Recommended Posts


HTC released their new range of mobiles recently called the "One" which includes the flagship mobile "X", the mid-range "S" and the lower end "V", however, does the "S" really belong to the "mid-range" class......lets find out! :p

I will only cover the areas, which are most important in this review (IMO) and try to keep it as brief as possible as being android and sense, this would be a very long review if I covered every area!




Some of the main specs.

  • Dimensions - 130.9 x 65 x 7.8mm
  • Weight - 119.5g
  • Display - Super AMOLED capacitive 4.3" 540 x 960 pixels (256 ppi pixel density) touchscreen, 16M colours and is corning gorilla glass
  • RAM - 1GB
  • Chipset - Qualcomm MSM8260A Snapdragon
  • CPU - Dual-core 1.5GHz Krait
  • GPU - Adreno 225
  • Storage - 16GB internal combined with 25GB extra of dropbox storage for the next 2 years, no SD card slot
  • Camera - 8MP, autofocus, LED flash, simultaneous HD video and image recording, geo-tagging, face & smile detection. VGA camera on the front of the device
  • Video - 1080P@30FPS, stereo sound rec. and video stabilization
  • OS - Android V4.0.3 (Ice cream sandwich) combined with Sense V4.0
  • Radio - Stereo FM radio with RDS
  • Battery - Standard battery, Li-Po 1650mAh


For a full list of features, check here.


Packaging & Accessories:


I was surprised at just how small the box was when I received it! The width and height was barely any bigger than the mobile itself, saying that though the box is sturdy enough and has a minimal design.

Inside the box we have the standard accessories;


  • Charger
  • Micro USB cable
  • Standard HTC ear phones


You may be wondering where the battery is? For the HTC One series mobiles, the battery is non-removable, therefore you can't use spares or/and use an extended battery etc. however, is the battery life sufficient enough that we won't really need to worry too much about this.......find out later ;)




Build Quality:


Now this is where the One S is truly the "one" for design, build quality and "perceived quality". The "S" has a uni body chassis made of Aluminium, which is then treated to Micro Arc Oxidation, this is essentially treating the aluminium case to a plasma bath and 10000 volts is then passed through, which means that it is carbonized, which in return gives a very nice matte finish and a ceramic feel to the case, this apparently increases the durability a lot as well (I am not willing to test the durability out though :p). The MAO process is only for the black model though, the gray model is anodized Aluminium, you have medium and dark shades of grey.


I have used a number of top end devices ranging from the Desire, Galaxy S2, iphone 4/4s, One X etc. and IMO the One S is easily the most "premium feeling" mobile to date and best looking device there is (of course some may disagree and say different). It is super thin at 7.8mm and super light at 119.5g.


If you have a read around on a few forums, there are many people who loved the "X" for the screen etc. and were going to buy it but once they tried the "S" out in the shop just before they were going to buy the "X", they ended up walking out with the "S" instead due to build and perceived quality, this just shows how good it really is.


Unfortunately there is a fault with the black models (due to the MAO process), there is a chipping issue, which seems to be affecting the majority of black "S" owners even under extreme care and use, tiny black chips are coming out of nowhere and leaving a silver layer visible especially around the USB port. I have had this mobile for three days now and have not got any chip issues except around the micro USB port *touch wood* :p


This will not be too much of an issue for people who keep their mobiles in cases etc. (I will be getting a case anyway)


If you have sweaty/greasy hands, sweat patches and fingerprints will easily show up on the back of the mobile.

I would suggest that everyone waits for a few weeks first though until it is confirmed that the problem has been fixed with new batches instead of returning the mobile every few days.




On the front of the mobile at the bottom, you have touch sensitive controls, which are the standard ICS buttons, back/return, home and multi-tasking window. At the top you have your standard HTC logo along with the ear piece grill, front VGA camera and a notification LED, however, the LED isn't separate, it is underneath the ear-piece grill, which is pretty tacky from HTC, the Desire notification LED was much better.


You have your standard orange/amber colour which means that the mobile is charging and if it is blinking orange/amber, your battery is low and a green LED means the battery is fully charged and if it is blinking green you have a missed call, text etc. The blinking will last only for a few minutes if you have a missed call, text etc. I am not sure if this is a bug or the way that it is suppose to be, to try and save power......however, it should keep blinking until you have unlocked the screen IMO.


It is easy enough to see when indoors and not at an extreme angle, however, outside on a bright sunny day or/and looking at the mobile from the slightest angle, you will really struggle to see the LED.


  • On the right side, you have your volume rocker, which is nice and long, however, not very good feedback is given when you press it and it feels a bit wobbly
  • On the left side, you have the micro USB port, which is for charging the mobile, connecting to the PC or if you have an MHL cable, connecting to a TV
  • At the top, you have a 3.5mm audio jack and the power/lock screen button. The lock/power button is a bit awkward to press, especially if you're only using one hand and you really have to push it in a certain way, but this is a good thing as it means there won't be any issues of it constantly turning the screen on or the device off when it is in your pocket
  • On the back, you have "HTC" engraved in the unibody part along with the "beats audio" logo and with two small pieces of plastic at the bottom and top (which feels great as well, but obviously not as sturdy as the rest of mobile). The top piece of plastic houses the 8MP camera (with a nice red metallic outer ring for the black model and a blue outer ring for the grey model), LED flash and microSIM card slot. The bottom piece of plastic houses the speaker.
  • And of course on the bottom you have the mouthpiece


As you may have noticed there is also no SD card slot and for a lot of people this is an extremely important factor if the internal storage isn't enough and this is the main reason why a lot of people haven't got the "S" and have gone for the "X" instead as it has 32GB internal storage or are now waiting for the Samsung Galaxy S3, hoping that it will include the SD slot.


To try and make up for the lack of a SD slot, HTC have partnered up with Dropbox to give any owner of a "One" series mobile an additional 25GB onto their current storage for free for the next two years, which combined with the 10GB of internal storage on the "S" for photos, videos, files and 2GB for apps etc. is more than enough for me (I have 30.9GB of dropbox storage now).


The "S" has a 4.3" SAMOLED qHD (540 x 960) display, but it doesn't have a RGB pixel arrangement like the Galaxy S2, instead it has the pentile pixel arrangement. It isn't as bad as what some people make it out to be though. Also it has been modified apparently, so lower power consumption, better colours etc. The screen is still super sharp, vibrant colours, great viewing angles and best of all, blacks are black!


Obviously compared to the likes of the iphone 4/4s, Galaxy Nexus, a couple of Sony's mobile screens and especially the One X screen, the "S" won't look as good but that doesn't mean that the screen is poor. Yes it would have been nice if a 720P res or/and RGB pixel arrangement was used instead or the IPS display from the X but the current screen is perfectly fine IMO, viewing videos and pictures on the "S" screen is great. Viewing the screen in direct bright sunlight is not a problem at all with the brightness set to 100%, I could easily read text and view pictures on neowin, I tried to get a good accurate picture showing this, but failed :p


Of course some people will prefer the AMOLED based screens over the IPS due to having the more vibrant colours, pitch-blacks, I personally love AMOLED screens and IMO they are better for viewing videos on the mobile than LCD IPS screens.


Obviously if you are downgrading from one of the mobiles that have a better 720P screen etc. then you wil notice the pixels but I suggest before you make your mind up on the screen without actually seeing it first to have a good look at it in a store. I personally don't notice the pixel issues with pentile unless I put my nose right upto the screen :p It is a bit more noticeable when you have white text on black backgrounds though, but again you still have to go looking for it. The screen is A LOT sharper and more vibrant than the desire AMOLED screen.




Unfortauntely the "S" doesn't have NFC either, granted in the UK (and probably most of the world) it isn't very popular yet and purchasing items using it still isn't a big thing (yet), there are more uses than just purchasing items using NFC though, such as tags, which means that you simply place your mobile on/near the tag and it will perform a certain action. Considering quite a few mobiles are coming out with this, it would have been nice to have anyway.




No point having a very nicely designed mobile with great hardware if the software is terrible to use.


ICS combined with the latest sense is unbelievably good! I was never a fan of sense on the desire, desire HD and sensation, sure it has great widgets and the homescreens looked pretty but the entire software just felt so bloated and there were far too many menus/sub-menus, which tried to make things easier to use and find but in the end it just made it more complicated and spending ages to get to one particular area.


Thankfully HTC made a comment about the recent versions and said they realised that they were bloating sense too much and adding un-neccesary things and that they would go back to what sense is suppose to be like, clean, minimal, light-weight and feature fulled and they most certainly have done so with sense V4.0. It is still not as clean and minimal as stock ICS.


Sense 4 with ICS is still feature rich for widgets and customizable skins, different lock screens etc. etc. They have got rid of the dock bar, which had your app drawer on the left, phone in the middle and personalisation menu on the right for adding widgets etc. instead we now have a standard dockbar just like every other android mobile, where you have the app drawer button in the middle and two shortctus to apps that you want to the right and left side of the app drawer (whatever you choose for your dock bar will also be on the lockscreen [if you choose to] for easy and quick access). We also have the same style of widgets to choose from including the famous clock/weather one and the notification bar is also transparent when on the homescreen but will go black when you are in an app or anywhere else apart from the homescreens.


The app drawer is very nice, you have your three tabs on the bottom, "all", "frequent" and "downloaded" and on the top you have "search", "playstore" and the "menu" button, which has the usual settings like arranging apps by name etc.


The lockscreen is the best I have seen on android yet as well (out of the box). You have 3 unlock types;

  • Face Recognition, which works very well and is extremely quick and if you haven't got enough light around you, it will use either the PIN or pattern lock instead
  • PIN, simply a keypad
  • Pattern, simply the same as every android pattern lock


We also have the sense modded versions of the stock android apps like the calendar, gallery, browser etc. The sense browser is the best browser I have used yet even better than the 3rd party ones that can be found on the play store, it is super quick and smooth even when browsing image/flash/GIF intensive pages with great rendering, and of course a very polished UI and some useful tweaks/features e.g. the full screen optimization so you get the most out of the 4.3" qHD SAMOLED screen without annoying bars at the top and bottom, which will only show when you scroll near the bottom or the top of the screen (I have noticed that sometimes the bars don't show at all and the only way to get them is to scroll to the very top of the web page).


The new keyboard with a ton of features is great to use, it now uses a dark theme and HTC have also integrated a swype feature, which works very well, it isn't as good as the proper swype keyboard though and so may not convert the hardcore fans! :p You also have cursor keys at the bottom, which means it is easier to move to specific parts in sentences. Does the keyboard top swiftkey X (once tailored to your texting style) though.......unfortunately no, swiftkey still has the best prediction there is with plenty of options as well and the new verison, which the team are working on should be much better.








This is another area where the One S is the best without a doubt, it really is the fastest/smoothest android handset to date. Many people will be going for the "X" purely because it is "quad core" and thinking more cores must mean it is better :p, but that is not the case. I had the "X", "S", Galaxy S2 and the Galaxy Nexus side by side trying various tasks out and the "S" was easily the fastest & smoothest handset out of them. Everything on the "S" was done lightning quick and super smoothly as well, you name it launching & playing games, loading an image intensive site etc., installing/downloading a numer of apps at the same time whilst browsing, nothing slowed this phone down, the only area were I have seen some lag is on the animations for the tabs part in the sense browser. Granted the difference in speed and smoothness between the handsets listed above isn't a huge amount, it is still noticeable.


A number of people who own both the "X" and "S" have also said the same.


The WIFI signal strength is very good! I am getting at least two bars no matter where I am in the house and even when I am outside the house, I still get two bars and this is with the Virgin SuperHub. My Virgin connection is 60MB and 3MB upload, however, due to the SuperHub?s atrocious wireless performance, we only get 29MB download speed so once we get a new router and are getting our proper speeds through wireless, I will test the mobile out using the app ?speedtest? to see what we get.


Here are a few screenshots for the people that love benchmark scores! The screenshot of the linpack score on the left is for "single thread" and the right "multi-thread".




The Dual-core 1.5GHz Krait CPU combined with an adreno 225 GPU make this is a true beast of a mobile.


We also have 1GB of RAM, which essentially means better/more multi-tasking and of course this also helps with performance. Here are a few screenshots of RAM usage according to go launcher, built in sense task manager and the stock android/ICS manager:




Battery Life:


The One S is truly exceptional for battery life, I haven't seen an android mobile that can achieve the same or better results out of the box as the "S" with similar or better usage as below (except the Motorola RZR :p), the Galaxy S2 and Galaxy Nexus come close. Thanks to ICS when the mobile is idle, there is now very little battery drain. I will just post screenshots of my first and second charge and usage:


First charge and usage was; A few texts, 10-20 min of video, fair amount of browsing, installing lots of apps, tweaking and changing everything about, GPS, camera etc. and brightness was at 70-85% brightness for about 1-2 hours and dropped to 50% for the rest of the time, however, I didn't have my SIM in for the first hour of use (testing the mobile first to make sure it worked ok), wifi was on constantly as well.


Second charge and usage was; the same as above but a fair bit more browsing was done and a few games (angry birds and ROM emulators) and brightness was at 50% the entire time, plus this time the SIM was in for the entire time.




I have disabled quite a lot of the apps that came on the mobile such as google+, facebook, twitter and a lot of other apps, which I don't use.

The battery life could be improved a bit more as well, as with sense, a lot of white is used throughout the UI i.e. messaging, gmail, youtube, system menus, colourful wallpapers, of course you can change a couple of those things with 3rd party apps.


Even though the battery life is very good, it would have been nice to have had the option to use an extended battery instead or/and to be able to use spares.


Media & Audio:


HTC have done great things regarding sense and the gallery & media capabilites. The gallery is is your standard modded app, photo albums are "stacked" and when you go into an album, the photos are in a "grid" layout then. Any image that is on your mobile is shown in the gallery, you can choose to show/hide certain albums though, but you can't do the same for individual pictures/videos. You also have all your other standard options, like delete, copy, cut, paste etc. We also have great editing features built into the gallery for photos and videos. The video player is very good as well, it has a great UI and features, there is no dedicated video app.




The music app is also very nice, it is more of a "hub" as you have the option to choose playing the songs on your phone or to use soundhound to identify certain music that you want to find out more on, such as lyrics, name, artist etc. and other music options (I have disabled them though)


We also have the FM radio, which has a nice minimal UI. This supports RDS as well.



The audio output of this device is outstanding, I don't have any equipment to properly test it though so you will just have to take my word for it :p As we all know, the latest big mutiplayer game BF 3 has got the best/most realistic sounds of warfare in a game yet and it sounds very impressive if you have a surround sound setup. I watched a few game play videos and trailers for it on youtube and WOW! The sound was so clear and great depth to it and not to mention it was very loud!




This is one area where HTC has always been pretty poor at when compared to other brands of mobiles particulary Sony Ericcson and Samsung, especially for video recording, so have HTC finally sorted this out with the latest one series mobiles especially as they said in a statement that the camera is the main thing that customers look at in the shops and so they wanted to make it as good as possible? Also given that the ad for the flagship handset is based solely on camera/video recording capabilities.


A simple answer.............YES! They really have worked wonders with the camera side of things this time round, not just for quality but features as well. Combined with the 8MP camera, we also have an f/2.0 aperture and a dedicated image processing chip, which really helps!


Photos are taken extremely quick, literally snapped instantly so you will never miss that special moment and you have a rapid "gun fire" burst mode, which captures a lot of images in seconds and afterwards, you can choose the best one from the lot and have the rest deleted straight away.


Whilst recording you can also take photos at the same time without any lag and essentially zero shutter time again.


Some photos below, unfortunately I don't really do the camera much justice in some shots :( so don't base a strong opinion on these shots alone, have a look around at other samples on the web: (depth of field effect was used) (depth of field effect was used) (no effects) (no effects) (no effects) (no effects) (this was taken in a pretty dark room with flash as you can see) (no effects) (HDR) (Macro shot)


Unfortunately HTC still haven't mastered the art of smooth video recording with smooth light metering focus. This is a problem on the software side as the hardware is more than capable enough of having smooth playback etc. so lets hope that HTC will fix this in an update. A few quick recordings can be found on my channel here, as well as a slow motion video of my cat! :D Unfortunately when using the slow motion feature, the video can only be captured at 768 x 432.


Now, this is where the camera is most impressive, the UI and features, you have a wide range of effects to choose from, all of which are very handy e.g. depth of field, HDR, slow motion video among others, which are a bit more "gimmicky" but still cool none the less.






It is a pleasure to use the One S for everything, be it games, social, media, browsing, camera etc. The premium feel to the mobile combined with a great sharp responsive touch screen (granted nowhere near the overall quality of the X IPS 720P screen when side by side) right down to the hardware and software make this mobile truly outstanding and the battery life is a huge bonus. I imagine that once rooted and a good custom ROM is out, the mobile will be even better!


I honestly can say that there is nothing that I hate about the mobile, the only thing, which I would have liked is for HTC to have included an option to use a black theme throughout the UI instead of mostly white and to have done a better job with the notification LED. Being a HTC phone, there are a lot of apps that still aren't neccessary for me (but may be useful for others), thankfully with ICS, you can disable apps that you don't need/use, therefore they will not use any resources :)


Usually I replace every stock app with 3rd party apps from the market such as go SMS pro, dolphin browser/boat/xscope, kaloer clock etc. however, this time I won't be as stated before, the new sense is great and IMO there is no need to replace the majority of stock apps. The only thing, which I have replaced is the launcher with go launcher and my own layout with custom icons (credits go to mrk for the layout idea, icons, minimalistic text widgets etc.




I will not be rooting (even though ads completely over run web pages and apps :angry:) or flashing a custom ROM on this mobile at all (unless HTC abandon the "S" and don't provide updates) as the software, performance and battery life is just great out of the box.


The question that you all are wanting to be answered though is, which mobile, the "X" or the "S"?


It is a very tough decision, they are both great mobiles and both have their strengths and weaknesses, the areas where the "X" is better than the "S" from my use and lots of research; is the screen, storage and NFC whereas the "S" has the better battery life, better performance, better build quality/perceived quality and it is more comfortable to use especially with one hand. From reading reviews etc. even though the camera on both mobiles is the same, the "X" appears to take slightly better photos whereas the "S" appears to record better 1080P content regarding smoothness, I have no idea why this is though.


Also, just like the "S", the "X" also has a fault as well, screen flicker.


Apparently the battery life should improve for the "X" in the next update, no idea as to how much, but I imagine that it won't be a huge difference and certainly not near the "S" battery life due to the screen.

I strongly suggest before making your mind up based solely on reviews, to go to a shop and try both out for yourself.


Unfortunately there is no such thing as the perfect mobile device yet, despite all the pros that the "S" has, it has many cons as well as has been stated throughout the review.




  • Super thin and light whilst still having the best "perceived quality" yet and great build quality
  • Gorgeous vibrant & sharp SAMOLED qHD display
  • Android V4.0.3 combined with sense V4.0
  • Great hardware (best processor)
  • Great camera for quality and features overall
  • Amazing battery life
  • Very fast & smooth for everything
  • 25GB of dropbox storage
  • Great Audio Quality




  • No NFC
  • No SD card slot and limited internal storage
  • Non-removable battery
  • Uses a pentile matrix instead of RGB
  • Notification LED isn't great


Thanks for reading and I hope this review has been helpful and as always any questions, ask away :)


Keep an eye on this thread for updates and for a mini review of a case (most likely a case mate barely there or tough case) and a quick video showing the mobile connected to the TV via MHL within the next few weeks.

  • Like 4
Link to post
Share on other sites

Muhammad Farrukh

Awesome read (Y)

Link to post
Share on other sites


Amazing review, really well written. Also out of all the cons there the only major downside is the pentile display. The other four I can easily do without (16GB is plenty for the majority of users, NFC isn't really that big, battery is fine since I'm used to it (iPhone), and again the LED is something the iPhone doesn't have).


Link to post
Share on other sites


great review! i was already decided to ditch the one s/x line and waiting for the galaxy s III, but after read the review and seen the lovely pics, i have to give it a 2nd thought...

Link to post
Share on other sites


Thanks guys! :D Glad you liked the review! :)

Link to post
Share on other sites

John Freeman

Im probably picking mine up sometime next month, but damn, i dont like the chipping issue. Here's me hoping they actually manage to fix in future batches.

Link to post
Share on other sites


Went to edit a small part of my review there, but I can't find the edit button :o Can we not edit our posts after a certain time or is it due to this being featured on the front page? Just I have a few more things to add :)

Im probably picking mine up sometime next month, but damn, i dont like the chipping issue. Here's me hoping they actually manage to fix in future batches.

Hopefully the issue will be sorted by then :)

Link to post
Share on other sites

Roger H.

From day one seeing both this and the X i thought i wanted the S because it's smaller. Now reading this review makes me even more sure i'm not missing out on anything compared to the X.

As for:


  • No NFC
  • No SD card slot and limited internal storage
  • Non-removable battery
  • Uses a pentile matrix instead of RGB
  • Notification LED isn't great

- NO NFC = not a big deal to me. It's nice to have but i wouldn't be using it much if at all since I don't know anyone with it and wouldn't be using NFC at the stores with it anyways.

- SD Card thing - not a big deal to me again as I have a SGS2 now with 11.49GB of Storage (16GB total spit with Apps) and I don't even use all of that now. I also have a 16GB MicroSD card that sits there empty.

- No-removable battery not a issue again as i don't swap batteries now on my SGS2

-This pentile thing is blah - I had a Nexus One and apparently that was Pentile too? :ermm: Didn't notice "pixels" then either.

- LED notification - now that's a real con for me and actually miss it on the SGS2 also :(

Link to post
Share on other sites


-This pentile thing is blah - I had a Nexus One and apparently that was Pentile too? :ermm: Didn't notice "pixels" then either.

- LED notification - now that's a real con for me and actually miss it on the SGS2 also :(

Yup the nexus one was pentile as well. The screen on the "S" is much better than the nexus one and better than the GS 2 as well :)

Don't get me wrong the notification LED isn't is better than nothing at least :p But it is far from ideal and HTC should have just kept it the way it was with previous handsets.

Sorry I forgot to mention this (review has been updated with this info as well), the notification LED only blinks for a few minutes if you have a missed call, text etc. I am not sure if this is a bug or the way that it is suppose to be to try and save power......however, it should keep blinking until you have unlocked the screen IMO.

Hopefully HTC will sort this out in an update :)

Link to post
Share on other sites


I think it's time to upgrade from my HTC Sensation :-)

Link to post
Share on other sites


How much is this device priced at ??

Link to post
Share on other sites


How much is this device priced at ??

In the UK, to buy it outright (brand new), it costs ?370-420, the cheapest being from 3 directly :)

And contract prices vary from ?21-30 for a 24 month contract and no up front cost.

Link to post
Share on other sites


Just took a quick panorama shot:

Not bad and I am pretty sure that I moved up and down a bit for each "shot", so it wasn't exactly even throughout as I had to readjust.

See if you can spot where the "stitching" hasn't quite worked out :p

Link to post
Share on other sites





ten years processor still kicking ass :laugh:

wake me up when they do something better, like at least 2Gflops

nice review, tho

Link to post
Share on other sites


You can't compare desktop processors to mobile processors though :p

You will be sleeping for a very long time till that happens :p :D

Thanks :)

A couple of photos that I took earlier on there, which I thought were pretty good:

And a slow motion video of my cat playing with his blue ball:

Link to post
Share on other sites

  • 2 weeks later...

MHL adapter arrived yesterday, ?7.28 including delivery (?4.58 just for the adapter), which isn't badly priced :)

Has gone up a tiny bit since I purchased it though:

Couple of photos below, as you can see, we have a HDMI port (I just used my Xbox 360 HDMI cable and it worked fine) and the micro USB port (just use the USB cable that comes with the S) for charging the device at the same time as when you're streaming to the TV at 1080P it can drain the battery pretty quickly especially when watching a 1080P HD film or playing a few games. You can either plug the USB into a socket near by or into one of the TV's USB ports (if available) to charge the mobile. The adapter is very tiny and obviously very light weighted, you could easily carry it around with you in your pocket.


When connected to the TV (Panasonic TX-P42G20B) the video mode of the TV switches to "1080P, 24Hz and 16.9 aspect ratio". I haven't looked at any of the settings on my TV to see if I can increase the refresh rate yet but everything seemed very smooth either way, 1080P films played flawlessly using BS player lite and looked perfect, the games also worked great but looked very jaggy as they are stretched to 1080P, this is down to the apps.

Here is the info. for the film trailers that were played:



And lastly a quick video demonstrating this. Sorry for the quality and jerkiness of this video, it was recorded using a desire on stock 2.2, the UI and actions etc. are smoother than what it looks in the video.

Yes I know my gaming skills are atrocious particularly for Goldeneye :( It isn't very easy using the on screen controls! :p

One thing, which should be noted is that the sound is very low! (hence why you can barely hear the audio of the films and games in the video) When watching standard TV, we have the volume bar at about 3/10, where as with the mobile connected and playing content, I had to turn the volume up to about 6/10 just to be able to hear it clearly. Not sure why this is and I don't know if a different, more expensive MHL adapter would be better for sound level......

To sum up; I can't complain about the adapter at all given the price, does what you expect of it and the only downside (which might not even be due to the adapter) is that the volume is very low and has to be turned up a fair bit to compensate for this.

Link to post
Share on other sites


The official HTC one S screen protector arrived today, ?3.74 including delivery (?1.79 just for the protector, the delivery cost more than the item itself :o), which isn't badly priced and I got two screen protectors, I was only expecting one.

So for ?1.79, I wasn't expecting good things with this screen protector especially after reading some reviews, but I was pleasantly surprised in the end.


Unfortunately you can't really judge screen protectors in photos, these are the sort of things that have to be seen in person.

The best way to apply screen protectors is after you or someone else has had a nice long hot shower and kept the door closed as the steam works wonders with dust :D

On my first application, the protector applied effortlessly, there were quite a few air bubbles in the middle and I was worried about this but thankfully I was able to push them out by just using my nail, only two air bubbles remained, which are on the top left as you can see in the photos below, and two tiny pieces of dust on the "home" button and right side on the edge (the other bits of dust that are visible in some photos is just "on top" of the protector), however, these are only noticeable at certain angles and under certain lighting conditions. I could reapply the protector to try and get rid of them but I will probably end up making it even worse! :p

Despite some user reviews saying that the protector wasn't the right size, mine seemed like a perfect fit pretty much.

With some screen protectors, the touch screen sensitivity and colours are impacted, however, with this protector, that isn't the case IMO, I couldn't tell the difference at all personally, the one thing, which is noticeable is the feel, it is more of a plastic "feel" now instead of glass, obviously :p

If it weren't for the tiny cut out on the top for the light sensor and the two air bubbles, you wouldn't even know that there is a screen protector on.

Unfortunately the screen protector shows grubby marks/fingerprints more easily now. But this is easily solved by giving the screen a quick wipe every now and then.


Needless to say I am very happy with the outcome and will be cancelling the Martin Fields screen protector (?12 :o) now.

Link to post
Share on other sites

  • 4 weeks later...

Bit of an update now!

Firstly for people that are still looking for a new phone and trying to get a bargain and by any chance are looking at the one S as an option, look no further!


24 month contract

200 minutes Anytime Any network

500 texts

unlimited data (no tethering)

Handset Price - Free

?16 per month

talkmobile network (pretty much vodafone)


You get ?35.25 cashback with topcashback to

There really is no beating this deal!

Also if you are considering the One S, you may want to hurry as it looks like HTC are going to be replacing the S4 chip with old gen tech, the snapdragon S3, however, possibly giving a 720P SAMOLED (pentile matrix as well) screen as well. In some ways this is good and bad if true, as obviously you get a lovely 720P screen, however, the S3 won't be in the same league as the S4 chip and the performance will be affected as well as battery life, even more so due to the higher res, not a good combination in the end.

A few more battery readings below now, it is still pretty much the same as my first two charges:

Usage: few texts, few phone calls, a lot of web browsing, installing/uninstalling apps, about 10-15 min of youtube videos, about 5 photos taken, about 10-15 min of games, about 15 minutes of TV catchup, a bit of GPS, mostly wifi connection and H/3G connection for a bit, snowstorm syncing every 2 hours and sense weather refreshing every 6 hours, general messing around in apps etc. some whatsapp use, gmail push and automatic brightness etc.


Usage: few texts, few phone calls, a lot of web browsing, installing/uninstalling apps, about 10-15 min of youtube videos, about 10-15 photos taken, about 10-15 min of games, about 15 minutes of TV catchup, a lot of speed tests (both wifi and 3G/H), mostly wifi connection and H/3G connection for a bit, snowstorm syncing every 2 hours and sense weather refreshing every 6 hours, general messing around in apps, gmail push and automatic brightness etc.


Have now installed qbright for manual control of the brightness, so I should hopefully get more on screen time if I adjust the screen when necessary for the appropriate lighting conditions :p

Also after the first software update for my device, WIFI related tasks seems to be much quicker now and loading web pages is even quicker as well! :o Feels like I am using my desktop PC for browsing now :p

Some speed tests and I never got near these dll speeds before the update, not even my PC gets over 29MB dll, 2.9MB ul and the wireless adapter that I have is pretty good (think it is related to the virgin superhub, but don't get why my mobile is getting better speeds and my PC isn't and my brothers PC gets exactly the same speeds as my PC.......)


Some photos that I took when I was away and I am pretty impressed with the quality considering the conditions for some shots!

Only a few photos, settings were left as auto/default.

Rome obviously :p However, these were taken when inside a bus and on a very dark cloudy day, poured that day :(

Obviously the below photo was not taken from inside a bus :p



Malaga, shot taken from inside a bus:

Apparently the MAO chipping issue has been properly addressed now:

slightly less sharp edge and a beveled USB port...

A quick thermal comparison test between the One S, Razr(A) and the SGS2(B):

Great news for the big gamers now! Sony and HTC are partnering to bring Playstation certification to HTC One Devices, this means that you will be able to play the Playstation classics on your One S/X/V when you're on the go! :D

Lastly, Nillkin are sending out this case for me to review, so hopefully I will have it sometime next week and the review will be posted up here :)

Link to post
Share on other sites


Here are some comparisons (same photos posted before) of standard photos and the same photos but with the auto enhanced effect applied via the stock sense gallery:

Standard photo first followed by the auto-enhanced one:

Pretty good IMO and you have loads more effects to choose from, doesn't take like 5 minutes or anything to apply/process the effect, simply choose the effect you want and it is instantly applied and then save or cancel the new photo with the applied effect instantly.

The HTC one series/sense V4 really are/is featured packed when it comes to multimedia especially concerning the camera area, they have thought of everything! :p

Link to post
Share on other sites

Noir Angel




ten years processor still kicking ass :laugh:

wake me up when they do something better, like at least 2Gflops

nice review, tho

Given that, for example an i7-2700k can do around 120 gigaflops when overclocked (peaks at around 100 at stock speed) those numbers aren't as impressive as you think. (Screenshot was taken of my 2700k which is running at 4.8 GHZ)

Besides, the amount of gigaflops that a CPU can pull are only a measure of their raw number crunching power, floating point operations are not on their own an overly good measure of how powerful a CPU is. It's also worth nothing that mobile CPU's are never going to even touch desktop CPU's in terms of power nor are they really designed to so it's not really a particularly good point on which to form a comparison. 200 megaflops is actually a significant amount of raw power for a mobile phone.


Link to post
Share on other sites


Link to post
Share on other sites


Haha :D

Link to post
Share on other sites

  • 2 weeks later...

Firstly, still no sign of the Nillkin Super Shield case :( Going to send Nillkin an email on Monday if there is still no sign, to see what is happening.

So, I decided to buy another case in the meantime till the Nillkin cases arrives, if at all :p

Ordered a transparent black TPU gel case for ?2.95 (including the delivery price) on Thursday and it arrived today and first impressions are, not bad considering the price.

The reason I am changing from the Tough case is due to the thickness it adds (more noticeable in the pockets), increase in weight and completely ruining/hiding the sleek & minimal design/look of the One S and the gel case seemed to be the best alternative to the Tough case in order to keep all sides protected but at the same time not increasing the size and weight by a considerable amount. Also, the silicone part of the Tough case gathered a lot of dust around the front edges of the screen area.

Now onto the mini review of the TPU gel case.


There are cut-outs for the bottom & top mic, the 3.5mm audio jack, the speaker, the camera and the USB port.


The case is very easy to fit on, a nice fit, not too tight and not loose at all once fitted. The case is relatively flexible, not as flexible as the silicone part of the Tough Case. It isn't as easy of a task to remove the case though, but still quicker and easier than removing the Tough case.

The colour suits the black MAO One S very well, was going to order the pitch black one but then thought that it would be too glossy and look a bit out of the place with my S, as the black model isn't completely black, it has more of a charcoal colour to it. With the transparent black case on, the back of the device looks pretty much the same regarding the colour in all different types of lighting conditions and you can still make out certain things i.e. the beats audio logo and the engraved HTC logo on the back (unfortunately the photos don't really reflect the true colour and doesn't capture the partially see through look :().

The case does look rather cheap overall, especially for the sides, you can see some form of stitching (you will see what I mean in some of the photos) and the glossy/shiny look doesn't help at all.


But the minimal/sleek design for the front of the S still remains in some ways. Very little bulk is added, maybe just over 1mm to the back of the S, which means that the camera lens is also below the surface now, this is the main reason I want a case as well, as the camera sticks out from the rest of the back by just less than a mm or so, thus more prone to getting scratches on the lens.



The gel case covers the edges on the front and adds a very tiny amount on to the front so that there is a a raised edge for when the mobile is placed flat down on a surface to stop the screen touching the desk surface.




The power/lock button is very easy to push, a very light push is all that is required, this isn't really a good thing IMO though, as it means that when the mobile is in your pockets (tight trousers etc.) it could very easily keep turning the screen off and on or/and even the mobile off, as for the volume buttons, they are harder to press with the gel case on. It isn't very easy to tell where the buttons are (when not looking at them e.g. in the dark :p) as they aren't raised above the rest of the case, the lock/power button has a tiny indentation around the button and both button areas feel different to the rest of the gel case, more of a "hard" plastic feel.


I may have to do a little modding to these parts sometime soon :p :D

It is more comfortable to hold the S with the gel case on, however, it does feel a lot cheaper and not as nice to touch as the ceramic back and the Tough case felt better to touch as well whilst not feeling cheap. Finger prints are shown, however, they are only noticeable when you look at the case from certain angles in very bright light. The case also provides more grip.


As for protection/durability, I would say that the case would do a good job protecting the mobile from normal drops and the standard scratches etc. however, a drop onto solid concrete etc. from a good height could damage the mobile i.e. crack the screen as their isn't enough thickness to the case like there is with the Tough case and there would be no shock absorption either. But for daily use, I would say it is perfectly fine.

Hard to say how this will last in the long run regarding wear & tear, if you're careful enough with it and put it in a pocket with nothing else, it should be just fine for a good while I would imagine. Saying that though, the case only costs about ?3, so you won't really be breaking the bank buying a new one every couple of months :p

Apart from the cheap looks (largely due to the stitching look on the sides and the glossy finish) and the power/lock button being too easy to activate and lastly the volume buttons being too hard to activate, there isn't really much wrong with this case at all, it does the job for ?3 :)

Link to post
Share on other sites

This topic is now closed to further replies.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Similar Content

    • By Fezmid
      Phyn Plus review: A water and leak monitor can save your home from a burst pipe
      by Christopher White

      Without question, water is the world's most precious natural resource. Indeed, 71% of the planet is covered by water, and up to 60% of the human body itself is made up of water. In many parts of the world, getting clean water is difficult, and even in developed countries, our use of water is tapping the limits of ground wells and aquifers.

      If you want to understand how much water your household appliances use and help prevent waste from leaks, you might be interested in the Phyn Plus, a device you install in-line with the water main of your home. This device can not only tell you how much water each toilet flush uses, but can also shut down the water in your house if it detects a catastrophic leak that could result in a flood in your house.

      I'm not a scientist, so won't pretend to fully understand how the Phyn Plus works. According to their marketing literature, the device uses an ultrasonic flow sensor that measures pressure waves 240 times a second. It is also the only connected water monitor that works this way: Other similar products use turbine flow sensors that are apparently less precise and more prone to breaking since the turbine is a moving part. This sensor allows the device to measure with high precision exactly how much water is being used at any point in time. There are also temperature and pressure sensors to measure those values within your home.

      The device itself is rather large, at 8.5" (215mm) long, 5.6" (142mm) wide, and 1.5" (38mm) deep. Since the Phyn Plus is installed in-line with your incoming water pipes, you have to make sure there's enough space to do the installation. In addition, you'll need a power source nearby. In my installation, I was able to run the power to an outlet in the ceiling that the hot water heater was also using.

      Phyn is backed by Belkin International and Uponor, so has a solid foundation, reducing the risk of the company disappearing, leaving the consumer with a worthless in-line device.

      Dimensions 2.97" (7.54cm) L x 8.43" (24.41cm) H x 5.6" (14.22cm) D Weight 5.5 lbs / 2.5 kg Network 2.4GHz 801.11b/g/n Power 110/220V 19W power supply Certifications IP55 certified, NSF certified for potable water Price $699 (no monthly charges)
      If you're handy with plumbing, you can probably install the Phyn Plus yourself, but make sure you know your limitations. Hiring a plumber to do the installation will run roughly $200, depending on where you live.

      To use the Phyn Plus, your incoming water pipe has to be smaller than 1.25" in diameter. Apparently that should accommodate the vast majority of households in the United States. The device can be installed inside or outside, but should be placed right after the water meter. Since I live in Minnesota, and it's common for the temperature to get to -20F/-29C in winter, the water comes into the basement from under the cement slab to prevent the water from freezing.

      The plumber who did my installation had never used a Phyn Plus before, but had installed a couple competing products. The process was very straight forward - shut off the water, cut the pipe, insert the Phyn Plus, and turn everything back on. The whole process took roughly 45 minutes, and the only complaint he had was that while the device has a blue dot showing which direction is up, he felt it should've had an arrow showing the flow direction like other devices do. Other than that, he said installation was really easy and straight forward.

      The device itself, while just a big black box, does have a blue LED strip on the side that lights up when you first turn it on. While it'd be cool if it simulated water flowing through the pipes, the fact that most of these will be installed in places that nobody will actually see makes that frivolous except for the initial installation.

      Initial Setup
      After the Phyn Plus is installed, you have to complete the configuration of the device. That consists of downloading the Phyn Plus app from your app store of choice and following the guide to connect the device to your WiFi network. After that, it runs a test to make sure it can start and stop the flow of water, and that's it. The whole process took about 20 minutes, most of which was simply waiting for the testing to complete.

      One of the steps that seems fairly important during the setup is to select how many water fixtures you have in your house. This was something I had never really thought about before. While it's easy to count the number of toilets you have, I hadn't really thought about things like the ice maker and water dispenser that's built into the refrigerator, or the two water spigots on the outside of the house. Altogether, there are 24 devices in the house that consume water, a number that was far higher than I would've initially guessed.

      Learning Phase
      Even after the Phyn Plus is installed, it won't shut your water off if it detects what it thinks might be a leak. Instead, it enters into a learning mode where it watches your water usage and tries to categorize it all based on what it sees. The app indicates that this takes around 1,000 water events, where an event is any starting and stopping cycle of water. In my house, this whole process took a little over a month to complete.

      The device is really accurate right out of the box, but you can assist by either confirming what Phyn Plus detected was correct, or by changing the guess to what the actual device was. The day it was installed, I went around to each toilet in the house and used both flush settings on each, then looked at the app to confirm the water usage. I had never thought about the amount of water the toilets used, but was able to identify that a basic flush uses 0.9 gallons (3.4 liters), while a larger flush uses 1.6 gallons (6 liters). After each flush, I pressed the water drop next to the device to confirm the usage. I did the same for all of the sinks in the house, as well as the showers, just to give the Phyn Plus a baseline (and because it was cool watching the water use statistics in real time!).

      During the first week, I noticed that when I washed my hands immediately after flushing the toilet, Phyn Plus lumped both events into the toilet category, so instead of the toilet using 0.9 gallons, it used slightly more, like 0.95 gallons. I was concerned that Phyn wouldn't be able to separate the water usage, but after a few more days, it started to label the sink usage separately from the toilet usage, which I was pretty impressed with. If you want to be Big Brother, it's also a great way to confirm that your children are washing their hands after using the bathroom.

      Although the Phyn Plus won't automatically shut your water off during the learning phase, it will still alert you if it detects an unusual flow. For example, a week after the installation, I took a long shower in the morning to help wake me up. When I got out of the shower, the app warned me about the flow because it went on for so long. I was able to tell the app that this was simply a shower and after a couple of instances of this, Phyn Plus has learned I sometimes take long showers and hasn't complained about it since.

      After roughly 1,000 events, the app alerts you that it's able to go into automatic shutdown mode if you choose to enable that functionality, but it never actually stops learning. I hadn't used my irrigation system before the Phyn Plus' learning phase was over, so the first two times it turned on, the app alerted me of a very high water flow and asked if it should turn off the water. After that, it hasn't asked about the irrigation system, even when I've run it manually at different hours.

      While Phyn does offer a dashboard for businesses that want to monitor multiple properties, there is no such web presence for individual homeowners, making the app a requirement.

      When you first bring up the application, you're presented with stats on your system, including water temperature, pressure, and current flow. It's interesting to see the water temperature coming into the house. In Minnesota, after a long winter, the water coming into the house was 58F/14.4C, and since the Phyn Plus can sense not only the temperature, but also can detect ice crystals in the pipes, it can warn you if you need to warm it up. The main page also tells you how much water you've used in the month compared to other Phyn Plus users of the same household size, when the last plumbing check was performed, and whether there are any current alerts to respond to. You're also presented with three buttons: Run a Plumbing Check, See Water Use, and See Water Events.

      Since your water pipes are closed system, the Phyn Plus can check the plumbing by turning off the incoming water and monitoring the system for any unusual changes in pressure. It does this on a nightly basis, but you can run the test at any time, and I'm happy to report that it works extremely well. I left a bathroom sink faucet on so that it dripped once every five seconds, and the Phyn Plus successfully detected the leak. Unfortunately, it can't tell you where the leak is so if you can't find it yourself, you might have to engage a plumber, but it's better to find the leak when it's small, especially if it's a pipe in your walls.

      Clicking on the See Water Use button brings up a calendar where you can see the overall amount of water used, the number of water events, and the amount of water your house has used compared to other Phyn Plus customers with the same number of family members. On the calendar, the darker the color blue, the more water that was used on that day. You can click on any of the days to get roll-up data about that day, or can scroll up to see previous months.

      Clicking See Water Events brings up all of the events from the current day, with the most recent event at the top of the screen. From here, you can filter based on specific fixtures, or change the sorting based on amount of water used.

      Under settings is where you configure how many fixtures you have in the house, how many people live there, and, most importantly, is where you configure the automatic shutoff. When turned on, Phyn Plus will automatically turn the water off when it detects an unusual flow that you don't respond to within a certain amount of time. Normally this is good, but I don't recommend turning it on right away, even when it's done with its learning cycle, as I did receive a couple of alerts while taking a long shower. After a couple of months, I have stopped receiving any false alarms though, and feel it's safe to turn the feature on, even when home.

      Related to the automatic turnoff is an "away mode." With this mode activated, the Phyn Plus forgoes waiting for the user to acknowledge any alerts. If it detects any water flow for 60 seconds, it will send an alert and automatically shut the water off in the house. This can mean the difference between a few hundred gallons of water flooding your house or thousands of gallons destroying your house.

      Overall, the app gets the job done, but it seems to be lacking some polish. Every time I open the app, it has to go through a loading screen that takes five seconds to finish, even if I try to pin the app in memory on my phone. None of my other home automation tools have this issue.

      The app also isn't always intuitive. For example, in the calendar view, there's no indication on how to see previous months, and instead of swiping from left to right like most other calendar apps, you have to swipe from bottom to top. It's not a showstopper, but isn't a good user interface.

      Another idiosyncrasy is that clicking See Water Use takes you to the calendar, and if you click back from there, you're taken to home page again, but if you click See Water Events instead, and then click back, instead of being taken back to the main menu, you're taken to the calendar for some reason. It works, and you get used to it, but it's a little strange at first.

      Finally, the app seems to have a bug that, when you change what an event was classified as, will occasionally take you back to the main menu. There's no indication the change was successful without going back into the menu, and since this doesn't happen all the time, feels like an issue that needs to be addressed.

      Aside from these minor quibbles, the app doesn't get in the way of using the device and getting proper insights, it could just use some extra work from the development team.

      Water Insights
      So did I learn anything interesting from the Phyn Plus during the review or is its only use preventing major flooding in your home? I'm happy to say I learned quite a bit.

      The first interesting piece of information, aside from the difference in water usage between a regular and large toilet flush, was that the seal on one of my toilets was not good. While it would usually be ok, there were times when it would drain 0.4 gallons (1.5 liters) from the tank into the bowl every couple of hours. Since this was a slow leak, it would only manifest if the water level in the tank went below a certain amount that caused it to refill. We never heard it, and only noticed it by seeing toilet use on the app. While this didn't really save money, and arguably cost more to fix than the water I was using, it helps use less which is good for the environment.

      Another interesting piece of information is that, while I knew lawn irrigation used a lot of water, I had no idea exactly how much it used. Now, from using the Phyn Plus, I can see that it's not uncommon to use over 1,500 gallons (5678 liters) of water just to keep the grass green. Everyone I asked vastly underestimated the amount of water an irrigation system uses, so while it's not driving any specific changes in my life, it's something I keep in mind in the back of my head and I understand why my city partners with Rachio to install smart irrigation systems in everyone's home.

      The Phyn Plus is able to integrate with Alexa and Google Home if you want to utilize voice control to find out how much water you've used or to turn your water on and off. Personally, I don't find this feature very useful and it's potentially harmful since someone could turn your water off via voice from outside your home.

      The device also integrates with IFTTT, which again has limited usefulness in my eyes. The example that's given by the company is that you could turn up your thermostat if the Phyn Plus detects a freeze warning in the pipes, but I'm not sure how helpful this would be compared to simply getting an alert from your home automation system about a low temperature in the home.

      One feature that would be useful, but that I wasn't able to get working with IFTTT, is forcing Phyn Plus to go into away mode if everyone's cell phone in the house leaves a geofenced location. However even that has a potential negative as it means you could never run the washing machine or dishwasher, or have the irrigation system run when you left the house, so use caution.

      Upon first glance, the Phyn Plus, at $699 without installation, appears to be a very expensive gadget. The truth is that, while it is very expensive, it can potentially save you thousands of dollars if it can prevent a catastrophic leak, such as a hose that disconnects from your washing machine. That said, it's an insurance policy that you may never actually use.

      Speaking of insurance, take note that some companies will offer up a discount on your insurance if you install one of these. Unfortunately, the list of partners is currently very low. A recent study by LexisNexis indicated that having an automatic water shutoff device could save both customers and insurance companies a lot of money, so it's unfortunate that so few insurance companies offer discounts for having a device like the Phyn Plus. According to the research, "in-line water shutoff systems correlate with a decrease in water claims events by 96%" and that "those without water shutoff systems reported a 10% increase in water claims events over the same time period."

      What happens if you lose power when the device is checking the water pressure or after you turn the water off? The Phyn Plus has a manual control that allows you to open/close the valve with a screwdriver that's attached to the device. That said, depending on where your device is installed, it may be difficult to access.

      Finally, when installing any Internet of Things (IoT) device, it's important to put it on a separate network. If the company or device becomes compromised, you don't want it to be able to access anything else on your home network.

      Overall, if the price of the Phyn Plus doesn't scare you away, I can highly recommend installing the device in your house. The insights into your home's water utilization are interesting, it can help you reduce your overall water usage by identifying leaks in your toilet or pipes, and can prevent a catastrophic nightmare if a pipe were to burst in your house. That said, it's only this theoretical catastrophic event that will cause you to save money with the Phyn Plus; the other use cases will only help you preserve Earth's most precious resource, which for many, is enough of a reason to install the device.

      There are competitors that I haven't looked at, such as the Flo by Moen, but while the devices are cheaper up front, their advanced features cost extra every month. Even excluding the fact that the ultrasonic flow sensor is superior to a turbine, for someone who wants to avoid a recurring charge, the Phyn Plus is the obvious winner.

      Ultimately, the device does exactly what it sets out to do, and while the mobile app could use a little polish, the device is very accurate and does a great job figuring out where the water is being used in the house. If you're considering an automatic water shutoff device, I would not hesitate to purchase the Phyn Plus.

    • By Usama Jawad96
      OnePlus: Yes, we throttle some popular apps but not to manipulate benchmarks
      by Usama Jawad

      While throttling of software has become a somewhat common practice from OEMs in pursuit of better battery life, lawsuits are still filed against firms when such discoveries become public knowledge. This time, OnePlus has admitted that it throttles certain apps in its OnePlus 9 and OnePlus 9 Pro smartphones following a report from AnandTech.

      AnandTech discovered that the OnePlus Performance Service makes changes to the CPU scheduler in order to throttle the performance of certain apps. While throttling based on app behavior isn't entirely uncommon, the issue here is that it explicitly identifies which apps to throttle. Some of these apps are quite popular, including Chrome, Twitter, WhatsApp, Facebook, Instagram, Microsoft Office apps, and even some of OnePlus' own apps. These apps are limited to the Cortex-A55 cores only instead of making use of Cortex-X1 core, which means that they suffer quite a performance hit. The report noted that this resulted in the blacklisted apps returning scores similar to a budget smartphone rather than a flagship device.

      In response, benchmarking website Geekbench has delisted the OnePlus 9 and OnePlus 9 Pro from its Android performance charts, saying that:

      Geekbench says that it will now investigate the benchmark scores of other OnePlus handsets as well, and if they exhibit the same behavior, they will be removed too.

      In a statement to XDA Developers, OnePlus has officially admitted that it does throttle the apps in question, but this is not to manipulate benchmark scores. The company's statement reads:

      The problem here is twofold. The first issue is misrepresentation of performance in the guise of battery life optimization. The OS uses more performant cores while some apps are restricted to slower cores, potentially making customers believe that slow performance is an issue of app optimization rather than the phone itself. This also results in manipulated benchmarks scores, as pointed out by Geekbench. The second issue is that apps that are to be throttled are explicitly singled out rather than it being in response to their battery-hungry behavior. The developers of these applications certainly won't be happy to find out about this. Overall, this leads to the question of whether OnePlus has been doing this with its older phones too or is this is just an exception it made based on user feedback? More importantly, will it revert its design changes based on the backlash it is currently receiving or will it stick with its stance? We will let you know as the situation unfolds.

      Source: AnandTech, XDA Developers

    • By mrk
      Huawei FreeBuds 4 true wireless earbuds review [Update]
      by Robbie Khan

      I would not label myself a hardcore audiophile, but I do love good quality sonic performance from audio gear whether I am sat at home, or on the move, and find it easy to find flaws in poor quality speakers, earphones, and other source equipment. Clear highs, mids and lows with natural separation of instruments and vocals make all the difference between just listening to music versus being immersed by it.

      It is hard to put into words how music makes me feel when a cracking track comes on the playlist and I am wearing my personal reference points, the Sennheiser HD 650 and Samsung Galaxy Buds Pro, but what I can say is that it is clear to my ears where other headphones or earphones I listen to often excel or fail.

      Having never owned or heard a pair of Huawei earphones before, I just had to jump on the opportunity to check out their latest FreeBuds in their fourth generation to see what these are all about. Just like with all my reviews, I will be giving my impression as a heavy smartphone user and a music listener going about his day to day, I will also test these out on my computer which has Bluetooth 5 capabilities.

      At the time of writing, the FreeBuds 4 have hit European retail channels priced at £129.99 / €149. It is worth noting that there are two versions available. The non-wireless charging version is the one that is featured in this review. The wireless charging version will be available mid-July 2021 for an extra £20 on top.

      Size & Weight Per bud: H 41.4 mm / W 16.8 mm / D 18.5 mm / 4.1 g
      Case: D 58 mm / H 21.2 mm / 38 g (without buds)

      Colours Silver Frost & Ceramic White Fit type Open-fit Driver 14.3 mm LPC dynamic driver capable of up to 40KHz Microphone Triple mics with 48 kHz HD recording Touch control Gesture based, 3 configurable presets Connectivity Two devices simultaneously
      Bluetooth 5.2
      USB Type-C (charging case)

      Latency 90 ms on Harmony OS 2 phones
      150 ms on EMUI phones Noise Cancellation Yes, via ANC 2.0 (Active Noise Cancellation) at up to 25dB noise reduction Battery life ANC off:
      Fully charged case: 22 hours
      Fully charged buds: 4 hours
      15 minute charge: 2.5 hours

      ANC on:
      Fully charged case: 14 hours
      Fully charged buds: 2.5 hours Special features IPX4 water resistance Price £129.99 / €149 (£149.99 / €169 for the wireless charging version)

      Design and materials
      Out of the box what immediately stuck out to me was the solid quality feel of the charging case. The finish is glossy but was not a fingerprint magnet at any point during my usage. Flip the hinge over and you are treated to a strong magnetic hinge that locks when open and closed which was a welcome surprise.

      Flipping the case over reveals just a single LED that shows the charging state. On the side of the case is a hidden button to activate the pairing mode when the lid is open. It is not obvious there is a button there at all and I only discovered this by accident before reading any instructions!

      Taking a closer look at the buds themselves I had flashbacks of the original AirPods. These FreeBuds do look uncannily like Apple's buds at first glance, but that is where any similarities end.

      The buds themselves feel just as robust as the charging case. There are no silicone or memory foam ear tips to be found in the packaging though, these are open-fit earbuds by design and Huawei say this removed any built-up air pressure that you might typically find with earbuds that create a tight seal by use of silicone ear tips.

      It was nice to see some high-quality finishing on the buds too, the metal mesh grilles are flush to the casing, as is the sensor window. The long stem houses the touch gesture sensor.

      Initially I had some difficulty getting the buds out of the case before discovering a trick to it. I guess everyone will find their own method, but my fingers could not grip the buds directly without slipping so just pushing one bud's head forwards allowed it to pop up from the magnet and be readily available to pull out fully.

      Speaking of magnets, the FreeBuds 4 are well secured in the case. I could not force them out even with some medium to major levels of Flossy Carter shaking.

      The wear sensor activates each bud as you put them in your ear. Like most true wireless (TWS) buds these days you can use just one at a time whilst the other charges in the case.

      I also wanted to try out the IPX4 rating in the field but during my time of testing the sun was out although I did manage to drop them in some dirt which gave me the opportunity to test how they fair when being rinsed under a tap. Since IPX4 means they are splash proof from water coming from any direction, having the tap set to low pressure was ample enough to simulate rain to clean them off and resume full working order.

      My ears are not exactly big, but typically I wear the large size memory foam ear tips on earbuds where available, silicone ones do not seem to give a good seal and slip out. The FreeBuds 4 match the large size of foam tips but due to their head design I found no issues with a snug fit and as a result, they were very comfortable, even for two hour listening sessions.

      Even when active they did not work loose, however the fit does need slight adjustment when you go to use the touch gestures on the stem as I found I was accidentally pushing them out slightly as I tapped or slid my finger on the stem to adjust volume or skip tracks.

      Normally I am used to having touch zones on the top head part of the buds not on the stem, so this might just be something I need more time to get used to.

      I tested how quickly the FreeBuds 4 reconnected to my phone after I opened the lid to the charging case. Connection happened within two seconds, which is excellent.

      I was impressed with the FreeBuds 4 for initial sound quality. In one word I would describe them as cinematic. The highs and mids were detailed enough to be enjoyable, with a wide soundstage giving an open feeling to music and movies only helped further by the open-fit design in the ear. The cinematic aspect comes from the volume of bass these kick out. It is very heavy and whilst for movies and other multimedia this works out nice, I would have preferred slightly less bass for the music that I mostly listen to currently consisting of acoustic, jazz, jazz-rap and classical hip-hop.

      Thankfully, most phones on the market these days have built in EQ options that can be adjusted regardless of what brand earbuds are connected. I was able to adjust a custom EQ within my Galaxy S20 but of course doing it this way only allows any EQ tweaks to be relevant to that phone.

      There is no detail on what codecs and Bluetooth profiles are used. Huawei also state different audio latency times between Harmony OS 2 and EMUI, so it may well be that when connected to either of these OSes, that a different codec or method is being used.

      Having said that, I saw no issues with audio latency paired to my Samsung Galaxy S20 5G but as a non-mobile gamer, I cannot comment on the low latency mode in this area which Huawei claim a delay of 90ms. There was no audio delay in videos that I noticed at all which was excellent.

      For music, if you are a person who likes bassy music, then there may well be right up your street with no EQ tweaking needed. They are fairly neutral but detailed in sound, just with emphasis on bass.

      Taking phone calls (VoLTE) was an excellent experience. Not only was my earpiece loud and clear, but callers on the other end told me I was naturally clear and had I not told them I was on earbuds, they would have assumed I was using the phone's built-in mic. Noise and wind control seemed to be particularly good too during calls with or without ANC.

      The AI Life software detailed below has an option called HD Voice. I toggled this on and off multiple times during a call and neither myself or my caller could tell any difference, so I am not sure under what specific conditions this setting works as both of us were on 4G and/or Wi-Fi calling at the time.

      Battery life seemed to meet the specifications. I should note that with ANC turned on, a little over 2 hours is what you can expect. More battery is drained on long voice calls I found too as the mics are active. 2 hours may be enough for many but do expect to do multiple 15-minute top-ups to reclaim those hours. I did expect more out of the battery in this regard considering the price. Competing earbuds seem to be ranging in the 3-4 hours per charge at the minimum with active features enabled.

      I installed the Huawei AI Life app from the Google Play Store first but was unable to add the FreeBuds 4 from within to customise and tweak any settings. With the advice of Huawei, I needed to install a newer version of AI Life via Huawei's own store called AppGallery. AppGallery is installed via side-loading from the AppGallery website on non-Huawei phones such as my Galaxy S20. It was only then that AI Life was able to add the FreeBuds 4.

      At the time of writing, even though the FreeBuds 4 have been out in the UK since the 21st of June, the Google Play Store version of AI Life still has not been updated to the latest version supporting the FreeBuds 4. This could be a concern for some as not everyone has a Huawei phone, and most users do not know how to, or even want to mess around with side-loading apps they are unfamiliar with.

      With the correct version of AI Life installed I was able to tweak several settings and enable features like ANC. The main home screen to AI Life shows core information about added Huawei devices.

      The app shows the battery status of each bud and the case, tapping through shows the settings and features available.

      Here we are given several useful options to check and tweak as needed. Most are self-explanatory and things we have all come to expect from wireless earbuds in this price range, but a couple remain missing, more on these a bit later. The first thing I did was to check for any firmware updates, but it appears that everything was already up to date.

      The Shortcuts menu allows customisation of the touch gestures. I found some limitations here, however. Whilst you can assign double tap gestures to a function such as skip songs or play/pause, you cannot have play/pause as well as skip tracks assigned in a combination of double/triple gestures.

      The Press & hold and Swipe gestures cannot be customised at all either. I found this frustrating in practice because I wanted to be able to have full control of playback via the touch gestures but the lack of triple gestures or the ability to change the hold gestures and swipe meant I could have one or the other.

      There were also no custom EQ settings that could be saved to the earbuds like you can on others on the market in this price category. There is a sound quality menu within AI Life, but this only has one option to enable HD Voice for voice calls. This makes multi-device usage a pain. Using my personal usage as an example, I listen to music on my phone and PC, so whilst I can adjust the EQ to my liking within the phone itself, I cannot change the EQ to the FreeBuds 4 connected to my PC so still have the heavy bass. The Galaxy Buds Pro, Cambridge Audio Melomania 1+ and Jaybird X3 that I also have allow me to save the whatever EQ pre-set is set on the app to the buds so whatever source I listen on, the EQ stays put.

      I reached out to Huawei on this issue and was told that an update to AI Life is due soon which adds some pre-set EQs within the app. This is promising news as this update will put the EQ on similar standing to the Galaxy Buds Pro which also has a list of predefined pre-sets you can select which then saves to the buds. Whether the AI Life update will do the same though remains to be seen but is well worth pointing out.

      For those who wish to skip using the AI Life altogether, you do get battery status of the buds from within Android's Bluetooth screen. Not as detailed as individual battery status, but it is better than nothing.

      Huawei hit the mark in several areas with the FreeBuds 4. The cinematic bass is lively, whilst the mids and highs being detailed. The bass out of them may be too much for those like myself, but one way or other there is a way to tweak the EQ to preference It is a shame that there is no baked in EQ however where a custom one can be defined which follows the buds between devices. This is a feature I am used to in this price range so is something I expect as standard.

      Huawei have promised an update to AI Life to add predefined pre-sets for EQ tuning, but this update may well only reach a limited audience due to only being on the latest version of AI Life whish resides within Huawei's own AppGallery store only available via side-loading for non-Huawei phones and tablets. Not something novice users will be wanting to do.

      The lack of full gesture customisation is also an annoyance and I believe this can also be fixed with a firmware/software update.

      I feel what could have been a truly excellent experience right from the get-go has been slightly tarnished by a lack of software development from a user's point of view. At around £130 (on Amazon) there are a lot of options out there for us consumers, and missing features like this could be deal breakers for some.

      The FreeBuds 4 are very well built and designed, they are comfortable for long sessions, and whilst the battery life might not compete with others, a quick top up in the case will regain a couple of hours.

      Excellent voice call experience and a cinematic media experience alone are not enough to earn top marks at this price. The software must marry the hardware and at this state I think the FreeBuds 4 will satisfy a small audience out of the box but will need a decent software update to grab the attention of everyone else.


      Huawei has reached out to me to confirm a new update to the AI Life app and FreeBuds 4. There are a suite of new features available which to my eyes and ears now make these wireless earbuds very good. It is also reassuring to see a brand request feedback from a review and then implement some of those changes so quickly.

      The new features are:

      AEM EQ (Adaptive Ear Matching) EQ effects Voice hearing enhancement The first feature, AEM, sends a tone signal when each earbud is inserted into the ear. The tone is then reflected back and picked up by the inner mic. This allows each bud to determine the shape of the ear canal and define the best processing EQ for that ear.

      Huawei also state that AEM adjusts the EQ through the entire frequency range per ear shape and they make note that this offers better performance than the Airpods Pro. I cannot verify this as do not have access to any Airpods Pro.

      The second feature update is EQ effects. Three new presets are available, Default, Bass boost and Treble boost.

      Finally, the third feature is Voice hearing enhancement. This is very similar to other phones fine-tune the sound they output to your specific hearing abilities via a hearing test mode. Those who have used Samsung's Adapt Sound will know exactly what this entails, the process is the same in AI Life and offers you the flexibility to add save your tuning for both calls and media or individually.

      From my personal experience, hearing enhancement features should be explored by everyone who uses earbuds to listen to their media regardless of whether hearing is good or bad. I have always found an audible benefit in tuning the sound specifically to my ears.

      The update brings the app version to V1.0.0.200 and as noted earlier in the review, should be updated through the Huawei AppGallery store. The Google Play Store version remains on a late 2020 version.

      With the inclusion of these new features I am happy to adjust the scoring to a very good mark as the sound quality has been improved. The Treble boost preset EQ reduces the overly bassy sound to something more neutral now. There is still no additional customisation for gesture controls however, and the battery life remains unchanged.

      As an Amazon Associate, Neowin may earn commission from qualifying purchases.

    • By Fezmid
      A look at Synology DSM 7 and Active Insight, the latest OS for your Synology NAS devices
      by Christopher White

      It's been more than five years since Synology released its current operating system, DSM 6. Earlier this week, the company provided a release candidate for install, so I decided to take a look and share the results of my exploration.

      Before starting, it's important to remember that this is not a production quality release yet, so if you run production workloads, you should not upgrade quite yet. Even after DSM 7 is fully released, I'd recommend waiting a few months before upgrading your production environment, just to be safe.

      Having said that, the upgrade process was really straight forward. I simply downloaded the file from Synology's website, went to the Control Panel on the NAS device, selected Manual DSM Update, followed the prompts, and within 30 minutes, was running the latest version of the OS with no issues. However keep in mind that the upgrade was performed on the DS720+ review unit, so while it had several volumes and an SSD cache, there were no virtual machines, Docker containers, or the like which could have made the upgrade a little more difficult.

      The most obvious thing you'll notice is that the overall GUI is more polished and modern looking now. The login screen no longer prompts for a username and password, instead pushing the password request onto a second page. This was done because the login process supports some new authentication methods that I'll touch on later.

      DSM 7 (left) vs DSM 6 (right) The main desktop includes a nice default wallpaper, in contrast to the stark blue default from the previous version. The new icons arguably look a little nicer, and overall the interface is just a bit more responsive when navigating and opening applications, which is nice. Overall though, this isn't a major overhaul that will require any sort of learning curve for existing users: Everything is still in the same places that you're already used to, it's just all a slight bit nicer.

      Storage Manager
      From a user experience perspective, the Storage Manager is where most of the visible changes have been made. The previous version of DSM, while straight forward, still made some assumptions that the user understood how storage worked. With DSM 7, Synology has attempted to streamline the process.

      The first change is that, after starting the Storage Creation Wizard, you're presented with a nice graphical depiction of what a storage pool and volume is and how that relates to the physical drives in your NAS. After you click the start button, you're asked what type of data protection you want to use, with descriptions of what they all mean, told to select which disks will be part of the pool, and how much disk space to allocate to the volume. The whole process takes less than a minute to setup your pool and volume.

      That said, there are still some minor display issues, most notably under the Usage Details section, where you can clearly see that the provided note about how the system calculates usage is cut off at the right, and the window doesn't provide the ability to resize. Minor issues like this are expected in a release candidate.

      The updated view in Storage Manager is much clearer in showing that a volume is part of the storage pool.

      One of the new features to Storage Manager that will be a welcome addition is "Fast Repair," which is enabled on the volume by default, and may be the best update in DSM 7. Whereas in previous versions, replacing a drive required a complete resync of the disks to ensure it was consistent, Fast Repair skips all of the unused space in a storage pool so that the repair is done faster. I put this to the test by pulling out a 4 TB drive and then putting it back in, and instead of taking hours to repair, was done in only an hour and a half. This means when replacing a failed drive, your data will be at risk for far less time than in the past, a welcome addition.

      Even more important than streamlining the initial configuration of a pool and volume is the streamlining of replacing drives in the system. After removing one of the 4 TB drives and then re-inserting it, I was given an option to manage the new drive, giving me selections such as "Repair storage pool," "Assign as hot spare," or even, "Create storage pool." After clicking the repair button, I was asked to select the drive and then click the apply button. This is much more streamlined a process than with DSM 6, and is a welcome addition.

      Active Insight
      One of the best improvements with DSM 7 is the addition of a new feature called Active Insight. In essence, it's a remote monitoring system that allows you to see the status of all of your Synology devices through a web portal, and get immediate notifications for any errors. If you have multiple devices, you can see the status of all of them from a single pane of glass.

      Using the feature requires linking your device up to your Synology account and then enabling the feature. You can decide if you want the basic monitoring, so you're notified of storage pool degredation, failed drives, and the like, or if you want all of your performance data sent to Synology for easy remote monitoring.

      After enabling Active Insight, you can navigate to the Synology website (or click the link in the interface) and you're brought to an overview page that shows all of the events that have occurred in the last seven days, as well as the real-time metrics of your device. In the above screenshot, the red underline on June 3rd shows you that there was a critical alert and has been resolved, while the solid yellow shows a warning that has not yet been acknowledged and closed.

      Clicking on the Host menu will bring up an information card for every Synology device you have registered with Active Insight, showing basic CPU and memory utilization, as well as network traffic, drive performance, and storage utilization. If you have multiple devices, you can filter based on the model number or, more importantly, any devices that currently have a warning or critical alert associated with them. For enterprises that have a large number of devices, this could be an extremely useful feature. If you only have one or two devices at home, I suspect most users would simply login to the device itself for this information.

      If you want more specific information about an individual host, you can click on the card and see performance data, what services are running on the device, a graph that shows the storage usage over time, and any events that have occurred.

      The Performance tab shows a lot of data, from high level information such as volume utilization, down to statistics such as read and write latency, the number of IOPS, and the overall throughput of the volume. You can change the timeframe of the graphs from 6 hours up to an entire year. In addition, if you hover your cursor over a specific time, a vertical red line is displayed on every graph, allowing you to highlight a potential problem area and see all of the stats associated with that specific time.

      While overall I love Active Insight, the downside is that you're now sharing performance data with a third party. While your private data is still safe in your own location, some people who are security/privacy focused may have purchased a home NAS in order to keep everything within their own walls and to not share anything with a third party. Most of the data available in Active Insight is available directly on the NAS device itself, including the ability to send notifications for errors, it's just more work to setup, so I can see casual users really benefiting from this functionality.

      The other shortcoming with Active Insight is that, while it will alert you of issues that impact your NAS, there is no immediate check on whether the device is sending data or not. If the NAS device is offline, Active Insight simply shows no data for the duration of the outage.

      After opening a ticket with Synology about this shortcoming, I found the Custom Event tab in the Management section that lets you create notifications for various system events. By default, there are no events associate with any devices, although there is a default event called "Disconnected from Active Insight server." Unfortunately, the default is set to send a warning after a NAS device is unresponsive for an hour and a critical alert after 12 hours, which seem like rather high defaults, and although you can tweak them to meet your needs, the level of granularity is an hour, and you can't use decimal points in the fields. Hopefully Synology updates these thresholds.

      It's important to note that Active Insight appears to be a feature that Synology will be charging for in the future. When registering your device, you sign up for the Beta plan, which gives you access to customized events, 1 year data history retention, and metrics updated every minute. There's no word on what the price will be when the service exits beta.

      Synology has allowed users to use two-factor authentication for a long time, and it's something I highly recommend everyone enable. With DSM 7, Synology is giving users even more flexibility when it comes to authentication. Instead of using only a username/password combination or a username/password/two-factor combination, the latest version of DSM allows you to configure a hardware security key (such as a Yubikey), Windows Hello, or macOS Touch ID, or simply approve a login via the "Synology Secure Signin" mobile app. That said, enabling these advanced authentication methods will take some time and require a bit of work on the administrator's part.

      If you want to configure passwordless authentication with the new mobile app, you'll need either a public IP address for your NAS device or will need to enable QuickConnect or DDNS to setup the remote access. If you want to use a hardware security key, you must have a registered domain address over hTTPS and cannot use QuickConnect.

      As with DSM 6, you can use two-factor authentication with an authenticator app, but whereas you could use other authenticator apps in the past, with the new version of DSM, you appear to be locked into the Synology Secure Signin app, which feels like a step backwards.

      As with Active Insight, some people may not want to expose their device to the Internet at all, making this feature not very helpful for them. However if you're ok with connecting your NAS device to the Internet or using QuickConnect, these new features could be very helpful.

      Synology Photos
      Synology is deprecating the use of Moments and replacing it with Synology Photos. In my limited use of the product, it looks very similar to Moments (you can see my review of that product from 2018 here). Usage of Photos looks very similar to Moments: upload photos, and it categorizes them based on the year and month. You can then create albums based on the pictures you've uploaded. By default, DSM 7 will use facial recognition to categorize the same people into groups, but while Moments would also use AI to detect other things like cats and dogs, Photos seems to have done away with that feature for some reason. I don't understand why they would remove such a useful feature, especially since all of the processing is done on the local NAS device, so hopefully they'll bring it back once DSM 7 is officially released.

      Other New Features
      While I talked about a lot of the visual features of DSM 7, many of the updates to the operating system are actually behind-the-scenes or for enterprise implementations.

      According to Synology, a lot of work has been done around the SSD cache. When I reviewed the DS720+, I recommended against using an NVMe drive as cache in a home setup because there was simply no performance benefit. However, according to Synology, you can now use the cache to store all of the Btrfs metadata, which should speed up file access and searching. Since building cache takes a long time, I'm hoping to be able to test this in the future. Another update is the ability to add and remove the cache without impacting availability to the volume, a welcome addition, albeit one that probably doesn't get used too frequently.

      Another feature that is nice to have, but is relatively minor, is the ability to lock the USB port. This protects the NAS device from someone plugging in a device and automatically copying potentially harmful files onto the server.

      There are also some features that have been discontinued, such as using USB devices such as Bluetooth dongles and 3G/4G dongles, so be sure to read the release notes for more specifics before beginning the upgrade.

      Overall, while DSM 7 isn't a revolutionary upgrade, there's sure to be at least a few nice additions for everyone. Considering it's a free upgrade, once the OS is available, there's no reason not to install it and take advantage of what it has to offer. Just make sure you have backups in place in case something goes wrong.

    • By indospot
      RedMagic Watch review: A basic fitness smartwatch with lackluster software
      by João Carrasqueira

      For a couple of years now, I've been reviewing RedMagic's gaming phones, and part of the conclusion is always very similar: the software experience holds back the otherwise stellar hardware. So it was probably not smart of me to be excited when the company announced a fitness smartwatch despite still not managing to perfect the software on its RedMagic 6 phone from earlier this year.

      The RedMagic Watch is a fairly basic smartwatch, and there really isn't a whole lot to it that we haven't seen before. It offers basic health tracking and a few workout modes along with fairly long battery life. The most unique thing about it is the overall design of the UI, but that's not necessarily a good thing.

      Dimensions 45x45x10mm, 30g (excluding the strap) Material Metal alloy casing, plastic back Strap Swappable (22mm), silicone strap Display 1.39-inch AMOLED, 454x454 Sensors Accelerometer Optical heart rate sensor (with sleep monitoring) SpO2 sensor Ambient light sensor GPS Battery life Up to 15 days in regular mode, 23 days in power saver Water resistance 5ATM OS LiteOS Colors Black/Silver (as reviewed)

      Price $99 Design and display
      The RedMagic Watch is a round watch with an overall decent build quality. There's nothing inherently wrong with how it looks, but reviewing it next to the beautiful hardware of the Huawei Watch 3 Pro really puts it in perspective. The case is made of a metal alloy that feels fine but unexceptional. It's fairly lightweight at 30 grams, and it's not too thick, but there's nothing super interesting about it.

      The left side of the watch has nothing to see, and on the right side, there are two buttons, one being the home/menu button and the other opening the workout app. The top button has a small red accent that fits the RedMagic brand, but that's about it. There's no microphone or speaker here, so you can't make calls or anything.

      The back of the watch is made of plastic and it feels fine. Most smartwatches in this price range do, so there's nothing wrong with that. This houses the body sensors and two charging pins for the included puck-shaped charger.

      The watch strap is made of silicone and you can get it in two colors, being black with the black case, or white with the silver case. You can swap it for anything you'd like, though, and it uses a standard 22mm fitting.

      As for the display, it's a 1.39-inch AMOLED display with a fairly high resolution of 454 by 454 pixels. It looks sharp enough, and being an AMOLED panel means true blacks and vivid colors as usual. It also means you can enable an always-on display that's not always on since you can set a timer for it. It's a fine display and it works well for the colorful UI of the RedMagic Watch, which we'll get into in a bit.

      Software and features
      The software experience on the RedMagic Watch is going to feel very familiar to you if you've used or seen any of the more affordable Huawei fitness bands and watches I've reviewed recently. It seems to be largely based on the same experience as LiteOS, with similar menus, built-in apps, and features. You can change the watch face, and swiping sideways gives you access to widgets like weather, your daily activity records, heart rate, and music controls.

      However, it all comes with a RedMagic flavor, for better or for worse. I like how colorful the UI is, with many icons and pages using color gradients that look great on this display. However, it's a very static experience. Almost no aspect of the interface seems to have any kind of animation, even the countdowns before a workout starts which just look off without any movement.

      On top of that, you get RedMagic's usual translation work which works, but feels off in many instances. Breathing exercises are called "breath training", stopwatch is written as two separate words, among other cases. The watch comes with the following apps pre-installed:

      Sport Sport record Heart Rate Blood Oxygen Breath Training Sleep Compass Weather Music Stop watch Count Down Alarm Clock Find Phone Camera Setting Most of the watch's settings are split into the RedMagic Sports app, too, which I find odd. The only options available directly on the watch are Always-on display, Screen off, Do Not Disturb (DND), and System. Everything else, like notifications, settings for the frequency of heart rate measurements, and setting up features like weather, raise to wake, music playback controls, and sedentary reminders are all set up in the app.

      Even then, parts of the experience here are a bit lackluster. Loading the list of online watch faces for the first time took a few seconds for each watch face design, with them showing up one at a time. Thankfully, they seem to be cached so they don't have to load each time you open the app.

      Health tracking
      The RedMagic Watch offers a few health tracking features, including all-day heart rate monitoring, sleep tracking, and manual SpO2 measurements. This is already fairly limited compared to other cheaper devices like the Huawei Band 6, which also includes stress monitoring and can also measure SpO2 levels throughout the day.

      But that's made all the worse by how little detail RedMagic provides for all of this. The heart rate measurement graphs seem to be missing a lot of data, and for sleep tracking, RedMagic's app offers nowhere near as much insight as Huawei's Health app. There are no reference values for how much sleep you should be getting or anything beyond just seeing what stage of sleep you were in throughout the night.

      That continues with the workout tracking, too. There are only 15 workout modes, but that doesn't mean they're all that detailed. For a bike ride or outdoor walk, the RedMagic Sports app only shows the number of steps, the duration of the workout, calories burned, and the average heart rate, and the UI that presents this information feels unfinished.

      You also get to see your path on a map, but for some reason, my workouts are all saved as if I was on the Italian island of Sardegna. If that sounds familiar, yes, that is near the location where the weather widget on the Huawei Watch 3 Pro says I am, as I mentioned in my review from yesterday. Oddly enough, the weather widget here works fine since it's powered by my phone, while workouts are registered correctly on the Huawei Watch 3 Pro.

      Another thing that bothers me with the experience here is that there's no way to control music playback from the watch once you start a workout, which makes the watch far less useful if you want to listen to music while exercising.

      One thing that RedMagic touts is support for soccer practice training, which uses GPS to analyze your position throughout the match so you can understand where you spend most of your time during the match. I haven't been able to properly test this because I don't have many opportunities to play soccer, but the rest of the experience doesn't fill me with confidence.

      Performance and battery life
      Measuring performance on a smartwatch this simple is kind of impossible because there isn't much you can do with it. It would be a bad sign if anything slowed down such a simplistic operating system, and thankfully that mostly doesn't happen. It seems like the GPS takes some time to detect my position before starting a workout, which might tie into why it registers my position as being so far away from where I actually am. Otherwise, it runs fine.

      As for battery life, RedMagic promises up to 15 days of use on a single charge of its 420mAh battery, and I'm inclined to believe that. I haven't had enough time to drain the battery on it, and after a little over four days of use, the battery level on the watch is at 67%. Based on that, you should be able to get around 12 days on a charge, which isn't bad at all.

      There's no way of circling around it: there seems to be no real reason to buy the RedMagic Watch. The large round screen may be interesting to some, but the feature set is more limited than some devices that are significantly cheaper. I already mentioned the Huawei Band 6, which is a great fitness band that costs far less.

      The health tracking features are limited in number and capability. You don't get stress monitoring, there's no mind of insight into your sleep habits, and the workout tracking is similarly limited. Only 15 workout modes pale in comparison to the dozens of modes available on the Huawei Band 6, and you also get very little in the way of details in the RedMagic Sports after the fact. The software experience is also lackluster, with poor translations and a very static interface that looks almost lifeless, despite the colorful look.

      The RedMagic Watch costs $99.99, and you can get far more capable fitness watches for less. If you really do want a round display, something like the Amazfit GTR 2e costs a bit more but offers a much better experience in just about every way. Regardless, you can check out the RedMagic Watch on the company's website.