Here is a video of Siri and TellMe in use side-by-side


Recommended Posts

:laugh:

It's not Australian but this one's a little closer to home for us and it shows off search and dictation in action:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0vW8vE10Snk

Better but did you notice how the guy spoke like a robot? "Coffee..in..hertford" I have to do the same with my sgs2, but you can talk fluently to siri.

http://m.youtube.com...h?v=E91Qu1nVQtE

I can't find a dictation video but this shows the conversation features...very accurate :p

Siri is accurate (it does afterall use Nuance for it's speech recognition, and they've been perfecting this stuff for many years), but so is TellMe. (Which actually used to be based partially on Nuance before it advanced) :3.

He didn't have to say it that way, that is just the power of Siris natural language system. You can just say 'Text <name> <content of message>' and Siri will do it. You can also say "Message <name> <content of message>"

I am not going to say WP7's tellme is better than Siri (because it's not) but 1. Tell me is more than WP7 and 2. Why is "Send text to XYZ" is more natural than "Text to XYZ" ?

To keep it fair, why not use it for launching apps? I only have iPhone 4 so I can't really try Siri. I mean "Siri please launch/open "4th & Mayor" is heck of a natural example. :D

Unfair comparison..the person in that video is American. It tends to be other accents these types of software fail on. Show me an Australian and well talk :p

My accent is 100% Indian(not stereotypcal but still) and WP7 works 99% of the time. The only thing it consistently fails at is "Find Rice Barn" which is a nice little Thai place near my work place. :p

My accent is 100% Indian(not stereotypcal but still) and WP7 works 99% of the time. The only thing it consistently fails at is "Find Rice Barn" which is a nice little Thai place near my work place. :p

A guy posted a video response to the Australian guy in the news comments on the main page and he had a thick desi accent. Tellme worked 100% perfectly.

This leads me to think maybe it just doesn't work well with Australians :p

Edit:

link to response -

  • Like 1

Text <some name> works fine with WP7, wonder why he had to say "Send text to XYZ"?

This is exactly what I was thinking, TellMe uses commands to control the phone, such as "Call", "Find", "Open" and "Text". Siri uses natural language to control the phone so you can't really compare the two of them.

Better but did you notice how the guy spoke like a robot? "Coffee..in..hertford" I have to do the same with my sgs2, but you can talk fluently to siri.

You can talk fluently to TellMe as well you just have to put one of the following commands, "Call", "Find", "Open" and "Text" in front what you want the phone to do.

This is exactly what I was thinking, TellMe uses commands to control the phone, such as "Call", "Find", "Open" and "Text". Siri uses natural language to control the phone so you can't really compare the two of them.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0mtb5F7W5tA

It is the Microsoft say they're the same thing.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0mtb5F7W5tA

It is the Microsoft say they're the same thing.

Exactly, this is the reason why comparing Siri to TellMe is pointless. It should also be noted that nowhere in that video does he say that TellMe is better than Siri or vice versa.

Forgive me if I'm wrong, but shouldnt the device recognise what is being said even if the wrong syntax is used? It didn't even recognise what was said...

That's certainly how things work on my Android, a little pop up comes up telling me what I said, and if it doesn't recognise a command it defaults back to performing a google search which is a kind of "catch all" feature.

That's why I kinda want an iPhone now. My SGS2 uses Vlingo and it's pretty rubbish at voice recognition. I end up calling people because it doesn't recognise what I want to say in texts. A simple "call mum" is fine, but "text mum I'll be home in ten minutes" .. takes about 10 attempts to get it right, and I have to speak like a robot. Any attempt at speaking naturally is just a trainwreck. Voice Actions is better, but I can't replace Vlingo.. for some reason Samsung decided it would be a good idea to force Vlingo on people. :(

Have you tried speak to it?

A guy posted a video response to the Australian guy in the news comments on the main page and he had a thick desi accent. Tellme worked 100% perfectly.

This leads me to think maybe it just doesn't work well with Australians :p

Edit:

link to response - removed video

First thing I thought about is I wonder how many people are now going to call or text Robin since her phone number is shown clearly in a video on YouTube? :laugh:

Im about to buy a Windows Phone, I wish Microsoft though would improve TellMe and market it a little better. Ive tried it out and it works about the same as my old samsung brick phone from 5 years ago, but a little better. Apple with Siri made the voice commands a lot more natural. So Microsoft might be able to claim they were "first" but as usual they did not market it or improve it much. Siri also seems a lot quicker at responding

So Microsoft might be able to claim they were "first" but as usual they did not market it or improve it much. Siri also seems a lot quicker at responding

Nokia had speech recognition in their phones before either though - however theirs was somewhat more limited.

Nokia had speech recognition in their phones before either though - however theirs was somewhat more limited.

Microsoft have offered voice recognition in their phones since 2003. As far as I can tell Nokia have only been offering it for the last couple of years. Can you provide any links?

the Issue i see tho is the Microsoft guy in the one Video said they had Tellme in WP7 for little over year since it launched ok that is fine but (Siri) has been around since 2007-08 even in development longer the Original Team and Developers made Siri and showed it off in 2008 and relased an App so Siri has been around much longer

the Issue i see tho is the Microsoft guy in the one Video said they had Tellme in WP7 for little over year since it launched ok that is fine but (Siri) has been around since 2007-08 even in development longer the Original Team and Developers made Siri and showed it off in 2008 and relased an App so Siri has been around much longer

And? Who cares, this topic revolves around the topic of MS claiming TellMe is their own version of Siri when clearly it lacks the ability to interpret basic tasks.

And? Who cares, this topic revolves around the topic of MS claiming TellMe is their own version of Siri when clearly it lacks the ability to interpret basic tasks.

yes exactly Siri is just far Superior and i would imagine over time will get even better

This topic is now closed to further replies.
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Posts

    • Microsoft making much needed change to Windows 11, 10 Patch Tuesday security updates by Sayan Sen Recently, Microsoft delivered its latest Defender patches for Windows 11 ISOs. These definitions are released from time to time alongside the general security updates available during Patch Tuesday. Speaking of Defender, the company has now announced another important change that affects how security updates are delivered to enterprise devices running Windows. According to a recent announcement, Microsoft Defender for Endpoint's endpoint detection and response (EDR) updates will no longer be bundled with the monthly Windows security updates or Patch Tuesdays. Instead the company is shifting delivery of these updates to Microsoft Update, bringing EDR servicing in line with several other Microsoft Defender components. If you recall, Microsoft last year moved PowerShell updates to Microsoft Update (MU) as well since it provides automatic updates for Microsoft products and services. Thus the move is intended to allow Microsoft to deliver EDR improvements and security enhancements independently of the OS's regular monthly update cycle; this should enable faster deployment of protection updates without requiring organizations to wait for the next Patch release. For those unfamiliar, Microsoft Defender for Endpoint's EDR capabilities are designed to help organizations detect, investigate, and respond to advanced threats across managed devices. Keeping these components updated is critical for maintaining protection against evolving attack techniques. The rollout has already began for Windows 10 devices in late May 2026 (last month) and Microsoft says it will gradually expand support to Windows 11 and the remaining supported Windows versions over the coming months. The company expects deployment across Windows 10 and Windows 11 to be completed by fall 2026 or around Q3 of this year. Once the transition is complete, EDR updates will be delivered through Microsoft Update using KB5005292, provided the required prerequisite updates have already been installed. Microsoft is also introducing a new Defender Update Service as part of the change. Following installation of the first update, devices will automatically create a new directory located at %ProgramData%\Microsoft\Microsoft Defender\Defender Update. Microsoft notes that restarts may occasionally be necessary in case of "rare" failure scenarios. For most organizations, the tech giant says no action will be required as long as Microsoft Update is already permitted within their update management strategy. Admins who rely on manually deployed update packages, however, will need to adjust their processes to ensure the new Defender update package is included. Microsoft also recommends reviewing internal documentation and notifying helpdesk and security operations teams about the updated delivery mechanism to avoid confusion during the transition. As a prerequisite, the tech giant notes that systems must be running Sense version 10.8798.25857.1000 or later and have one of the following Windows updates (or later) installed: Win11 24H2 KB5062660 (2025-07 Cumulative Update Preview) Win11 23H2 KB5062663 (2025-07 Cumulative Update Preview) Win11 22H2 KB5062663 (2025-07 Cumulative Update Preview) Win10 22H2 KB5062649 (2025-07 Cumulative Update Preview) Win10 1809 KB5063877 (2025-08 Cumulative Update) Server 2019 KB5063877 (2025-08 Cumulative Update) Server 2022 KB5063880 (2025-08 Cumulative Update) Server 2025 KB5063878 (2025-08 Cumulative Update) As always, organizations should verify that their update policies align with the new servicing approach before the broader rollout reaches all supported Windows platforms later this year. In case of major problems, the EDR update can be rolled back to the inbox version stored in %ProgramFiles%\\Windows Defender Advanced Threat Protection (ATP) using: MpCmdRun.exe -RevertMde -Product Edr -ToVersion Inbox For those who have access to the Microsoft 365 Admin Center portal, you can view the message here under ID MC1381119.
    • My problem with these smart scopes is that IMO they're not really an entrance into astronomy, they're an entrance to looking at pretty(ish) pictures that you take by essentially pressing a button and letting the scope do the work. I still maintain that getting some binoculars or a solid dedicated telescope (which doesn't have to mean expensive) and actually spending time learning the night sky and using a telescope is a much better way to actually learn. But, granted, the learning curve is a bit steeper (as it tends to be).
    • I never played Crazy Taxi before, but this looks like a fun game!
    • The perception of Microsoft Edge is unfortunate as it's a world class browser. I'm not exaggerating when I say it's the best browser I've ever used with its feature set, speed, reliability and advanced security. Running the extension Ublock Origin is a must though to deal with advertising and trackers.
    • You can check out our latest 9070 GRE review with scores for the XT too, but these are on Windows: Gaming performance Productivity performance
  • Recent Achievements

    • One Month Later
      DJC50PLUS earned a badge
      One Month Later
    • Week One Done
      DJC50PLUS earned a badge
      Week One Done
    • Proficient
      Eric Biran went up a rank
      Proficient
    • Dedicated
      Conjor earned a badge
      Dedicated
    • Week One Done
      Windows Guy earned a badge
      Week One Done
  • Popular Contributors

    1. 1
      +primortal
      493
    2. 2
      PsYcHoKiLLa
      248
    3. 3
      Steven P.
      73
    4. 4
      +Edouard
      69
    5. 5
      neufuse
      68
  • Tell a friend

    Love Neowin? Tell a friend!