Recommended Posts

I just installed the latest minefield, and my fonts in Chrome got terrible. I previously did not have Direct2d enabled. I enabled and it vastly improved, although I can tell the difference from GDI or whatever it used to use.

Did something happen, or did I just not notice this before. I think I'd rather stick with the old GDI style, but on this build, it seems to be worse than Direct2D.

-Dan

So the Firefox nightly, pre beta 10s have better or enhanced font rendering compared to Beta 9 (on Windows) ?

Anyways, I think Firefox 4 is probably my preferred choice over Safari now. It feels much faster, less beach balls on the Mac.

The difference is that now DirectWrite will keep it's sub-pixel anti-aliasing in more places, before it'd fallback to grey-scale in all but the most optimal cases (it's a deficiency of the API, it can only paint properly over fully a opaque background)

So the font rendering is the same, it's just now more consistent (and the crazy colours are a bug that'll be fixed in time)

2px gap at top

click on gap or tab: browser behaviour (i.e. select tab)

double click on gap: window behaviour (i.e. restore)

double click on tab: browser behaviour (i.e. new tab, etc)

drag gap: window behaviour (i.e. aero stuff)

drag tab: browser behaviour (i.e. move tab, tear off tab, etc)

If you stand back and look at that, wouldn't you agree that it would be rather complex and confusing to educate?

You can argue that Microsoft is using Fitt's law in this case with areo snap. It's a personal preference of what a person wants to happen when they throw their mouse to the top of the screen.

People with Windows 7 will tend to want the application to function the same way all of the other programs function in windows. People with Vista, or XP ( or other) won't care.

Yes, Windows uses Fitt's Law for titlebars too, but that doesn't mean it can't be replaced with an alternative use. Switching tabs is a far more common occurrence than dragging around windows (esp. in Windows which is generally designed for leaving windows maximised).

Having a different design between Vista and Win7 is something I don't think I've ever heard before - and would be another point of confusion for users.

The current design doesn't confuse or make anything more complex - it just makes finding a draggable spot more difficult. (Which could certainly stand to be improved).

I just installed the latest minefield, and my fonts in Chrome got terrible.

Careful when typing: 'Chrome' (capitalised) is a browser, whereas 'chrome' refers to the Firefox UI.

The font rendering in the latest nightly has indeed improved.

The font outlines aren't as hazy, but there are still issues with:

  • font weight - type weight isn't consistent. Both across different characters, and in the letter itself. Grotesk types like Arial and Helvetica don't have the same weight on different character parts, which is weird.
  • kerning/tracking - The characters keep sticking together in some texts. Could be a problem with the weight mentioned in #1.
  • hinting - Still no hinting, that is, pixel-snapping. Fonts start getting rendered at (virtual) 1/3 of a pixel, leading to an assymetrical look, and issue #2.

The same problems have been reported numerous times on the issue tracker. Here's hoping to it getting fixed!

The font rendering in the latest nightly has indeed improved.

The font outlines aren't as hazy, but there are still issues with:

  • font weight - type weight isn't consistent. Both across different characters, and in the letter itself. Grotesk types like Arial and Helvetica don't have the same weight on different character parts, which is weird.
  • kerning/tracking - The characters keep sticking together in some texts. Could be a problem with the weight mentioned in #1.
  • hinting - Still no hinting, that is, pixel-snapping. Fonts start getting rendered at (virtual) 1/3 of a pixel, leading to an assymetrical look, and issue #2.

The same problems have been reported numerous times on the issue tracker. Here's hoping to it getting fixed!

=> Some fonts are not drawn

=> Rainbow lllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllll

=> Possible performance regression

I just installed the latest minefield, and my fonts in Chrome got terrible. I previously did not have Direct2d enabled. I enabled and it vastly improved, although I can tell the difference from GDI or whatever it used to use.

Did something happen, or did I just not notice this before. I think I'd rather stick with the old GDI style, but on this build, it seems to be worse than Direct2D.

-Dan

My bad, I should have said "chrome," as was pointed out. Did GDI fonts in the "chrome" get worse in the latest nightly?

The font rendering in the latest nightly has indeed improved.

The font outlines aren't as hazy, but there are still issues with:

  • font weight - type weight isn't consistent. Both across different characters, and in the letter itself. Grotesk types like Arial and Helvetica don't have the same weight on different character parts, which is weird.
  • kerning/tracking - The characters keep sticking together in some texts. Could be a problem with the weight mentioned in #1.
  • hinting - Still no hinting, that is, pixel-snapping. Fonts start getting rendered at (virtual) 1/3 of a pixel, leading to an assymetrical look, and issue #2.

The same problems have been reported numerous times on the issue tracker. Here's hoping to it getting fixed!

That's on purpose, it's one of the main benefits of DirectWrite (and IE9 does it as well) GDI did pixel snapping for backwards compatibility, it was only slightly related to the hinting (it had to force stems to whole pixels boundaries, or it simply wouldn't render anything)

I haven't seen any problems with kerning (I know there is a slight issue with the advances used, but it's nothing major), and the strange character weights (like the w in Trebuchet MS) is an issue with the font's hints that doesn't show under GDI (due to the pixel snapping) and doesn't show under OS X or Linux either (They treat hints as just a guide and render closer to the geometric shape)

If you stand back and look at that, wouldn't you agree that it would be rather complex and confusing to educate?

not really, it could be simplified to this:

browser elements: always browser behaviour

title bar: always window behaviour except for single-click, which doesn't do anything normally anyways

it would take advantage of fitt's law for both tab switching and window management, and doesn't compromise any functionality whatsoever.

This topic is now closed to further replies.
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Posts

    • I think this will appeal to a lot of enthusiasts. If the thermals are similar to those of a single system in a compact case, many people running multiple systems may choose to combine them into one machine, provided the case footprint remains reasonable.
    • No, "a great deal" for 32GB of DDR5 is $50, not $350. I mean I see what you mean, that it's a decent price compared to what's currently available, but you really should put a disclaimer in this articles explaining that it's still multiple times more expensive than it used to be.
    • Linux 7.1 stable launch looms as Linus Torvalds releases the final release candidate by Paul Hill Linus Torvalds has just released what’s expected to be the final release candidate of Linux 7.1, rc7. The Linux founder said that this RC is not small, but smaller than recent releases, which is a good sign because he expects the stable version to drop next week if things continue on this trajectory. Linux kernels see a merge window for the first two weeks of their life, where developers add new features, then there are about seven or eight weeks of release candidates before the stable version. Typically, there are seven release candidates, but if more time is needed, then an eighth release candidate is released too. This week’s RC’s biggest area of fixes was for GPUs, with networking just behind. Torvalds said that the rest of the release was “pretty random and spread out” with some architecture fixes, driver fixes, filesystem improvements, and build fixes for more unusual configs. In terms of specific pieces of hardware receiving improvements in this update, we had more AMD Zen6 models supported and fixes for AMD SDMA 7.1 and GFX11. Hardware that got improvements includes Lenovo laptops, HONOR laptops, and MSI laptops. Here are the changelogs for those: ASoC: amd: acp: Add DMI quirk for Lenovo Yoga Pro 7 15ASH11 Input: atkbd - add DMI quirk for Lenovo Yoga Air 14 (83QK) Input: atkbd - skip deactivate for HONOR BCC-N's internal keyboard ASoC: amd: yc: Add MSI Raider A18 HX A9WJG to quirk table ASoC: amd: yc: Enable internal mic on MSI Bravo 17 C7VF When the stable Linux 7.1 is released, it will be up to distribution maintainers, such as Canonical and Red Hat, to release the update to their users via the update manager. Some versions of Linux will get it before others, and some will never get it at all. Fedora and Arch-based distros will be among the first to get it, though. If you don’t get it, the security fixes will be backported to your system’s kernel, so you won’t be at risk, but you won’t get newer hardware support, which is fine if your computer works now.
  • Recent Achievements

    • One Month Later
      DJC50PLUS earned a badge
      One Month Later
    • Week One Done
      DJC50PLUS earned a badge
      Week One Done
    • Proficient
      Eric Biran went up a rank
      Proficient
    • Dedicated
      Conjor earned a badge
      Dedicated
    • Week One Done
      Windows Guy earned a badge
      Week One Done
  • Popular Contributors

    1. 1
      +primortal
      493
    2. 2
      PsYcHoKiLLa
      248
    3. 3
      Steven P.
      71
    4. 4
      ATLien_0
      68
    5. 5
      +Edouard
      68
  • Tell a friend

    Love Neowin? Tell a friend!