I am writing a game in C++ using SDL as the main library, and everything seems to be going okay. However I am noticing large memory usage when I load in a texture, and freeing up pointers/objects with delete() doesn't seem to be actually freeing up memory. So on linux I used ValGrind but I find it difficult to understand where my problems are happening.
I copied my code over and have it compiling and running under Windows using Visual Studio 2010 Pro. I notice the memory usage is the same on both windows and linux, and the memory use doesn't rise constantly but it does rise when objects are created (normal), however before creation is should be deleting the one previously taking that memory space (not freeing), and using some couts I can see that it is freeing them.
ie)
MyObject *obj = new MyObject() // results in + 200kb used
delete(obj) // Doesn't reduce memory by 200kb
obj = NULL // Just sets the pointer to null
If I kept running that my memory would constantly grow by 200kb (which I think is far more than that object should be using anyways). So to try and figure out what was going on I tried adding in the leak code as stated by MS on MSDN.
AttikClient::StartGame() initializes a static function in a static class, that has the main game loop and other logic. However when I close my program there is no leak output in the output window. I have debug on as I can step through the code and can see basic output but no leak information.
So.... slower fixes and slower security updates are preferred?
I mean, there is no goldilocks zone here until it can literally update without ever needing a restart, and even then I'm sure someone would complain.
[New Deal] Save 73% on a lifetime EbookMagic Starter Plan by Steven Parker
Today's highlighted Neowin Deal comes via our Apps + Software section, where you can get a lifetime subscription and save 73% on a lifetime EbookMagic Starter Plan.
EbookMagic helps turn your ideas into complete, professionally formatted ebooks without spending weeks writing, editing or designing. Simply enter your title, genre and key details, and EbookMagic creates structured content, polished layouts and a custom cover in just minutes.
Instead of juggling separate writing tools, formatting software and cover generators, EbookMagic handles the entire ebook creation process in one place. Generate content, customize your book and export ready-to-use files designed for publishing, sharing or personal projects.
EbookMagic Lifetime gives aspiring authors, creators and entrepreneurs the flexibility to build, publish and scale projects over time without ongoing subscription fees. Whether you're building lead magnets, creating educational resources or starting your self-publishing journey, EbookMagic simplifies the process and helps bring ideas to life faster.
AI-Powered Ebook Creation
AI Writing Assistant: Transform prompts & ideas into complete ebook content.
12 Professional Writing Styles: Write using multiple styles and tones.
Author Style Mimicking: Adapt content to preferred writing styles.
Personalized Cover Generator: Produce custom ebook covers automatically.
AI Audiobook Creator: Convert your books into professional-sounding audiobooks using a variety of realistic AI voices (1 audio book included).
Built to Help You Create Faster
Lightning Fast Creation: Build complete ebooks in minutes.
Target Audience Optimization: Tailor content to specific demographics and reader preferences.
Intelligent Chapter Structure: Automatically organize chapters and generate a table of contents.
15+ Genres Supported: Create fiction, non-fiction, business, romance, self-help and more.
Quality Assurance: Improve readability and engagement with built-in content optimization.
Convert to Interactive Books: Transform standard content into interactive experiences.
57 Major Languages Support: Produce ebooks across supported languages.
Ready for Download & Publishing
Ready for Sale: Create professional books that can be published and sold on Amazon KDP and other major publishing platforms
Kindle & Print-Ready Formats: Export files prepared for publishing.
No Watermarks: Create cleaner deliverables for publishing.
Commercial Usage Rights: Sell or publish your ebooks.
Built-In Editing Tools: Make edits before export.
What You'll Get
5 Ebooks per month
Each generated ebook can support up to 500,000 words per book.
Up to 50 cover generations
12 professional writing styles
Author style mimicking
Personalized Cover Generator
Convert to Interactive Books
Multiple languages support
Kindle & Print-ready formats
Commercial usage rights
No watermarks
Good to know
Length of access: Lifetime
Redemption deadline: Redeem your code within 30 days of purchase
Access options: Desktop and mobile
Max number of devices: Up to 3 devices can be used per license.
Available for both new and existing users that are not on lifetime plan.
Updates included
A lifetime subscription to EbookMagic Starter Plan normally costs $149, but this deal can be yours for just $39.99, that's a saving of $109. For full terms, specifications, and license info please click the link below.
Get this EbookMagic Starter Plan lifetime deal for just $39.99 (was $149)
Although priced in U.S. dollars, this deal is available for digital purchase worldwide.
Support queries
If you have queries or need support for any of the Neowin Deals, please use the contact form here. Neowin Deals are managed and sold by StackCommerce who represent Neowin on an affiliate basis.
Why we post these deals
We post these because we earn commission on each sale so as not to rely solely on advertising, which many of our readers block. It all helps toward paying staff reporters, servers and hosting costs. So for those that keep moaning and complaining, be thankful we're still online for you to even do that.
Other ways to support Neowin
Whitelist Neowin by not blocking our ads
Create a free member account to see fewer ads
Make a donation to support our day to day running costs
Subscribe to Neowin - for $14 a year, or $28 a year for an ad-free experience
Disclosure: Neowin benefits from revenue of each sale made through our branded deals site powered by StackCommerce.
Question
firey
I am writing a game in C++ using SDL as the main library, and everything seems to be going okay. However I am noticing large memory usage when I load in a texture, and freeing up pointers/objects with delete() doesn't seem to be actually freeing up memory. So on linux I used ValGrind but I find it difficult to understand where my problems are happening.
I copied my code over and have it compiling and running under Windows using Visual Studio 2010 Pro. I notice the memory usage is the same on both windows and linux, and the memory use doesn't rise constantly but it does rise when objects are created (normal), however before creation is should be deleting the one previously taking that memory space (not freeing), and using some couts I can see that it is freeing them.
ie)
MyObject *obj = new MyObject() // results in + 200kb used
delete(obj) // Doesn't reduce memory by 200kb
obj = NULL // Just sets the pointer to null
If I kept running that my memory would constantly grow by 200kb (which I think is far more than that object should be using anyways). So to try and figure out what was going on I tried adding in the leak code as stated by MS on MSDN.
http://msdn.microsoft.com/en-us/library/e5ewb1h3(v=vs.80).aspx
I put that in my main.cpp file and put the "_CrtDumpMemoryLeaks();" in my main function which looks like
AttikClient::StartGame() initializes a static function in a static class, that has the main game loop and other logic. However when I close my program there is no leak output in the output window. I have debug on as I can step through the code and can see basic output but no leak information.
I have also tried VLD (Visual Leak Detector) http://www.codeproject.com/Articles/9815/Visual-Leak-Detector-Enhanced-Memory-Leak-Detectio
And got the same results. The build mode is for sure set as debug, and I make sure to do F5 which is Debug Application. Am I missing something?
Link to comment
https://www.neowin.net/forum/topic/1155344-c-visual-studio-2010-memory-leak-tracking/Share on other sites
8 answers to this question
Recommended Posts