Don Mattrick: 'If you're backwards compatible, you're really ..

By Motoko.
in Xbox

 Share

Recommended Posts

Grand Master

Phouchg

Posted
Posted

So the move from PowerPC RISC to the x86 AMD APU is the cause for difficulty with backward compatibility? If so, that could be a formidable/costly barrier. Sony was smart to try and at least offer some sort of workaround.

Pretty much everything needs to be emulated. Starting with byte order for both instructions and data.

Sony is in a bit better position here, as far as cloud gaming goes. They bought Gaikai technology, didn't have to build it all from scratch. I suppose Microsoft could have sacrificed several containers of Azure, for starters, for Full Circle* or something, but it would cost them way more. Probably not worth all the good PR.

* - a tacky name I've just invented for Xbox 360 cloud solution

True But the first Xbox was x86. So now Xbox One should be compatible with the first Xbox's games.

Build the whole Xbox into the controller, like some of the late NES clones :D

Veteran

xWhiplash

Posted
Posted

I'm being serious though. You'd use a usb wireless mouse and keyboard. The Xbox One is basically a gaming computer with a modified APU and custom OS. It has gaming, tv and social things, but it is missing the computing part. It would definitely be the ultimate "one for everything" console. It would be good for college and school kids, because they could quit playing an Xbox game and launch Microsoft office to start working!

Why don't you just hook up your PC to your TV and use that?

Grand Master

DConnell Member

Posted
  • Member
Posted

This is slightly disappointing but not a deal-breaker. The backwards-compatibility on the 360 was nice, but when I want to play an XBox game, I normally fire up one of my 2 modded original Xboxes. They're modded for XBMC, but they still do games just fine. It seems to me if you've got a collection of 360 games, you've also got the console to play it on. It would be nice to have the One truly be able to replace the 360 so I don't have more clutter in my entertainment center but if it keeps the cost down I can deal.

Grand Master

Julius Caro

Posted
Posted

You know what? I believe that the whole "less than 5% use their consoles to play previous-generation games" is reasonable enough to not implement the whole backwards compatibility thing. But lord knows how they measured this, because we know how well the same argument went for getting rid of the start button on windows.

Grand Master

threetonesun

Posted
Posted

You know what? I believe that the whole "less than 5% use their consoles to play previous-generation games" is reasonable enough to not implement the whole backwards compatibility thing. But lord knows how they measured this, because we know how well the same argument went for getting rid of the start button on windows.

It's a made up number. You know why they don't do backwards compatibility? Because now they can release the same games for the second (or third) time, and get people to buy them again.

I will admit that it's not the easiest thing to implement, especially when you're switching architectures. Even on the PC there's usually some hacks and emulators required if you go back far enough.

Grand Master

theyarecomingforyou

Posted
Posted

You know what? I believe that the whole "less than 5% use their consoles to play previous-generation games" is reasonable enough to not implement the whole backwards compatibility thing. But lord knows how they measured this, because we know how well the same argument went for getting rid of the start button on windows.

There's simply no way to accurately gauge what percentage of people use their consoles to play previous generation games. When the X360 launched the percentage was probably much higher but obviously as the lifecycle goes on the need for backwards compatibility diminishes. That said, backwards compatibility really isn't much of an issue. Those that already have X360s will be able to continue using them and most TVs have plenty of HDMI connections - it's not worth increasing the price for everyone when only a minority will benefit from it.

Grand Master

dead.cell

Posted
Posted

I never played an Xbox game on my 360. However, I did play some PSOne and PS2 games on my PS3. Hmmm... :/

Probably because the library selection of the PS1 and PS2 were ridiculous. Hell, I still kick on the PS2 just to play some old school games.

Grand Master

BajiRav

Posted
Posted

You know why they don't do backwards compatibility? Because now they can release the same games for the second (or third) time, and get people to buy them again.

I will admit that it's not the easiest thing to implement, especially when you're switching architectures. Even on the PC there's usually some hacks and emulators required if you go back far enough.

If you know a better way of emulating a 3 Core PPC architecture on a 8 Core x86_64 processor - you should contact Microsoft. I am not sure why people are singling out Microsoft over this. Even Sony is not doing it. They will be using Gaikai for playing PS3 games - well and that requires an ALWAYS ONLINE internet which apparently many gamers don't have.

Grand Master

threetonesun

Posted
Posted

If you know a better way of emulating a 3 Core PPC architecture on a 8 Core x86_64 processor - you should contact Microsoft. I am not sure why people are singling out Microsoft over this. Even Sony is not doing it. They will be using Gaikai for playing PS3 games - well and that requires an ALWAYS ONLINE internet which apparently many gamers don't have.

As I said, it's not easy when you're switching architectures, as both MS and Sony are doing. It's possible, however, but when there's very little value in doing it, and some possible income by forcing people to rebuy, it's a pretty obvious choice.

On the other hand... there's an obvious possibility that downloaded games could be ported for free. However, it seems very unlikely that MS will do that.

Grand Master

Growled Member

Posted
  • Member
Posted

You know what? I believe that the whole "less than 5% use their consoles to play previous-generation games" is reasonable enough to not implement the whole backwards compatibility thing. But lord knows how they measured this, because we know how well the same argument went for getting rid of the start button on windows.

Lots of people would use it if it was implemented.

Grand Master

BajiRav

Posted
Posted

On the other hand... there's an obvious possibility that downloaded games could be ported for free. However, it seems very unlikely that MS will do that.

You can't cross-compile for "free" when you are switching to an entirely different architecture. It doesn't matter if the game is downloadable or on a disc.

Grand Master

JustGeorge

Posted
Posted

Microsoft always tries to put a positive spin on why they choose to be lazy. Anyway, of they had stuck with x86 since the original Xbox, none of this would matter. I get the reasoning behind going back to x86, which is to simplify things for developers that cater to multiple platforms, but they should've had the forethought to see this as a problem when they transitioned to PPC in the 360.

One thing that they've not clarified yet is if this lack of BC includes XBL Arcade games. Given what I already know about the One, if XBL games don't carry over, that will be the last straw for me. I'll either skip this generation entirely or get a PS4.

Grand Master

shakey

Posted
Posted

Well, the hammer I have can't screw or unscrew things either... But if it came with that ability to, I'm sure I would use it.

Can't base what people don't do with something as a reason to not do something, just because it didn't have the capability to do it in the first place......

Grand Master

+virtorio MVC

Posted
  • MVC
Posted

Given what I already know about the One, if XBL games don't carry over, that will be the last straw for me. I'll either skip this generation entirely or get a PS4.

Might want to get your PS4 pre-order in early then.

Grand Master

BajiRav

Posted
Posted

Well, the hammer I have can't screw or unscrew things either... But if it came with that ability to, I'm sure I would use it.

Can't base what people don't do with something as a reason to not do something, just because it didn't have the capability to do it in the first place......

Agreed, he didn't have to badmouth BC because X1 doesn't have it. There is no reason to say what he said.

Grand Master

threetonesun

Posted
Posted

You can't cross-compile for "free" when you are switching to an entirely different architecture. It doesn't matter if the game is downloadable or on a disc.

Yes, there is some cost there somewhere, but it would certainly be easier than backwards compatibility for disc based games. The majority of Xbox Arcade games are already running on Windows, it would not be an incredible feat to bring them back to the X1.

The point is that they're not going to, and they don't care, which is something that was an ok answer back in the days when games were always on a cartridge or a disc and intrinsically tied to the hardware, but once you've got a digital distribution system up and running, killing backwards compatibility is a real crap policy compared to what Steam offers, what Sony appears to be offering, and even compared to what the Windows Store seems to offer.

  • 3 weeks later...
This topic is now closed to further replies.
 Share
Go to topic listing

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.

  • Posts

    • Nothing kills CMF Phone 2 Pro's successor due to rising memory prices

      By Hamid Ganji · Posted

      Nothing kills CMF Phone 2 Pro's successor due to rising memory prices by Hamid Ganji Storage and RAM prices have been rising over the past year, leading to a significant increase in the cost of electronics for customers around the world. Many companies are now revising their plans for upcoming devices due to higher component costs and overall production expenses. CMF is the latest company to cancel the successor to one of its best-selling phones due to rising memory prices. CMF is a sub-brand of Nothing and focuses on making budget smartphones for growing markets. The brand launched the CMF Phone 2 Pro last year with some eye-catching specifications and an affordable price. While many customers may have been waiting for a successor this year, one of the company’s executives has announced that CMF will not release a new smartphone this year. And AI is to blame. As Nothing co-founder Akis Evangelidis announced on X, the company has been working on a successor to the CMF Phone 2 Pro, but with current memory prices, it cannot “build a phone that feels like a genuine step forward at a price that makes sense for CMF.” So, no new CMF phone will be launched this year. Meanwhile, Evangelidis said the company still has several new products in the pipeline, including some in entirely new categories. He added that the Nothing brand will also continue launching new products through 2026. Budget smartphones are among the first victims of the surge in RAM and memory prices, as they have become more expensive to build. The sharp increase in memory costs could also reshape the traditional price ranges associated with budget phones. Apple CEO Tim Cook also recently said that price increases for some of the company’s products are unavoidable because RAM and memory have become significantly more expensive this year. Analysts estimate that the base price of the upcoming iPhone 18 Pro could rise to $1,399 due to current market shortages.
    • Windows 11 gets new audio improvements in the latest builds

      By RejZoR · Posted

      Nudge me when they bring back hardware audio acceleration so I can get my EAX 5 back. We've evolved graphics to real-time path tracing, but regressed audio some 15 years back in time with this stupid software audio stack.
    • Ocenaudio 3.19.4

      By Copernic · Posted

      Ocenaudio 3.19.4 by Razvan Serea  Ocenaudio is a full featured, fast and easy to use audio and music editor. It is the ideal software for people who need to edit and analyze audio files without complications. Ocenaudio also has powerful features that will please more advanced users. To assist ocenaudio development, a powerful toolset of audio editing, analysis and manipulation called Ocen Framework was created. ocenaudio is also based on Qt framework, a well known library for cross-platform development. Cross-platform support ocenaudio is available for all major operating systems: Microsoft Windows, Mac OS X and Linux. Native applications are generated for each platform from a common source, in order to achieve excelent performance and seamless integration with the operating system. All versions of ocenaudio have a uniform set of features and the same graphical interface, so the skills you learn in one platform can be used in the others. VST plugins support Ocenaudio supports VST (Virtual Studio Technology) plugins, giving its users access to numerous effects. Like the native effects, VST effects can use real-time preview to aide configuration. Real-time preview of effects Applying effects such as EQ, gain and filtering is an important part of audio editing. However, it is very tricky to get the desired result by adjusting the controls configuration alone: you must listen the processed audio. To ease the configuration of audio effects, ocenaudio has a real time preview feature: you hear the processed signal while adjusting the controls. The effect configuration window also includes a miniature view of the selected audio signal. You can navigate on this miniature view in the same way as you do on the main interface, selecting parts that interest you and listening to the effect result in real time. Multiselection for delicate editions To speed up complex audio files editing, ocenaudio includes multi-selection. With this amazing tool, you can simultaneously select different portions of an audio file and listen, edit or even apply an effect to them. For example, if you want to normalize only the excerpts of an interview where the interviewee is talking, just select them and apply the effect. Eficient edition of large files With ocenaudio, there is no limit to the length or the quantity of the audio files you can edit. Using an advanced memory management system, the application keeps your files open without wasting any of your computer's memory. Even in files several hours long, common editing operations such as copy, cut or paste happen almost instantly. Fully featured spectrogram Besides offering an incredible waveform view of your audio files, ocenaudio has a powerful and complete spectrogram view. In this view, you can analyze the spectral content of your audio signal with maximum clarity. Advanced users will be surprised to find that the spectrogram settings are applied in real time. The display is updated immediately when altering features such as the number of frequency bands, window type and size and dynamic range of the display. Ocenaudio 3.19.4 changelog: Adds fallback fonts so every language and symbol displays correctly Improves autosave and session recovery stability Improves region navigation and display Fixes a crash when the level meter is used on displays with a scaling greater than 200% Fixes memory corruption when using the silence selection tools Fixes crashes when closing a file while effects are still being processed Fixes a freeze when applying effects to many files at once (macOS) Fixes crashes related to audio devices on Windows Fixes invalid file names when exporting regions whose label is used as the file name Other bug fixes and improvements Download: Ocenaudio 64-bit | Portable | ~40.0 MB (Freeware) Download: Ocenaudio for Linux and Mac OS View: Ocenaudio Homepage | Screenshot Get alerted to all of our Software updates on Twitter at @NeowinSoftware
    • Hasleo Disk Clone 5.8.2.1

      By Copernic · Posted

      Hasleo Disk Clone 5.8.2.1 by Razvan Serea Hasleo Disk Clone is a free and all-in-one disk cloning software for Windows 11/10/8/7/Vista and Windows Server that can help you migrate Windows OS to another disk, clone one disk to another disk or clone one partition to another location quickly and efficiently. Completely Free Windows Migration and Disk/Partition Cloning Software Migrate Windows from one disk to another without reinstalling Windows, apps. Clone one disk to another and makes the data on 2 disks are exactly the same. Clone a partition to another location without losing any data. Easily adjust the size and location of the destination partition. Convert MBR to GPT or convert GPT to MBR by cloning. Creation of Windows PE emergency disk. Extremely fast cloning speed and multi-language support. Supported OS: Windows Vista/Server 2008 or later, fully compatible with GPT and UEFI. Hasleo Disk Clone 5.8.2.1 changelog: Fixed an issue that caused disk enumeration to fail Fixed an issue where WinPE created under Windows ARM64 26H1 did not work properly Download: Hasleo Disk Clone 5.8.2.1 | 32.3 MB (Freeware) Link: Hasleo Disk Clone Home Page | Screenshot Get alerted to all of our Software updates on Twitter at @NeowinSoftware
    • Waymo recalls self-driving software after cars enter closed freeway work zones

      By ExecutiveFunction404 · Posted

      This got me thinking, would you rather a self driving car prioritise protecting its passengers or everyone else? I'd choose the one that keeps me and my kids safest. At some point, these cars have to make those choices already, don't they? Wonder if we have a way to find out what way they lean.

  • Recent Achievements

    • Collaborator
      ryansurfer98 went up a rank
      Collaborator
    • Week One Done
      Eurosoft10 earned a badge
      Week One Done
    • One Month Later
      Eurosoft10 earned a badge
      One Month Later
    • One Year In
      Skeet Campbell earned a badge
      One Year In
    • One Month Later
      Sharbel earned a badge
      One Month Later

  • Popular Contributors

    1. 1
      +primortal
      546
    2. 2
      +Edouard
      187
    3. 3
      Michael Scrip
      78
    4. 4
      PsYcHoKiLLa
      74
    5. 5
      neufuse
      71
    Show More

  • Tell a friend

    Love Neowin? Tell a friend!