DHCP over wan problem


Recommended Posts

hey guys

i have a problem with our dhcp server. I am trying to get have it run as a backup dhcp for a remote location. connection speed would not be an issue here.

at the remote location scope is x.x 167.11 to x.x.167.125 /25 I know this works because thats what they have had configured for years.

at our location here.. we set up another scope x.x.167.192 to x.x.167.254/25

scope options are the same for both sites.

i had our network WAN guys turn on ip helper and when i run a packet sniffer on the server here.. i do see discover packets coming in from the remote location. I even know what computer is requesting a ip renew.

it is requesting an ip x.x.167.73 which is what it had before, but obviously it should get a different one since the scope here is different.

the problem i'm getting is that the dhcp server is only getting discover packets and not doing anything else... it's probably something really stupid but i can't figure this thing out..

any ideas?

Link to comment
https://www.neowin.net/forum/topic/800948-dhcp-over-wan-problem/
Share on other sites

  ]SK[ said:

DHCP traffic can't route over the internet. Man the internet would be one broken place. Just imagine all them home users plugging in their cable modem into the LAN rather than WAN ports on their routers.

I guess its possible with a DHCP Relay.

we have this implemented down east so i know it does work. and sicne the dhcp packets are actually hitting the local dhcp server here it means that the routers are doing their job...

i'm thinking that it might be something on the server??

another thing to note is that we already have a different scope that does exactly the same thing for a different remote location... and it works perfectly

  ]SK[ said:

DHCP traffic can't route over the internet. Man the internet would be one broken place. Just imagine all them home users plugging in their cable modem into the LAN rather than WAN ports on their routers.

I guess its possible with a DHCP Relay.

Couldn't see any mention of routing DHCP over the internet in his post. If it's routing DHCP over a WAN link, then yes it's perfectly possible but it needs to be configured correctly. DHCP could be routed over the internet if there was a VPN WAN link as well.

What you need to happen is local DHCP server answers requests as it's quickest.

If the local DHCP server is down, then the router or a DHCP relay agent forwards the request to your remote DHCP which sends a lease back for the client.

If that's how you've got it configured but it's not working then there's something wrong with your DHCP forwarding or your scope. If you are trying to test it with local and remote DHCP server's and the scopes both running it's down to timing as to which answers first.

This topic is now closed to further replies.
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Posts

    • whats the deal with the richt-click menus?
    • Anthropic trained its models on copyrighted books, US judge says it's fair use by Paul Hill The rise of artificial intelligence large language models has raised many ethical debates. One of the key debates is about whether AI companies should be allowed to train their models on copyrighted books. Today, we’ve gotten a definitive answer from U.S. District Judge William Alsup, who ruled in favor of Anthropic that its use of copyrighted books to train models was indeed considered fair use. This case will be a massive relief for the likes of OpenAI, Google, and Meta who have all used thousands, if not millions, of copyrighted books to train their models. The judge also said that while the use of these books for training is fair use, it was also a copyright violation to store authors’ books in a “central library”. This adds a bit of ambiguity to the whole matter as presumably a library is needed to be compiled before training can occur. The judge essentially agreed with the argument put forth by Anthropic that its training on these books was a transformative use, meaning it more strongly falls under fair use rules that allow for the use of copyrighted works without the copyright owner’s permission. The judge compared AI to any person aspiring to be a writer. He said the AI is not trying to race ahead and replicate or supplant the copyright holders, but instead turns a “hard corner” and creates something different. One of the key complaints from authors is that sometimes the books being used to train models are obtained through piracy websites. Judge Alsup’s comments could essentially be saying that it’s a copyright violation to download the books illegally and that companies ought to purchase a copy before training on it, though, ambiguity remains. This case is monumental because it’s one of, if not, the first decision made by a judge on fair use in relation to generative AI. It is likely to set a precedent in the United States. Outside the country, his decision may be more difficult to cite based on copyright rules. In the UK, for example, there is no fair use, just fair dealing, which is more restrictive. It’ll certainly be interesting to see how the legal tussles evolve going forward, with authors seeking to protect their hard work and AI companies trying to create the latest technologies. Source: Reuters
    • TeamViewer 15.67.3 by Razvan Serea TeamViewer is the fast, simple and friendly solution for remote access over the Internet - all applications in one single, very affordable module. Remote control of computers over the Internet, Instantly take control over a computer anywhere on the Internet, even through firewalls. No installation required, just use it fast and secure. Training, sales and teamwork, TeamViewer can also be used to present your desktop to a partner on the Internet. Show and share your software, PowerPoint presentations etc. File transfer, chat and more, Share your files, chat, switch the direction during a teamwork session, and a lot more is included in TeamViewer. TeamViewer 15.67.3.0 new features: It's now possible to use the AI-based TeamViewer CoPilot functionality within a session. This feature allows users to analyze remote device data, receive suggestions on IT questions, and diagnose error messages displayed on the remote screen. This feature is accessible exclusively through the new user interface and limited to connections to Windows devices. Company administrators can now access user reports on the newly introduced Security Center page. This page offers an overview of security features that can be enabled to enhance protection at both the user and device levels. The initial release includes recommended settings within the user report. Session Insights can now be activated for all outgoing connections at the company level. By default, logging requires end-user confirmation, but this behavior can be adjusted through access control settings. The new offline filter button on the Device List page enables users to effortlessly filter out offline devices with just a single click. A new column showing the installed TeamViewer version has been added to the device list. Users can now view and sort devices by version. The Remote Support page now utilizes the classic ID and password layout. The option to start a connection via link is available in the Sessions tab. The process of adding a remote device has been simplified. It is now possible to either bookmark the device (by saving it with its ID and password) or assign it directly to a company's account for enhanced management. When the assignment option is selected, a unique link is generated. Sharing this link will either add the device directly to the list (if TeamViewer is already installed) or download TeamViewer and then automatically add the device - all in one seamless step. In general, the assignment method provides more administrative options and improved security. It is now possible for users to view contacts in the device dock. Users will now have the ability to send messages directly to devices. This option will be accessible from both the command bar and device drawer. Information about device eligibility criteria has been added to the DEX Essentials activation flow. Improvements It is now possible to resize the desktop app window and expand or collapse the navigation menus. The Connect and Overview tabs have been combined into a single view within the device details drawer. It is now easier to change device names in the device list. New functionality has also been introduced which allows the user to copy the TeamViewer ID with a single click. The most frequently used pages in the TeamViewer app have been updated to improve accessibility and usability for users with disabilities who rely on screen readers. DEX Essentials product, previously available in web app, is now available in TeamViewer Windows desktop version. It is now possible to filter by device category for all managed devices, legacy devices, contacts, legacy groups, and device groups. This makes it easier for users to manage and organize their devices effectively. The global contact search experience has been improved. The search results will now include the contact's email address. DEX Essentials activation via policy flow now allows selection of offline devices. Download: TeamViewer 15.67.3.0 | 32-bit | Portable | Mac | ~70.0 MB (Free for personal use) View: TeamViewer Home Page | Release Notes | Screenshot Get alerted to all of our Software updates on Twitter at @NeowinSoftware
  • Recent Achievements

    • Week One Done
      DrRonSr earned a badge
      Week One Done
    • Week One Done
      Sharon dixon earned a badge
      Week One Done
    • Dedicated
      Parallax Abstraction earned a badge
      Dedicated
    • First Post
      956400 earned a badge
      First Post
    • Week One Done
      davidfegan earned a badge
      Week One Done
  • Popular Contributors

    1. 1
      +primortal
      597
    2. 2
      ATLien_0
      223
    3. 3
      Michael Scrip
      170
    4. 4
      +FloatingFatMan
      151
    5. 5
      Som
      136
  • Tell a friend

    Love Neowin? Tell a friend!