Which graphics card to buy?


Recommended Posts

I am in need of a new graphics card. It needs to be a simple midrange graphics card for normal PC operations like running the OS, watching movies etc. My budge is $200. There will be no gaming.

I will also be running 3ds Max & Other such workstation applications but not a lot.. I have heard that ATI graphics card have problems in the view port with 3ds Max etc, is this true?

Feature wise Radeon 3650 is better then 9600GT, however the cost of 9600GT is more compared to Radeon 3650. So what should i do? Buy a Radeon 3650 or buy 9600GT.

Link to comment
https://www.neowin.net/forum/topic/624018-which-graphics-card-to-buy/
Share on other sites

I know I cannot compare 9600GT & ATI 3650 in terms of gaming, but as I have already mentioned that I will not be gaming with this card, I prefer XBOX 360 for that. I am comparing them in terms of features.

Although my budget is $200, but the cheaper the better. I was preferring ATI due to higher feature set in general desktop usage, the only thing I am concerned about is how the quality will be in 3ds max with ATI cards cos I have never used them in ATI Gaming cards.

So far, from all the reviews I have read, ATI 3650 pwns GeForce 8600GT in feature & performance, & pwns GeForce 9600GT in features. The extra performance in Geforce will hardly be used in my case.

Anyone used here apps like 3ds max & maya on ATI 3xxx series cards?

It's funny how everyone is posting video cards that people use for gaming...

Go for ATi's FireGL: http://ati.amd.com/products/firegl.html http://www.newegg.com/Product/ProductList....amp;x=0&y=0

Whether you’re an engineer designing mechanical subassemblies or an animator creating eye-popping visual effects, the ATI FireGL™ series of PCI Express and AGP workstation graphics accelerators offers complete top-to-bottom solutions with industry leading performance, ground-breaking features, and unprecedented visual fidelity for the most demanding workstation users from entry-level to ultra high-end at prices to match any budget.
ATI’s award-winning ATI Mobility FireGL™ workstation graphics technology enables engineers, animators, and designers to run professional 3D CAD and DCC applications whenever and wherever they go. ATI’s innovative ATI Mobility FireGL solutions have been integrated into mobile workstations by leading manufacturers including Dell, HP, IBM, and Fujitsu Siemens.

Card is not for gaming, its for 3D stuff ;)

Edited by BlackShadow
It's funny how everyone is posting video cards that people use for gaming...

Go for ATi's FireGL: http://ati.amd.com/products/firegl.html http://www.newegg.com/Product/ProductList....amp;x=0&y=0

Card is not for gaming, its for 3D stuff ;)

i already said this, i did, i did :D

they cost over $200 though don't they ?

I am in need of a new graphics card. It needs to be a simple midrange graphics card for normal PC operations like running the OS, watching movies etc. My budge is $200. There will be no gaming.

I will also be running 3ds Max & Other such workstation applications but not a lot.. I have heard that ATI graphics card have problems in the view port with 3ds Max etc, is this true?

Feature wise Radeon 3650 is better then 9600GT, however the cost of 9600GT is more compared to Radeon 3650. So what should i do? Buy a Radeon 3650 or buy 9600GT.

Depending on how much you're going to use 3ds Max, you want something like a Ati FireGL or some of the Matrox cards.

Well, I am from India & FireGL cards cost a lot here & are hard to find, I would rather buy a Dell workstation instead of looking for a separate workstation graphics card.

I am getting Sapphire Radeon HD 3650 here for $135 with 256 MB DDR3 Memory, should I deal? The only card better then this will be Radeon HD 3850 which will go over $200.

Note : The rate in $ is approx, as I need to Pay Rs 5,500 for the Radeon HD 3650.

Don't mean to hijack the thread, I just have a few questions:

- Does 9600GT has two independent display controllers (to drive two displays simultaneously with independent resolutions, refresh rates, color controls and video overlays for each display)?

- Where does 3870 get its source of sound from? Can 9600GT or 3870 get digital audio signal from from a soundcard through SPDIF?

tia

The 3650 is nice in that it can be ran fanless-- PowerColour and HIS sells it that way, and the Sapphire card can be fitted with an Arctic Cooling Accelero S2 (about USD 20)

However, the price difference is here like USD 80/105 for 512M GDDR2/GDDR3 cards here.

If my Sapphire GDDR2 version is typical, there isn't an audio-inbound connector. If you want to use sound over HDMI, I think it sets up a second sound device "inside" the card.

No need to spend so much money, you're not going to game, an 8600GT will serve you just fine :)

-Rich-

That makes sense but for only $15 more I am getting Radeon 3650 which gives more features then GeForce 8600GT, so it makes sense to buy HD 3650

This topic is now closed to further replies.
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Posts

    • Latest Rufus update improves new Windows 11 install method by Taras Buria Pete Batard, the maker of Rufus, a very popular app for creating bootable Windows (and other OS) media, has released a new beta version of its app. Rufus 4.15 beta is now out, and while it offers no new features, there are all sorts of improvements and fixes, including for the new Windows 11 installation method that was introduced in version 4.14 in early May. The "Silent Windows 11 installation" is a new feature whose goal is to automate operating system installation. All you have to do is boot from the drive, and then Rufus takes over, doing all things for you, such as setting up a new account, skipping ads and prompts, and more. It is a very handy tool, but initially, it had some bugs and issues that required addressing. With version 4.15 beta, Rufus is fixing that, particularly a bug with installation failing at 75%, crashes on Snapdragon X-based PCs, and more. Here is the changelog: Rufus 4.15 beta is now available for download from its GitHub repository. If you have never used Rufus before, you can check out our guide here. It is a very useful utility to have, as it allows you to deal with plenty of Windows 11's annoyances, which are still there, despite Microsoft's ongoing efforts to fix them.
    • Microsoft fixes one of Excel Copilot's most frustrating limitations by Usama Jawad Microsoft began integrating Copilot into Excel a couple of years ago and has been upgrading it with new functionalities since then. While some changes have been controversial, Microsoft is hoping to win over users by allowing them to be more productive via Copilot. To that end, it has now announced a Copilot improvement that may actually be appreciated by people who use it regularly. Excel customers often use the Copilot prompt box to issue instructions to format and customize their data, but it can become quite tiring to keep repeating the same instructions again and again. Microsoft now allows you to define Copilot personalization rules for formatting, naming conventions, formulas, and report styles. These can be accessed via Settings > Personalization, where you can explain your rules in natural language like "Always format currency in USD with no decimals", and just let Copilot take care of the rest. Microsoft is going a step further in this direction by allowing you to set workbook rules too. These rules are stored as a .Rules sheet, and are preserved while the workbook is shared. This fosters collaboration while making sure that standard rules govern the Copilot editing experience across the organization. Other advantages of this capability include pointing it to specific examples, defining dynamic formulas, and referencing an entire sheet and asking Copilot to infer rules based on that. You can leverage this feature by opening Copilot in Excel, clicking on "+", and selecting Create workbook rules. If you have an existing .Rules sheet, you can simply start listing the rules in column A as well. Personalization features are available to all Copilot in Excel users across the web, Mac, and Windows. Meanwhile, workbook rules are currently being previewed for Windows and Mac customers on the Insiders channel. General availability is scheduled after a few weeks, but a concrete date is currently unknown. Overall, the Excel capability is quite similar to ChatGPT's memory features, which allow you to permanently store items in the AI model's context window.
    • Imagine you still haven't discovered Total Commander that is doing all those things for three decades already...
    • This sounds like underneath the nice marketing spin, either someone at Adobe got tired of their lazy devs and asked Microsoft to help them sort at least some of Adobe's ancestral spaghetti code to make it go faster, or Microsoft wanted Adobe's crap to run better on Windows to make it look better when compared to Apple, so they offered to intervene. Either way, GOOD.
    • My favorite file manager for Windows 11 finally gets a long-requested feature by Taras Buria Files is among the best File Explorer alternatives for Windows 10 and 11. This free app is packed with all sorts of features and conveniences, but there is one crucial feature that is still missing—Tree View. Fortunately, the latest update in the Preview channel finally delivers it. With version 4.1.4, which is now available for download in the Preview channel, developers implemented Tree View, a new mode that displays folders in an expandable hierarchy. Windows 11's stock File Explorer always had this feature, but it was nowhere to be found in Files until now. Starting with the latest preview update, you can expand each drive and its nested folders without leaving the current location and then open the folder you need in the main view. To try Tree View in Files, update the app to the latest preview version, then click the small arrow next to a drive to expand its content. The developers say they are rolling out Tree View in Preview first to gather feedback from users and improve the feature before bringing it to all in the stable channel. In addition to Tree View, Files 4.1.14 improves the Windows Fonts folder. You can now preview each font directly in Files with no need to open the built-in font viewer. For now, these two features are only available in the Preview channel. For those using the stable release, developers recently released version 4.1.3, with improvements for the built-in tag system, on-demand folder size calculation, and plenty of various fixes. You can check out the full release notes here. You can download Files from the Microsoft Store (paid version) or its official website (free).
  • Recent Achievements

    • One Month Later
      Vincian earned a badge
      One Month Later
    • First Post
      Jocimo earned a badge
      First Post
    • Week One Done
      suprememobiles48 earned a badge
      Week One Done
    • One Month Later
      Windows Guy earned a badge
      One Month Later
    • One Month Later
      Prasann earned a badge
      One Month Later
  • Popular Contributors

    1. 1
      +primortal
      517
    2. 2
      +Edouard
      172
    3. 3
      PsYcHoKiLLa
      90
    4. 4
      Steven P.
      79
    5. 5
      ATLien_0
      68
  • Tell a friend

    Love Neowin? Tell a friend!