Why is watching 720p Youtube vids so cpu intensive?

By Inctye
in Smart Home, Network & Security

 Share

Recommended Posts

Experienced

Inctye

Posted
Posted

As many of you might know by now, youtube videos can be watched in 720p HD quality by adding "&fmt=22" to the end of video urls. I use a Greasemonkey plugin called YousableTubeFix and dev updated the script yesterday with a feature that automatically switches to 720p quality when available.

But, the problem I noticed when watching these 720p vids is my cpu usage started shooting up to 50-100% usage and the video played less smoothly than it normally does at lower quality levels. Anyone know why this happens? I have a AMD Turion 64 X2 Mobile Technology TL-56 1.8Ghz and 2gigs of memory.

Grand Master

Jase

Posted
Posted

What what what?.. Youtube now offer 720p?.. yeah right!

Last time I checked they offered high quality videos..but still the Quality was not that good.. I have never seen a good quality high-res Video on youtube... What I have seen are Videos that where 720p Compressed on youtube (poorly) and uploaded.. The outcome = Rubbish Viewing.

If this is a new feature.. please do share the news.

Now back to topic; Have you updated your version of Flash to the new version?

Grand Master

Jase

Posted
Posted

whoa! that's amazing! is there a section just for High Quality Videos?

OP: The Video Plays perfectly fine for me, maybe updating Flash will help?

Experienced

Inctye

Posted
  • Author
Posted
Flash is poorly optimized yes, but even there, a 720p video would be hard on the CPU if not hardware accelerated by the GPU.

I have updated to Flash 10 since it was first released. But, you are probably are right on the GPU part. I have a crappy integrated Radeon x1200, which probably pushes most of the load onto the CPUs. Completely overlooked the GPU when I made my decision to buy this laptop two years ago and kind of regretting it. So for now, I guess I'm stuck with watching just plain "high quality" instead of HD.

Grand Master

Jase

Posted
Posted

From your first post it looks like you are using Firefox.. try running Firefox in Safemode and trying to see if the Video playback is better. Firefox still seems to be a big memory hog.

also you might as well check out alternative browsers

Grand Master

Matrix XII

Posted
Posted

Oh my! How could I not have know this? :|

Very smart of youtube to do this, maybe I'll start browsing there a bit more again.

Grand Master

Jase

Posted
Posted
Oh my! How could I not have know this? :|

Very smart of youtube to do this, maybe I'll start browsing there a bit more again.

Man I am as shocked as you.. I am glad Youtube now have this! Just hope they don't pull a Stage6 with this move.

Proficient

arturogoga

Posted
Posted

Doesn't matter much if you have a powerful videocard: flash just stinks for video. If you wanna watch 720p, better get the h.264 version (mp4).

Not much of an issue in Windows (I get 20-30% CPU in Windows Vista x64), but on my MBP (with the 9600M) it's nearly unwatchable. Same goes for linux.

Grand Master

Jase

Posted
Posted
Doesn't matter much if you have a powerful videocard: flash just stinks for video. If you wanna watch 720p, better get the h.264 version (mp4).

Not much of an issue in Windows (I get 20-30% CPU in Windows Vista x64), but on my MBP (with the 9600M) it's nearly unwatchable. Same goes for linux.

Is there a way to switch from Flash to quicktime Video or something?

Grand Master

Blackhearted

Posted
Posted

The 720p link Prickly posted didn't really seem that cpu intensive to me. It averaged around 25-30% and peaked at a mere 35% on my athlon64x2 4000+ @ 2.82ghz. I've seen flash do much worse than that without 720p video.

Experienced

Inctye

Posted
  • Author
Posted
If hulu can't live up to 720p, youtube may have won

Hulu already has a small designated HD section for 720p and 1080p that works amazingly, but the selections are limited to some old episodes. There are probably some server-side and website kinks and capacity that need to be worked out before they do a wide release for all of their shows and movies. I don't see them losing the advantage they have anytime soon given that it is the best online tv show/movie player there is.

Doesn't matter much if you have a powerful videocard: flash just stinks for video. If you wanna watch 720p, better get the h.264 version (mp4).

Not much of an issue in Windows (I get 20-30% CPU in Windows Vista x64), but on my MBP (with the 9600M) it's nearly unwatchable. Same goes for linux.

Yep, the greasemonkey script called YousableTubeFix is amazing and has features that allows for watching 720p in mp4 format. Did a little more testing on a few other vids and its still consistantly around 50-60% usage on both cores, around 20-30% on another computer better hardware. Must be mostly flash and a little bit of hardware too.

Grand Master

Brandon Live Veteran

Posted
  • Veteran
Posted

As much as I love to rag on Flash for being total crap, my CPU usage doesn't go above 5% while playing back that video. Though, this is on a Q9540.

Give me some reasons why?

Vastly more secure, efficient, and better video quality?

Grand Master

Jase

Posted
Posted
As much as I love to rag on Flash for being total crap, my CPU usage doesn't go above 5% while playing back that video. Though, this is on a Q9540.

Vastly more secure, efficient, and better video quality?

Can you please elaborate on that?

This topic is now closed to further replies.
 Share
Go to topic listing

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.

  • Posts

    • Nearly half of American adults now use AI, but concerns are also growing

      By Hamid Ganji · Posted

      Nearly half of American adults now use AI, but concerns are also growing by Hamid Ganji Since the launch of ChatGPT in 2022, the way people research, get their news, and perform routine tasks has changed dramatically. Now, almost everything around us has a touch of AI, and companies are trying to embed it into nearly every product and service they offer. With that in mind, new research shows how Americans are actually adopting this change and using AI in their everyday lives. According to new research conducted by the Pew Research Center, 49% of American adults now use AI chatbots like ChatGPT or Gemini. This marks a significant increase over last year, when only 33% of American adults reported using AI. Additionally, four in ten U.S. adults (42%) said they use AI tools to research information, while 38% said they use these tools to handle tasks at work. Entertainment, image and video editing, and getting medical advice are among the other ways Americans are using AI. Moreover, ChatGPT dominates the U.S. AI market, with 44% of respondents saying they use OpenAI's chatbot. Gemini follows at 24%, while Copilot and Meta AI account for 17% and 14%, respectively. Respondents also said that AI chatbots generally have a positive impact on their productivity and how informed they are. But when it comes to AI’s impact on society, Americans remain largely skeptical. About 40% of American adults believe AI will be more harmful than beneficial to society over the next 20 years. Additionally, 31% expect AI to have a negative effect on them personally. Another 31% of respondents say AI could be equally positive and negative. As for data security, pessimism remains high: 71% of respondents say AI will make their personal information less secure, while only 3% believe it will make their data more secure. American adults also largely lack confidence in both the government and AI companies when it comes to regulating and developing AI. About 67% of Americans have little to no confidence in the U.S. government’s ability to regulate AI effectively. Six in ten adults are also not confident that U.S. companies will develop and use these tools responsibly.
    • MultiOS-USB 0.11.1

      By Copernic · Posted

      MultiOS-USB 0.11.1 by Razvan Serea MultiOS-USB is a versatile, open-source utility designed to create multiboot USB drives capable of hosting multiple operating systems on a single portable device. The project simplifies the process of building a bootable USB by automating the configuration of various boot loaders and file systems, enabling users to install and run diverse operating systems, including Windows, Linux distributions, and diagnostic tools, directly from one drive. It supports ISO booting and persistence, which allows changes made during live sessions to be retained, making it ideal for testing, troubleshooting, or system recovery. Features: BIOS and UEFI support Secure Boot support (boot, manage uefi keys) Load UEFI drivers Launch .efi executables and other boot loaders Boot Linux from .iso images Boot WinPE from bootable .wim images Boot Windows 10/11 installer from ISO (currently, SB must be disabled during installation) Boot Linux installer from network (experimental) Boot locally installed systems: Linux, Windows Automatically update configuration files Without background services exFAT file system support Automatic detection of compatible ISO images (GRUB loopback) Support for systems without loopback support Allows customisation of ISO boot menu (for example: custom kernel options) Support for USB, SSD, nvme, mmcblk, loop, nbd and virtual disks Support for x86, x86_64 A list of tested ISO images can be found here MultiOS-USB 0.11.1 changelog: 68122b7: Fixed-release AUR package #63 fba0283: Update shim to 16.1 8c2ae95: Update grub to v2.14-1 ea15c1d: Update Memtest86+ to v8.10 162f4e6: Add secureblue (#71) b2da8ae: Add AerynOS (#74) ac6640e: Bump config.version 34e9ca6: Add Bluefin (#72) 7a10edd: Add Aurora (#66) cab701b: Update wimboot to v2.9.0-1 90da7f7: Fix Windows error: 0x80070001 - 0x4002F (#52) 2dea73d: Add Microsoft certificates 01f479e: Remove old efi_uga module Download: MultiOS-USB 0.11.1 | 5.3 MB (Open Source) View: MultiOS-USB Website | Screenshot Get alerted to all of our Software updates on Twitter at @NeowinSoftware
    • Classic 7 is Windows 10 LTSC cosplaying as Windows 7

      By Skyfrog · Posted

      Seems to be working fine for me.
    • Latest Rufus update improves new Windows 11 install method

      By TarasBuria · Posted

      Latest Rufus update improves new Windows 11 install method by Taras Buria Pete Batard, the maker of Rufus, a very popular app for creating bootable Windows (and other OS) media, has released a new beta version of its app. Rufus 4.15 beta is now out, and while it offers no new features, there are all sorts of improvements and fixes, including for the new Windows 11 installation method that was introduced in version 4.14 in early May. The "Silent Windows 11 installation" is a new feature whose goal is to automate operating system installation. All you have to do is boot from the drive, and then Rufus takes over, doing all things for you, such as setting up a new account, skipping ads and prompts, and more. It is a very handy tool, but initially, it had some bugs and issues that required addressing. With version 4.15 beta, Rufus is fixing that, particularly a bug with installation failing at 75%, crashes on Snapdragon X-based PCs, and more. Here is the changelog: Rufus 4.15 beta is now available for download from its GitHub repository. If you have never used Rufus before, you can check out our guide here. It is a very useful utility to have, as it allows you to deal with plenty of Windows 11's annoyances, which are still there, despite Microsoft's ongoing efforts to fix them.
    • Microsoft fixes one of Excel Copilot's most frustrating limitations

      By Usama Jawad96 · Posted

      Microsoft fixes one of Excel Copilot's most frustrating limitations by Usama Jawad Microsoft began integrating Copilot into Excel a couple of years ago and has been upgrading it with new functionalities since then. While some changes have been controversial, Microsoft is hoping to win over users by allowing them to be more productive via Copilot. To that end, it has now announced a Copilot improvement that may actually be appreciated by people who use it regularly. Excel customers often use the Copilot prompt box to issue instructions to format and customize their data, but it can become quite tiring to keep repeating the same instructions again and again. Microsoft now allows you to define Copilot personalization rules for formatting, naming conventions, formulas, and report styles. These can be accessed via Settings > Personalization, where you can explain your rules in natural language like "Always format currency in USD with no decimals", and just let Copilot take care of the rest. Microsoft is going a step further in this direction by allowing you to set workbook rules too. These rules are stored as a .Rules sheet, and are preserved while the workbook is shared. This fosters collaboration while making sure that standard rules govern the Copilot editing experience across the organization. Other advantages of this capability include pointing it to specific examples, defining dynamic formulas, and referencing an entire sheet and asking Copilot to infer rules based on that. You can leverage this feature by opening Copilot in Excel, clicking on "+", and selecting Create workbook rules. If you have an existing .Rules sheet, you can simply start listing the rules in column A as well. Personalization features are available to all Copilot in Excel users across the web, Mac, and Windows. Meanwhile, workbook rules are currently being previewed for Windows and Mac customers on the Insiders channel. General availability is scheduled after a few weeks, but a concrete date is currently unknown. Overall, the Excel capability is quite similar to ChatGPT's memory features, which allow you to permanently store items in the AI model's context window.

  • Recent Achievements

    • One Month Later
      Vincian earned a badge
      One Month Later
    • First Post
      Jocimo earned a badge
      First Post
    • Week One Done
      suprememobiles48 earned a badge
      Week One Done
    • One Month Later
      Windows Guy earned a badge
      One Month Later
    • One Month Later
      Prasann earned a badge
      One Month Later

  • Popular Contributors

    1. 1
      +primortal
      510
    2. 2
      +Edouard
      172
    3. 3
      PsYcHoKiLLa
      90
    4. 4
      Steven P.
      76
    5. 5
      neufuse
      68
    Show More

  • Tell a friend

    Love Neowin? Tell a friend!