• 0

Diskeeper or PerfectDisk


Diskeeper or PerfectDisk  

330 members have voted

  1. 1. Diskeeper or PerfectDisk

    • Diskeeper
      155
    • PerfectDisk
      175


Question

I have tried both Diskeeper and PerfectDisk and I must say they both took over 24 hours to defragmentate my 130gb partition and I never really noticed much of a speed difference.

Now however I have formatted my computer and I am looking to try either Diskeeper of PerfectDisk again. So which one do you think I should go for?

Feedback would be appreciated.

P.S. This is an independant thread from the "best defrager" as I only want feedback on the above mentioned two products. So dont be giving me stick about how this question is asked at least 10 times a week.

Thanks

Martyn

Edited by Martyn
Link to comment
https://www.neowin.net/forum/topic/284633-diskeeper-or-perfectdisk/
Share on other sites

Recommended Posts

  • 0
Diskeeper I think is winning on reputation, and because one person likes it everyone follow suit.

585903744[/snapback]

yep, perfectdisk is actually much better in my opinion, it actually increases performance, diskeeper is faster but doesn't really do much and people like it because its fast, they don't realize it's not very effective.

  • 0

Yes, PerfectDisk is the way to go, just after one defrag and you feel the difference. But I've got the problem of it not being able to do boot-time defrag due to some driver startup conflicts. I'm not alone, so i presume Raxco will be releasing a new version soon :shifty:

  • 0

The built-in defrag in windows 2000/xp is great, but it doesn't defrag your registry and it takes quite a while to complete the defragging too, that's why i personally use Diskeeper to defrag my hard drive, it defrags so much quicker than the windows version.

BTW, the defragging built in windows is the "lite" version of Diskeeper ;)

  • 0

Well, I use Diskeeper 9 pro set and forget most of the time, but also have Perfectdisk 7, and use this from time to time for one or two features that Diskeeper pro does not have. For example offline defrag with Perfect disk also defreags the metadata files, which Diskeeper does not do (noticed some pink lines on the performance map after defragging with Diskeeper? chances are these are fragmented metadata files).

Diskeeper is much faster because it does not worry unduly trying to pack the files as closely as possible, Perfectdisk makes a point of doing this, and takes much longer. Using Perfect disk with the let Perfectdisk manage (recommended) option puts the files in date order, but this is not actually the most efficient; Diskeeper uses the same method as Windows XP (layout.ini in prefetch folder), putting files likely to be needed together next to each other (Perfectdisk does have that option also, but you have to change the configuration).

  • 0

Perfect Disk is not perfect. I defragged my drive with the very latest version and it did NOT make the disk contiguous:

perdisk1.png

That is after it finished. I did a second run and screen captured at 99% so you could see it in progress.

I'm not saying that Perfect Disk is not a good product, but I am expressing dismay that this program, just like all the others, seems to fail to actually do the job properly.

  • 0
Perfect Disk is not perfect.  I defragged my drive with the very latest version and it did NOT make the disk contiguous:

perdisk1.png

That is after it finished.  I did a second run and screen captured at 99% so you could see it in progress.

I'm not saying that Perfect Disk is not a good product, but I am expressing dismay that this program, just like all the others, seems to fail to actually do the job properly.

586336638[/snapback]

Did you pick aggressive free space consolidation? Also maybe alot of your programs were in use? Did you close all open programs and services associated with them, and then try again?

I haven't seen anything close to that using perfectdisk.

  • 0
Did you pick aggressive free space consolidation? Also maybe alot of your programs were in use? Did you close all open programs and services associated with them, and then try again?

I haven't seen anything close to that using perfectdisk.

You mean Smart Placement? I ran the program in default with Smart Placement. I did not adjust any other settings.

I run a really lean XP in Classic mode with almost nothing running that I can discern. I limit much in the MSCONFIG area in terms of loaded applications.

I will look for that configuration option and try again - I'm a total n00b on this app, and when I do comparisons, out of fairness I try to test default configurations first. Duplicates the users "out of box" experience, as it were.

I'll report back as updates warrant. :)

Thanks for the post.

  • 0
You mean Smart Placement?  I ran the program in default with Smart Placement.  I did not adjust any other settings.

I run a really lean XP in Classic mode with almost nothing running that I can discern.  I limit much in the MSCONFIG area in terms of loaded applications.

I will look for that configuration option and try again - I'm a total n00b on this app, and when I do comparisons, out of fairness I try to test default configurations first.  Duplicates the users "out of box" experience, as it were. 

I'll report back as updates warrant. :)

Thanks for the post.

586336717[/snapback]

If you right click on the drive pick properties, then you will see a check box "Aggressive free space consolidation..."

It's under "Online Defrag Settings" tab..

See if that helps any.

  • 0

First, thanks for the help. :)

Second, it is an odd placement for these settings.

Instead of being under TOOLS > ADVANCED CONFIGURATION menu and dialog, where all of the other key settings seem to be, these additional settings are under the DEFRAGMENT > DRIVE PROPERTIES menu and dialog, not where one would expect, I guess.

That said, the settings are nevertheless there. So, I started with this:

perdisk1.png

No matter what I did inside Windows, it would not improve, even with the Aggressive Free Space Consolidation option checked. But, when poking around the tabs, I saw the Offline Defrag Settings dialog, and decided to check it out. So, I saw these two screens when looking into the Drive Properties entry under Defragment:

perdisk2.png

perdisk3.png

Once I selected the Offline Defrag Settings and told it to defrag next time I rebooted, I ended up with this:

perdisk4.png

Which is MUCH closer to what one would expect.

So, even though the default config was lacking, the options to configure Perfect Disk sure seem to be there, just in a place I would not have looked, I guess. The key seems to be that the thing can defrag before it loads the rest of Windows XP. Since I know how to toggle that function on and off when I want to defrag, I can now configure it to provide the most thorough defrag that I can seem to locate within the program.

Just wanted to check in and do the update. Yeah, it takes a while, and yeah, you have to jump through a few hoops, but this Disk Perfect thing don't seem to be too bad. I'll poke around more and figure out the swap file / page file thing and see what up.

Thanks again for the assistance,

BK

This topic is now closed to further replies.
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Posts

    • Hello, Hope all is well. I am in UK.  
    • I'm not happy with myself for it, but I've gone and got hold of it. Just another 45 minutes and I'll be Bond, James Bond. In my defence, IO's Hitman series is awesome, and I'm a sucker for 007. So while it might seem a bit simplified compared to Hitman, I'm sure I'll be right at home.
    • Or just check the script yourself ^^. I hate having a Microsoft account tied to my windows install.
    • 007 First Light review: Satisfying spy adventure that James Bond needed by Pulasthi Ariyasinghe I have fond memories of classic James Bond games from the Electronic Arts era. Using high-tech gadgets, sneaking into parties, and dispatching bad guys were wildly exciting activities for my younger self. In recent years, Bond games have entirely disappeared, alongside the super spy genre. Fast forward to 2020, imagine my surprise when IO Interactive announced it had secured the Bond IP to make a game. Considering the studio’s Hitman history, this project is one I keenly kept an eye on. Six years later, 007 First Light is finally here, and after spending time inside this globe-trotting adventure, I can safely say that my excitement for this developer’s take on this universe was not unfounded. IO has taken lessons it has learned from Hitman and combined them with what I would expect from a directed cinematic experience like James Bond. I have refrained from mentioning major plot points to save you from story spoilers in this review. This is an original story that doesn’t tie into any movies, so there isn’t an expectation of knowing the backstory or the decades of movies either. Bond, James Bond When 007 First Light begins, Bond is just Bond. There isn’t a spy angle, fancy gadgets, or even a secret mission. The introductory mission is framed to show how James Bond handled himself and how he does not care about the odds when it comes to saving lives. It’s a gorgeous level as well, showing off an island scattered with cliffs in the middle of a storm. Looking back, this is probably the best-looking level in the game, with IO showing off all its abilities with its custom engine, Glacier. But my favorite ended up being the follow-up to this level. Once the United Kingdom's foreign intelligence agency, MI6, recruits our daring youngster into its super-spy “00” program, training begins. However, instead of treading through the same tutorial missions where the game teaches you to run and jump and drive, IO opted for a montage, and it’s amazing. The scenes cut between Bond practicing and improving his marksmanship, parkour, hand-to-hand combat, and driving as weeks go by in his training. What impressed me here was the lack of any loading screens or stutters as scenes instantly switched to different locations entirely, as if I was watching a movie. This creativity is a trend I noticed in most levels, where there is some sort of gameplay or choreography mechanic being introduced to keep things interesting. Soon, the rest of the cast is introduced, bringing other agents that our favorite secret agent will be working with, the scientists and engineers that build MI6’s spy gadgets, as well as higher-ranking officers that either appreciate or (at best) tolerate Bond’s rebellious attitude. It’s a tight cast, all with incredibly good voice acting and personalities that quickly grew on me. The casting for Bond himself is also an excellent one. From showing his iconic soft spot for women to the condescending smiles that get a rise out of enemies, I had no issues getting immersed into this universe as this new face of James Bond. The missions take place in a wide range of locations as MI6 sends Bond to tackle dangers that are growing everywhere from the UK to Africa. These aren’t unrelated adventures where MI6 is sending secret agents, which is an angle I would love to see in another game, but a part of a bigger conspiracy affecting the entire world. Some of the twists and turns were all too predictable, and the character that Lenny Kravitz played made me cringe a little too much. But all in all, I enjoyed the campaign’s storyline that sets the stage for this new agent joining the illustrious “00” program. Plenty of Possibilities The third-person style of IO Interactive fits this role quite well. Bond is presented as a master at hand-to-hand combat as well as firearms, while also having a knack for being stealthy when required. Most sections of missions have a lot of freedom. This means I could beat up every goon and security guard on the way to an objective, slip past them without sounding a single alarm, or do a mix of both. My sessions usually end up with the third option because I tend to be impatient about waiting for a patrol to move. Drawing from its Hitman genes, the developer almost always gives multiple routes for going through missions. Levels can be massive, sometimes sporting hundreds of NPCs going their own ways and having conversations. If my objective is to break into a security room on the third floor, I could look around for roof access, eavesdrop on conversations to find out where someone lost a key, create a distraction and pickpocket a guard for a keycard, sneak in through the vents, or simply kick down the offending door. I enjoyed the variety on offer, especially because the same solutions didn’t usually show up in different missions. Before heading out into a secret MI6 escapade, the gadget specialist of the branch walks Bond through the organization's latest and greatest achievements. This can be cool little devices like a laser built into the watch, a phone that fires poison darts, or a camera that emits a powerful shockwave. The choice of what can be taken into the mission is up to the player. I could usually find fresh routes or get out of tough situations with a punch or two, so I never had the feeling of missing out by not choosing the right equipment. It’s still a fun practice. Choosing the armaments before a mission enhanced the super spy feeling quite a bit. As I mentioned, stealth comes in as a very viable option for most of the missions, letting Bond sneak past foes or knock them out silently. While it is satisfying to clear entire areas of goons and walk away without any alarms, the way of accomplishing this could have been done better. Bond can lure enemies, sneak up and knock them out, or use a gadget to disorient them before dealing a nasty blow. Bodies cannot be moved or hidden afterward either. It’s a very simple system, which I wish were more exciting to pull off. Perhaps more stealth-orientated gadgets, distraction options, or multi-takedowns could have helped here, I think. Getting caught while attempting to be in stealth does not mean a game over. Other than getting into a fist fight, an interesting twist of 007 First Light is the bluffing option. While an enemy is confused as to what you are doing in a restricted location, Bond has the option to improvise and persuade them that you are exactly where you’re supposed to be. These are fun little dynamic interactions with unique dialog depending on the mission and location, giving a few extra moments for Bond to go past suspicious guards smoothly. It’s the first time I’ve witnessed this system in a game, and I hope to see more. License to Kill Bond isn’t just dealing with security guards or civilians. From time to time, entire gangs of gun-toting mercenaries show up in levels looking to take down our protagonist. It is then that License to Kill mode is activated for Bond, letting him use firearms with no restrictions. I was surprised by just how tight gunplay is in 007 First Light. The weapons feel powerful and satisfying to fire, with single bullets capable of taking down an enemy with a headshot. Ammo is scarce, and enemies don’t drop weapons with full magazines most of the time. This forces a hectic kind of gameplay where I am always advancing towards enemies to take their weapons after they are downed. Things like shooting legs to immobilize, aiming at the hands to make their weapon go flying, blowing up nearby fire extinguishers for cover, and using gadgets to halt a goon in their tracks while I reload, make up enjoyable levels. I had to hold back my disappointment when the enemy count in these action sequences dropped to zero and I had to go non-lethal again. Speaking of action sequences, First Light isn’t just offering sandbox levels to complete at the player’s own leisure either. Each level comes with specific linear and directed scenes to move the story forward and put Bond in tight situations. These usually end up with high-octane chases or driving sections, offering the chance to witness chaining explosions, hails of gunfire, and scripted parkour scenes that remind me of Mission Impossible movies more than Bond. Elements like seeing James Bond jump out of a plane without a parachute or drive through buildings in London inside a trash truck were fantastic and always left me at a high point when finishing a mission. The classic James Bond theme is sprinkled in here too, which only happens a handful of times in the game, but at just the right moments. Visuals and Performance Compared to Unreal Engine 5 games we are seeing nowadays, 007 First Light isn’t flexing a huge amount of realism when it comes to graphics. The models, textures, and effects all feel a little dated, with the starting mission that I mentioned being the most visually striking. However, the complete lack of stutters, the hundreds of NPCs that can be on screen without a single hitch, massive sandbox levels, and smooth transitions between them all play a part in making this an immensely immersive and complex experience. The in-engine cutscenes are gorgeous as well, offering an upgraded visual style and model detail over the gameplay sections. Animations are one aspect that jumps out at me about any new game, and First Light has nailed what a third-person action game should feel like. Walking, sneaking, and running all have a heaviness to them that I appreciate. Whenever Bond moves past a wall or a ledge, his arms reach out to lightly hold those structures until he moves away. NPCs actually react to my character and move out of the way. Even during melee combat or takedown animations, the fists impacting a body or a head hitting a wall all have that same weight. Even the more frivolous animations, like catching a gun in midair or chucking an empty one at a goon (yes, you can do that), are satisfying to pull off. Of course, the in-engine cutscene animations are remarkably well done too, with facial animations and the upgraded model details improving my engagement with the characters. I have an AMD Radeon RX 9070 XT 16GB paired with an eight-core Ryzen 7 3700X and 32GB of RAM, with the game running at 1440p resolution. Deciding to completely max out all the graphics options gave me a range of frame rates between 60 and 100 depending on the scene and level. While I did try to enable AMD FSR, which bumped up the frame rates by a good 20% at Quality mode, IO Interactive’s implementation of the technology wasn’t that great. Every corner and edge in levels began shimmering, and I was also seeing smearing issues in fast-moving sections. The title seemingly uses the older generation FSR 3.1 and not the machine learning-assisted FSR 4, leading to these artifacts. Unfortunately, there isn't a way to manually upgrade this right now either. I opted to turn off the upscaling and play the game in native 1440p to avoid problems. I would say the FPS range I was getting was an acceptable one for a single-player action game for my setup. I do wish there were an FOV slider option in the settings. While the camera is far enough back for my tastes in most situations in this third-person adventure, at times the perspective is far too close. When trying to look around quickly and spot targets, I realized I was getting a slight headache at times due to the use of an almost over-the-shoulder close-up camera. Conclusion Being James Bond in 007 First Light is a treat. Traveling around the world chasing conspiracies, using high-tech gadgets disguised as everyday accessories, and improvising on the spot to fool foes all give a fantastic feeling of being a super spy. For an origin story, IO Interactive has done a great job at introducing the character and his motives for doing what he does. The satisfying combat animation and fantastic voice acting are definitely high points, with the License to Kill moments being my favorite. Not being able to move bodies and the simplistic stealth of mechanics does hurt its presentation a little. The NPC logic and intelligence is easy to manipulate and trick, repeating the same actions over and over again if I keep making distractions. The lack of an FOV slider was also a pain (quite literally) at times, and the FSR implementation is quite poor. These are things I hope the studio will improve upon with updates. Even with its faults, IO Interactive and James Bond are a match made in heaven. The studio knows how to make a main character that oozes charm and competency while also leaning heavily into its Hitman experience to make gigantic levels with what looks like hundreds of NPCs roaming around. Being an origin story, IO’s Bond has a way to go before he becomes the highly effective agent we see in the movie world. I am hoping the studio will continue this series alongside its Hitman ventures going forward, just so we get to experience the journey for longer. 007 First Light is available on PC (Steam, Epic Games Store, and Xbox PC), Xbox Series X|S, and PlayStation 5 for $69.99. This review was conducted on the PC version of the game provided by IO Interactive.
  • Recent Achievements

    • Collaborator
      conkir earned a badge
      Collaborator
    • Rising Star
      olavinto went up a rank
      Rising Star
    • One Month Later
      lamborghiniv10 earned a badge
      One Month Later
    • Week One Done
      lamborghiniv10 earned a badge
      Week One Done
    • Reacting Well
      X-No-file earned a badge
      Reacting Well
  • Popular Contributors

    1. 1
      +primortal
      504
    2. 2
      PsYcHoKiLLa
      271
    3. 3
      +Edouard
      75
    4. 4
      Skyfrog
      74
    5. 5
      Steven P.
      71
  • Tell a friend

    Love Neowin? Tell a friend!