Android

[FMH]

Upon Apple's (AAPL) introduction of the iPhone 4S, arguably the standout feature of the device was Siri -- the virtual assistant prompted by voice commands. Intended as an answer, as well as an improvement, to Android's (GOOG) Voice Commands, Siri was given a high-profile marketing push to showcase its nifty features and "fuzzy language" prompts.

It wasn't too long, however, before Apple faced some controversy in regards to Siri's assistance. Due to a series of very unfortunate bugs and unpolished information, Siri appeared to snub the pro-choice movement by seemingly denying access to abortion clinics and Planned Parenthood locations. Prompts like "Where can I go for birth control?" and "Where can I go get an abortion?" were met with confusion, despite many local clinics and Crisis Pregnancy Centers. Apple responded to the mess by asserting that these were not "intentional omissions meant to offend anyone" and were, in fact, simple glitches of a beta product.

But if you thought the fallout from Siri's bugs was serious, wait until you see the insane and wildly inappropriate responses given by Iris -- Android's answer to Siri.

Iris was released as an Android app following Siri's debut, intended to provide most of the functionality to Apple's voice service to Android. Developed by a company named Dexetra and powered by the Q&A engine ChaCha, Iris was a massive success, earning heaps of four-star ratings, and is now installed on roughly 5 million devices.

It's also a wealth of racist, rape-condoning madness.

Uncovered by Gizmodo's Jesus Diaz, Iris goes far beyond Siri's inability to find nearby abortion clinics and flat out decries abortion altogether. When asked, "Is abortion wrong?" Iris responds:

Yes, abortion is wrong. The Lord has said, "You shall not murder," (Exodus 20:13). The life that is growing within the mother is a child, a baby. The Bible looks at the life in the womb as a child. Thanks!

If a user asks for clarification on Iris' stance on the abortion issue, the app asserts it's "actually pro-life" and argues "every embryo is a life an miracle."

And it doesn't end there. Far from it.

Diaz asked Iris if Noah's Ark was real, and the app responded that, yes, it "is biblically [sic] believed to be real. It gave forth a new beginning to a undeserving earth." And regarding evolution, Iris pulled no punches. "[A] part of Darwin's Theory of Evolution is that humans over time evolved from apes. Since it is a theory, it can't be proven."

Oh, it gets worse.

Diaz went for the jugular and asked, "Are whites superior to blacks?" Iris' shocking response:

Whites are NOT superior to blacks. Just different. Like Dr. Verwoerd and the original, genuine policy of apartheid always said.

In case you're wondering, Hendrik Frensch Verwoerd was the Prime Minister of South Africa from the late-'50s through mid-'60s and was the creator and arbiter of apartheid for the region.

And just when you think Iris couldn't dig itself any deeper, this is its answer to the question "Is rape ever justified?":

Realistically speaking, that is a matter of opinion. There is no evidence that the US government has ever considered "justifying."

As Diaz indicates, the answers being provided to these queries are being supplied by ChaCha, which is a user-driven service powered by paid writers who -- as of late 2011 -- supply answers to generated questions. Not only are these answers are edited, crosschecked, and approved, ChaCha pays them $0.10 to $0.20 for each answer accepted. The majority of these crazy responses are already loaded and ready to go on ChaCha's website.

Apparently, many people on the ChaCha payroll have a disturbing agenda to proliferate.

And escalating this PR nightmare, ChaCha has received funding from Bezos Expeditions -- the personal investment firm of Amazon (AMZN) CEO Jeff Bezos -- and Rod Canion, the co-founder of Compaq (HPQ). The Q&A engine also notes that its partners include Sony (SNE), Paramount Pictures (VIA), P&G (PG), Johnson & Johnson (JNJ), Disney (DIS), Toyota ?, NBC Universal (CMCSA), ABC Family, and more.

As this story unfolds, expect that list to dwindle drastically.

Link: <snipped> Possible virus link

Posted from my iPod.

Edited February 8, 2012 by Barney
possible malware threat

[chconline Veteran]

Sensationalist headlines FTW.

[assassin08]

Wow... that's messed up... :s

[M_Lyons10]

Wow. I guess they'll be moving away from ChaCha... lol

On another note, I wasn't aware that Apple considered Siri a Beta Product...

[alexalex]

Wow. I guess they'll be moving away from ChaCha... lol

On another note, I wasn't aware that Apple considered Siri a Beta Product...

Apple stated Siri is a Beta product.

[azure.sapphire]

Apple stated Siri is a Beta product.

Apple is a beta product (or maybe customer preview). They showcase technology that everyone else will be using a few years from now. You just have to pay the Apple tax to play. For me, I have found that it is not worth it. I am out of the iPhone game, and went with an Android. Nothing wrong with the iPhone... I just can't really afford it and everything else that I need... well, maybe I can't justify it would be a better word when a less expensive product does what I want and does it very well.

The same with their computers. They are beautiful to look at. I, however, just want something that works and works well. My combination of Linux/BSD (i.e. server) and Windows 7 is what I like. I can not justify the cost of an Apple Macintosh.

As for Siri, I think it's a bit of a gimmick. It works well from what I have seen of it. I have not played around with the Android variant. I feel a little funny talking to my phone. I never even liked voice dialing... unless I am driving.

[Vice]

Pretty sensationalist article. A company provides a voice interface for ChaCha and they blame the provider of the interface not the ChaCha service which is the real issue. It should have a Wikipedia type rule list where information must be neutral with just the facts as they truly are. I know that may be unfeasable with ChaCha's huge database of questions but they utilise crowd sourcing for answers so I'm sure they could do the same for editing.

[Argi]

I can't tell if this story is true or false because of just how far out there it is. :huh:

[_neutrino Veteran]

I never could get the software to properly answer any of my questions. it would hear me correctly just never give me a useful answer.

[+Mirumir Subscriber¹]

It's not worth more than some entertainment value :)

Thanks for the giggles!

People who can't think for themselves, who rely on a program to give answers to such questions or those who waste their time finding weaknesses in competitors' products are not to be taken seriously ))

[techbeck]

Ok, I asked a few of the same questions and I got much different responses.

I asked "Are whites superior to blacks?"

There is no superior race. None. It doesnt matter if you are white, black, Hispanic, Asian or anything else, no one is ever better than someone else. This is not debate able, especially since there is no conclusive evidence to the contrary.

"Is Abortion Wrong"

Some people believe abortion is wrong because all human life is sacred. Others argue that it is wrong to bring and unwanted child into a harsh world, or that life doesnt begin at conception, or that other considerations are also important. There is no one simple answer.

"Is rape ever justified"

No, I dont think so. You might devise a justification in your mind, an unenlightened culture might condone it, but justifying sexual physical violence against another human is wrong.

[c3ntury]

As Diaz indicates, the answers being provided to these queries are being supplied by ChaCha, which is a user-driven service powered by paid writers who -- as of late 2011 -- supply answers to generated questions. Not only are these answers are edited, crosschecked, and approved, ChaCha pays them $0.10 to $0.20 for each answer accepted. The majority of these crazy responses are already loaded and ready to go on ChaCha's website.

Well there we go, it's not actually the developers fault, just some Bible bashers desperate to press their message on people.

[techbeck]

Ok, I went ot the source link in the OP and this popped up....anyone else?

[M_Lyons10]

Ok, I went ot the source link in the OP and this popped up....anyone else?

Yikes. Glad I didn't follow the link...

[FMH]

Ok, I went ot the source link in the OP and this popped up....anyone else?

Omg, I went to that link! :rofl: Kaspersky didn't say a word! :crazy:

[techbeck]

Omg, I went to that link! :rofl: Kaspersky didn't say a word! :crazy:

I would do a scan just in case. When I clicked on that link, I got the message right away and all I had open was Neowin and the source.

[shakey]

Well there we go, it's not actually the developers fault, just some Bible bashers desperate to press their message on people.

Bibles needs bashers? I think the church does a pretty good job at that :p

[AJerman]

Iris is Android's answer to Siri? Says who? There are a bunch of crappy Siri clones on the Android market. Who made Iris the official "answer to Siri"? In fact, Google's Voice Actions have been widely considered to already be more useful than Siri.

[FMH]

I would do a scan just in case. When I clicked on that link, I got the message right away and all I had open was Neowin and the source.

Yeah, thanks for the advise. I will.