Recommended Posts

Hi everyone

Here's the situation - a stand alone laptop (connected to ADSL via a router) with XP Pro SP2, CD/DVD and floppy attached, along with 2 USB 2.0 ports.

I would like to restrict users from accessing the command screen. I know that I can take <Run> from the Start menu and I can set the permissions of cmd.exe so that only Administrators can use it, but what if someone had a copy of cmd.exe on a floppy, CD or USB memory stick? Users need access to USB or floppy so disabling these (along with the CD) is not an option.

Basically, I'd like to prevent limited users from running cmd.exe, *whatever the source* of the file (i.e. they could e-mail a copy to themself). Can this be done? A lot of harm (and prying) can be done from the command screen and I'd like to prevent it. The situation is a stand alone at present, but I may increase the number of PCs to a small home network behing the router or a hub. I doubt that I'd get to the state of a large network with a server, MS Server 2003 etc.

Thank you for your time.

Link to comment
https://www.neowin.net/forum/topic/454369-prevent-users-from-using-cmdexe/
Share on other sites

  John said:

You can set permissions on cmd.exe itself (Y)

Yes, but that wouldn't stop a Limited user having a copy on a floppy or USB memory stick, or e-mailing another copy of cmd.exe to himself, would it?

I've been thinking about the earlier option of using a registry tweak, for instance DisallowRun or RestrictRun. If a user had another copy of cmd.exe (as above) and renamed it, I suspect that neither of these registry tweaks would prevent it from running.

I just wonder if cmd.exe accesses some other file(s) (such as a .dll) and, if so, would altering the permission of that file help in any way? I'm thinking aloud now.

This can be done through Group Policy. Click Start and then click run and type:"gpedit.msc" without quotes to launch Group Policy. Click System under Administrative Templates in User Configuration on the left pane and select "Prevent access to the command prompt" in the main window. Click on "Enabled" and then click OK and close Group Policy.

EDIT: betasp was faster than me.

Thanks to both of you. It works fine, bringing up the command screen and it gives a warning that the Administrator has disabled it (whether I'm logged in with Limited or Administrative privileges). However, is it possible to still allow someone with Administrative privileges access to it? I guess that I could go back into GPE, reset it, do what I have to with cmd.exe and then disable it again but that seems a bit fiddly. I'm not sure just how bespoke Policies can be and how I'd set it exactly as I'd need.

Personally I would just disable cmd full stop on the machine and use an alternative command line processor which isnt subject to such restrictions, however that wont stop your errant users accessing a similar utility. It might just delay them slightly if theyre not so techical.

  Tosca said:

Thanks to both of you. It works fine, bringing up the command screen and it gives a warning that the Administrator has disabled it (whether I'm logged in with Limited or Administrative privileges). However, is it possible to still allow someone with Administrative privileges access to it? I guess that I could go back into GPE, reset it, do what I have to with cmd.exe and then disable it again but that seems a bit fiddly. I'm not sure just how bespoke Policies can be and how I'd set it exactly as I'd need.

With the modification I suggested you, all users including those with administrative privileges can't use CMD.EXE, with the exception of Administrator. If you want to use CMD.EXE and have modified Group Policy as I suggested you, open Start menu, click "All Programs", navigate to "Command Prompt" then right click it and select "Run as..." from context menu. A new window will open: From here you can run CMD as Administrator providing you know the password.

Edited by MPH

That's great. In a way, I'm a little surprised that a Policy can't be set to do what I want. I was under the impression that the Group Policy Editor could be very flexible in creating Policies to fit with required circumstances. The suggestion that you've made regarding running it as Administrator works well.

I just came across command.com on my PC which works similar to cmd. I've not tried it yet, but I *hope* that the setting in Group Policy will disable this too. If not, I dare say that I'll be back asking if that can be disabled!

Thank you.

I prefer to avoid third party software. I understand that bespoke policies can be set, but I don't know how. It's a very powerful utility so, rather than floundering, can you give me a nudge in the right direction about setting a policy specifically to prevent command.com from running?

I've done some googling and have come across Software Restriction Policy (SRP). There are several ways to implement this - one uses the MD5 hash of the file. I think this should allow me to authorise only an Admin user to run command.com. I don't think there's any way to prevent a "foreign" copy of command.com or some other command.com-like utility being run.

I suppose the other way around is to set SRP, based upon the MD5 hash, of those files to which I wish to grant a Limited user access. Everything else would be set to Deny for this group. I anticipate that this would prevent their using extenal applications, running batch files etc. I'm thinking aloud here so will have to try it to see how it works.

You really don't want people running a command window, huh? ;)

Consider the implications of restricting ALL programs except the ones you specify... A command prompt itself isn't that dangerous. The only thing you can do with it is launch other programs, and you're better off restricting those programs instead of the command prompt.

You can do a lot of damage with cmd.exe .

A lot of things that are restricted in the windows gui are not using cmd.exe.

I use software restriction policies on my network at work.

I dont go as bad as using hashes but I just block the exe. I use it to block chat and p2p programs.

I say try it its great.

Yes, but you're doing it differently from what he's suggesting. You block certain programs and allow everything else not specified. He's talking about blocking everything by default and specifying programs to allow. That list would fill up rather quickly.

^ if you are going to do that, besure that you set the program that you are using to be able to run... i did that once back in the day using Windows 98SE's "system policy editor" ... it was VERY powerful and i forgot to set it to run "poledit.exe" which was the name of that program... and then i couldnt run that program anymore in order to change settings, so i was stuck, lol.

  majortom1981 said:

You can do a lot of damage with cmd.exe. ........ I dont go as bad as using hashes but I just block the exe. I use it to block chat and p2p programs.

I know that command.com and cmd.exe aren't identical, but I want to be able to block both. I'm not keen on users, for instance, accessing any network commands.

I've not looked at simply blocking the .exe as you suggest. How exactly do you go about blocking chat and p2p programs?

  mujjuman said:

^ if you are going to do that, besure that you set the program that you are using to be able to run... i did that once back in the day using Windows 98SE's "system policy editor" ... it was VERY powerful and i forgot to set it to run "poledit.exe" which was the name of that program... and then i couldnt run that program anymore in order to change settings, so i was stuck, lol.

<LOL> I'd already thought about that - I'd be sure to leave myself a backdoor to apps such as gpedit.msc, regedit, cmd.exe, command.com etc.

This topic is now closed to further replies.
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Posts

    • Harmful to them because it affects their business. *Sigh*
    • TCL 75" 4K Smart TV hits lowest price, now less than £500 by Paul Hill Are you in the UK and looking for a massive 75-inch Ultra HD 4K HDR TV at a relatively affordable price? If so, check out this TCL (75P755K) 75-inch TV now because it’s at its lowest price of just £499.00, down 15% from £589.00. The model in question is slightly older, from 2024, but it’s still an excellent home entertainment upgrade given its feature set and aggressive price point. What you get: Features for the price The feature set of this model is definitely pretty impressive. It supports 4K HDR, wide colour gamut, and multiple HDR formats including HDR10+ and Dolby Vision. It also leverages MEMC (Motion Estimation & Motion Compensation), a proprietary algorithm from TCL that helps to reduce motion display blur and keep motion trails to a minimum. While MEMC will do heavy lifting to ensure the best picture, the TV only has a 60Hz refresh rate, but an effective rate of 120Hz thanks to efforts by TCL. This TCL model features Dolby Atmos 2.0 that immerses you more in whatever you’re watching on the TV. In terms of software, this TV comes with Google TV (based on Android) which is well-known and widely supported, ensuring you can use all the apps you depend on. It also supports Google Assistant, Chromecast, and voice control. The Chromecast support allows you to easily stream from your computer or phone to the TV to share what you’re watching to the people around you. The Google Assistant support can also be good if you have smart home devices around the house that can connect to it. The audio features for this TV are also good and mean you don’t need to buy a separate sound bar immediately. User experience and potential considerations According to What Hi-Fi, which reviewed the smaller 65-inch version of this TV, TCL’s TV delivers when it comes to HDR; gaming features such as low input lag, VRR, and Game Bar; wide colour gamut, and the operating system. What it didn’t like about the TV was the limited brightness, which degraded the HDR in bright rooms; the average motion handling; the lack of bass; the lack of local dimming; and the budget-oriented build quality. Making the smart buy decision If you can overlook its limitations, this TV could be a good pick if you need a new TV in the living room on a budget. If you are a serious gamer looking for a high refresh rate, or someone in a very bright room, then you will probably want to look elsewhere. Amazon is also offering free add-on services including wall mounting and unpack. If you do decide to pick up this TCL TV and find a fault with it, you have 30-days from getting the receipt to return it. TCL 75P755K 75-inch 4K TV: £499 (Amazon UK) - MSRP £589 / 15% off This Amazon deal is U.K. specific, and not available in other regions unless specified. If you don't like it or want to look at more options, check out the Amazon UK deals page here. Get Prime, Prime Video, Music Unlimited, Audible or Kindle Unlimited, free for the first 30 days As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.
    • I came here to post something similar, you beat me to it. Why on earth would somebody buy Windows again, even this shady grey-market cheap key, when they already have it and an upgrade from 10 to 11 is free?
    • I maintain that the Cybertruck was a social experiment.  "Can we convince the massively insecure petrol guzzling, Dodge Ram loving, right wing idiots to buy a poorly built, underpowered, underspecified, electric vehicle that they know everyone will laugh at them in"
  • Recent Achievements

    • Week One Done
      theevergreentree earned a badge
      Week One Done
    • Dedicated
      Fryer Tuck earned a badge
      Dedicated
    • Week One Done
      luxoxfurniture earned a badge
      Week One Done
    • First Post
      Uranus_enjoyer earned a badge
      First Post
    • Week One Done
      Uranus_enjoyer earned a badge
      Week One Done
  • Popular Contributors

    1. 1
      +primortal
      439
    2. 2
      +FloatingFatMan
      247
    3. 3
      snowy owl
      226
    4. 4
      ATLien_0
      212
    5. 5
      Xenon
      152
  • Tell a friend

    Love Neowin? Tell a friend!