• 0

Issues Validating XML with DTD


Question

Hey guys.  So I've been taking an XML class but I am having trouble getting this file to validate correctly.  Keep getting that it is not well-formed.  Not sure where I am going wrong and can't find a solid answer, not to mention the teacher doesn't seem to know much about what she is teaching.

This is the error I get from xmlvalidation.com:

 

 

Errors in file photos.dtd: 

errorjump.png 13: 3 The markup declarations contained or pointed to by the document type declaration must be well-formed.

 

And when I use Notepad++ XML Tools validation I get:

XML Parsing error at line 31:

Start tag expected, '<' not found

 

Here is the XML:

 

<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8" standalone="no" ?>
<!--
   New Perspectives on XML
   Tutorial 2
   Case Problem 1

   Catalog of photos from the Our Lady of Bergen Historical Society
   Author: <removed>
   Date:   1/28/2016

   Filename:         photos.xml
   Supporting file:  photos.dtd
-->
<!DOCTYPE catalog SYSTEM "photos.dtd">
 
<catalog type="photos">

   <photo cid="c1748" donatedBy="John Borelli">
      <name metadata="tunis cooper property museum">Tunis R. Cooper property</name>
      <description>
      <![CDATA[ 
         This photo was taken by John Borelli's great-grandfather. It is believed to have been taken around 1830.
         David Demarest originally purchased the site of the chair factory in 1663. This site was under the ownership 
         of the Demarest family until 1758.  The property is listed in the National and New Jersey Registers of Historic Places.
      ]]>
      </description>
      <date>1830 circa</date>
      <images>
         <img src="1748a.jpg" />
         <img src="1748b.jpg" />
      </images>
   </photo>

   <photo cid="c1749" donatedBy="John Borelli">
      <name metadata="tunis cooper property museum">Tunis R. Cooper property</name>
      <description>
      <![CDATA[ 
         A more recent picture of the property taken by the Borelli family.  The property is listed in the 
         National and New Jersey Registers of Historic Places.
      ]]>
      </description>
      <date>1950 circa</date>
      <images>
         <img src="1749a.jpg" />
      </images>
   </photo>

   <photo cid="c1411" donatedBy="Saint Johns Catholic Church">
      <name metadata="saint johns catholic church">Saint Johns Church</name>
      <description>
      <![CDATA[ 
         A more recent picture of the property taken by the Borelli family.  The property is listed in the 
         National and New Jersey Registers of Historic Places.
      ]]>
      </description>      
      <date>1921</date>
   </photo>

   <photo cid="c2003" donatedBy="Linda Choo">
      <name metadata="bergenfield elementary school">Bergenfield School</name>
      <description>
      <![CDATA[ 
         The No. 5 Public School, a.k.a. Bergenfield School
      ]]>
      </description>
      <date>1920 circa</date>
      <images>
         <img src="2003a.jpg" />
         <img src="2003b.jpg" />
      </images>
   </photo>

   <photo cid="c2078" donatedBy="Maria Giodelli">
      <name metadata="coopers pond water">Coopers Pond</name>
      <description>
      <![CDATA[ 
         A favorite spot where we used to go hang out as kids.  The picture shows my brothers Robert and Michael.
      ]]>
      </description>
      <date>May 4, 1941</date>
      <images>
         <img src="2078a.jpg" />
      </images>
   </photo>

   <photo cid="c2079" donatedBy="Linda Uffington">
      <name metadata="watch timekeeping pocket railway">Pocket Watch</name>
      <description>
      <![CDATA[ 
         A more recent picture of the property taken by the Borelli family.  The property is listed in the 
         National and New Jersey Registers of Historic Places.
      ]]>
      </description>
      <date>1870 circa</date>
      <images>
         <img src="2079a.jpg" />
         <img src="2079b.jpg" />
      </images>
   </photo>

   <photo cid="c3233">
      <name metadata="hotel">Bergenfield Hotel</name>
      <description>
      <![CDATA[ 
         The Knollfield Hotel was known as the Bergenfield Hotel.  The property is listed in the 
         National and New Jersey Registers of Historic Places.
      ]]>
      </description>
      <date>circa 1920</date>
   </photo>

   <photo cid="c3433">
      <name metadata="sweeney coal fuel">Sweeney Coal</name>
      <description>
      <![CDATA[ 
         Sweeny Fuel Company located near New Bridge Road and railroad tracks.
      ]]>
      </description>
      <date>1920</date>
      <images>
         <img src="3433a.jpg" />
         <img src="3433b.jpg" />
         <img src="3433c.jpg" />
      </images>
   </photo>

</catalog>

 

And the DTD file:

 

<!--
   New Perspectives on XML
   Tutorial 2
   Case Problem 1

   Catalog of photos from the Our Lady of Bergen Historical Society
   Author: <removed>
   Date:   1/28/2016

   Filename:         photos.dtd
   Supporting File:  photos.xml
-->
<!DOCTYPE catalog [
    <!ELEMENT catalog (photo+)>
    <!ATTLIST type catalog NMTOKEN #REQUIRED>

    <!ELEMENT photo (name, description, date, images?)>
    <!ATTLIST cid photo ID #REQUIRED>
    <!ATTLIST donatedBy photo CDATA #IMPLIED>

    <!ELEMENT name (#PCDATA)>
    <!ATTLIST metadata name NMTOKENS #REQUIRED>

    <!ELEMENT description (#PCDATA)>
    <!ELEMENT date (#PCDATA)>

    <!ELEMENT images (img+)>
    <!ELEMENT img (EMPTY)>
    <!ATTLIST src img CDATA #REQUIRED>
    ]>

Edited by Perfect72
Link to comment
https://www.neowin.net/forum/topic/1287978-issues-validating-xml-with-dtd/
Share on other sites

3 answers to this question

Recommended Posts

  • 0
<!--
   New Perspectives on XML
   Tutorial 2
   Case Problem 1
   Catalog of photos from the Our Lady of Bergen Historical Society
   Author: <removed>
   Date:   1/28/2016
   Filename:         photos.dtd
   Supporting File:  photos.xml
-->
<!DOCTYPE catalog [
    <!ELEMENT catalog (photo+)>
    <!ATTLIST type catalog NMTOKEN #REQUIRED>
    <!ELEMENT photo (name, description, date, images?)>
    <!ATTLIST cid photo ID #REQUIRED>
    <!ATTLIST donatedBy photo CDATA #IMPLIED>
    <!ELEMENT name (#PCDATA)>
    <!ATTLIST metadata name NMTOKENS #REQUIRED>
    <!ELEMENT description (#PCDATA)>
    <!ELEMENT date (#PCDATA)>
    <!ELEMENT images (img+)>
    <!ELEMENT img (EMPTY)>
    <!ATTLIST src img CDATA #REQUIRED>
]>

Should be:

<!--
   New Perspectives on XML
   Tutorial 2
   Case Problem 1
   Catalog of photos from the Our Lady of Bergen Historical Society
   Author: <removed>
   Date:   1/28/2016
   Filename:         photos.dtd
   Supporting File:  photos.xml
-->
<!ELEMENT catalog (photo+)>
<!ATTLIST type catalog NMTOKEN #REQUIRED>
<!ELEMENT photo (name, description, date, images?)>
<!ATTLIST cid photo ID #REQUIRED>
<!ATTLIST donatedBy photo CDATA #IMPLIED>
<!ELEMENT name (#PCDATA)>
<!ATTLIST metadata name NMTOKENS #REQUIRED>
<!ELEMENT description (#PCDATA)>
<!ELEMENT date (#PCDATA)>
<!ELEMENT images (img+)>
<!ELEMENT img (EMPTY)>
<!ATTLIST src img CDATA #REQUIRED>

The doctype is only needed when you put the dtd inline in the xml file.

Source: http://stackoverflow.com/questions/5455394/problem-with-external-referenced-dtd-in-xml

 

Also you're missing quite a few attribute declarations :rofl:

  • 0

Woops, I forgot I did end up removing that after figuring it out, but still keep getting errors. Is it the missing declarations?  I am completely new to XML and like I said, my teacher isn't much help besides just reading passages from the book which I'm not very good at learning with.

  • 0
  On 06/02/2016 at 17:02, Perfect72 said:

Woops, I forgot I did end up removing that after figuring it out, but still keep getting errors. Is it the missing declarations?  I am completely new to XML and like I said, my teacher isn't much help besides just reading passages from the book which I'm not very good at learning with.

Expand  

Your teacher isn't much help teaching you something as defunct as DTD.  Can I ask why you aren't learning XSD instead?

This topic is now closed to further replies.
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Posts

    • Sounds like a tool is needed to backup drivers from Win Update for older devices. Anyone got a rough idea besides doing a manual backup of driverstore?
    • Stylish Samsung Galaxy S25 Edge gets 20% discount sending it to lowest price by Paul Hill If you’re in the market for a powerful, stylish phone, then you may be interested in the Galaxy S25 Edge, which is now reduced to $969.99, down 20% from the $1,219.99 list price. This is the lowest price that the device has been at on Amazon. You can get the device at this price if you go for the Titanium Icyblue or Titanium Silver editions. These models are the top-end S25 Edge variants with 512GB of storage. While this Samsung device may be about as thick as a pencil, it’s constructed from titanium and uses Corning Gorilla Glass Ceramic 2 on the display. This should ensure durability, despite its thin design. The thickness of this phone is just 5.8mm, and it weighs 163g. Camera capabilities and AI enhancements The Galaxy S25 Edge's camera system is impressive. It has a 200MP main camera with optical image stabilization and a 2x optical quality zoom. This feature magnifies the image using optical mechanisms in the camera lens so that the zoomed image retains its original clarity, detail, and resolution of the scene. On the back, there is also a 12MP ultrawide camera with autofocus and on the front, there’s a 12MP camera. Like many phones coming out now, there are AI-powered camera features such as Night Video, Best Face for group shots, Portrait Selfie, and Gallery Search by description. Notably, there is no dedicated telephoto lens like in the S25+ and S25 Ultra. This is a tradeoff that the company decided to make to achieve its ultrathin design. Telephoto lenses are camera lenses that are designed to make distant objects appear closer and larger in your photos and videos. The absence of this telephoto lens may be a deal breaker for those looking to use this camera for professional shots; otherwise, it’s still very impressive, especially with that 200MP main camera. Performance, display, and integrated AI features The S25 Edge is powered by the Snapdragon 8 Elite chipset, specifically the 3-nanometer Qualcomm SM8750-AB. It has an octa-core CPU (2x4.47 GHz Oryon V Phoenix L + 6x3.53 GHz Oryon V2 Phoenix M) and an Adreno 830 GPU. This model's display is a 6.7-inch QHD+ Dynamic AMOLED 2X with a 120Hz adaptive refresh rate and high brightness. This device has plenty of other AI features too, outside of the camera, including Cross App Action, Audio Eraser for videos, Now Brief/Now Bar for personalized information, and of course, Google Gemini. With 12GB of RAM, the specs on this phone are really very good. It should be capable of doing most tasks you throw at it, including gaming. You may wonder if it will handle games well, given that the thin design means it could overheat. Samsung has already thought about this and included a reconfigured vapor chamber that helps to keep the phone cool. Battery life and charging speed: The main compromise Aside from the removal of the telephoto lens, this phone also has a drawback in terms of battery life. Its 3,900 mAh battery capacity means it’s smaller than many other devices, even compared to budget phones. Another disappointing aspect is the charging, where the wired charging speed is limited to 25W—that’s lower than what you find on very affordable Xiaomi POCO devices. This battery limitation might make this device a bad choice if you’re away from a charger for long periods. One affordable way to mitigate this downside is by carrying a portable charger, but still, it’s ironic that you buy a thin phone to be lighter and then end up carrying a brick-sized charger around with you. You could also just bring your charger and plug it into an outlet. Is the Galaxy S25 Edge the smart buy for you? If you’re someone who wants a sleek, lightweight phone that has a premium build and can easily slice through tasks you throw at it, then the Galaxy S25 Edge is very likely for you. It’s also great for anyone looking for a standout camera that doesn’t need a telephoto lens. However, if you need a device with all-day battery life because you’re going camping or to the middle of nowhere, then you could probably find a better fit with a longer battery life. If this device is for you, check out the links below. Samsung Galaxy S25 Edge (Titanium Icyblue): $969.99 (Amazon US) / MSRP $1,219.99 Samsung Galaxy S25 Edge (Titanium Silver): $969.99 (Amazon US) / MSRP $1,219.99 This Amazon deal is US-specific and not available in other regions unless specified. If you don't like it or want to look at more options, check out the Amazon US deals page here. Get Prime (SNAP), Prime Video, Audible Plus or Kindle / Music Unlimited. Free for 30 days. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
    • I got too many apps I use actively. Theres been too often I completely blank on the name of the application and had to manually look through the list for it. Now I'm using Start11 and got my apps sorted in the Start menu by categories so that if I'm looking for Krita i can find it under "Art editors". If MS are going to change it, they should consider making automated categories. Seen some Linux distros do that. But if they do, theres probably gonna be a lot of wrongly categorized apps though, unfortunately.
  • Recent Achievements

    • emptyother earned a badge
      First Post
    • Crunchy6 earned a badge
      Week One Done
    • KynanSEIT earned a badge
      One Month Later
    • gowtham07 earned a badge
      One Month Later
    • lethalman went up a rank
      Collaborator
  • Popular Contributors

    1. 1
      +primortal
      675
    2. 2
      ATLien_0
      277
    3. 3
      Michael Scrip
      220
    4. 4
      +FloatingFatMan
      168
    5. 5
      Steven P.
      161
  • Tell a friend

    Love Neowin? Tell a friend!