best LINUX File System ?


Recommended Posts

OK. First of all: There is no single best filesystem. If there was

one particular filesystem that was better than all of the others, do

you think anybody would continue to use those others? No they wouldn't

- everybody would be using this super-filesystem.

In the real world, every filesystem has its strengths and weaknesses.

For an average everyday desktop, I'd choose either ext3 or reiserFS -

ext3 can be read from windows fairly easily, and reiser is perhaps

marginally faster. Both are very stable, and both are journaled

filesystems, so no long filesystem checks during boot.

XFS, JFS, reiser4, et al are good if you know you have a specific need for them,

but as its just going to be a normal desktop box, I wouldn't worry

about them.

  Knight said:
For desktop Linux I wouldn't reccomend ReiserFS, mainly because it doesn't fully support extended atributes, so things like Beagle and a few other search tools don't like it. I use it, however, it's a good FS aside from that.

586370825[/snapback]

Umm.....

Are you sure I don't know much about file systems, but this is on the 2.6.11.* kernel mabye even lower

  Kernel2.6.13rc5 said:
ReiserFS extended attributes (REISERFS_FS_XATTR)

Extended attributes are name:value pairs associated with inodes by

the kernel or by users (see the attr(5) manual page, or visit

<http://acl.bestbits.at/> for details).

If unsure, say N.

  ranasrule said:
iam leanin towards ext3....can i convert later 2 somethin else ?

586371303[/snapback]

Non-destructively? No. You'll need to migrate your data to a reserve-storage solution before re-mk.fs'ing

Having files that are mostly < 600mb-1gb in size does not justify choosing xfs as your fs. You can do without the additional disk-thrashing during simultaneous writes as well. Notwithstanding, it's a fine fs for media-creation. I personally use it on several boxen with raided scsi, and I love it.

For all-round performance on your desktop machine, though, stick with ext3.

If you choose to use ext3, my suggestion would be to do the following upon fs-creation:

[after mkfs.ext3..]

tune2fs -O has_journal,dir_index -o journal_data,acl /dev/hdXY

(this will ensure full-journaling, access control lists, and b-tree hashes for faster listings of large directories.)

Keep in mind that while some fs-types outperform others in certain benchmarks, efficient disk-operation occasionally requires a combination of fs-types. It's up to you to figure out how you'll be using your computer, and take the necessary steps to configure it accordingly.

Edited by sentio
  sentio said:
Non-destructively? No. You'll need to migrate your data to a reserve-storage solution before re-mk.fs'ing

Having files that are mostly < 600mb-1gb in size does not justify choosing xfs as your fs. You can do without the additional disk-thrashing during simultaneous writes as well. Notwithstanding, it's a fine fs for media-creation. I personally use it on several boxen with raided scsi, and I love it.

For all-round performance on your desktop machine, though, stick with ext3.

If you choose to use ext3, my suggestion would be to do the following upon fs-creation:

[after mkfs.ext3..]

tune2fs -O has_journal,dir_index -o journal_data,acl /dev/hdXY

(this will ensure full-journaling, access control lists, and b-tree hashes for faster listings of large directories.)

Keep in mind that while some fs-types outperform others in certain benchmarks, efficient disk-operation occasionally requires a combination of fs-types. It's up to you to figure out how you'll be using your computer, and take the necessary steps to configure it accordingly.

586371551[/snapback]

thanks for the advice :)

I' building a new Gentoo system and I have a simillar question, I can't decide between Ext3 and ReiserFS, it says ReiserFS is good at dealing with small files (4k or smaller) does that mean it will be slower (than Ext3) when dealing with bigger files?

I dunno, I may just give it a shot...

  msg43 said:
Umm.....

Are you sure I don't know much about file systems, but this is on the 2.6.11.* kernel mabye even lower

  Kernel2.6.13rc5 said:
ReiserFS extended attributes (REISERFS_FS_XATTR)

Extended attributes are name:value pairs associated with inodes by

the kernel or by users (see the attr(5) manual page, or visit

<http://acl.bestbits.at/> for details).

If unsure, say N.

586370836[/snapback]

I'm not sure what you mean, "Are you sure I don't know much about file systems", my comment wasn't a slight on you.

Linux has had support for Reiser3 xattr for a while now, but not 4. What you quoted has nothing to do with Reiser4. If no xattr is found, then Beagle jumps to SQLite, which is slow in comparison. This is why I don't always suggest Reiser4 for desktop use.

  Knight said:
I'm not sure what you mean, "Are you sure I don't know much about file systems", my comment wasn't a slight on you.

Linux has had support for Reiser3 xattr for a while now, but not 4. What you quoted has nothing to do with Reiser4. If no xattr is found, then Beagle jumps to SQLite, which is slow in comparison. This is why I don't always suggest Reiser4 for desktop use.

Oh ok I thought you were talking about reiserfs my mistake :blush:

This topic is now closed to further replies.
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Posts

    • PDF Shaper 15.2 by Razvan Serea PDF Shaper is a set of feature-rich PDF software that makes it simple to split, merge, watermark, sign, optimize, convert, encrypt and decrypt your PDF documents, also delete and move pages, extract text and images. The program is optimized for low CPU resource usage and operates in batch mode, allowing users to process multiple PDF files while doing other work on their computers. PDF Shaper is available in three editions - Free, Premium and Ultimate. Compare and pick edition which is suitable for you. Compatible with Windows 7, 8, 10, 11. Features: Extract text, images of other objects from single or multiple PDFs Convert PDF to Word RTF or image, or convert image to PDF Extract pages from PDF and save them as separate PDF files Combine several PDF files into single PDF Encrypt and decrypt PDF with password, set user permissions Rotate, crop and normalize pages, set meta data Add watermark or remove images from PDF Benefits: Easy-to-use, intuitive user interface Low CPU resource usage during any process, including conversion Free for personal use and for any non-commercial organization Supports Unicode characters Supports batch processing for any operation Small installation size PDF Shaper 15.2 changelog: Updated translations. Improved table positioning for better layout accuracy (DOC to PDF). Enhanced image resizing to more accurately reflect DPI settings (Image to PDF). Improved text positioning for consistent formatting (TXT to PDF). Optimized overall performance on 64-bit systems. Enhanced support for Unicode text documents. Fixed an issue where font settings were not applied correctly to text files Download: PDF Shaper 15.2 | 7.9 MB (Free for personal use only) Link: PDF Shaper Home Page | Screenshot Get alerted to all of our Software updates on Twitter at @NeowinSoftware
    • I kind of do not engage much with people whose first retort is an ad hominem. Nevertheless the data is there.
    • I don't know if this is helpful or not, but just something I have an opinion on... Gaming PC builds where you've specced up the parts you want, built the system, colour matched things, etc... They may well be a labour of love, but on the 2nd hand market - nobody cares.  People are looking for deals, not your passion project
    • Firefox 139.0.4 fixes browser freezes, wallpaper bugs on Windows, and more by Taras Buria Mozilla is rolling out a new update for Firefox 139. Version 139.0.4 arrived today with four fixes and security patches. With today's release, Mozilla fixes freezes that occur when switching between apps or opening certain parts of the browser, issues with drop-down menus and triple-clicking text, and a bug with incorrect file names when setting a picture as the desktop background on Windows (the image would save as a BMP file with a blank name instead of Desktop Background.bmp) Here is the changelog: Security updates in Firefox 139.0.4 include two patches for vulnerabilities of high impact: CVE-2025-49709: Memory Corruption in canvas surfaces. Certain canvas operations could have led to memory corruption. CVE-2025-49710: Integer overflow in OrderedHashTable. An integer overflow was present in OrderedHashTable used by the JavaScript engine. As usual, you can update Firefox by heading to Menu > Help > About Firefox. Alternatively, grab the browser from the official website, Microsoft Store (if you are on Windows 10 and 11), or Neowin's Software page. For reference, release notes for version 139 and its subsequent bug-fixing update, 139.0.1, are available here and here. In other Firefox news, Mozilla recently announced the end of Pocket, Fakespot, and some other services. The company says its goal is to consolidate efforts and focus on Firefox development, its primary product.
  • Recent Achievements

    • Reacting Well
      Alan- earned a badge
      Reacting Well
    • Week One Done
      IAMFLUXX earned a badge
      Week One Done
    • One Month Later
      Æhund earned a badge
      One Month Later
    • One Month Later
      CoolRaoul earned a badge
      One Month Later
    • First Post
      Kurotama earned a badge
      First Post
  • Popular Contributors

    1. 1
      +primortal
      494
    2. 2
      ATLien_0
      267
    3. 3
      +FloatingFatMan
      225
    4. 4
      +Edouard
      199
    5. 5
      snowy owl
      141
  • Tell a friend

    Love Neowin? Tell a friend!