Even With Telemetry Disabled, Windows 10 Talks To Dozens of Microsoft Servers


Recommended Posts

<snipped>

 

 

Quote

 

Like many of you, I am concerned about the telemetry, spying and other surveillance features, known or unknown, of Windows 10. It has concerned me enough to push me to Linux Mint as my main operating system. Even so, I wanted to better understand Windows 10, but internet search results for a decent windows 10 traffic analysis leave a lot to be desired. As such, I decided to do my own investigating on what, exactly, Windows 10 is doing traffic-wise, and post the results. For this analysis, I wanted to simply analyse the network traffic of Windows 10 on a clean install, and just let it sit and run without using it.

What I have done for this analysis:

  1. I have installed DD-WRT on a router connected to the internet and configured remote logging to the Linux Mint laptop in #2.
  2. I have installed Linux Mint on a laptop, and setup rsyslog to accept remote logging from the DD-WRT router.
  3. I have installed Virtualbox on the Linux Mint laptop, and installed Windows 10 Enterprise on Virtualbox. I have chosen the customized installation option where I disabled three pages of tracking options.
  4. I have configured the DD-WRT router to drop and log all connection attempts via iptables through the DD-WRT router by Windows 10 Enterprise.
  5. Aside from installing Windows 10 Enterprise, and verifying the internet connection through ipconfig and ping yahoo.com, I have not used the Windows 10 installation at all (the basis for the first part of this analysis)
  6. Let Windows 10 Enterprise run overnight for about 8 hours (while I slept).
  7. I use perl to parse the data out of syslog files and insert said data into a Mysql database.
  8. I use perl to obtain route data from whois.radb.net, as well as nslookup PTR data, and insert that into the Mysql database.
  9. Lastly, I query and format the data for analyzing.

 

 

 

Read the rest: https://voat.co/v/technology/comments/83574

  • Like 2
15 hours ago, SpeedyTheSnail said:

<snipped>

 

Now back to my 2 hour repair attempt of MS Office since I can't uninstall anything or repair on Windows 7 right now.... all while in the middle of a project. 

 

Would the Office 2013/2016/O365 repair / removal tool be of assistance:

https://support.office.com/en-us/article/Uninstall-Office-2013-Office-2016-or-Office-365-from-a-Windows-computer-9dd49b83-264a-477a-8fcc-2fdf5dbf61d8

 

If Office 2010 Removal Fixit

https://support.office.com/en-us/article/Uninstall-or-remove-Office-2010-90635a1d-aec8-4653-b358-67e1b766fc4d

 

 

1 hour ago, SpeedyTheSnail said:

MS Fanboys will be here shortly to defend their beloved Windows 10, as they can never be wrong even when they are!

 

Now back to my 2 hour repair attempt of MS Office since I can't uninstall anything or repair on Windows 7 right now.... all while in the middle of a project. 

What is to defend? Anyone who has read the EULA knows the OS talks to MS. OS X talks to Apple too. 

1 hour ago, Eternal Tempest said:

Tried all of them, eventually my solution was this: 

http://mslivesupport.com/error/office-2016/error-code-0-1018-0-office-2016-how-to-fix-error/

and

http://superuser.com/questions/944057/office-2016-installation-halts-with-message-another-installation-is-in-progress

Which involved deleting some files, folders, and settings as well as removing schedules.

 

Either MS Visio or Intuit Quickbooks took a 2 hour assignment and turned it into a 6 hour nightmare (I had to use Visio to make a system diagram, but Visio was corrupted and when I repaired it, it deleted Office FML). I've had nothing but problems lately on that, but thank you and back on topic I go!

I like how he calls the post "Windows 10 telemetry network traffic analysis" and then does absolutely zero analysis of "telemetry" data. 

 

He did a fresh install of Windows 10 Enterprise, didn't disable any network-based apps (Windows Update, NTP Syncing, News, MS Money, Store, Weather, XBOX, Bing Popular Feed) and is then surprised when connection requests are made. Not only that, but rather than actually monitoring what data is sent, he has his router blocking connections silently. The OS/Apps know they're connected to a network, but wouldn't know why their connections are failing so a lot of them will periodically retry their requests, potentially to multiple servers if the app assumes it's the remote server that is down rather than him blocking the connection. 

 

I'm not saying there isn't additional telemetry collection in Windows 10, there might be, but this data shows nothing useful. 
 

  • Like 3

I thought this was cleared up by now?!?

YES, MS collects data from you, about your system, to make sure everything keeps running smoothly, they are not stealing your personal data.

Why do people struggle so much with this? Every OS does this by now

  • Like 2

The fact of the matter is that Microsoft has decided to only grant enterprise customers the privilege to turn off telemetry completely due to privacy / data protection concerns those customers have  voiced.

A friend of a friend of a friend of mine works at MS in the document shredder department and he says that everything he's read/viewed before shredding hasn't contained any personal info, soooo he doesn't think they (MS) are spying.   There you go, proof from an MS employee himself!  :p

 

Now we can all sleep at night, our porn "personal entertainment" data is safe!   :shifty:

  • Like 3

I am hoping that once Satya gets replaced, we will see these sneaky tactics exonerated. I will once again fall in love with Microsoft, as I did in the late 80's. 

  • Like 2

I'd ask that anyone born in the last 20 years, realize that, those of us who started with Windows 1.0 - 3.11 to consider we have seen most of microsofts developments good and bad. So don't be too hard on us older fellas who don't like seeing where this is going (Windows in the bigger picture).

  • Like 3
5 minutes ago, chrisj1968 said:

I'd ask that anyone born in the last 20 years, realize that, those of us who started with Windows 1.0 - 3.11 to consider we have seen most of microsofts developments good and bad. So don't be too hard on us older fellas who don't like seeing where this is going (Windows in the bigger picture).

Correct. In the grand scheme of things, I'm not a fan of their game plan. 

11 minutes ago, JHBrown said:

I am hoping that once Satya gets replaced, we will see these sneaky tactics exonerated. I will once again fall in love with Microsoft, as I did in the late 80's. 

Yep I still have faith that once Microsoft decides to make desktop users a high priority again we will get a solid OS with Windows 10.1 or 10.2 or whatever, possibly with things like Aero Glass being restored, the ability to customize vertical spacing between rows on jumplists to be EFFICIENT and COMPACT for us mouse users, and also the ability to again customize how many items you can pin -- where the crippled XAML jumplists are limited to 11 items now with zero customization. You can't even drag to reorder jumplist items anymore. 

 

I have faith that in a couple years or so, desktop users will be catered to once again and Microsoft will be content to make iOS and Android programs in terms of their mobile sandbox instead of a "one size fits all" OS. 

  • Like 3
3 hours ago, Raze said:

A friend of a friend of a friend of mine works at MS in the document shredder department and he says that everything he's read/viewed before shredding hasn't contained any personal info, soooo he doesn't think they (MS) are spying.   There you go, proof from an MS employee himself!  :p

 

Now we can all sleep at night, our porn "personal entertainment" data is safe!   :shifty:

Was this meant to be a joke? A friend of a friend of a friend? Why would people's personal info ever be on physical paper even if Microsoft was straight up spying on us?

2 minutes ago, DeusProto said:

Yep I still have faith that once Microsoft decides to make desktop users a high priority again we will get a solid OS with Windows 10.1 or 10.2 or whatever, possibly with things like Aero Glass being restored, the ability to customize vertical spacing between rows on jumplists to be EFFICIENT and COMPACT for us mouse users, and also the ability to again customize how many items you can pin -- where the crippled XAML jumplists are limited to 11 items now with zero customization. You can't even drag to reorder jumplist items anymore. 

 

I have faith that in a couple years or so, desktop users will be catered to once again and Microsoft will be content to make iOS and Android programs in terms of their mobile sandbox instead of a "one size fits all" OS. 

My thoughts also. As long as the great Bill Gates is alive and kicking, I will be a fan even with these bone headed decisions. They've slacked off in the one department that made them great, and have chosen to give us Beta Shareware for an operating system. Microsoft better get it together!

  • Like 2
11 minutes ago, oldtimefighter said:

Was this meant to be a joke? A friend of a friend of a friend? Why would people's personal info ever be on physical paper even if Microsoft was straight up spying on us?

You've got to be kidding right?   lol    :no:

Obviously Microsoft has a problem with rampant spying in windows 10, why else would there be a slew of 3rd party programs out there that tries to disable the spying?

 

Is everyone one so paranoid that they devote weeks and months creating a program for no reason? Do thousands of people install and run these programs for no reason?

 

Something is obviously going on and its nothing good.

Can the world survive without Microsoft operating systems? -yes.

 

People would flock to alternatives. however, gaming will take a hit for a long while since MS owns the largest gaming PC platform. But as history has proven time and again that, people/companies can reach the top after a time but can lose their poise and creativity because entities like MS tend to then focus on bottom line than a great product when they hit the top. If MS were to fail, the world would NOT end rather, a new player would take the reigns and be the flavor until they lose it.

55 minutes ago, chrisj1968 said:

Can the world survive without Microsoft operating systems? -yes.

 

People would flock to alternatives. however, gaming will take a hit for a long while since MS owns the largest gaming PC platform. But as history has proven time and again that, people/companies can reach the top after a time but can lose their poise and creativity because entities like MS tend to then focus on bottom line than a great product when they hit the top. If MS were to fail, the world would NOT end rather, a new player would take the reigns and be the flavor until they lose it.

I agree. I made a post similar to that last week. Microsoft has gamers by the throats with Direct X. Microsoft could not pull off this spying nonsense, and half-baked operating system if we had some kind of competition. Their monopoly over the operating system market is the only thing holding them together. We need competition desperately! Gamers would leave in droves if Linux had the proper gaming support. 

13 minutes ago, JHBrown said:

I agree. I made a post similar to that last week. Microsoft has gamers by throats with Direct X. Microsoft could not pull off this spying nonsense, and half-baked operating system if we had some kind of competition. Their monopoly over the operating system market is the only thing holding them together. We need competition desperately! Gamers would leave in droves if Linux had the proper gaming support. 

They tell you what they collect, you agreed to it in the EULA, yet you call it spying. It isn't spying if they tell you about it. If they are collecting more than that, lets back it up instead of making wild claims.

11 hours ago, adrynalyne said:

I have asked for this proof so many times. I'm sill asking and will still not get it. 

Microsoft has an advertising ID for you in Windows by default.

 

Windows 10 EULA refers to: https://privacy.microsoft.com/en-us/privacystatement

Windows 10 may not apply to all of those statements, but if ads are displayed within Windows 10 in an official Microsoft app for example, it would make no sense not to collect a lot of what stated in their Privacy Statement within Windows 10 as there is a lot of profit to be made by doing so. The statement also states they can share this data with a trusted third party. I would actually like to know more about who those trusted third parties are.

 

But should we use the word "spying"? Maybe, maybe not.

This topic is now closed to further replies.
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Posts

    • I am not a US citizen nor a Trump fan. Respect to both left and right. But I will, for the sake of fun, predict something for my own. There will come a day when the US and China will collide like titans ( over Taiwan or anything else ). Then, on that day, some people in this comment section will realize how good an idea it was to become independent in areas like that. ( Or atleast try )
    • Microsoft Edge gets tons of security features, including AI model that can see your screen by Usama Jawad Microsoft Edge may not be the most popular browser out there, but it does receive quite frequent updates that sometimes bring surprising new features and axe others that are not as popular. Now, Microsoft has detailed some of the new security enhancements that it has introduced in Edge for Business, typically used by commercial customers. Microsoft has emphasized that security features are baked into Edge for Business and offer native integration with security and governance tools like Defender and Purview. Browser sessions are governed by default on managed devices but can also be governed through dedicated work profiles on unmanaged devices. An important aspect in this area is controlling the use of shadow AI. We have talked about this before, but it essentially restricts employees from using unsanctioned AI apps through data loss prevention (DLP) policies, with Edge redirecting them to trusted AI services like Microsoft 365 Copilot. This feature, available as a pay-as-you-go (PAYG) license, ensures that confidential data never exits AI boundaries set by your organization in Purview. Additionally, Microsoft also has strong DLP policies for contractors. Contractors leveraging a Entra ID-joined work profile provisioned by their contracting company on a device managed by their actual employer can be restricted from downloading files locally. In such scenarios, the file is saved on the contracting firm's OneDrive rather than being downloaded locally. Another useful Edge security feature disallows copying and pasting from unmanaged locations and apps. Similarly, DLP policies can be configured at a granular level to restrict screenshots or downloading of files from certain locations. In the same vein, IT admins can block the installation of extensions, hosted apps, themes and scripts, and control if users can install extensions from external locations. They can also enable the installation of specific extensions and allow users to request access to certain extensions, so that they can be managed on a case-by-case basis. Finally, Edge for Business now has an on-device AI model that uses computer vision to see what's on your screen and block potentially malicious content immediately. This does not rely on site reputation, as it simply monitors what is being displayed on your screen, which means that it is effective against malicious content that takes over your screen and employs scareware tactics. Since this is an on-device AI model, it does use your system's resources, so it's enabled by default only on devices with at least 2GB of RAM and four CPU cores. You can find more details in the Microsoft Mechanics video here.
    • Could you come up with a slightly less depressing background for Tux instead of that gray gradient? Doesn't have to be cheerful, just less of a downer...
    • Linux 7.2's first release candidate gets off to a good start by Paul Hill Credit: Larry Ewing It has been a few weeks since the release of Linux 7.1, and in that time, the Linux 7.2 merge window has been open, where developers can submit their features and patches ready for the upcoming release. That window is now shut, and the release candidate phase has begun so that new features can be tested and further fixes applied. According to the founder of Linux, Linus Torvalds, this week’s release candidate looks “reasonably normal”. Although we are super early in the release candidates, this is a good sign as it makes it more likely that an eighth release candidate will not be needed. Torvalds even mentioned that the update’s stats are only larger than they really are because there was another AMD header drop with a third of the patch just being AMD GPU register definitions, which aren’t big changes but make the code contributed look larger overall. In addition to this, he noted that just over half the patch is drivers, even when excluding the AMD register dump. The rest of the changes are spread out over architecture updates, tooling, documentation, and core kernel updates. In the next week, Torvalds says that he will be chilling out, taking the week “mostly off”. Despite this, he will be reading emails and keeping up with things, so if he is slow responding, now you know why. He said he is hoping for a calm week, but we will just have to see if the second release candidate is actually like that. We should expect seven or eight release candidates before Linux 7.2 is released, so expect it around the end of August. If you missed it a few weeks ago, be sure to check out our coverage of Linux 7.1's release.
    • Ridiculous claim that the labor cost difference of $6000 annually would increase cost per phone by $200. The employees produce 3 phones per month or what?
  • Recent Achievements

    • Dedicated
      Zeynel earned a badge
      Dedicated
    • One Month Later
      JKR earned a badge
      One Month Later
    • Dedicated
      Asgardi earned a badge
      Dedicated
    • Conversation Starter
      jessse3334 earned a badge
      Conversation Starter
    • Reacting Well
      JuvenileDelinquent earned a badge
      Reacting Well
  • Popular Contributors

    1. 1
      +primortal
      496
    2. 2
      +Edouard
      248
    3. 3
      PsYcHoKiLLa
      154
    4. 4
      Steven P.
      86
    5. 5
      macoman
      65
  • Tell a friend

    Love Neowin? Tell a friend!