• 0

J2EE vs .Net


Question

I'm learning about these two development environments and I was wondering what your thoughts are on the differences between the two, specifically from a standpoint of integration to existing environments and interoperability? For example, I thought .Net was proprietary to M$oft and can only run in their environments, whereas J2EE is proprietary but can be run on multiple platforms. What are some other comparisons/contrasts between the two? What do you favour?

Link to comment
https://www.neowin.net/forum/topic/661830-j2ee-vs-net/
Share on other sites

12 answers to this question

Recommended Posts

  • 0

I've yet to meet anyone with depth in both technologies, so I sincerely doubt you'll be getting, uuummm, unbiased answers. I'm sure they both have plusses and minuses, but they both get the job done. Really, your questions, especially when you include the $ in MS, are probably going to invoke a mudslinging contest.

Frankly, I like working with MS tools and languages. I think MS has the best tools around, and I'm quite fond of C#. I don't work enough in Java to speak to it. I do know that I missed a lot of C# features when I had to use Java for a couple of courses. But, that was years ago and a lot has changed. The few people I do know that have worked a bit in J2EE are happy to be in .NET.

Technically, .NET can run on multiple platforms, too. Mobile, web, *nix(via Mono), and Windows. I've yet to be in a company that had such a heterogeneous environment that they needed both Java and .NET. At best, I've been in places that have both AS/400 and Microsoft servers, and we can communicate with the AS400 stuff just fine. I think the majority of interoperability between Java and .NET is going to come from web services or generic protocols, and not at a link level.

I've been using .NET since its inception and I think its growth is fantastic. It's a great platform to work on, and the tools are excellent. Again, I cannot speak to Java. I think C# is advancing at a more rapid pace than Java, and personally, think it is the better of the two in terms of consistency and expressiveness(from what I recall having to deal with in school). As anything in technology, it all changes, so take this stance with a grain of salt. By no means is my opinion an assault on Java. It is a great tool by all accounts, and has a great developer base. I learn a lot from that camp. Of the two, I think Java has the most mature developer base and probably the most depth in the engineering discipline. I think .NET is catching up, tho.

Link to comment
https://www.neowin.net/forum/topic/661830-j2ee-vs-net/#findComment-589699000
Share on other sites

  • 0

^^

excellent answer....

  Quote
thought .Net was proprietary to M$oft and can only run in their environments, whereas J2EE is proprietary but can be run on multiple platforms.

both are open standards, thus why you have the mono project (no one that I know of uses mono in corprate world).

So MS and Sun publish the specs. to be a certified J2EE vendor such as BEA, you need to meet specs specified by Sun.

lots of corps like runnin unix... so J2EE is I would say preferred. Though I am bias towards J2EE as that is the area I work in.

I think I agree with this statement

"I think Java has the most mature developer base and probably the most depth in the engineering discipline".

Link to comment
https://www.neowin.net/forum/topic/661830-j2ee-vs-net/#findComment-589699468
Share on other sites

  • 0
  _kane81 said:
both are open standards, thus why you have the mono project (no one that I know of uses mono in corprate world).

So MS and Sun publish the specs. to be a certified J2EE vendor such as BEA, you need to meet specs specified by Sun.

lots of corps like runnin unix... so J2EE is I would say preferred. Though I am bias towards J2EE as that is the area I work in.

I think I agree with this statement

"I think Java has the most mature developer base and probably the most depth in the engineering discipline".

Wow these are excellent points that I never even considered. It makes sense that .Net typically roll out things (such as whatever it contributed to Vista) which was arguably inappropriate for the needs of the market because of its serious flaws, and I've not seen this sort of thing originate from Sun. I like your points about certifications.

Link to comment
https://www.neowin.net/forum/topic/661830-j2ee-vs-net/#findComment-589701728
Share on other sites

  • 0
  Asymptote said:
Wow these are excellent points that I never even considered. It makes sense that .Net typically roll out things (such as whatever it contributed to Vista) which was arguably inappropriate for the needs of the market because of its serious flaws, and I've not seen this sort of thing originate from Sun.

What? :huh:

Link to comment
https://www.neowin.net/forum/topic/661830-j2ee-vs-net/#findComment-589701834
Share on other sites

  • 0
  Asymptote said:
Wow these are excellent points that I never even considered. It makes sense that .Net typically roll out things (such as whatever it contributed to Vista) which was arguably inappropriate for the needs of the market because of its serious flaws, and I've not seen this sort of thing originate from Sun. I like your points about certifications.

.NET doesn't have serious flaws, nor does MS' OS platforms nor its database server, and _kane81 wasn't implying that it did. He was merely saying that there are companies that prefer unix, which makes J2EE the preferred platform for them. Mono isn't mature enough to bet your business on just yet.

I work for a fairly large company with soon to be over 500 stores running on Microsoft platforms. We have to have 24/7 uptime as we are a convenience store chain. Our AS400 stuff is for our accounting system. We are converting to .NET in many areas, albeit with some growing pains, but we're finding better reliability and resilience in the platform than what we have/had in VB/ASP/COM, mainly due to the change in programming paradigm and a more robust platform. Most, if not all of the problems we have are due to developer problems, not platform problems.

Link to comment
https://www.neowin.net/forum/topic/661830-j2ee-vs-net/#findComment-589701906
Share on other sites

  • 0
  _kane81 said:
Asymptote

I think you have misuderstood my post... (as stated above)

When I said "serious flaws" I was thinking of things like the emails between Msoft execs saying what a horrible o/s Vista was yet they had to sell it, or all the problems XP had before it got its first service pack. Aren't those operating systems written in the .Net environment?

Link to comment
https://www.neowin.net/forum/topic/661830-j2ee-vs-net/#findComment-589708134
Share on other sites

  • 0

Most problems at launch with XP and Vista were driver-related and had nothing to do with the .NET framework, and as drivers mature they reveal themselves as versatile, fast and reliable operating systems.

Besides, XP was released 1 year before version 1.0 of the .NET framework. :rolleyes:

Link to comment
https://www.neowin.net/forum/topic/661830-j2ee-vs-net/#findComment-589708336
Share on other sites

  • 0

I've worked with both C# (.NET) and J2EE (JSP, servlet, beans) in the past, I'd say it's easier to get a project start and running with C#, while there are more mature and open frameworks for J2EE, for example struts + hibernate. But then I'm not too familiar with MVC frameworks in .NET

Link to comment
https://www.neowin.net/forum/topic/661830-j2ee-vs-net/#findComment-589708664
Share on other sites

  • 0
  wellofsouls said:
I've worked with both C# (.NET) and J2EE (JSP, servlet, beans) in the past, I'd say it's easier to get a project start and running with C#, while there are more mature and open frameworks for J2EE, for example struts + hibernate. But then I'm not too familiar with MVC frameworks in .NET

Thank you, Asik. I wasn't sure if it was because of inabilities of .Net or something else. Just one of those things I learn as I read more about this.

Link to comment
https://www.neowin.net/forum/topic/661830-j2ee-vs-net/#findComment-589709164
Share on other sites

  • 0
  Asymptote said:
Aren't those operating systems written in the .Net environment?

XP and Vista are not written in .NET. .NET is a platform that sits on top of the OS. The OSes themselves are written in a blend of Assembly, C, C++, etc.

There is research going into writing an OS using mostly managed code (such as Singularity), although there will probably always be parts written in lower level languages.

Link to comment
https://www.neowin.net/forum/topic/661830-j2ee-vs-net/#findComment-589709378
Share on other sites

This topic is now closed to further replies.
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Posts

    • The most corrupt and vile CEO any company ever had ! The only company that makes an insane amount of money decade after decade but doesn't deliver on even barely passable quality to customers, screws over partners and treats employees like trash
    • PSA: Some other versions of Windows are losing support on October 14 too by Usama Jawad All of us here at Neowin likely know pretty well by now that Windows 10 is reaching end of support on October 14, 2025. You can extend support through paid and "free" means, but if you don't, you won't get any more security or feature updates following the aforementioned date. We also highlighted that the Long-Term Servicing Channel (LTSC) version Windows 10 22H2 is also reaching end of support on that date. Now, Microsoft has reminded customers that yet another variant of Windows is reaching end of life on October 14, 2025 too. On the Windows Release Health dashboard, Microsoft has published a reminder that the Enterprise, Education, and IoT SKUs of Windows 11, version 22H2 will hit end of support on October 14 as well. It is important to keep in mind that the Home and Pro variants of Windows 11, version 22H2 already reached end of life on October 8, 2024, and the extra year of lease on life will end for other SKUs within a few months too. Windows 11, version 22H2 for IoT, Enterprise, and Education was released on September 20, 2022, which means that they would have received just over three years of support by the time they "die", compared to the regular two years for Home and Pro. Customers on any of these versions should consider upgrading to version 23H2 or 24H2 as soon as possible, which have end of support dates of November 10, 2026 and October 12, 2027, respectively. Staying on a supported version of Windows is crucial as that allows you to receive regular security updates on your machine. If you're an IT admin, you should immediately begin planning a migration to a supported version of the operating system, and if you're an employee or someone using these versions of Windows in some other scenario, go to Settings > System > About and check out Windows Specifications > Version.
    • Secret Changelog: New Features: Settings > Start, home, and new tab page > New tab page > Copilot new tab page (Chat, search, and navigate with a modern new tab page inspired by Copilot) Settings > AI innovations (Explore Copilot Mode)
    • Microsoft is adding some very useful features to Word, Teams, Outlook, and more by Usama Jawad Image via Microsoft Microsoft 365 is the Redmond tech firm's premier solution for Office apps and cloud storage, among other things. Microsoft offers both consumer- and enterprise-oriented subscriptions for this solution, enabling customers to take full advantage of cloud-powered capabilities, in contrast to the LTSC versions of Office. Microsoft 365 apps and services regularly receive new updates and the good thing is that Microsoft tracks them in a very transparent way on its public roadmap. The Redmond company has updated its Microsoft 365 Roadmap with a lot of items in the past week or so, and there are several interesting features there that may excite its customers. For starters, Word is getting a very useful utility that will likely help people writing detailed documents using the software. Microsoft is integrating third-party citation providers in the Reference tab, so that users can quickly add citations. This is being made available to GCC, GCC High, and Department of Defense (DoD) customers on desktop and web this month. There are several improvements on the way for Copilot Notebooks too. Users can customize the format, style, and duration of Audio Overviews in the application through natural language prompts. These Audio Overviews can then be saved on OneDrive so that they can be shared with others too. All of these capabilities are landing on the web next month. Speaking of Copilot, Microsoft is moving the navigation pane for Copilot Chat from the right side of the app to the left. Apart from retaining the existing features, this repositioning allows Microsoft to add new capabilities such as an All Conversations tab, while also streamlining the overall navigation experience. This is being implemented for all customers using Outlook and Teams on the web from next month. In the latter software, Microsoft is also introducing regional settings that gives controls over the app's language and datetime formats. This is being made available for all Teams customers on Android, iOS, desktop, and the web from next month. Meanwhile, the desktop version of Teams is exclusively gaining the ability next month to search for meetings and participants in the search bar and take actions directly from there. Available actions include viewing recaps, accessing the dedicated meetings tab, and RSVP-ing. Microsoft added 39 items to the Microsoft 365 Roadmap, so you can understand that the selection of items described above is only scratching the tip of the iceberg. Check out other upcoming capabilities like Universal Print enhancements and more Copilot improvements on the dedicated webpage here.
  • Recent Achievements

    • Week One Done
      hhgygy earned a badge
      Week One Done
    • One Month Later
      hhgygy earned a badge
      One Month Later
    • One Year In
      NIKI77 earned a badge
      One Year In
    • Week One Done
      artistro08 earned a badge
      Week One Done
    • Dedicated
      Balaji Kumar earned a badge
      Dedicated
  • Popular Contributors

    1. 1
      +primortal
      639
    2. 2
      ATLien_0
      237
    3. 3
      Xenon
      166
    4. 4
      neufuse
      144
    5. 5
      +FloatingFatMan
      122
  • Tell a friend

    Love Neowin? Tell a friend!