Apache Hammers Microsoft Over Do Not Track


Recommended Posts

This is a new feature in IE10 which so far is only available on Windows 8. During the installation of Windows 8, if you choose to use the express settings option, it will default to turning DNT on. If you click customize, you are presented with a choice to keep it on or turn it off.

Well, that sounds fine to me, then. They're informing users it will be turned on by default or giving them the option to change it before it is turned on.

I haven't installed 8 and I have no interest in ever doing so.

And it's fine to tell the user DNT is enabled, the issue is them enabling it by default. It should either prompt the user (and not just if you do a custom install), or leave the header out entirely. All MS has succeeding in doing by defaulting it on in IE10, is ensure that advertisers will ignore it for IE10.

But the user is being prompted. It isn't being enabled by default. The user has two options when installing Windows 8: To use the Express feature or the Custom feature; before the user chooses either of those options, Windows 8 informs them that Do Not Track will be enabled if they choose Express. So they are being prompted and it isn't being enabled by default without the user knowing.

The problem is that advertisers are under no legal obligation to comply with DNT. Without that it is completely irrelevant.

Correct. I personally feel this shouldn't be an option on their end. I feel that before the standard is ratified that it be put in that advertisers MUST honor DNT flags in a similar manner that telemarketers are supposed to honor the Do Not Call lists.

Why would anyone WANT to be tracked in the first place?

It helps with contextual advertising, so that ads are more relevant.

Have you ever noticed that after you go to Amazon.com and search for something specific and then come back to Neowin you'll see ads that look like things you were just looking at, or are a direct competitors item?

That's supposed to be the main purpose of tracking. It does come in handy and does have a use, but some people do not like it.

Don't implement DNT as part of Express people will ask why such an important security setting is so obscure and requires digging to find.

They wouldn't ask about that "important security feature" if MS hadn't touted it as such. Ultimately users are being tracked the same no matter what DNT setting they choose.

They wouldn't ask about that "important security feature" if MS hadn't touted it as such. Ultimately users are being tracked the same no matter what DNT setting they choose.

That wouldn't be the case if Fielding wasn't screwing with Apache to prevent DNT from working. I mean what was the point of all the work he put into it if he's just going to pull this kind of crap?

Who actually reads the express settings and makes a well thought decision?

Did you ever see The Human CentiPad episode of South Park?

The whole point of that episode was about how no one reads things before clicking and how they really should.

This isn't necessarily an EULA, but it's still important to read the options as you set things up on anything. If someone doesn't read the options, that's their fault, not the fault of the person who created the Express option.

When did making an intelligent decision become a bad thing?

MS should just ask the user anyway during the express install, and force them to make a choice, have it neither on/off by default, make the user chose one before hitting next.

But the result would be the same, offer someone a choice and *most* people are gonna enable DNT.

What are we even discussing at this point? The original issue was whether or not IE defaults to having DNT on, if you have to do a custom install to disable it then how can you possibly claim it's not the default setting?

That wouldn't be the case if Fielding wasn't screwing with Apache to prevent DNT from working. I mean what was the point of all the work he put into it if he's just going to pull this kind of crap?

Users are being tracked not because Apache changes the DNT flag, but because ad companies don't give a damn about it since no one is enforcing the standard.

And then even if some ad companies did actually care they could just easily argue that most users just go with the Express install and don't actually specifically choose to enable DNT, so going by the letter of the standard they have an excuse right there to keep tracking users.

Then again they don't even have to explain anything to anyone since they can just outright ignore the flag, so no matter what Apache does DNT (as it stands) is definitely not an "important security feature".

It doesn't work, it's about as useful as dropping a DoNotInfect.txt on your desktop and expecting Viruses to stay away from your computer.

Users are being tracked not because Apache changes the DNT flag, but because ad companies don't give a damn about it since no one is enforcing the standard.

And then even if some ad companies did actually care they could just easily argue that most users just go with the Express install and don't actually specifically choose to enable DNT, so going by the letter of the standard they have an excuse right there to keep tracking users.

Then again they don't even have to explain anything to anyone since they can just outright ignore the flag, so no matter what Apache does DNT (as it stands) is definitely not an "important security feature".

It doesn't work, it's about as useful as dropping a DoNotInfect.txt on your desktop and expecting Viruses to stay away from your computer.

That's because it isn't a standard yet /facepalm

What are we even discussing at this point? The original issue was whether or not IE defaults to having DNT on, if you have to do a custom install to disable it then how can you possibly claim it's not the default setting?

It doesn't default to anything. The user has to decide which setting to use. Express or Custom.

If you choose Express then it enables DNT. If you choose Custom then you can set it either way (along with many other settings)

That's what you don't seem to be getting. The user still has to make the choice regardless.

Didn't you say earlier you'd never installed Windows 8? If not I don't expect you to understand how the installer shows things to the user.

It helps with contextual advertising, so that ads are more relevant.

Have you ever noticed that after you go to Amazon.com and search for something specific and then come back to Neowin you'll see ads that look like things you were just looking at, or are a direct competitors item?

That's supposed to be the main purpose of tracking. It does come in handy and does have a use, but some people do not like it.

I never noticed that, but then again, my browser is running in TFH enabled mode.

If someone doesn't read the options, that's their fault, not the fault of the person who created the Express option.

If someone doesn't enable DNT it's their fault, not something Microsoft or any other company should worry about.

It helps with contextual advertising, so that ads are more relevant.

Have you ever noticed that after you go to Amazon.com and search for something specific and then come back to Neowin you'll see ads that look like things you were just looking at, or are a direct competitors item?

That's supposed to be the main purpose of tracking. It does come in handy and does have a use, but some people do not like it.

I would rather have ads based on the site I visit, than ads based on what they think I want ads about based on my random surfing patterns throughout the day.

Who actually reads the express settings and makes a well thought decision?

Surprisingly, the average "dumb" users. then they call an "expert" to ask what this "spy" thinkg is and if they shoudl click yes and leave it on or not.

If someone doesn't enable DNT it's their fault, not something Microsoft or any other company should worry about.

In that case then everything should be turned off by default on the OS, and you should have to enable them one by one, using that logic.

Why should they care if I have SmartScreen on? Why should they care if I don't have Windows Update enabled? Why should they care if I don't enable any sort of system protection?

In fact why even enable anything at all. Let's go back to building all or own stuff a piece at a time.

I think you've inspired me to hook up my old Commodore 64, and see if I can program myself a decent enough interface to be able to view webpages...just hope I don't forget to back it up to the tape drive before I turn it off at the end of the night. I'll also have to find where I put all that old networking gear for it and see if I can make any of it interface with my modern stuff.

;)

BTW this is more of what I predicted earlier. MS will get hammered regardless of what road they take with security.

It doesn't matter if it's a standard if no one enforces it.

/facepalm :shifty:

Yes, and it cannot be enforced if it's not a standard... ...by the very definition of what it means to be a standard in normal industry jargon.

Is it just me or am I spending a lot of time talking in circles with about half the people I reply to?

This topic is now closed to further replies.
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Posts

    • Trailer park trash “sport “, fits the current White House
    • KataLib 5.3.0.0 by Razvan Serea KataLib is more than just a music player — it's a complete audio suite designed for music lovers and creators alike. It combines a powerful audio player, a flexible metadata editor, a capable audio converter, and a music library manager into one streamlined application. Core Features: Audio Player Enjoy seamless playback of virtually any audio format or even streaming video files. DJ Mode lets you mix tracks with manual or automatic crossfades. You can also load and save WinAmp-style playlists for quick access to your favorite sets. Audio Converter Convert between a wide range of audio formats effortlessly. Trim or normalize your output automatically, and even extract audio from streaming video sources. Ideal for preparing files for different devices or platforms. Metadata Editor View and edit ID3v2 tags and other metadata. Batch edit multiple files at once, and fetch missing information directly from the MusicBrainz database. You can also apply or update album art with ease. Music Library Manager Organize your entire audio collection, search across tracks instantly, and download cover images from the internet — or use your own custom artwork. KataLib makes it easy to keep your library tidy and enriched with useful info. Supported Formats: KataLib supports a wide range of both lossy and lossless audio formats: Input: OPUS, AAC, FLAC, M4A, MP3, MP4, MPC, APE, AIF, MKV, AVI, MOV, FLV, WEBM, Ogg Vorbis, WAV, WAVPack, WMA, AC3, OGA, MP2, MPGA, MPEG, DTS, M4B, DSD (DFS) Output: OPUS, FLAC, M4A, MP3, Ogg Vorbis, WAV Under the hood, KataLib uses the trusted FFmpeg engine for audio conversion and media playback, ensuring compatibility with virtually all mainstream media formats. KataLib 5.3.0.0 changelog: Added Option to select the Zoom level of the Oscilloscope visualizer. The taskbar button of the app now displays the progress of its processing tasks. The metadata text of the Visualization Video can now be aligned by the user. We can now reorder the order of the Visualizers and Metadata, in the Visualization Video Setup dialog, by removing any item and adding it again. It will be added at the end. Changed The font size of the Visualization Video can now be more than 30 points. Updated yt-dlp library to version 2026... Fixed Opening the Visualization Video Setup dialog could fail if the settings were wrong. Sometimes there were false duplicates in the Rename Tracks dialog. Tracks without metadata appeared without title in the Recent menu. Download: KataLib 5.3.0.0 | 90.0 MB (Open Source) Links: KataLib Home Page | Github | Screenshot Get alerted to all of our Software updates on Twitter at @NeowinSoftware
    • EA Sports UFC 6 review: Brutal, satisfying, and surprisingly accessible to newcomers by Pulasthi Ariyasinghe EA’s UFC series of fighting games has been putting out games for over 10 years now, but it’s a series I have never spent any time with. As a PC guy, the series being console-exclusive is the primary reason for that. The latest entry to the series, EA Sports UFC 6, is still not coming to PC, but I have an Xbox now. When EA reached out to see if I could have a crack at the game and give my opinion about it, I finally got the chance to see what this franchise is about. I have spent about a week playing UFC 6 on the Xbox Series X. Despite my lackluster skill with fighting games, I still have fun with entries like Street Fighter and Tekken. I quickly came to realize this is a different kind of fighting game, not the arcade titles I am usually dabbling with. Most of the week that I spent playing UFC 6 was in the career mode, trying not to get knocked out while slowly improving my combos and reactions. The review below will be from the perspective of a newcomer to the series and an amateur fighting game fan, so please forgive any mistyped lingo or series-staple mechanics I am not comprehending. In the Ring Getting a solid hit in UFC 6 is satisfying. It’s probably the most satisfying impact reaction I have seen in a fighting game. The ripples in the muscles, the spray of sweat (and blood), the meaty sound, and the subsequent stumble all carry a lot of weight. If I miss a heavy swing like that, though, I already know that I'm in for a world of hurt from the incoming counters. The fighting is a real treat. The actions aren’t as snappy as arcade titles, so a miss feels like a much bigger mistake here. This slowness did take some getting used to, but I felt the improvement in my abilities even after a few drills with basic punch and kick combos. If I’m not deliberate with my actions in the ring, whether it be a hasty retreat or a flying punch, the possibility of getting instantly knocked out is always there. The head, chest, and legs all come with their own health bars, so guarding just one area is just asking for trouble. A few hits to the head, and it's game over. Meanwhile, you won’t even be able to stay on your feet if they get damaged enough, drastically lowering the total amount of stamina available for the rest of the match. I was also encountering a large range of fighting styles to customize my own fighter with. There are a huge number of real-life superstars here from multiple eras. It’s not as exaggerated as Street Fighter or Tekken, but the way they move, evade, throw punches, or even take steps is based on their real-life counterparts. I can see this being a big draw for any mixed martial arts fan. One feature I was surprised to see here was the 'Flow State' ability. As rounds progress, a power-up meter can give a temporary boost to the unique fighting style of the selected fighter, essentially boosting what they are good at. There is an entire visual effect that kicks in when activating this, too. The surprising part was seeing something like this in a game that feels like it’s aiming to be more of a simulator than an arcade fighter. My skill level is too low to use this exactly how the game wants me to, so I ended up triggering it whenever the opponent did it as well. Streamlined vs Authentic When I first started it up, UFC 6 asked me about my experience with the series. Being genuinely new, I took its advice and opted for a lowered difficulty level and 'Streamlined' controls. Quickly, I realized that this wasn’t for me. My chosen fighters were throwing random attacks, no matter what combination the game was trying to teach me. Win streaks were happening, and I was already getting bored out of my mind just a few matches in. Turning off this mode and switching to 'Authentic' controls fixed everything right up. I was now able to control my fighter with more precision than I expected. I could control each arm and leg, which body part my attacks would aim at, and the fully customizable controls for setting up unorthodox moves were a cherry on top. None of these made me an expert at the game, but at least I was being beaten up fairly. This is not a point against UFC 6, though. Giving the option for anyone to enjoy the game is always a good thing in my eyes. There is a lot of customizability in the difficulty, with everything from slow-motion reactions to specific assists being offered as toggles. If I had a friend coming over and wanted to try a quick 1v1, the streamlined controls option is one I’d consider to make it a light and fun fight. The one part of the fighting that did not click with me was the grappling. Being taken to the ground brings in an entirely new control mechanism involving mounts and submissions that feel more like quick-time events than the heavy, tactical fighting I had seen so far while standing. The game wants me to hold sticks in certain directions to change the position or pull off submissions, trying to do the opposite actions of the opponent. Even though I tried to get used to this gameplay, it just felt like a momentum killer, and I eventually just wanted to get back on my feet to get back into the action. Legacy and Career It was UFC 6’s career mode that I wanted to play the most when I started it up. I grew up with EA Sports games, and taking my team from the ground to the top has always been my favorite task. UFC 6 has that same option but also offers a more cinematic entrance to the career experience than I expected with ‘The Legacy’ mode. This mini-campaign follows an up-and-coming fighter, Chris Carter, who is attempting to reach the heights his father had reached in the sport. Starting with a small-time gym and coach, the story follows both his growth in the space as well as the growing rivalry with a friend and fighter, Danny Lopez. The fights in this mode are very good at introducing a newcomer like me to the sport and its varying techniques. Cinematics land between the major fights, showing the growing tension between the two fighters as the years go by, feeling the pressure to not miss out on the hard-earned chances. The dialogue can be a little corny at times, especially when the bar fights kick off, but I largely enjoyed the storyline. At the end of it, I was pretty much familiar with all the mechanics of the career mode, unlocking new skills and moves, and how I needed to approach fights, both outside and inside the ring. This story mode isn’t a very lengthy one, so don’t expect an hour-long campaign. Once the conclusion is reached, Carter’s journey continues as if it’s a normal career playthrough, though I decided to start over from scratch now that I have some know-how about the basics. The career mode is very streamlined, which is to be expected considering there isn’t a team to manage like in other EA Sports games. It’s the journey of one fighter. When a fight comes up in the calendar, I could choose how many weeks I dedicate to preparing for it at the gym. A longer prep time gives the opportunity to get my fighter’s fitness up (giving a bonus during fights), earn more money and points for unlocking new skills, and gain more fans to fast-track the rise to stardom. While that sounds like a lot of things to manage, it’s more like a few clicks. There is a social media menu that sometimes pops up with canned replies I can send to fans, and the sponsors are once again a single click away from being assigned as finished. It’s the training aspect that adds a gameplay angle. Using the money from winnings and sponsorships, I was hiring different types of trainers and learning fancier moves to use in the ring. One small thing I appreciated was that it was possible to injure each other during these training sessions. If a trainer goes down in a bad way while sparring, they won’t be available for the remainder of training. If my fighter is injured, it takes valuable time and resources to heal and recuperate. Just like in real life, it makes sense not to go so hard during training sessions and save that energy for the main event. Every training or sponsorship activity I took part in used up the days and weeks I had before the next fight, bringing a balancing element to the whole ordeal. There were times I simulated most of these to just get to the next fight, but the grind for gaining even the slightest bit of advantage while trying not to overdo it is an enjoyable one. Outside of quick fights and career modes, UFC 6 also introduces an almost museum-like mode to explore a trio of fighters considered to be legends of the sport: Max Holloway, Alex Pereira, and Zhang Weili. The aptly named Hall of Legends mode is unlike everything else seen in the game. Each of these fighters has entire levels dedicated to them that I could walk around in and explore their journey into the UFC. This includes footage from real-life fights and interviews about their original inspirations and training methods. Each of these spaces is almost like an interactive documentary. Once the highlights are done, the mode offers the opportunity to take over a deciding fight from the superstars. It’s an impressive transition. Going from the real-life televised event with crowds and commentary to immediately taking over in the game has some real hype behind it. Performance and visuals It’s clear to see that UFC 6 is going for a photo-realism look with its visuals compared to any other fighting game. The fighters don’t look great in selection screens. But inside the arenas, under the flood lights, surrounded by crowds, and facing an opponent, the visuals are more than impressive. As ghastly as it is to witness, things like blood spraying into the mat and muscles reddening as they get pummeled keep improving the immersion. The fluid animations help sell the illusion even further. A missed kick carries the momentum to require a corrective step. Hard punches that glance off blocks give off the air of a hit that still took some wind off the opponent’s guard. The special moves with flips and spins look mega awkward when missing, just as they do in real life. Suffice to say, the Frostbite Engine powering this game is one of the biggest strengths of EA development studios. Playing on the Xbox Series X, the 60 FPS gameplay did not miss the mark or cause any slowdowns that I could detect. I still wish this series were on PC to see just how far the developer can push the engine. One area I continue to have issues with, surprisingly enough, is the menus. The game has fast loading screens, but almost every menu I click through has a large amount of noticeable lag before it registers. This is immensely painful in the career mode, since I have to go through multiple menus between fights to train and do sponsorships, and having a 3-second pause when selecting a simple move between pages is the only time that made me quit the game. Thanks to Xbox’s quick resume, though, I was able to instantly jump back in the next day to the same point (and wade through more laggy menus). Conclusion My primary mission going into this EA Sports UFC 6 review as a newcomer to the series was to find out if this is a good jumping-in point for someone like me. Suffice it to say, the game passed that test with flying colors. Despite the high skill ceiling, the legacy mode introduction campaign, multiple types of accessible controls, and streamlined career had me picking up the basics and fighting styles much faster than I expected. I wish I had gotten to try out competitive multiplayer during my time with the game, too, but the lack of players in the pre-release version prevented this. The impressive visuals and animations, coupled with the impact physics that let me feel every punch and kick easily, made this the most immersive fighting game I have played. The only part that gave me pause was the grappling gameplay, which killed the momentum in most fights. The Flow State amplifying system didn’t hamper the experience, but I also felt like it made more sense for an arcade fighter, not this. Easily the most annoying thing about UFC 6 was its laggy menus, which I hope get some sort of fix later. Returning series veterans might have a completely different experience from me. But for a new fan like me looking to climb ranks and see fighters get floored in spectacular ways, UFC 6 doesn’t miss a step. EA Sports UFC 6 is releasing on June 19 across Xbox Series X|S and PlayStation 5 for $69.99. Ultimate Edition owners can already jump in via advanced access. This review was conducted on the Xbox Series X version of the game provided by EA.
    • No, Microsoft is obviously just spending money on maintaining a product with 0 users.
  • Recent Achievements

    • Week One Done
      ssd21345 earned a badge
      Week One Done
    • Contributor
      MarkHughes4096 went up a rank
      Contributor
    • Dedicated
      jordanspringer earned a badge
      Dedicated
    • Rookie
      Rimplesnort went up a rank
      Rookie
    • One Year In
      Markus94287 earned a badge
      One Year In
  • Popular Contributors

    1. 1
      +primortal
      486
    2. 2
      +Edouard
      173
    3. 3
      PsYcHoKiLLa
      138
    4. 4
      ATLien_0
      94
    5. 5
      Steven P.
      79
  • Tell a friend

    Love Neowin? Tell a friend!