Not your average Mac question.

By sanctified
in Apple (macOS)

 Share

Recommended Posts

Grand Master

sanctified Veteran

Posted
  • Veteran
Posted

I really need a Mac for my graphic design career. After some conferences now I understand the true advantage of Macs over Windows based computers: Color Management. This is a very important thing for me since most of my work its going to be sent to offset and mass printing (CMYK) but I need to work in a custom colormatchRGB and Color Lab.

I can get a device that configures my desktop monitor to EMULATE (yes, just emulate) the Mac color management. But I need the real thing.

*Stop blabbing idiot, ask your bloddy question*

My question is: All the Mac monitors are preconfigured for those settings or I need to spent a lot of money in a G5 + Display?

For OSX, what it is more important, processor or RAM?

Do I want to wait months for a new hardware revision that includes Tiger?

I dont have a lot of money. Maximun I can spend $2,200

Link to comment
https://www.neowin.net/forum/topic/308780-not-your-average-mac-question/
Share on other sites
Grand Master

Southern Patriot

Posted
Posted (edited)
,Apr 14 2005, 18:00]

My question is: All the Mac monitors are preconfigured for those settings or I need to spent a lot of money in a G5 + Display?

For OSX, what it is more important, processor or RAM?

Do I want to wait months for a new hardware revision that includes Tiger?

I dont have a lot of money. Maximun I can spend $2,200

585776640[/snapback]

I can't honestly answer the first question. As for RAM vs. CPU, I'd say RAM is more important. Even for tasks that don't take advantage of AltiVec, my 600Mhz machine with 1GB seems much faster than my 800Mhz machine with 384MB. You wouldn't be waiting months for Tiger. Once it starts shipping on the 29th, all machines will include it. Even if you buy one today, you'll be eligible for the upgrade free + shipping (about $20).

For that amount of money, I'd recommend an iMac G5 with as much RAM as you can afford.

edit: I just configured a 20" iMac G5 on the Apple Store site with 1GB of RAM and an AirPort Extreme card: total $2203.

Edited by roadwarrior
Veteran

VGVL

Posted
Posted

The iMac G5 is likely to be updated very soon, and it would be perfect for what you want. The screen quality of the 20" iMac G5 is almost on par with the 20" Apple Cinema Display. I've compared both side-by-side and there is very little difference between them.

Calibrating the screen will most likely have a significant impact if you are going to do print work. ColorVision makes the Spyder2, I plan to get one soon to calibrate my ACD and PowerBook.

RAM makes more difference than CPU speed. A 20" iMac G5 with 1GB RAM and Tiger will not disappoint you.

Veteran

Bling3k12

Posted
Posted

1) If anything, invest in a color calibration tool if you will be doing all that work.

2) I'd go with RAM over CPU.

3) Buy now, Tiger will be $10! NOT $20 like everyone else says (see below). If wanting to get a low-end G5 or an iMac, wait a week or so until after the NAB Conference.

Apple would like to give you the opportunity to upgrade to Mac OS X v10.4 ?Tiger? for US$9.95* and change the way your Mac works for you. *Product availability: April 29th, 2005.
Collaborator

macssuck

Posted
Posted

From apple's store under "hot deals" (refurbished)

Power Mac G5 DUAL 1.8GHz/ 256MB/ 80G/ SuperDrive/ PCI/ GeFr5200/ GigE/ 56K - Apple Certified

Your price: $1,699.00

From Dell's small business store:

DELL - UltraSharp 1905FP 19-inch Flat Panel Monitor with Height

$399

From Crucial.com

CT352879 DDR PC3200 CL=3 NON-ECC UNBUFFERED

$58.19

Total: $2,214

It's $14 over budget but you end up with:

  • Dual 1.8 GHz G5
  • 1.25 GB RAM
  • 80 GB HDD
  • GeForce FX5200
  • SuperDrive
  • FireWire 800
  • Gigabit Ethernet
  • 19" LCD (1280x1024)

It still has full a full warranty and qualifies for applecare, it's also significantly more upgradable and faster than anything else mentioned in this thread (so far). If you want to go through rebate hell you can sometimes find really great details on Dell's site. I don't have time for that kind of hoop jumping, but if you do then more power to you.

Don't forget the cost of software.

Veteran

Yvo

Posted
Posted
Sanctified if your looking for a Mac for image editing. Go with the Mac Mini, slap a fat hard drive in there and 1gb of RAM, nice flat 19in CRT monitor, and booyakow, you're set :)

585776769[/snapback]

With all the upgrading he is basically better off getting an imac or refurb powermac.

CRTs aren't that great anymore. Most LCDs now surpass the quality of CRT plus you don't have the bulkyness.

Getting to the point. $2200 is a good amount. I would recommend waiting until Tiger is shipping (I know I am hitting myself in the head right now, oh well) because apparently there will be an update to the imac and powermac line within that same week. Check thinksecret.com for more info.

Grand Master

Elliott

Posted
Posted

Either a high-end 20" iMac G5 or a refurbished Power Mac G5 should work extremely well for you. Buying an Apple display (either by getting the 20" iMac or getting an Apple Cinema Display) will assure you the best color calibration, but you can always fine-tune a third-party display.

Veteran

betasp

Posted
Posted

WTF are you people talking about. He is going to be doing graphic desgin. What is up with al the flat panels?

Get a refurbed 1.6 or 1.8 G5 and add RAM to at least a gig. The get a REAL graphics deisgners monitor like the Lacie ElectronBlue. I have never worked with or in a place that takes design seriously that has switched to an LCD. I used to create and author DVD, before that I was Operation Managers for an advertising agency and now I am the IT Manager of a large printing firm. We have a room packed full of G5s with 1.5GB Ram and Electron Blue Monitors. You cannot get proper colors on an LCD. The corners are always a little brighter or darker and color always shifts with viewing angles.

Grand Master

sanctified Veteran

Posted
  • Author
  • Veteran
Posted
CRTs aren't that great anymore. Most LCDs now surpass the quality of CRT plus you don't have the bulkyness.

585777735[/snapback]

The thing is that Im doing graphic design. LCD's are the worst option for this.

Grand Master

sanctified Veteran

Posted
  • Author
  • Veteran
Posted

How about this?

A 1.25ghz Mac Mini with 1gb ram $882

A LaCie electron19blueIV $379

Harddrive will be no problem since the devices has an USB 2.0 port and I have an external drive box and a 200gb drive

A decent Graphic Design equipment for just $1261

Veteran

fukachu

Posted
Posted

unfortunately it only has 1 ram slot. but you would be better off getting the 256 standard and then getting the 1gb stick from crucial etc. cause its a fair bit cheaper. even sticking one of your 512 sticks in there will keep you going until you get the gb stick

Grand Master

Southern Patriot

Posted
Posted

3) Buy now, Tiger will be $10! NOT $20 like everyone else says (see below).

585777352[/snapback]

Thanks for clearing that up. In the past they have charged $20 for Up-to-Date, which is the information I was going on. Nice that they have lowered the price.

Collaborator

macssuck

Posted
Posted
A 9200 or FX 5200 will not run Core image apps smoothly on high resolutions.

Might want to wait a while for the next revision with 9600 or above.

585779184[/snapback]

Core Image does absolutely nothing for Photoshop, Illustrator, Indesign, Maya, After Effects, etc.

It's unlikely any of the big cross-platform graphics applications will ever be updated to take advantage of it, and even if they are it's likely to be a few years coming. We already know that Photoshop CS2 will not use them and it will be a couple years the one after that ships.

Grand Master

Toastyone

Posted
Posted
How about this?

A 1.25ghz Mac Mini with 1gb ram $882

A LaCie electron19blueIV $379

Harddrive will be no problem since the devices has an USB 2.0 port and I have an external drive box and a 200gb drive

A decent Graphic Design equipment for just $1261

585778930[/snapback]

(Y) very good monitor I have one :wub: But if it was me I would look around ebay or somewhere and try to get a good G4 or G5, You really want a lot of ram when you are working with graphics......and I the most you can get in a mini is 1GB....2GB is so much better I upgraded a while back and was blown away :p If you do look at G4s don't get a quicksilver it has a max of 1.5 GB of ram

Veteran

Yvo

Posted
Posted
The thing is that Im doing graphic design. LCD's are the worst option for this.

585778894[/snapback]

Depending on your LCD. There are LCDs that have better ways of producing colors then a CRT does. I have a Samsung 173P and it looks amazing on my PC... it even looks better then the built in LCD on my imac.

However I will be honest and didn't pay attention to the detail about your graphic work.

But please (as I am a pretty new apple user) explain this to me. If LCDs are so bad then why has Apple abandoned the CRT (except for the eMac) in all of their high end solutions in favor of their LCD line (or LCDs in general). Considering Apple is the platform of choice for graphic development you would think they still produce CRTs for their high end. Instead their Powermac DP 2.5 comes with a DVI / ADC card, both inputs are not supported by a CRT.

I truly believe that any high end 17 inch (like the 173p by Samsung or Apple's displays) have better quality then those of a CRT.

This topic is now closed to further replies.
 Share
Go to topic listing

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.