Computer Browser Service across multiple subnets


Recommended Posts

I've got around 20 computers spanned across multiple subnets in a network. They all are configured to be a par tof the same workgroup called "Workgroup". All the computers are running windows 2000 profesional.

My issue is that i cannot see the computers from different subnets in Network Neighbour hood, although i can ping across those from anywhere in the network.

I know i have to use computer browser service to achieve the functionality. But the question is how do I do so. The computer browser service is running by default on all the computers.

My questions are is it possible to define the computer role in CBS or is it automatically assigned based on some criteria.

On referring to the document from microsoft for CBS, i came to understand that for every subnet there needs to be a different master browser and i need to have a master browser for the whole work group, but how can these be defined?

Also, as mentioned before, i have different subnets on the network and they are being linked using CISCO C3750's, so can i still work with work groups or do i need to setup domain for this purpose.

I appreciate if anyone can assist me out there.

this may help you:

Lmhosts File

NetBIOS name resolution is typically performed through broadcasts, which will resolve names only on the local subnet. To resolve names of computers located on another subnet, the Lmhosts file (located in the directory systemroot\System32\drivers\etc) must be configured. The Lmhosts file must contain a NetBIOS name?to?IP address mapping for all computers that are not on the local subnet.

To implement communication between subnets and the domain master browse server, the administrator must configure the Lmhosts file with the NetBIOS names and IP addresses of all browsers. To ensure that the master browse server for each subnet can access the domain?s PDC, the PDC for each domain must have an entry in the Lmhosts file for each master browse server. Also, each entry must have the tag #DOM, which designates the named computer as a domain controller.

To guarantee that the domain master browse server can request the local browse list from the master browse server of each subnet, the Lmhosts file on the domain master browse server must contain entries for all the potential master browse servers. Thus, the Lmhosts file on the master browse server of each subnet needs to contain the following information:

IP address and NetBIOS name of the domain master browse server

Domain name, preceded by the tags #PRE and #DOM

You know I am not sure it will work without a domain.. Normally once you get to the point that you are running multiple segments, you have enough machines where a domain would make sense.

I have to ask -- WTF you have multiple segments for with only 20 machines?? If you want browsing to work - and broadcast name resolution the easiest fix would be to flatten your network. I see little reason for multiple segments with only 20 machines. Are you doing ACL's between the segments? Please tell me your not using soho routers and natting between the segments!!

http://support.microsoft.com/kb/117633

How browsing browsing over a multi-subnet TCP/IP network works in a domain and in a workgroup

Multi-subnet TCP/IP network browsing support is available only in a domain environment

http://networking.nitecruzr.net/2005/08/br...ss-subnets.html

If a workgroup is segmented, there will be no domain (workgroup) master browser, and no ability for servers on one segment to be seen from another segment. Segmented workgroups simply can't be browsed across segment boundaries.

Kind of hard to have a DOMAIN master browser without a domain ;) You could always just run a wins server if you want netbios name resolution across segments, samba will do this and even act as your PDC, etc. so you could get browsing to work ;)

But with only 20 machines - unless you have some security reason you have the machines in different segments, and are actually using ACL's between segments, etc. I would just flatten your network out. Now if you had 200 machines or 2000 multiple segments might come in handy but with 20.. Not really unless done for security reasons.

Ok I just reread your post -- the 3570's did not kick in the first time ;) Quite often in these small ma and pop shops (20 machines) you see soho routers used to add more ports vs switches, etc. But with 3570's seems you got some decent networking hardware in place.

So are these segments in the same building, or campus -- or do you have wan connections connecting the segments?

Again unless you have specific security requirements, or wan connections between the segments? It would be just easier to flatten the network this would allow broadcasting for netbios names and also allow for 1 machine to be the master browser for the segment.

Do you have a machine being used as a server? Do you have a machine that is on 24/7/365? If so I would set this machine up to be the master browser - and then set the other machines to not be able to be master browsers - this will limit the number of elections, and if all of them are running 2k pro -- they are all at the same level and any of them could be the master browser, so you could have it switching between machines and mess up the browse list, etc.

As already mentioned if you do not have windows server os running -- there are free options to having a domain be it for central userbase or just for wins and network browsing with samba. Another free option to the windows server OSes is to grab a copy of ClarkConnect - there is a free version and this can be used ad your Domain Controller and be your PDC and wins, and your domain master browser, etc.

Even if you flatten the network - I would pick a machine and set it up to always be the master browser and turn off the other machines from being able to do so -- this will make for much more stable network browsing.

This can be done with this reg key.

http://www.pctools.com/guides/registry/detail/54/

Control Network Browser Elections at Registry Guide for Windows

This topic is now closed to further replies.
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Posts

    • Microsoft confirms Windows Outlook breaks in many ways after major Calendar feature upgrade by Sayan Sen Microsoft has been trying to get more users onto New Outlook for Windows, and it is doing so not just by enforcing the newer app but also by making improvements along the way. In doing so, though, the company has caused the Classic Outlook app to bug out in the past. The classic app received a major Shared Calendar-related upgrade recently, with many " long-awaited improvements" as well as "small changes in form and function." As the name suggests, the Outlook Shared Calendar essentially allows multiple people to interact with and manage the calendar. With Shared Calendar improvements enabled, users will see the following changes: Instant sync and view of shared calendars Editing series end date does not reset the past Accepting meeting without having to send a response Last Modified By no longer shown in the meeting item Adding same calendar multiple times can't be done Duplicate calendars simultaneously selection Attachments addition not possible when responding to a meeting invitation Event drafts auto-save changes The "Download shared folders" setting is ignored Unfortunately, as with any major feature upgrade, there are bugs, and Microsoft has confirmed this is no different. The tech giant has shared official guidance for it so that users can work around the problems. According to the company, "Shared Calendar improvements are now enabled by default in the most recent versions of Outlook, in all update channels for Microsoft 365 Apps," and thus, the bugs are likely to affect many. Here are some of the bugs Microsoft is investigating, as well as their workarounds: Bug Workaround Meeting cancellation sent unexpectedly to some attendees in classic Outlook In a REST shared calendar, after adding or removing an attendee, or forwarding a meeting, a meeting cancellation may be sent unexpectedly to some attendees. Use the Outlook Web App or new Outlook when adding or removing an attendee or forwarding a meeting. Attendees do not get updates on attachment changes by Delegate When a delegate sends an update on a meeting that requires removing an attachment on an occurrence of a meeting series, the recipients may not get some or all of the attachment changes. In the delegate's Sync Issues folder, you'll see sync errors. Example: 17:23:26 Synchronizer Version 16.0.15313 17:23:26 Synchronizing Mailbox 'Delegate User' 17:23:26 Synchronizing local changes in folder 'Manager User' 17:23:27 Uploading to server 'https://outlook.office365.com/mapi/emsmdb/?xxxxxxxx-xx' 17:23:30 Error synchronizing folder 17:23:30 [0-320] There is no known workaround. It is recommended, whenever possible, to save attachments to SharePoint or to OneDrive and share with a link. After an attachment is deleted from an existing meeting, it may reappear after being deleted Please wait approximately one minute to give the sync time to complete. Additionally, it is advisable to save attachments to SharePoint or OneDrive whenever possible and share them using a link. A meeting created by a delegate with limited calendar access disappears and is unsent when a sensitivity label other than "Normal" is selected Three potential solutions to address this issue, each with their own implications for functionality: Manager can update delegate's permissions to allow viewing of private items. Delegate can change the sensitivity label of the meeting to "Normal". Delegate can disable Shared Calendar Improvements (not recommended). Aside from these, Microsoft has also fixed several other bugs, which you can find in the official support article here on the company's website.
    • I’ve just paid £290/$390 for a 4TB Samsung 990 Pro for my PS5 Pro so it’s not too far from the going rate. Microsoft should definitely copy Sony and let users buy their own SSD in their next consoles rather than this proprietary stuff. I paid £374/$505 for the 2TB Seagate card for my Series X a few years ago so it’s not exactly over priced. 4TB of NVMe storage ain’t cheap!
    • The EU regulations force companies to respect users privacy, choice and data. Something all tech companies have abused to the hilt and would continue to do so if it wasn’t for important legislation and laws the EU brought in, which have been adopted elsewhere around the world. The EU can be a nuisance, but they actually do more good than harm. Forcing Apple, Google, Microsoft etc to make changes hasn’t negatively impacted anyone apart from their financials as they aren’t free to pillage our data like they once were, unless they explicitly provide options to obtain consent.
    • Windows 10 Enterprise IoT LTSC will continue getting updates until January 2032. I would expect support from most programs to continue until then. Firefox still supports Windows 7 (until the end of August), which will be just over 16 years since release. Windows 10 will be of a very similar age in January 2032. I'm sure some things like games will move on earlier, but I imagine a Windows 10 machine will be safe and usable for a long time to come yet, despite the pressure and fearmongering from those who stand to gain from selling you a new PC.
    • Refined dock and bug fixes land in latest Elementary OS 8 updates by David Uzondu If you're running Elementary OS 8, there's a new round of updates available, bringing some neat enhancements, particularly to its signature Dock and the underlying window manager, Gala. If you are not familiar, Elementary OS positions itself as a polished alternative to Windows and macOS. It runs its own custom desktop environment called Pantheon, with Gala handling all the window management magic, like animations and how windows behave. In the new update, the Dock gets some notable new tricks, including the return of a couple of features that old-school Plank (the Dock's foundation) users might remember. For starters, the Dock now shows multiple indicator dots beneath an app icon if you have more than one window open for that application, which is useful for quickly seeing what is running. Plus, if you are dragging something and hover over an app icon in the Dock, it will cycle through that app's open windows, making it easier to drop your item into the right place. You can also now long-press an app icon to bring up its context menu, a nice touch for those who prefer that interaction. The elementary OS team also squashed some bugs related to hide modes and memory usage, keeping things running smoothly. Gala itself recently got a massive update, addressing around 20 reported issues and introducing a brand new Gesture Controller. This means users can now swipe up in the Multitasking View to close windows, a slick and intuitive gesture. App titles are now always shown in Multitasking View, a significant improvement for touchscreen users. Users also get notified when they take a screenshot with a keyboard shortcut, and this notification lets them jump straight to the image in Files. Some other welcome Gala improvements include saving window states on sleep and shutdown, and fixing an annoying bug where menus might only show once. For gamers, a fix for Lutris Flatpak installations causing Gala to crash with GE Proton setups will be a relief, and users of the Postman app will be happy to know that window captures for it are no longer partially rendered. Shifting back to Elementary OS 8, in System Settings, choosing light or dark mode properly snoozes your schedule instead of outright disabling it. The Reduce Motion setting has been expanded to cover a wider array of animations, which is a blessing for folks prone to motion sickness. Hotcorners got some fixes too, and there is a new option to keep them active even when an application is full screen. Other notable updates include added screen reader support for notifications and the shortcut overlay, fixes for Flatpak sandbox issues that affected apps like Steam, and the latest version of GNOME Web, which brought better performance and a redesigned bookmarks sidebar. You can download all these updates by opening System Settings, heading to System, and hitting "Update All."
  • Recent Achievements

    • Enthusiast
      Epaminombas went up a rank
      Enthusiast
    • Posting Machine
      Fiza Ali earned a badge
      Posting Machine
    • One Year In
      WaynesWorld earned a badge
      One Year In
    • First Post
      chriskinney317 earned a badge
      First Post
    • Week One Done
      Nullun earned a badge
      Week One Done
  • Popular Contributors

    1. 1
      +primortal
      186
    2. 2
      snowy owl
      131
    3. 3
      ATLien_0
      129
    4. 4
      Xenon
      121
    5. 5
      +Edouard
      91
  • Tell a friend

    Love Neowin? Tell a friend!