Bioshock Vs Halo 3 - Wich one is better?

[KaiSerSoze]

Both games are out now. I bet most of you have played them both. Wich one takes the cake? Bioshock or Halo 3 in single player mode? Why?

EDIT: following the suggestion of some posts I have added "single player mode" to Halo 3 option. It was unfair to compare 2 games in different player modes.

Edited September 27, 2007 by KaiSerSoze

[Kerm]

Halo 3. More fun.

[HawkMan]

Well I'm not a huge Halo fan, but I ordered H3, mostly because of the multiplayer.

But Bioshock really didn't impress me, neither with graphics gamepla or the so called story, though I only played the demo, but nothing in the demo intrigued me to want to play the full game.

And Halo 3 got multiplayer.

[Gangsta]

Is this a serious question, or are you trying deliberately to make Bioshock feel bad? Because I think Halo's gonna win. Just being HALO. And the "3" part.

[NienorGT]

Bioshock got extreme high Review, but as only Single Player. The game is really good, but it was too short and easy at my taste.

Halo 3 got the mega hyper hype, but I read one review right now and huh... It have a really average score O.o

They says also that the Single player campaign is poor. so...

Anyway, I don't own a X360, I'm just telling what I saw.

[Spookie]

Halo 3. More fun.

Bioshock has the better SP without a doubt. Since, currently, my MP interests are held by Team Fortress 2 I'd say Bioshock.

[Ji@nBing]

Bioshock for me. TBH I'm not all that impressed with the single player of Halo 3 thus far. Multiplayer is a different story though...

[+jamesyfx Subscriber²]

I don't like Halo.

So BioShock. For sure.

[KaiSerSoze]

I see a legion of Halo fans and at a sales level, Halo wins... nevertheless I find Bioshock a better game... the story is great and Rapture rules... :)

[UKDarkJedi]

Bioshock gets my vote, but then I dislike getting screamed at by angry 12 year old boys saying "ZOMG I so PWNED j00!!one" when they get a lucky headshot.

Multiplayer bores more in most games, and H3 will be no different.

There is rumoured to be expansion packs in the making for Bioshock as well, to extend the storyline.

[Prince Charming]

Bioshock, but Bioshock is a single player game and once you're done, you're done. Halo3 on the other hand has the Multiplayer and Forge crap, so I'm tempted to go for Halo3, but as said above, theres the 12 year old XBLive kiddies which kind of ruin stuff. Think I'll vote with Bioshock, it was *that* good.

[SacrificialSoldier]

Halo 3

[Titanium_NX]

Well I have played both and here is my views

Bioshock: The game has a deep feeling with tons of content and an amazing story line. The graphics are amazing and I find the game to be really well done. Since the game has choices to make it makes the game fun to replay and see the different ending.

Halo 3: Continuing with the story line of the Halo games, this game has impressed me too. If you have a nice huge tv and a big sound system I have to say this game is just amazing since you will just sit in some parts to listen.

Coming down to which game is better, neither is better since they both are different in their own way, if I had to pick one, i'd say based on my interests Bioshock wins.

[SacrificialSoldier]

I'd say Halo 3. I am not quite finished with BS but it is IMO what the initials are. BS

[stephen_0002]

Bioshock, I dunno but the gameplay, the spookyness to the game I like more

[TogaForComfort]

Halo for me, but If bioshock had a good multiplayer element It would have won

[Chaos at Dawn]

I Love both these games, two of the best games I have ever played but halo 3 is by far the winner.

[MightyJordan]

I've only played the BioShock demo, but I can safely say Halo 3 is better. Halo 3 has online multiplayer, and you can customise the maps yourself and share them with your friends! How cool is that?! I might make a racetrack!

[Voyn1x]

If the poll was Halo single player vs Bioshock, Bioshock easily wins hands down.

[KaiSerSoze]

I've only played the BioShock demo, but I can safely say Halo 3 is better. Halo 3 has online multiplayer, and you can customise the maps yourself and share them with your friends! How cool is that?! I might make a racetrack!

Yep.. but in Bioshock you can create weapons... not to mention the Plasmids and the Genetic upgrades... awsome!

[Jason S. Global Moderator]

Is this a serious question, or are you trying deliberately to make Bioshock feel bad? Because I think Halo's gonna win. Just being HALO. And the "3" part.

+1 (Y)

Halo is pretty overrated imo. it's just extremely popular b/c it's an "everyman's game" so to speak. im certainly not saying the franchise is bad by any means, just overrated.

I've only played the BioShock demo, but I can safely say Halo 3 is better. Halo 3 has online multiplayer, and you can customise the maps yourself and share them with your friends! How cool is that?! I might make a racetrack!

yeah and i used to do this w/ Duke Nukem 3D

[MightyJordan]

Yeah, but that was a PC game. You can do a lot more on PC games than console games. That's why I'm praising Halo 3 for this feature, because it's a console game.

[shakey]

how can you compare the 2? 1 is single player rpg stylish, the other is a co-op/multiplayer game. halo 3 is great and all, looks good, is fun, but it sort of the same old thing, where as bioshock, with only single player mode, will become the same old thing very shortly.

[gunnerhkjp]

Halo3.

Bioshock was a real let down for me.

[Leo Natan]

Halo 3 is crap.

BioShock.

CB's Jericho pwns them both though.