Distro Ideas -- Consolidation, etc


Recommended Posts

On Barney's prodding, I'm finally posting my ideas here in the forum.

I've been speaking with Barney and Crimson and was enlightening them to my ideas for the distro. Currently there are a few version (KDE, GNOME, LIGHT) and my proposal was to combine all of the version into a single dvd (as DVD drives are very prevalent and downloading a DVD sized iso for many people is just cheese stuck to the pot). My thinking was this could be accomplished by just placing all three into the same sort of directories by simply copying and pasting. The common files between the three would be overwritten, those that are different would be kept. If someone knows anything about grub or any kind of bootloader that can run on the disk so that we have a menu, it would be just as simple as picking which one you wanted to boot... KDE GNOME or LIGHT and each version of the live installer should know which files its installing.... Unless it's just copying the whole image... In that case we would have to figure out a way to get Ubiquiti to install just what was required.

Also, I would like to congradulate everyone involved for their efforts, this is an amazing project for the community and seems like at least one place where everyone is coming together. Keep it up! The art is awesome, those that I know on the team do a great job and I look forward to working with all of you

Brian

Link to comment
https://www.neowin.net/forum/topic/626601-distro-ideas-consolidation-etc/
Share on other sites

It's a decision that the Shift Team has to make, but I am rather fond of the idea that a "Lite" user (like myself) can quickly download and burn something small-ish onto a CD, and not need to download the full KDE and Gnome sets.

What you mention is what the Fedora team already does. While I like having one image for all, it does put light users at a disadvantage. Plus, look in various forums, including Neowin, and see how many people criticize Fedora as "bloat" because of the large DVD size needed, as they point to Ubuntu being one CD. Yes, I typically chime in at that point and mention that they are comparing one orange to a basket containing an orange, and apple and a banana (ok, I don't think I have ever used that exact metaphor, but you get the idea ;)).

I'm not a member of the Shift team (just a Linux-using Neowin member who wants to help out where he can), so I don't have a vote on this. Do these things even get "voted" on? :unsure: But just wanted to point out what to expect as far as community comments to the size of the distro.

My opinion on one disk is that currently there is a lot of selection, especially for the new user... It's almost like the issue that was brought up about Vista having a whole bunch of versions. By using just one install media containing all of that you're making it easier for those that may not know what do with three versions.

My opinion on one disk is that currently there is a lot of selection, especially for the new user... It's almost like the issue that was brought up about Vista having a whole bunch of versions. By using just one install media containing all of that you're making it easier for those that may not know what do with three versions.

But you still have to make that choice, either by downloading the appropriate iso, or in your example, from a menu system during boot/installation.

Choice is good. It's what Linux is all about. Shift should offer a choice, but if there's confusion, then that is something we need to look at. Education. Show the differences and all the pros and cons. Get it all on the Shift website if necessary. Aim to have the best comparison of Desktop Environments on the net. Eliminate the confusion.

I prefer the multiple CD's idea to one DVD. For a start, once you know more about the different DEs, you don't waste time and bandwidth downloading components you don't want (anyway, they're only an apt-get away should you change your mind...) Secondly... I haven't got a DVD writer :D :cry:

Thanks for your idea, Brian. I appreciate that you posted it for us. We definitely want ideas and opinions. We will take up this idea at our next IRC meeting. And thanks also for the kind words! :)

If this is the semi-official Shift "distro ideas" thread, may I add one that just hit me?

Neowin offers all members (even non-subscribers) a special neowin.us email. Can we have Shift set up to access this email for Shift users? I think that (if we use Thunderbird) that a webmail add-in might need to be included.

http://webmail.mozdev.org/

I think Brian's idea is an awesome one. Let me elaborate on it from my side as well ... Why not have a specialized installer that would handle all of the choices. One setup, one Dvd, and then let the user choose exactly what he wants on his install ?

As long as there was still a small-sized option for "Lite", because it seems kind of silly to me to offer a "Lite" version, but have a huge iso that includes full KDE and GNOME environments.

As long as there was still a small-sized option for "Lite", because it seems kind of silly to me to offer a "Lite" version, but have a huge iso that includes full KDE and GNOME environments.

Yeah... I don't see why we can't just offer it like we do now. ;)

This topic is now closed to further replies.
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Posts

    • Samsung is shutting down yet another app used by millions by David Uzondu Samsung has announced that it is shutting down Samsung Max, its VPN service used by more than 50 million people, effective today. Samsung Max VPN, if you don't know, was an Android app born on February 23, 2018, out of the ashes of Opera Max, a very popular data-saving VPN that Opera had discontinued the previous year. Samsung bought the discontinued service, rebranded it, and added a native Samsung UI to fit the Galaxy ecosystem. The app could do things like compress images, help you manage background data on a per-app basis, reduce video data consumption, shrink music files, optimize webpages, block advertisement trackers in incognito mode, and encrypt your internet traffic on public Wi-Fi networks. Image via SammyGuru If you open the app now, you'd be greeted by a shutdown banner warning that all VPN, data saving, and privacy services stopped functioning on June 15, 2026. The creators failed to provide a reason for the shutdown, instead publishing a farewell note that read: "Thank you for being with us over the years. Your support and activity truly meant a lot to us and helped shape this app into what it became." This same message appears on the Google Play Store listing for the app as well. Max VPN is the latest service from Samsung to join the list of discontinued applications from the company. Just two months ago, the Korean tech giant announced that it is completely shutting down Samsung Messages, forcing millions of users to migrate to Google Messages by next month. The only devices that the shutdown won't affect are older smartphones running Android 11 or lower. Some of the features of Google Messages that Samsung hopes will entice users include AI-powered scam detection to block suspicious links, integrated Gemini AI tools to generate quick replies, custom chat bubbles, and universal RCS compatibility for sharing high-quality media with iOS users. The platform also offers seamless syncing across tablets and smartwatches. In addition to that, users gain access to message scheduling, smart classification, and automated category sorting. Via: SammyGuru
    • 1. Define "better". 2. It's still more expensive than equivalent PCs so... And there is not one Windows platform. This is the mistake ALL Apple oriented people make. Apple is one OEM. You could reasonably compare them to one PC OEM, say Dell or HP. But you can't compare them to ALL PC OEMs. Case in point, Apple has NO touch screen MacBooks. No tablet Macs. There are no rugged Macs. The variety of PC OEM design is insane. With Apple, you have... Apple. The problem is that you're starting with Apple as the definition of "good" then filtering out anything that isn't close to an existing Apple product, then trying to homogenise all of those left into a fictional product line and then ignore any innovations to create a minimal feature subset so you can say "See! Apple better!" PS: I was an Apple dev for 17 years and helped develop MacInTalk and disability solutions for Apple, and worked on Microsoft Office for MacOS - and I have several Macs and MacBooks - so tread very carefully.
    • Major Xbox layoffs may claim South of Midnight developer Compulsion entirely by Pulasthi Ariyasinghe Microsoft has been making major changes in its gaming wing Xbox for a few months now, including the appointment of a new CEO, a large number of leadership changes, and strategy shifts. However, the company is seemingly also looking at initiating a major layoffs wave at Xbox and perhaps even a studio closure. The new report lands from Kotaku, Xbox first-party developer Compulsion Games is being shuttered soon by Microsoft. For those unfamiliar with the studio, it's the team behind Contrast (2013), We Happy Few (2018), and South of Midnight (2025). Its latest game was quite well received, even winning a Peabody Award for its writing. It even received a 9/10 in Neowin's own review, highlighting its engaging storyline, gorgeous world, and curious characters. The studio joined Xbox Game Studios in 2018, just as Microsoft announced it is acquiring Playground Games, Undead Labs, and Ninja Theory. Despite recent listings for new staff roles, according to the new report, Compulsion Games is being closed entirely, with over 90 staff being let go. Kotaku also added that the studio's leadership is in negotiations with Microsoft about this decision, but no official details have been revealed yet. The report lands just as two senior managers of Xbox leave their posts at Microsoft Gaming. Head of Xbox Game Studios Craig Duncan and chief of staff Louise O'Connor originally began their journey in Rare and have been a part of Xbox for over two decades. Dunkan has been responsible for games like Kinect Sports and Sea of Thieves, while O'Connor was primarily working on Rare's Everwild project before its cancelation. If this report about the studio shutdown is accurate, this may just be the start of a major new layoffs wave at Xbox Game Studios. There are also rumors of Arkane Studios being heavily affected. As always, take all these reports with a grain of salt until something official materializes from Microsoft or the studios.
    • The flaw with this analysis is that this laptop has a cellphone CPU in it. In the Intel world, that would be an N150 and those are everywhere, even in low end laptops. You can get an N150 based NUC with 16GB RAM and 256GB-512GB SSD... NOT soldered in... for < $500 Canadian (around US$360). The problem is two fold: tech bloggers/writers on most tech site (like this one, ironically) overvalue Apple and apparently aren't in the same earnings class as most regular people. As a result, we get breathless articles about how everyone needs a folding phone when most people just cannot afford one... or really need one. And we get Apple used as the baseline metric regardless of whether that comparison makes any sense. If Dell or HP released a retail laptop with a cellphone motherboard, you'd be all over them for doing that - but Apple does it and it's genius. I see articles suggesting what Samsung - a company that basically started the foldable phone market and has built them for eight years - needs to do to compete with Apple's unreleased, unspecced and unseen folding phone. Sorry, no - if the Neo (really creative name there BTW - still, better than the Go, the other "creative" product name everyone's using) encourages PC makers to make cellphone laptops using lower end ARM processors, we all lose. It's a step backwards and a capitulation to the fact that semiconductor makers and computer OEMs (and tech bloggers) have totally lost the plot.
  • Recent Achievements

    • One Year In
      ThatGuyOnline earned a badge
      One Year In
    • Week One Done
      Jeroen Wilms earned a badge
      Week One Done
    • Week One Done
      rolfus earned a badge
      Week One Done
    • One Month Later
      Leroy Jethro Gibbs earned a badge
      One Month Later
    • Conversation Starter
      flexorcist earned a badge
      Conversation Starter
  • Popular Contributors

    1. 1
      +primortal
      507
    2. 2
      +Edouard
      197
    3. 3
      PsYcHoKiLLa
      127
    4. 4
      Steven P.
      82
    5. 5
      neufuse
      73
  • Tell a friend

    Love Neowin? Tell a friend!