• 0

How would this level of fragmentation slow down my PC performance ?


Question

I noticed in trying to extract 40gb of data the process was taking a bit longer than usual. I also noticed if I downloaded multiple files playing videos etc can stutter and general navigation is slower. I download and delete various HD movies etc and I believe this may be the read there were so many fragmented block ..How often should I defrag to maintain the highest level of performance ? 





 

defrag.jpg

Recommended Posts

  • 0

Normally not until there's a lot... this seems like a lot if red = fragmented.

If you use Bittorrent, does the client allow you to pre-reserve / pre-create the space before it downloads?

  • Like 1
  • 0

This definitely is great candidate for defrag. Never seen so fragmented drive myself (but I rarely use defrag since most my devices use SSD's nowadays). Generally though it might be good to defrag when it gets to 30-40% or more in the red...

  • Like 1
  • 0

Almost a day later and it's still defragging ..Using the optimizing feature on Auslogics tho. Really hope to see a speed increase across the board. Was hoping to hear what kind of impact my heavy fragmentation should cause.  

  • 0

free isn't always great. i have been using raxco perfectdisk for over 10 years. it is a set it and forget it (for the most part) product. it even has functionality for SSDs

letting your drive get into double digit fragmentation increases search and workload considerably for your spinning drives.

  • 0

This is why I always just use the auto defrag/optimize in Windows, have not needed to actually defrag an HDD in a few years, SSD is also set to auto optimize 

 

There's no good reason to not use the built in tools in Windows  these days 

  • Like 2
  • 0
  On 15/10/2015 at 15:18, sjms said:

free isn't always great. i have been using raxco perfectdisk for over 10 years. it is a set it and forget it (for the most part) product. it even has functionality for SSDs

letting your drive get into double digit fragmentation increases search and workload considerably for your spinning drives.

Disk Optimizer (Windows 10) *is* the current version of Condusiv's Diskeeper - literally, there is no difference other than minor GUI differences.

Like Diskeeper (which had the feature first) and Raxco PerfectDisk, it is "launch and leave" and/or schedulable.  Like both, it also supports SSDs and TRIM (and for the same reasons - SSDs are more commonplace).  Unless you need a particular proprietary feature in either PerfectDisk OR Condusiv Diskeeper, Disk Optimizer is plenty good enough for typical use.  (That wasn't exactly fun for Condusiv to hear (from me) for several reasons - I have been a Condusiv (and Diskeeper Corporation) partner since 1998 - going back to when Diskeeper added support for FAT32 - in other words, their first branching out from Windows NT; while Diskeeper is actually cheaper to license for individuals and SMBs compared to PerfectDisk, being branded "irrelevant" compared to a free product that your own company wrote DOES sting -  Condusiv WROTE the manual Disk Defragmenter that every NT-based OS has included - and wrote Disk Optimizer as well - which includes automatic multipasss defragmentation as well; the only time I recommend Diskeeper is for OSes older than 10.

  • 0

how would your disk get so fragmented?  Windows has had auto defrag for YEARS..  Are you still using xp?  There should be no possible reason for fragmentation to ever get so high unless you turned off auto??

As others have said there has been no reason for 3rd party defrag for years either.  If you really want to see jump in performance just move to SSD.

  • 0

do you leave your computer on, or is it only on when you use it? If it is only on when actively in use, then maybe windows never has an idle period long enough to slot in a defrag, or it ironically goes so slow to preserve disk performance that it just can't put a dent in it.

  • 0

how big is D?  Downloading files would not do such a fragmentation..  How much space do you have free on D.. You need free space to be able to defrag efficiently

  • 0

2tb with tons of free space which varies depending on if I downloaded a 300gb 4k video etc lol. I got it defragged down to only 10% fragmentation but I did a performance test with samsung magician and it's performing worse. Which is surprising as another drive I defragged improved after defragmentation. 

  • 0
  On 20/10/2015 at 04:25, sammy2 said:

It's at 500 plus gb right now but I have a ton of movies to delete. If 10 is high then the 60% it was a few days ago was disastrous. That's what I wanted to find out how bad it was to be heavily fragmented. 

Large files don't always need to be fully defragmented, though any specific file being too fragmented is a problem if you're accessing it.

Your filesystem and system files getting badly fragmented are usually more serious.

  On 15/10/2015 at 15:18, sjms said:

free isn't always great. i have been using raxco perfectdisk for over 10 years. it is a set it and forget it (for the most part) product. it even has functionality for SSDs

letting your drive get into double digit fragmentation increases search and workload considerably for your spinning drives.

Auslogics latest defraggers are great, free or pro.  Perfectdisk has a tendency to take far longer than it should, though the end result is usually pretty damn good I'd go for Auslogics stuff anyday.

Edited by randomevent
  • 0

enough can not be said about SSD...  It is the prob the best thing you can do for a performance..  Prices are good, you can get a 128GB for under $70 for sure..  This is normally more than enough for a OS/Working drive and then you just use your older spindle drives for storage.  Once you go ssd you will never want to use old school spindle drives ever again..

What was the benchmark you are seeing on the drive?  Is it inline with what it is suppose to be for that drive? Did you get your frag down to normal numbers.. As someone mentioned when defrags run they quite often can skip larger files unless you specific say to do them..   Contig is a tool from MS to take a deeper look into your fragmentation then the gui tool always and can be used to defrag specific large files, etc.  Or free space.

https://technet.microsoft.com/en-us/library/bb897428.aspx

  • 0

If they're writing 40+ gigs of data every day an SSD might not be a great way to go...they are fantastic but they do have their limits.

  On 22/10/2015 at 12:52, BudMan said:

As someone mentioned when defrags run they quite often can skip larger files unless you specific say to do them..

I then installed the program in question and realized that rule was disabled by default.  (Still might apply in some modes, but I didn't check.)

  • 0

40GB a day is nothing for modern SSD..

Take a read http://techreport.com/review/27436/the-ssd-endurance-experiment-two-freaking-petabytes/4

The results of our experiment do, however, point to some more general conclusions about SSDs as a whole. Although only two drives made it to 2PB, all six wrote hundreds of terabytes without issue, vastly exceeding their official endurance specifications. More importantly, the drives all survived far more writes than most users are likely to generate. Typical consumers shouldn't worry about exceeding the endurance of modern SSDs.

So Warranty on 850 pro 128GB ssd is listed as 10 years or 150 TBW.. At 40GB a day... that is

150,000,000,000,000 / 40,000,000,000 = 3750 days.. And from the article listed above all the drives tested seem to live well past those numbers...

The evo model is listed at 75TBW or 5 years.. I don't think that is an issue either...

Home users would have to be worried about, what are the odds that you would be using that drive for anywhere near that length of time..  When they keep coming out with larger, faster, cheaper drives.. Do you really think you will be using the drive you buy today in 10 some years?  And really who is going to write 40GB a day every single day??

The oldest spindle drive I have still in operation is 6+ years old..  Its a tiny little 650GB drive... I really have no use for such a small slow drive with todays standards, I use it as a back up disk in my overall DR plan..  Its not the only backup of my files, just one of many..  I keep an eye on it with smart and it when I get another drive it will be retired and replaced with a my next smallest slowest drive 1TB that is only 3 years old, etc.. 

Edited by BudMan
  • 0
  On 22/10/2015 at 13:16, BudMan said:

The results of our experiment do, however, point to some more general conclusions about SSDs as a whole. Although only two drives made it to 2PB, all six wrote hundreds of terabytes without issue, vastly exceeding their official endurance specifications. More importantly, the drives all survived far more writes than most users are likely to generate. Typical consumers shouldn't worry about exceeding the endurance of modern SSDs.

Different drive firmwares still react differently based on how much activity they've had recently.

(I do have a fast older SSD that will kick down to ~40MB/sec writes if you've written too much to it, though that's an unusual case.)

Plus, SSDs are still comparatively expensive.  Far cheaper than they used to be certainly, but they're talking about 300gb video files...

I honestly don't know how good a drive you'd even need for that.

  • 0

Not sure where he is getting 300GB movies, nor what kind of connection they would have they could download that in a DAY?  Do they have Gig fiber or something?

Even their reference to 40GB was more than 1 movie, from my take. ###### in my library that would be 40+ movies..

As to expense of ssd, while it is not as low as your typical 3TB off the shelf home use drive.. When you compare the speed and endurance of the drive they are very reasonable price point if you ask me.. And it only goes down every day..  At somepoint in the not so distant future I could see the old spindle drive being useless for anything other than archival storage media.  Stuff that is not accessed very often, and not written too all that often as well.  With most likely a ssd as cache drive between..

If I was working with 100's GB per day of file moving I sure and the hell would not be using some older spindle single disk.. It would be an 0 array for sure and most, and most likely SSD to boot.. You can get the 500GB m.2 for like 175.. So for a 2TB array your looking at what $700.. Seems very reasonable for the performance you would see... 

I would be very curious to the specs of the hardware the OP is working with and actual what they are doing that they move about such size movies - are they in the editing biz?  And working with single 2TB disks that are frag to all get out??  Come on...

 

  • 0

I had an issue with an External HD getting fragmented this bad (it was my storage for MKV files for my Plex server) since Plex kept locking the files Windows would never auto-defrag it like I had it set to.

Just some relevant information that may help someone in the future.

This topic is now closed to further replies.
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Posts

    • LG gram Book 15U50T: Is this lightweight laptop the right upgrade for you? by Paul Hill If you’re in the UK looking for a new mid-range laptop that won’t feel underpowered, check out the LG gram Book 15U50T now because it’s at its all-time lowest price on Amazon UK thanks to a 14% discount from its £699.99 RRP. You can get it now for just £599.99 (Buying link at the end). At this price, the laptop definitely makes this mid-range option much more appealing, it’s also pretty new having only come out in January 2025, so you’re definitely getting more value for your money. The delivery is free and will take a few days to arrive unless you take advantage of a Prime member trial and get it next-day in time for Father’s Day. LG gram Book 15U50T: Key features and who it's for The LG gram Book 15U50T features a 15.6-inch Full-HD (1920x1080) anti-glare IPS display, making it ideal for use in well-lit areas as you won’t see yourself staring back. It’s powered by an Intel Core i5 processor (1334U), 16GB of RAM, and has a very fast 512GB NVMe Gen4 SSD. In my opinion, the storage might be a bit tight for some users; however, the device comes with two M.2 slots if you want to upgrade the storage. The LG gram Book 15U50T is ideal for students or professionals who need a device to carry with them out and about. It has an ultra-lightweight design and weighs just 1.65kg - that’s not too far off a similarly sized MacBook Air, but for a fraction of the cost. In terms of ports, there is an HDMI port, two USB-A ports, and two USB-C ports. There's also a 3.5mm headphone jack if you need to plug in headphones. Other noteworthy details about this laptop include that it's running Windows 11 Home with Copilot integration, it has a HD webcam with a privacy shutter, it uses Dolby Atmos audio for immersive sound, and it has a unique feature called gram Link for multi-device (including Android and iOS) connectivity. Should you buy it? If you are a student or a professional that won’t be doing heavy gaming, or using other super intensive applications, this laptop is a solid pick. It’s lightweight - so easy to carry around, it has an anti-reflective screen - so good in well-lit environments; and it features upgradeable storage slots if 512GB is not enough space. On the downside, this laptop has a mid-range processor that could limit your ability to use high-end professional tools. Another thing I’m not really a fan of here is how opaque LG has been with the battery life. As a portable laptop, you’re obviously going to want to take it on the go where you don’t have a charger handy, but all LG says about the battery is that it has a capacity of 51Wh. According to some online sources, variants of this laptop manage about 7 to 10 hours, so if you need a super long battery life, you might be better off with something like a MacBook Air. So should you buy it? If you’re not going to be doing anything super intensive, but can’t stand underpowered and slow budget laptops then this could be the ideal laptop for you. The £100 discount makes it even more appealing! LG gram Book 15U50T: £599.99 (Amazon UK) / RRP £699.99 This Amazon deal is U.K. specific, and not available in other regions unless specified. If you don't like it or want to look at more options, check out the Amazon UK deals page here. Get Prime, Prime Video, Music Unlimited, Audible or Kindle Unlimited, free for the first 30 days As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.
    • Totally different vehicles. Uber has partnered with Waymo for level 5 autonomous vehicles. Waymo has completed 10 million trips and to date, there have been 696 accidents in 4 years and of those 16 of them appear to have been due to an error by the car. In total airbags have only been deployed 38 times. The technology should always be under review and continued to be improved on, but this is a totally different animal to Tesla FSD PS. no I don't work for them etc. I am an analyst for a market intelligence firm and we have a lot of interest from clients looking at the connected car space for advertising etc. so I have studied them
    • But it's not full self driving it's level 2 autonomy. Audi, BMW and Mercedes all have level 3 and make far less noise about it
    • Edge for Business gets secure password deployment for organizations by Paul Hill Microsoft Edge for Business now offers organizations secure password deployments as a generally available feature, the Redmond giant said. Instead of users sharing passwords on sticky notes or via email to access certain websites or tools, admins can deploy encrypted shared passwords to specific users within their organization. When a user receives a password, it is stored in their Edge password manager and can be used to log into websites seamlessly using autofill. Microsoft has made this enterprise-grade solution available to customers at no additional cost. How it works and the user experience Administrators have to manage the feature via the Microsoft Edge management service within the Microsoft 365 admin center. From there, they can add, update, and revoke credentials for specific user groups through configuration policies. Once an admin has set it up and shared passwords with users, the users will see the passwords in their Edge password manager and can be used with autofill on corresponding websites. The passwords are tied to work profiles in Edge on managed Windows devices to limit their misuse. Further boosting security, the shared passwords cannot actually be viewed, edited, or deleted (unless the website allows), or exported from the password manager. This is a good addition for security because if an unauthorized user gains physical access to the computer, they cannot learn what the password is. Administrators reading this do need to be aware of an important caveat related to developer tools. A motivated user who wants to reveal the passwords can do so by digging into the developer tools, for this reason, you should consider restricting access to the developer tools by configuring the DeveloperToolsAvailability policy. The underlying security and encryption Microsoft’s new secure passwords feature has been built using the Information Protection SDK. The passwords are encrypted and the encryption is tied to Entra identities which lets organizations enforce them without manual key management. The decryption of the passwords takes place at runtime using the same SDK, validating the user’s identity. Availability and getting started Secure password deployment is available through the Edge management service in the Microsoft 365 admin center. Once in the admin center, you should choose an existing configuration policy or create a new one. Inside the policy, go to the Customization Settings tab and then to the Secure password deployment page. To use this feature you must have a Microsoft 365 Business Premium, E3, or E5 subscription. The feature also requires the Edge admin or Global admin role. Source: Microsoft
    • Is it though?  I built a new rig a few months ago and it was literally impossible to get one without RGB, but within 10 minutes of setting it up, I turned all that crap off.  It was REALLY distracting, and who needs additional heat INSIDE a PC? It's popular on YouTube for sure, it's neat looking and whatnot, but it's about as practical as a coffee cup with a hole in it. As for the price, a non-enthusiast would just see something priced way above what they can get from a retailer brand new...
  • Recent Achievements

    • Week One Done
      somar86 earned a badge
      Week One Done
    • One Month Later
      somar86 earned a badge
      One Month Later
    • Apprentice
      Adrian Williams went up a rank
      Apprentice
    • Reacting Well
      BashOrgRu earned a badge
      Reacting Well
    • Collaborator
      CHUNWEI earned a badge
      Collaborator
  • Popular Contributors

    1. 1
      +primortal
      505
    2. 2
      ATLien_0
      260
    3. 3
      +Edouard
      188
    4. 4
      +FloatingFatMan
      175
    5. 5
      snowy owl
      132
  • Tell a friend

    Love Neowin? Tell a friend!