Bioshock Vs Halo 3 - Wich one is better?

[curme]

How can people vote when they only played one of the games? Are you guys just guessing?

And the poll says 'single player mode' for Halo3. So please stop voting for Halo3's multiplayer.

[Remysaus]

halo 3, purely because it was fun to play. unlike bioshock that just started to become more and more irritating near the end. (just my opinion here)

[darkpuma]

bioshock got really repetitive and stuff... the missions were pretty annoying, it was like.. run over here, run back. run over there, run back. run to the first place again, run back. etc etc etc

halo.

[Remysaus]

bioshock got really repetitive and stuff... the missions were pretty annoying, it was like.. run over here, run back. run over there, run back. run to the first place again, run back. etc etc etc

halo.

have you not played the halo 3 sp yet? :p

the third mission or so was the most backtracking i've ever seen in a game.

[Guest]

If you're looking purely for a single player experience, then BioShock is the clear winner.

[Elliott]

have you not played the halo 3 sp yet? :p

the third mission or so was the most backtracking i've ever seen in a game.

Lies! Oblivion has far more backtracking than Halo 3. :p

I know, different genre, but still. Actually, I remember Doom 3 having a good bit of backtracking. Same with HL/HL2.

[Emn1ty]

How can people vote when they only played one of the games? Are you guys just guessing?

And the poll says 'single player mode' for Halo3. So please stop voting for Halo3's multiplayer.

Halo 3's MP is part of the campaign though (at least online co-op and the meta game). Both of those combined add alot more to Halo 3 than bioshock could ever wish for.

And the voting without playing both games is called bias. Some people will play one game and never consider another game being better. I hate that kind of thing, since one game being better than the other doesn't matter when they are both great games.

[Badie05]

I own both. Halo 3 for the win...

[carmatic]

Halo 3's MP is part of the campaign though (at least online co-op and the meta game). Both of those combined add alot more to Halo 3 than bioshock could ever wish for.

And the voting without playing both games is called bias. Some people will play one game and never consider another game being better. I hate that kind of thing, since one game being better than the other doesn't matter when they are both great games.

if only i could vote... when will halo 3 turn up on the PC? its not like i can walk out right now and buy halo 3 ... together with an xbox360...

[DELTETHISACCOUNT]

Halo 3 Singleplayer > Bioshock Singleplayer

Extremely higher replay value.

[Hoopla]

Bioshock

http://www.escapistmagazine.com/articles/v...ctuation-Halo-3

/end of thread

[planetik]

I like Bioshock's singleplayer more than Halo 3's. I love how it doesn't conform to regular FPS's (I know, I know, it's not THAT much different)

[Flash]

Single player Bioshock beats Halo 3 single player hands down. Try to compare single player only because it's only fair, I mean Bioshock doesn't even have a multiplayer so to say Halo 3 is better just because of its multiplayer is :s