Kinect Reviews


Recommended Posts

I was hoping it would work with Media Center, as I dont remember seeing anything about that mentioned anywhere, but it doesnt far as I can tell.

Nope, but I'm hoping that these other applications (i.e., Netflix, Windows Media Center, etc.) get updated to support Kinect

Source: Kotaku

Someone posted this on the main page as well but I forget who, the reason is level of contrast. The camera needs enough light to see the details on your face, it's harder to do so in low light with darker skin. I'm sure MS tested the hell out of this either way, and anyone with a manual can you see what they say about lighting conditions? Everyones talking about space needed to play but no one has said anything about required lighting.

Wrong thread mate, your talking about a failed sony product there. Maybe post this in the move thread.

I believe he was replying to the post right above his.

Anyway, i'm more interested in how this gets used in traditional gaming experiences. Like i said before, being a person with no imagination at all, i struggle to come up with ways that can be used but hopefully the people making games in the future will be able to come out with some innovative ideas to incorporate it into games that use the controllers too.

On a whim I picked one up on the way home yesterday. For reference, I live with my fiance, and she's a fan of simple iPhone games, and the Sims. Not Halo, obviously. I figured she could get into the Kinect as well.

The Hardware: First off, it needs a lot of room. I have (what I thought was) a large living room, although the space between the TV and the couch isn't as far as we could make it. But without moving the couch, when I first booted up Kinect Adventures, it said I was at the back of the "Good" area, which meant one player only. Recognizing me, calibration, voice recognition all worked wonderfully, although voice recognition isn't supported on a lot of things. Navigating with your hand takes about 2 seconds to get used to, and works wonderfully, IMO.

But the distance thing is a killer. I wanted to play two player Kinect Adventures, but it kept saying we needed to move back. I've since repositioned the Kinect, but didn't get a chance to retry that, as I started up the Dance Central demo, and we played that for a few hours.

And I can say this, everything about Dance Central is awesome. The menus, the technology, the concept of the game. I hate dancing, but I still think what the game is capable of doing is impressive, and even more importantly, fun. Also, if that's what the future of Kinect games is going to be like, this thing will be a massive success. There were definitely a few moments playing both Dance Central and Kinect Adventures where I thought, "this isn't like anything I've played before". And I've been playing video games for a long time. Simply being able to use your feet, or being able to use both hands (without a cable connecting them) to twist into odd shapes to grab coins in Adventures is game changing. It made me realize that while the Wii and Move are interesting, they're still essentially pointers, and a lot of games for them could be played with a normal controller. That's not the case with Kinect.

TL;DR: The hardware itself is neat but not mind blowing, it has some potentially major flaws depending on where you live, but there are already games out showing how awesome the idea of using your body as controller is, and I have to assume they will only get more impressive over time.

Really nice seeing that something innovative got of the ground better, hope this works and the smaal quirks are straightened out soon

Happy with my purchase, wife is loving it especially the video chat thing

For those wondering (even though it was debunked) about dark-skinned people not being recognized. False. I'm mixed and it recognizes me but I went to my friend who is WAY darker than me (like dark as night...just joking but still) and Kinect setup for him perfectly. Funny thing is, it wouldn't recognize me but it would him, thing was, I was wearing glasses and the light was doing some weird stuff. It happened to me back at my place but you have to give kinect more than just 1 sample for it to recognize you. Different times of day, different lighting and it gets better. Now it recognizes me if I have my glasses on or off. :D

I picked up the 250GB Kinect bundle today and a copy of Ubisoft's Fitness Evolved. My kids love it. They played practically non-stop until bed. I didn't have to tell them how to play -- it was very intuitive. The only down side is that they're going to be very disappointed when Black Ops comes out on Tuesday........

For those wondering (even though it was debunked) about dark-skinned people not being recognized. False. I'm mixed and it recognizes me but I went to my friend who is WAY darker than me (like dark as night...just joking but still) and Kinect setup for him perfectly. Funny thing is, it wouldn't recognize me but it would him, thing was, I was wearing glasses and the light was doing some weird stuff. It happened to me back at my place but you have to give kinect more than just 1 sample for it to recognize you. Different times of day, different lighting and it gets better. Now it recognizes me if I have my glasses on or off. :D

This makes sense, it should get better over time with enough samples in different conditions so you bring up a good point.

A couple of days in on our kinect purchase and we are loving it. We have tweaked it a bit and its working really well. Can't wait to get some more games.. Anyone use that any of the workout ones? (all though at my age kinect adventures is quite the workout lol)

i wonder if a 3rd party would come up with clip-on Kinect optics or something to reduce the distance that it needs to work... it would probably be quite complex, having to exactly scale down the positions of the cameras , and you'll end up as giant people to kinect...

I thought the idea was that the higher off of the floor you set it the less room back from the TV it would need.

So far the only two good titles that work with the Kinect are Dance Central and Kinect Sports. Hopefully the game developers can do better in the future.

We haven't put down kinect adventures.. its not nearly as bad as some places make it out to be. It gets really fun the more you progress through some of the challenges. Simple, yeah.. But fun and thats what counts :)

Great excersize too when you're on advanced mode.. Makes me want to see some downhill skiing or snow boarding games!

I've been watching giantbomb use the kinnect and it looks ****ing AWFUL to me. Seems to be incredibly glitchy and very limited to use. Not even in the same realm as the stuff Microsoft was hyping. The playstation moves looks far more precise and versatile from the videos I have been watching of both.

I've been watching giantbomb use the kinnect and it looks ****ing AWFUL to me. Seems to be incredibly glitchy and very limited to use. Not even in the same realm as the stuff Microsoft was hyping. The playstation moves looks far more precise and versatile from the videos I have been watching of both.

i was very skeptical too. until i used it. it is amazing. Just go to walmart and try it. if you don't like it. return it

I've been watching giantbomb use the kinnect and it looks ****ing AWFUL to me. Seems to be incredibly glitchy and very limited to use. Not even in the same realm as the stuff Microsoft was hyping. The playstation moves looks far more precise and versatile from the videos I have been watching of both.

i was very skeptical too. until i used it. it is amazing. Just go to walmart and try it. if you don't like it. return it

my room is barely big enough and i have to move stuff way to the left and right each time i want to play :(

Kinect requires space. It was known since it was first announced. Don't buy a 60 inch TV if you don't have the room, why buy Kinect if you don't have the room?

I would recommend anyone who is short on space, to put kincet above the TV/ontop. I screwed a small shelf above mine (about 6 inches above TV) and I'm able to stand about a 1 1/2ft closer to the TV due to that. It really makes a difference, not to mention how much better it is at tracking from that high (eye level /shoulder height) compared to being waist level.

I tried Kinect out at Best Buy. I was pretty skeptical at first but it does work as advertised. I didn't experience any glitchy experiences and it tracked my movement accurately. As for UI being slow, it takes about 1.5 seconds of hold your hand in one place which isn't too slow imo. It seems like something that will get better the longer it's out there. It certainly has potential.

I've been watching giantbomb use the kinnect and it looks ****ing AWFUL to me. Seems to be incredibly glitchy and very limited to use. Not even in the same realm as the stuff Microsoft was hyping. The playstation moves looks far more precise and versatile from the videos I have been watching of both.

It's actually pretty awesome. We already took down the PS Eye and replaced it with Kinect. We are trading in the Move bundle at gamestop for in store credit to go towards the 3DS when it comes out.

This topic is now closed to further replies.
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Posts

    • Indeed. But note that this has Wifi7, HDMI 2.1, BlueTooth 5.4, and 5G Ethernet, so even in the additional features list this bundle blows the Steam Machine away. And, with the money saved, one could improve this dramatically.
    • One of the strangest galaxies in our Universe could help answer some long overdue questions by Sayan Sen Image by Pixabay via Pexels | Not representative An international team of astronomers led by the Department of Astronomy at Tsinghua University has discovered an unusually metal-poor galaxy that may contain signs of first-generation star formation. The galaxy, named Metal-Pristine Galaxy COSMOS Redshift 3 (MPG-CR3), or CR3, was identified using observations from the James Webb Space Telescope (JWST), the Very Large Telescope (VLT), and the Subaru Telescope. The findings, published in The Astrophysical Journal Letters, describe CR3 as the most metal-poor galaxy known from the period known as "cosmic noon," around 11.5 billion years ago. Cosmic noon refers to a period when the universe was producing stars at its highest rate and galaxies were growing rapidly. In astronomy, "metals" refers to all elements heavier than helium, including oxygen, carbon, and iron. Because CR3 contains so few of these heavier elements, researchers say it closely resembles what scientists expect the earliest galaxies in the universe may have looked like. The discovery is significant because it could offer clues about Population III (Pop III) stars, the first generation of stars thought to have formed after the Big Bang. These stars are believed to have formed from gas made almost entirely of hydrogen and helium, before heavier elements were created inside stars and spread across the universe through supernova explosions. Hence this is why CR3 has been referred to as a "living fossil." Scientists have long believed that Population III stars existed only in the very early universe. As more generations of stars formed and died, they enriched surrounding gas with heavier elements, making the conditions needed for metal-free star formation increasingly rare. Because of this, researchers expected the formation of such stars to have largely ended after the epoch of reionization, a period when radiation from the first stars and galaxies transformed the neutral hydrogen filling the universe and made it largely transparent to ultraviolet light. CR3 appears to challenge that idea. The galaxy was observed at a redshift of z = 3.193 ± 0.016. Redshift measures how much light from a distant object has been stretched as the universe expands and helps astronomers determine how far back in time they are looking. In this case, the redshift corresponds to roughly 11.5 billion years ago during cosmic noon. Although the universe was already several billion years old by that point, CR3 shows characteristics more commonly associated with much earlier galaxies. Observations revealed exceptionally strong emissions from hydrogen and helium, including Lyα, Hα, and He I λ10830. Lyα, or Lyman-alpha emission, is a specific wavelength of light produced by hydrogen and is widely used to study distant galaxies. Hα emission is another hydrogen signature commonly used to trace active star formation, while He I λ10830 is produced by helium and can indicate the presence of very hot, young stars. The measured equivalent widths of EW₀(Lyα) = 822 ± 101 Å and EW₀(Hα) = 2814 ± 327 Å are among the highest ever observed in star-forming galaxies. Equivalent width is a measure of the strength of an emission line relative to the surrounding light, and such large values are typically associated with intense and very recent star formation. At the same time, researchers found no statistically significant detections of metal emission lines, including [O III] λλ4959, 5007 and C IV λλ1548, 1550. Emission lines act as chemical fingerprints that reveal which elements are present in a galaxy. Oxygen and carbon lines are commonly seen in galaxies that have already undergone significant chemical enrichment. Their absence in CR3 suggests an unusually pristine environment. Using abundance calibration methods developed with JWST observations, the team placed a 2σ upper limit on the galaxy's gas-phase metallicity of 12+log(O/H)<6.52, corresponding to less than 0.7% of the Sun's metallicity (Z < 7 × 10⁻³ Z⊙). Gas-phase metallicity measures the abundance of heavy elements in a galaxy's gas. A 2σ upper limit indicates that the true value is very unlikely to be higher than the quoted threshold. Even when accounting for uncertainties in the calibration methods, the most conservative limit remains 12+log(O/H)<6.95, making CR3 the most metal-poor galaxy identified at cosmic noon. The galaxy also appears to contain very little dust. Researchers measured a Lyα/Hα flux ratio of 13.9 ± 2.5, a result that suggests negligible dust attenuation, meaning very little of the galaxy's light is being absorbed or scattered by cosmic dust. Because dust is usually produced by earlier generations of stars, this finding further supports the idea that CR3 has experienced very little chemical enrichment. Further analysis using spectral energy distribution modelling, a technique that compares observed light with theoretical models, suggests that CR3 contains an extremely young stellar population only around 2 million years old. The modelling, which used Population III stellar templates, also indicates the galaxy has a stellar mass of approximately 6.1 × 10⁵ M⊙. The symbol M⊙ represents one solar mass, or the mass of the Sun. One of the key questions raised by the discovery is how such a chemically primitive galaxy could exist in a universe that had already spent billions of years producing heavier elements. To investigate this, the researchers examined CR3's surroundings. Their analysis suggests the galaxy may lie in a slightly underdense environment, with a density contrast of roughly δ ≈ −0.12. An underdense region contains less matter and fewer galaxies than average. The team suggests that this relative isolation may have helped preserve pockets of pristine gas. Metal-rich material expelled from nearby galaxies may never have reached CR3, while the lower rate of galaxy mergers and interactions could have slowed the mixing of enriched gas into the system. If future observations confirm these findings, CR3 could provide some of the strongest evidence yet that first-generation star formation continued well after the epoch of reionization. Such a result would challenge the conventional view that pristine star formation ended by z ≳ 6 and suggest that small pockets of metal-free gas survived much longer than previously thought. Researchers stress that more observations will be needed to determine the galaxy's true nature. Future spectroscopic studies with higher resolution and better signal quality could help confirm whether CR3 is genuinely hosting Population III star formation. The discovery is also expected to encourage searches for other similar galaxies, which could help astronomers better understand how the first stars formed and how galaxies evolved in the early universe. Source: Tsinghua University, IOPscience This article was generated with some help from AI and reviewed by an editor. Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, this material is used for the purpose of news reporting. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing.
    • "I think in the immediate absence of a partner to apply relief" In the words of Sterling Archer... "Phrasing!"
    • For me, the fundamental problems with these "smartglasses" is that they really don't work well for people with significant prescriptions and massively up the price if you use attached lenses if they have displays, and if they don't, then they're not actually "smart" anything, rather just connecting to your phone and relaying voice to an AI. In a few cases like this, they throw in small cameras to feed video to the AI. All around, these feel like both a solution looking for a problem, and the problems it tries to solve seem more easily solved by different approaches and designs. Oddly, if the rumours are true, Apple may actually have invented something for once and it kind of does this right: put cameras in ear buds and manage the interface to AI exactly as most of us do: tapping on an ear bud and saying "Hey Google" or "Hey Siri." That makes them compatible with almost everyone, can double up as a hearing assist device, an impaired vision assist device, a "smart" device... and answer your phone and play music. That just seems like a better solution all around.
    • Usually the bigger ones with many fixes/changes take a few, theyre an exception to the rule most likely
  • Recent Achievements

    • Dedicated
      HidekoYamamoto94 earned a badge
      Dedicated
    • One Month Later
      timbobit earned a badge
      One Month Later
    • One Month Later
      nates earned a badge
      One Month Later
    • Week One Done
      Almohandis earned a badge
      Week One Done
    • Rookie
      dorf went up a rank
      Rookie
  • Popular Contributors

    1. 1
      +primortal
      452
    2. 2
      +Edouard
      161
    3. 3
      PsYcHoKiLLa
      107
    4. 4
      Michael Scrip
      84
    5. 5
      Steven P.
      71
  • Tell a friend

    Love Neowin? Tell a friend!