[Ayepecks]

Yeah, saw this... bad stuff :(

[Veedems Veteran]

There is alot worse stuff than Steam. It's worked almost flawlessly for me since the day of the 1.0 release.

Ditto. The only thing they are really screwing up badly is HL2 and it's their damn PR department that makes them look terrible.

[Ryan Versaw]

i didnt see anything too exciting about the article when i read it yesterday, but i am kinda glad that this happened. he may be a fan of half life, but he is anything but a fan of valve. it has been quite a while since he has been fit for the position he was in.