Recommended Posts

I tried encoding a 2 minute movie with H.264 a few hours ago. I must say I am dissapointed. Please say I'm doing something wrong.

The movie ended up being exported from iMovie @ H.264/256kb. The file was 6.2MB. I thought that it was going to be an excellent quality movie, just like the uncompressed DV format it was before. It wasn't.

I contacted my Mac friend Photo Monkey. He says that to take full advantage of the H.264 codec I need a G5 processor.

Whats going on here?

Link to comment
https://www.neowin.net/forum/topic/315350-encoding-with-h264/
Share on other sites

H.264 works just fine on a G4. The HD resolution of H.264 really taxes the G4, so it's not usable at all. That may be what he was referring to.

Also, make sure in the Quality slider, always choose Best. Sometimes this is an oversight for some people, they think it will make it bigger by selecting Best.

Edit: I'm gonna export an iMovie I made in H.264 just to check it out. Used 256kb/sec as the limit. We'll see how it turns out.

Edit 2: I'm starting to think the iMovie encoder somehow sucks. Just completely blows. No matter what I do, the results are horrible. I select Automatic (for data rate) and the quality is amazing, but a 31 second movie at 480 x 260 is 42MB! Maybe this is acceptable for playing off a CD, but not for digital distribution, unless file size/bandwidth issues aren't a problem.

Top: 297 kbits/sec

Bottom: 11405 kbits/sec

compare.png

post-12815-1115007400.png

Edited by Bling3k12

Any of you have QT Pro? Export it from iMovie and then open it in QT Pro and re-export it with H264. If it still sucks, then there's a problem. Though I have to say, the Apple Galleries are encoded at 6400kbps and the resolution is 1280x532... I would guess iMovie is having an issue (or a setting is borked) for a movie to come out looking that bad.

I just did a little test of my own on an iMovie project, DV NTSC movie.

320x240, 24fps

256kbps H.264 Video, 128kbps AAC Audio

Duration: 3:12

Filesize: 8.6MB

Looks absolutely wonderful for me... I don't know what you're doing (or if it is an installation problem) that is screwing it up though.

http://grab.onlyinkenya.com/movie.tiff

http://grab.onlyinkenya.com/settings1.tiff

http://grab.onlyinkenya.com/settings2.tiff

(Sorry for the TIFF's, too lazy to change 'em :p )

  Max? said:
Hm, looks like H264 has a problem with interlacin:/:/ I'll try some more stuff tonight.

585861199[/snapback]

H264 doesnt have a problem with interlacing, Apples implementation might do..... Ive just recently switched from xvid to x264 for all my encodes and ive never looked back.

This topic is now closed to further replies.
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Posts

    • It's not really related to the speed of the system. A menu that appears instantly is of course going to feel more responsive than a menu that slides or fades into view.
    • How did two companies come up with the same stupid name for the same stupid type of product?
    • I honestly think this does not make any noticable difference to anyone with a PC with average specs.
    • OpenAI takes down all traces of Jony Ive "io" deal following court order by David Uzondu Early this month, we reported that OpenAI was working on a mobile gadget in the form of a screenless, wearable device, born from a newfound partnership (friendship?) between renowned former Apple designer Jony Ive and OpenAI CEO Sam Altman. The announcement came with a video that had the two men talking about the future of technology. Well, that video has now been made private on YouTube, and the original announcement page has been taken down. The whole thing is on pause because of a simple trademark dispute. OpenAI was forced to pull the materials following a court order. If you visit the original announcement page, it now says: Despite the legal hassle over the name, the actual business deal seems safe. According to Bloomberg's Mark Gurman, the acquisition itself is unaffected by the complaint. So, who is iyO (pronounced eye-oh), the other party in this mess? If the name sounds unfamiliar, its background will not. This iyO company is an independent startup that graduated from X, Alphabet's moonshot factory, and yes, that is the same Alphabet, the parent company of Google. iyO claims to be on a mission to bring "natural language computing" to the masses. A quick look shows two products listed on its website: the Vad Pro, a high-end wired audio device for professionals, and iyO One, a set of AI-powered earbuds the company is calling the "world's first audio computer." A judge reportedly found its trademark lawsuit against OpenAI credible enough to issue the restraining order, suggesting the ChatGPT creator's video could create genuine consumer confusion between the two similarly named ventures.
    • I've set since XP - Best performance in the Performance settings. 11 included. I enable only the show shadows after that, so I can see better fonts and mouse.. But hardly I can say I can see a difference today.
  • Recent Achievements

    • Conversation Starter
      Brett76 earned a badge
      Conversation Starter
    • One Month Later
      Miguel Batista earned a badge
      One Month Later
    • Dedicated
      moojay67 earned a badge
      Dedicated
    • One Month Later
      Jim Dugan earned a badge
      One Month Later
    • First Post
      Johnny Mrkvička earned a badge
      First Post
  • Popular Contributors

    1. 1
      +primortal
      655
    2. 2
      Michael Scrip
      229
    3. 3
      ATLien_0
      220
    4. 4
      Steven P.
      150
    5. 5
      Xenon
      143
  • Tell a friend

    Love Neowin? Tell a friend!