Does Windows Vista Aero look like Mac OS X Aqua to you?

By MightyJordan
in General Discussion

 Share

Recommended Posts

Grand Master

Glassed Silver

Posted
Posted

overkilled... no they look completely different,

btw: Apple did not invent some glassy effects etc you may find in OS X and "similar" ones in Win.

Glassed Silver:mac

edit: / addition:

linux rocks.

OT of the day

Proficient

richter

Posted
Posted

Let's face it. Whatever MS comes up with it will be total rip off of Apple (Insert whatever here). As if Apple is the only driving and innovative force in the computing world. It's logical that MS implements features in their products. I am more amazed how much bashing can go on regarding how much MS "stole" from Apple. Not being OS X user, I cannot comment on features and capabilities, but tell me one thing OS X can do that you already can't do on Windows either built in or via 3rd party applications? As if fast index feature and other features have been Apple property. MS planned WinFS (which is basically just that to my knowledge) and a lot of other things which got scrapped in the process a long time ago. A lot of things that get built into Apple OS is already available via 3rd party software on Windows platform. It's not like they don't borrow ideas from others also. But when MS implements something, they ripped off Apple. Get real. If MS released "a new OS" with changelog - "Search bar implemented, sidebar and new shiny icons" it would get blasted to death. I am not saying ME was original or anything...but if MS were to release OS at Apple's pace and list of changes, it would be over from them. Vista for example probably brings a lot of changes and new stuff, but yet it is still labeled as XP with new skin or what not. I don't use it. I won't be upgrading anytime soon, if ever. But I have to admit that the changes they bring with new release are far from cosmetic ones. I don't dig that eye candy at all. I want features. And wasn't Luna rip off of Aqua to begin with? I could have sworn that I read that somewhere.

I personally don't care who did what...I buy and use what suits me best, no matter who makes it and I pretty much don't care who and how they did it as long as they did. I wish MS would implement a lot of things in Windows so I could scrap most 3rd party applications, but we all know how would that end - lawsuit from 3rd party vendors.

Contributor

duke dynamite

Posted
Posted
i hate mac fanboys.

im not a windows fanboy either...

why not say Ubuntu stole their design from osx too? i mean cmon. the menus are at the top :o

omg!

they dont look ANYTHING alike.

if you think they do. your either

1) a blind pink monkey

or 2) a mac fanboy.

are you kidding? have you heard of GOSSIP? hulllooo... most mac osx fanboys WONT GO NEAR A windows rig. use vista. then tell me that its the same.

I used to like the OSX eye candy then MS gave us...wait for it...one more moment...VISTA! (Angels are singing.)

I do notice that the window transition, i.e. minimize and restore remind me of OSX, but the GUI does not look alike in any manner.

It reminds me of that Mac commercial from the eighties, all the Mac fanboys are sitting in front of a screen showing Steve Jobs' face and listening to him tyrade on their iPods.

Just Mac Fanboys trying to justify their egoes. That is all they have.

Grand Master

Linkinfamous

Posted
Posted
MS didnt rip the glass but everything else like the search thing has been ripped

Microsoft showed off Windows Desktop Search before Apple demoed Spotlight. It was rather obvious that they'd integrate it into their next OS, rather than leave it as a separate entity.

Veteran

d3nuo

Posted
Posted

ok, so the calendar apps look the same, oh and the search box.. so what.. there's a generic design that's kind of hard to make unique without breaking usability.. mac fanboys get over that.. osx looks like crap and can't achieve anything close to that what vista can. they look absolutely nothing alike aside from that which is inherently similar. there's only so many ways you can put a simple box in a window and have an icon showing that it's a search box.. OMG they used a magnifying glass in a small box! they MUST be copying off our our awesomenesssss OSX!!!

get a hold of reality and realize that no one's copying anything.. apple isn't this awesome company they have so many people deceived into thinking they are.. microsoft is just as lame but can at least make a fast OS that's got some advanced capabilities.. no one is right or wrong for using vista or osx, it's all your own prerogative whether you want to waste $$ on crap hardware and osx that's way overpriced, or wast $400 for an OS that's better but not worth half it's cost.

look at the obvious rather than trying to slight vista as attempts at justification for defending your precious(ly corrupt) stevie jobs and his overprices pieces of crap.. thank you for your time, and i'll go back to resting my feet upon our Mac Minis which serve little use for real computer geeks..

Grand Master

gigapixels Veteran

Posted
  • Veteran
Posted

No, they don't look the same. The only thing that reminds me of OS X is the new alt-tab (no, not the Flip3D), except instead of large icons in the window it has an actual preview. Other than that, I fail to see any similarities.

Grand Master

chopyaedoff

Posted
Posted

This is like saying that Lamborgini ripped off Ferrari - sure, the cars look to some extent similar and provide a similar function, they didn't rip each other off.

The same can be applied to the OS - they serve one function! To allow the user to interact with the applications, nothing else!

And to people who say OS X looks ugly, I agree, it does look ugly when on Windows, but when on a Mac the UI looks fantasic. (It's down to the gamma - my signature for example looks awful at 2.2 gamma, which is what is used by Windows, but at 1.8 gamma like on the Mac it looks as I intended to make it.)

Experienced

Berto

Posted
Posted

To quote chopyaedoff above:

"This is like saying that Lamborgini ripped off Ferrari - sure, the cars look to some extent similar and provide a similar function, they didn't rip each other off.

The same can be applied to the OS - they serve one function! To allow the user to interact with the applications, nothing else!

And to people who say OS X looks ugly, I agree, it does look ugly when on Windows, but when on a Mac the UI looks fantasic. (It's down to the gamma - my signature for example looks awful at 2.2 gamma, which is what is used by Windows, but at 1.8 gamma like on the Mac it looks as I intended to make it.)"

/End Quote

That was the first thing I noticed is that all the walls and sigs that I made on Xp Pro looked massively different on the iMac I got recently. Yeah the OS looks different than one another but the true difference is always going to be under the hood.

For the longest time I had my XP system looking, or mimicking rather, the OS X visual style, with Rocket Dock, Windowblinds etc...but it still 'felt' like Windows. The file structure was always Windows etc...

Now that I'm on a Mac, it 'feels' like a Mac and not like Windows. Little nuances that you can't see are what really make the difference. It's just something that you have to find out and feel for yourself. It really doesn't come down to looks between the OS as anything can get duplicated on either one of the operating systems, OS X or XP.

Apprentice

wetlegs6

Posted
Posted
No, they don't look the same. The only thing that reminds me of OS X is the new alt-tab (no, not the Flip3D), except instead of large icons in the window it has an actual preview. Other than that, I fail to see any similarities.

Note: There was a powertoy for Windows XP that did that, and was available from release.

Enthusiast

sk8er_boi6000

Posted
Posted
iCal:

osx-ical.jpg

Windows Calendar:

vista-windows-calendar.jpg

Oh and the search?

header.jpg

osx-homedir.jpg

OH NOES THEY STOLED OUR SEARCH BOX!!!!!!!11oneoneone

Its a search box, who cares there are only so many ways to do a search box. There are similar looking search boxes in Opera, Firefox, IE7, Maxthon, and so on. I guess they copied apple as well right? because a search box is such an amazing piece of technology apple just had to pioneer it right?

Oh and ROFL had to laugh at the calendar one. How many different ways are there to make a calendar application lol? may i point out that a similar calendar has been in Outlook for years

The image didn't reveal all of iCal's buttons on the buttom of the window--new task and new appt. are all there.

Also forgetting the iLife suit? Windows Photo Gallery? DVD Maker?

In that case, I guess nero also copied apple since they also have some of that stuff in their product suites. Seriously, get over yourself dude, DVD apps and photo galleries again, not exactly such marvellous examples of technological achievement that they need to be copied off apple.

Grand Master

Tech Star

Posted
Posted

.....1 word and two letters....**** no. :laugh:

All I know is that Apple stole all the ideas from Vista, as Vista was being worked on for about 5 years and Apple had time to release a new OS (which they did) with all those features before MS and say they did it before MS. That also means why Vista is not as innovative as you think. ;)

@st8er agreed. :)

Grand Master

NoneAvail

Posted
Posted

They both look different from each other. Vista or OSX, I don't see anything that looks the same. Colors are different plus the search bars on the right top of the screen always been there, ever since Netscape Navi. I think Apple went too far when they said Vista is the same as OSX on their keynote. Plus their both computers they do the same ****, a windows computer or a OSX computer can do.

Grand Master

Brandon Live Veteran

Posted
  • Veteran
Posted
what about windows sidebar... a cheap ripoff of dashboard?

Nope. Sidebar was shown long before Apple even hinted at Dashboard. And there are plenty of other implementations (Konfabulator, DesktopX, etc) to even begin to claim that's Apple's idea. Plus, Dashboard is another gadget/widget platform - but the design is quite different.

what about that winkey+tab bs which shows your desktop in 3d... looks a lot like a ripoff of expose to me.
How so? You do realize that Expose is just the "Tile Windows" function that's been in Windows for ages, right? Apple added an easy hotkey and a slick animation. That doesn't mean every animated window-switching mechanism is copying them now, does it? Flip3D is Alt-Tab in 3D, and it was ALSO shown in Longhorn builds and preview shots before Expose.
Windows Calendar? thats iCal without a doubt.

OMG, it's a calendar! How dare Microsoft make a calendar app that looks like... a calendar. Of course iCal isn't a rip-off of Outlook's calendar or anything. Nope, definitely not. Apple invents everything.

The new save interface... quite similar to OS X.
In what way?
the "Search" bar in the start menu? Isn't that spotlight?

You do realize that Spotlight is just a lame copy of Windows Desktop Search, right? And that WDS shipped before Spotlight, right?

All Apple did was move the search box from the taskbar to the top-right of the screen. And now in Leopard they're playing catch-up again by adding features that Vista / WDS already has.

This topic is now closed to further replies.
 Share
Go to topic listing

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.