Could my iPod be dangerous?

By BananaMan
in Hardware Hangout

 Share

Recommended Posts

Grand Master

BananaMan

Posted
Posted

A quick question.

Today I'm at work with my 3g iPod. Because the battery is next to useless on this thing, I've got it charging whilst I listen to it at my desk. I noticed something when I first started doing this (which was in fact today), that when the iPod is charging, a mild electrical current runs through the metal backing (and sides). It's not enough to sting but it is certaintly noticable when you rub your fingers on it.

It's of course no harm to me as is, but is there a potential that this could possibly get worse, and hurt me? Or is this just another normal iPod quirk?

Link to comment
https://www.neowin.net/forum/topic/311155-could-my-ipod-be-dangerous/
Share on other sites
Grand Master

BananaMan

Posted
  • Author
Posted

On your advise I gave them a call. They think that firewire cable is slightly damaged and relaying a small arc onto the metal backing, and suggested I try another one. As my 3g iPod is out of warranty by a couple months they weren't interested in taking the iPod and having a look unless I pay $300 (which is $100 shy of a brand spanking new 4g iPod).

They we're very friendly and they took me seriously, but still, I'm a bit disappointed. I'm skeptical about it being the cable, though I will test their theory.

Maybe I should sell it on eBay as a special electrocution edition iPod!

Mentor

djsaad1

Posted
Posted
On your advise I gave them a call. They think that firewire cable is slightly damaged and relaying a small arc onto the metal backing, and suggested I try another one. As my 3g iPod is out of warranty by a couple months they weren't interested in taking the iPod and having a look unless I pay $300 (which is $100 shy of a brand spanking new 4g iPod).

They we're very friendly and they took me seriously, but still, I'm a bit disappointed. I'm skeptical about it being the cable, though I will test their theory.

Maybe I should sell it on eBay as a special electrocution edition iPod!

585811377[/snapback]

that used to happen to me when i would travel with the ipod out of the country and use an adaptor with it. I never really thought much of it though.

Grand Master

BananaMan

Posted
  • Author
Posted
that used to happen to me when i would travel with the ipod out of the country and use an adaptor with it. I never really thought much of it though.

585811384[/snapback]

I'm guessing this is happening because the international adapter (and my Australian adapter) has no connection for earth and is therefore earthing through whatever comes it contact with the metal plate (which must clearly be in contact with an electrical component).

I'm not worried about the amount of electricity going through the metal backing now (though the sensation is not pleasant), I'm worried that it may suddenly get worse and cause harm to myself or someone else.

Grand Master

Shadrack

Posted
Posted

They wanted $300 to work on it!!! They might as well should of said: we won't work on it. Thats the feeling I get, anyway.

Kind of reminds me of the time my iPaq's screen busted. I had it for less then a month, and it broke while in my pocket. I called up HP support and they said I could send it to them. So i did, and they didn't want to fix the screen for free, they wanted $180. I was like: forget that! The unit only cost $240 (after student discount). I told them the device was defective because it was called a PocketPC, so it should be able to survive in ones pocket. After a week of going back and forth with them, they finally replaced the screen for free.

Hehe..i still carry the thing around in my pocket. Its been a year and 6+ months since I got the replacement, and have had no problems.

But in your situation: they probably wouldn't see it as a "safety risk" even if it is a safety risk for you. They judge safety risks by how many people are affected. If you do get hurt you can always sue.

Mentor

loc[a]lhost

Posted
Posted

i don't think you have anything to worry about.

I've looked at my iPod power adapter, and it says it has a 12V output. combining the voltage of the iPod itself, which i think is about 3.7V like on a cell phone, the maximum voltage you could feel on the back panel is less than 16V. it shouldn't be dangerous AFAIK.

Grand Master

BananaMan

Posted
  • Author
Posted
i don't think you have anything to worry about.

I've looked at my iPod power adapter, and it says it has a 12V output. combining the voltage of the iPod itself, which i think is about 3.7V like on a cell phone, the maximum voltage you could feel on the back panel is less than 16V. it shouldn't be dangerous AFAIK.

585832575[/snapback]

That's a really good explanation - thank you. I'm still not overly impressed that my iPod is zapping me but it's reassuring to know that there is no possible way that this problem could get worse to the point of it being dangerous.

Grand Master

temple_treefrog

Posted
Posted
You shouldnt feel anything on the exterior case when the iPod is charging.? Call Apple on this one, even if the unit is out of warranty as this is a possible "safety issue"

585808274[/snapback]

I work at a well known technology retailer in Sydney, and about six months ago I did a return/exchange on a brand-new Microsoft Wireless Desktop. The mouse had melted around the top and bottom (we realised that it was the customers fault for putting the batterys in the wrong way), however she said that she "hurt her hand badly".

If aMicrosoft IntelliMouse can melt and hurt someone>, then I wonder what the iPod could do.:pp

Btw, I use a Microsoft Wireless Desktop and it's never harmed me. lol:happy::

This topic is now closed to further replies.
 Share
Go to topic listing

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.