• 0

Convert DVD main feature to video file without transcoding/losing quality?


Question

8 answers to this question

Recommended Posts

  • 0
  On 19/07/2016 at 02:04, Elliot B. said:

Is this possible?

 

Is it as simple as changing a file extension?

Expand  

The video on a DVD is encoded in a compressed MP2 video format.

 

Bluray uses MP4

 

Either format can be copied to a computer directly "as is" bit-for-bit without loss of quality, about 4 gigs for DVD and 20 to 40 gigs for Bluray.

 

For a DVD you can just look for the .VOB file and most media players will recognize it as a MP2.

 

To reduce the size of the video file on your disk you need to transcode the original file and it is completely absolutely impossible NOT to lose quality in that process. The reason it can work for most people is that there is a difference between actual quality loss and subjective quality loss.

 

The proper way to do this is to Re-Encode from the original video source since both DVD and Bluray are already compressed formats with a certain amount of loss in quality. But of course you don't have access to the original so the transcode process introduces a second type of quality loss that is unavoidable when you use a different compression algorithm.

 

To make it all work you have to accept your losses and make transcoding decisions that make sense for you and it becomes a subjective process. People that transcode all the time have experimented with a lot of variations and usually end up with a preferred tool chain and customized settings that work for them.

 

If you don't mind the storage hit, you can just ignore all these considerations and just keep original copies.

 

  • 0
  On 19/07/2016 at 02:04, Elliot B. said:

Is this possible?

 

Is it as simple as changing a file extension?

Expand  

Yes it's possible.

 

The .VOB file is actually an MPEG file.  I have done exactly what you are describing... changing the file extension from VOB to MPG so I could edit it with Premiere Pro.

 

But I did this from a home video DVD that someone created on their computer... not from an encrypted commercial DVD movie.  

 

And also note that contents of a DVD are spread across multiple files:

 

VTS_01_0.VOB

VTS_01_1.VOB

VTS_01_2.VOB

etc

 

All video DVDs have this file structure.  Just remember that the main feature and all the supplemental features are inside these files.   The main movie is probably contained within the first few VOB files... but you also might get parts of the other features of the DVD in some of the VOB files.

 

What exactly are you trying to do?

  • 0
  On 19/07/2016 at 02:52, Michael Scrip said:

<snip>

 

What exactly are you trying to do?

Expand  

I have 50 DVDs that I want to put away in storage.

 

I want them available on my PC.

 

I don't care about menus, extra features etc.

 

I also don't want to transcode, as it will drop the quality.

  • 0
  On 19/07/2016 at 12:38, Elliot B. said:

I have 50 DVDs that I want to put away in storage.

 

I want them available on my PC.

 

I don't care about menus, extra features etc.

 

I also don't want to transcode, as it will drop the quality.

Expand  

You just don't seem to be asking an actual question.

 

If you don't want to transcode them, then just copy them to a large hard drive, approx 2-3 gigs per movie.

 

It is impossible to reduce the storage requirement without transcoding them. The only way to make them smaller is to use a more modern video compression format such as x265/HEVC which achieves significant compression improvements over the MP4 used in Bluray and of course much better than DVD.

 

A high bitrate transcode should give you decent storage compression with the possibility of a quality loss you won't be able to notice. You should try one and see if in fact you notice it.

 

The better solution would be to transcode the Bluray versions of your 50 DVDs since huge quality loss to Bluray will still be better than DVD. An insanely compressed 30 gig Bluray down to lets say 1 gig will still look much better than a 4 gig DVD direct copy.

 

  • Like 2
  • 0

I would suggest you check out make mkv.. It will grab what you want from your dvd or bluray and put it in mkv container no transcoding, no loss of quality

 

http://www.makemkv.com/

 

Its FREE while in beta, its been in beta for quite some time ;)  The current version just expires and you grab a new version.

 

This is very simple way to grab the data you want off your optical disk..

  • Like 2
  • 0
  On 19/07/2016 at 12:38, Elliot B. said:

I have 50 DVDs that I want to put away in storage.

 

I want them available on my PC.

 

I don't care about menus, extra features etc.

 

I also don't want to transcode, as it will drop the quality.

Expand  

Ok... you started the thread talking about changing the file extension... which a couple of us explained what that does and how to do it. Unfortunately... those files contain the main movie and all the other features.  There's no way to pull out just the main movie by changing the file extension. That solution won't work for you.

 

You will need another solution if you just want the main movie.  BudMan's suggestion will work... you can extract the main movie and put it into an MKV container while keeping the full quality.

 

Hell... pretty much any DVD ripper has the option to extract the main movie without reducing quality.  Just rip it without compression.  It's very simple.

 

But you were confusing me with the "changing file extension" talk.  That's a whole other thing and is not related to what you're trying to do.   :D 

 

You just need some kind of DVD ripper. Easy peasy.

  • 0

if you want to go the manual route, keep in mind the main title is prob going to be in more than 1 vob..  You would have to join them.. Its much easier to just let makemkv do it ;)  Unless you got something against the mkv container?

 

And if you have say a tv series dvd collection, its even harder..  I have for example titus tv show all 3 seasons which is multiple dvd per season.  Using makemkv it was just a few minutes to grab out all the episodes per disk and put them into their own mkv file.  Allows you to grab the audio track(s) you want as well.  No reason to grab say the spanish soundtrack if you don't speak spanish, etc.

This topic is now closed to further replies.
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Posts

    • Huawei's Mate XT successor launches this year with a performance and camera boost by Hamid Ganji Last year, Huawei reimagined our perception of folding smartphones by launching the world's first tri-folding device, Mate XT. Contrary to regular folding smartphones like the Samsung Galaxy Z Fold 6, the Huawei Mate XT utilizes a dual-hinge mechanism that allows the device to fold into a "Z" shape. The success of the Mate XT has allegedly prompted Huawei to release a sequel this year. Chinese tipster Digital Chat Station on Weibo says Huawei will release a successor in the second half of 2025. While the folding and screen solution remain unchanged, the tipster claims the second-generation Mate XT gets a faster processor and upgraded camera setup. Digital Chat Station says Huawei will also improve the device's accessories. Last year's Mate XT included an Aramid Fiber Case with an integrated rotating stand in the box as official accessories. Though the tipster doesn't mention quality improvements, Huawei could reinforce the phone's folding endurance. As for the release date, the first-generation Mate XT was released in September 2024, and the Mate XT 2 might also be released at the same time. Interestingly, Huawei announced its Mate XT, the world's first tri-folding device, on September 10 last year, just one day after Apple announced its iPhone 16 series. If Huawei wants to tease Apple again, we can expect the Mate XT 2 to drop simultaneously with the iPhone 17 series. While these devices are not in the same category, Huawei's rivalry with Apple is common knowledge. Tri-folding smartphones provide bigger screens at a more compact size compared to tablets. For example, the Huawei Mate XT has a screen size of 10.2 inches when it's fully open and 7.9 inches when folded once. Also, when you fold it twice, you get a 6.4-inch screen like regular smartphones. Huawei is now the biggest contender in the tri-folding segment, but Samsung may also join the race with a tri-fold version of its Galaxy Fold devices.
    • You can now measure internet speed and download videos using PowerToys Run by Taras Buria PowerToys Run is among my favorite modules, which I use daily (some of them should be integrated into Windows 11). This powerful utility is great for finding stuff, launching apps, navigating the web, and a lot more. Third-party modules help expand PowerToys Run's functionality and add additional capabilities like controlling Spotify, asking ChatGPT, and more. Now, there are three new modules you may find useful: speed test, video downloader, and vocabulary. The SpeedTest module uses Ookla Speedtest CLI for local execution without third-party tracking or ads. It has a modern, theme-aware user interface, and runs with a single command: just open Run and type spt to measure your internet connection speed. The result will show up in a new window with the ability to copy the result URL. The module also supports x64 and ARM systems. The VideoDownloader plugin lets you download videos from YouTube and other websites. You can specify the video quality and format (audio-only, for example) and select where to save the video. To make it work, open PowerToys Run, type dl and add a video URL. Finally, the Definition plugin from the same developer works as a powerful vocabulary that offers word definitions, word pronunciations, phonetics and synonyms, usage examples, and more. Note that these modules are not available in PowerToys out of the box. You need to download them from GitHub and install them manually. Here is how to do that: Download SpeedTest, VideoDownloader, or Definition plugins from their GitHub repositories. Extract downloaded plugins into %LOCALAPPDATA%\Microsoft\PowerToys\PowerToys Run\Plugins\ Open PowerToys Run (Alt + Space is the default shortcut) and launch plugins using their corresponding shortcuts (spt, dl, or def, all three can be customized in settings). You can also configure plugins in PowerToys Run settings. You can find more third-party modules for PowerToys Run on GitHub.
    • Showing people how to self host their own media is harmful, according to YouTube by David Uzondu YouTube has taken down a video from tech creator Jeff Geerling that demonstrated how to use LibreELEC, a lightweight operating system for turning devices into media centers, on a Raspberry Pi 5 for 4K video playback. The video, titled "I replaced my Apple TV—with a Raspberry Pi", originally published in May 2024, was removed in June 2025 under YouTube's "Harmful or dangerous content" policy. According to the violation notice, YouTube claimed the video showed "how to get unauthorized or free access to audio or audiovisual content, software, subscription services, or games that usually require payment." Image via Jeff Geerling Geerling strongly refuted YouTube's claims. He stated clearly, "I purposefully avoid demonstrating any of the tools that are popularly used to circumvent purchasing movie, TV, and other media content." He also emphasized that his own Network Attached Storage, or NAS, contains only legally acquired content. This isn't Geerling's first run-in with YouTube over self-hosted media tools. Last October, his tutorial titled "Better than Disney+: Jellyfin on my NAS" was hit with a similar strike for showing how to set up Jellyfin, an open source media server for organizing and streaming personal media. That strike was quickly overturned after an appeal. But this time, YouTube rejected his appeal, even though the LibreELEC video had been live for over a year, had racked up over half a million views, and contained no promotion of anything illegal. This whole thing feels a lot like what happened with youtube-dl. It's a simple command-line tool for downloading videos, used by tons of people for perfectly legal reasons like saving public domain content or backing up their own uploads. But that didn't stop the RIAA from hitting it with a DMCA takedown on GitHub, calling it a piracy tool. The community pushed back hard, and eventually it was brought back, thanks in part to support from groups like the Electronic Frontier Foundation who pointed out that not everything that can be misused is automatically bad. Side note, the youtube-dl project appears to be unmaintained (the last release was in 2021), if you're looking for an alternative, consider its very popular fork, yt-dlp. After the appeal was rejected, YouTube required Geerling to complete "policy training" to avoid a more serious, permanent strike on his channel. He eventually gave in and took the training. Anyways, if you're interested, he has uploaded the removed LibreELEC video to Internet Archive for anyone to watch.
    • Thanks to Herr Musk being a total poison pill, they can't even give those pieces of scrap away.  They can't even ship them to the UK/EU because they're completely illegal over here.  
    • Intel vs AMD? Microsoft seemingly has a clear recommendation for Windows 11 Pro PC upgrade by Sayan Sen Microsoft and its partners are now quite actively and regularly promoting the upgrade to Windows 11. Asus, for example, recently published blog posts about the "mandatory Windows 11 upgrade" that is coming as the Windows 11 end of support date nears. Microsoft itself, from time to time, urges users to upgrade to its newest OS. Back in February 2024, Microsoft released an advert highlighting the best things about Windows 11 over Windows 10. Later, in June in the same year, the tech giant busted "myths and misconceptions" surrounding a Windows 11 upgrade. And towards the end of 2024, in December, Microsoft put up a blog post outlining the gaming features a user enjoys on 11 if they were to upgrade from Windows 10. While technically there is nothing wrong with a company promoting its own product, sometimes these campaigns make little sense and they fall flat. For example, in January earlier this year, Microsoft shared a blog post headlined "Free Upgrade to Windows 11 (For a Limited Time Only)" which did not make sense as it offered little information about it being a "free upgrade," and it was rightfully, later taken down. The company is back again with a new commercial about Windows 11. This time it is aimed mainly at IT professionals and enterprises as the advert talks about upgrading to Windows 11 Pro from Windows 10. This landed a few days after Microsoft released a new backup tool for organizations for such a purpose. What is interesting is that the company is promoting Intel's vPro processors and there is no mention of AMD's Ryzen PRO parts. The commercial is posted on the Windows official YouTube channel and has been titled "Right side of risk | Windows 11 Pro and Intel". The video description says, "Windows 10 support ends October 14. Stay on the right side of risk—upgrade now to the power of Windows 11 Pro PCs with Intel vPro®." AMD does have a support article about the subject headlined "Support Your Customers’ Move to Windows 11, With AMD Ryzen™ PRO Processors" and you can find it here. This is not the first time Microsoft has promoted Intel CPUs over AMD ones. Back in 2021, the company also put up a full page explaining how users should "look for the Intel EVO badge" on a new device before making a purchase decision because such PCs are "verified wonderful" which was a bit of an odd language. Like the limited upgrade time article, the page above was taken down after we reported on it (can be viewed via the archive) and replaced with something else. The new commercial was published about a couple of days ago, and it is possible that Microsoft may have a dedicated AMD advert too in the pipeline scheduled for a later release, and that would only be fair if both companies get a similar treatment.
  • Recent Achievements

    • Week One Done
      luxoxfurniture earned a badge
      Week One Done
    • First Post
      Uranus_enjoyer earned a badge
      First Post
    • Week One Done
      Uranus_enjoyer earned a badge
      Week One Done
    • Week One Done
      jfam earned a badge
      Week One Done
    • First Post
      survivor303 earned a badge
      First Post
  • Popular Contributors

    1. 1
      +primortal
      436
    2. 2
      +FloatingFatMan
      237
    3. 3
      snowy owl
      216
    4. 4
      ATLien_0
      207
    5. 5
      Xenon
      152
  • Tell a friend

    Love Neowin? Tell a friend!