Recommended Posts

[all of the following is said, fully knowing that this is beta software and subject to change. I'm saying this considering the apparent release is impending, Microsoft has very little time to make big changes, if they plan on providing a final release at the end of the year. I'll be very impressed if this is fixed prior to final release, but still acknowledge it could happen, but they appear (and rightly so at this point in development if they plan to release in a few months) to be primarily bug fixing right now, not implementing features]

 

OK, so I understand the new Start Menu is quite polarising, if it works for you, absolutely fantastic. Can I live with it in it's current incarnation? In a literal sense, obviously, yes I can. That doesn't mean I can't also recognise it's deficiencies.

 

Windows 11's pitch is "being the centre of your digital life", I find one design choice to be extremely glaringly bad and I'd even go as far as saying extremely lazy -

image.thumb.png.d9100a6a628d12ae0ac244dafff2671e.png

 

It's most obvious of all when removing move everything from the start menu; it isn't dynamic at all. Remove recommended, that section stays there, removed pinned apps, yes, that section also stays there. The new start menu has been designed to be a static size, not resizable manually, and customisation does not alter it's size.

 

In fact, changing resolution scaling and resolution, to the most part maintains the same size, drop resolution and the start menu is simply larger. 

 

Granted I totally understand that it's fair to cut features to streamline things sometimes (I'm all for minimalism).

 

Previously, you've been able to hide tiles (the analogue would be the pinned items on Win 11), hide all apps, only show one or the other, change the height and width of the start menu, all manually and tailor everything to your own personal preference as much as you liked. Consider the Windows 95 start menu - Even this was more dynamic than the start menu shipping with Windows 11.

 

When something like this is designed and programmed, from the start, the dynamic scaling would be designed first, a framework would be built so the layout can follow a certain logic based on the size of the application, but right from the start, it appears that Microsoft have designed the Windows 11 start menu to be a static, non dynamic graphic to hold it's contents. 

 

IMO this is the main reason that Windows 11 is going to ship with the worst start menu Microsoft has designed.

 

Edit - mods, if this is soapy enough to be in The Soapbox section, my apologies for not posting it there lol

 

 

Edited by cacoe

I honestly think they should have left the start menu the way it was back in Windows 98: Simple. I hate this mess they have now.

 

At least give the user the option to choose which Start Menu they want instead of shoving in our faces what THEY think is best for us.

  • Like 2
On 14/08/2021 at 12:47, spacelordmaster said:

I honestly think they should have left the start menu the way it was back in Windows 98: Simple. I hate this mess they have now.

 

At least give the user the option to choose which Start Menu they want instead of shoving in our faces what THEY think is best for us.

I don't have a problem with change, I've said it before and I'll say it again, the start screen on Windows 8 was widely hated, but I didn't mind it, I adapted to it, it allowed for customisation (although you can't really compare it to any other version with it being full screen) - It was actually functional though and did allow app groups with 8.1

 

In terms of what they should provide us, I feel regression is the wrong way to do it, adding too many options is a problem as well. It's a hard balance to achieve, but I feel that we've been given something objectively worse than we've had before.

 

The fact the Windows 11 start menu doesn't scale, is just the tip of the iceberg, it feels to me like a freeware start menu replacement (which might be an insult to them which are more functional that what we're being provided with), not something that should ship with Windows, it's just that limited.

Edited by cacoe

I actually like most of the ui changes, but I do have some annoyances, like that Recommended apps section that cannot be removed, or the missing start task manager option in the taskbar right click menu. I guess there's still time for these things to be fine-tuned or changed if enough people ask for them, we'll see. What my ocd would like most is some sort of generic icons or some wrappers for the icons in the taskbar and start menu, so that all of them are the same shape - like in Android for example, with all square icons, or round icons. One can dream, right? :D

First thing i did was align the start menu left.

 

Im not even oposed to what theyre trying to do, but please just give a ticky box for "open to all apps by default" as im sure 90% of users will be pressing it anyway or typing into the start menu to search the app theyre looking for

 

Also the right click on the taskbar for task manager is missed

The Windows 11 Start Menu is the biggest piece of ######. I really cannot put to words just how much a *HATE* this thing. Poor design, absolutely no ability to customize the layout, or ability to go fullscreen like I can in Windows 10.

  • Like 1
On 14/08/2021 at 13:34, Midge said:

First thing i did was align the start menu left.

 

Im not even oposed to what theyre trying to do, but please just give a ticky box for "open to all apps by default" as im sure 90% of users will be pressing it anyway or typing into the start menu to search the app theyre looking for

 

Also the right click on the taskbar for task manager is missed

Opening all apps by default as an option would be welcome.

 

Here's a redesign for the people who only use search -

image.png.42e19398ccab8b015b043490259769ed.png

 

I guess this is good enough for most people and everything else is just window dressing 🤷‍♂️

 

If Windows shipped like this, there really would be an uproar lol.

Btw if those unhappy with the stock menu want to try Open Shell (a continuation of Classic Shell), here's what they need to do to properly set it up: 

http://www.classicshell.net/forum/viewtopic.php?f=18&t=8580. It works best with the Classic Taskbar, although it *does work* with the new taskbar as well.

 

With the new Taskbar, it works better if you use a square Start button without transparent pixels in the Start button PNG image. With the classic Taskbar, no such issues.

On 14/08/2021 at 11:54, cacoe said:

It's most obvious of all when removing move everything from the start menu; it isn't dynamic at all. Remove recommended, that section stays there, removed pinned apps, yes, that section also stays there.

That screenshot you posted... that's been reported as a problem already, even if it ended up being bundled with a bunch of others as a suggestion: https://aka.ms/AAd8p49

 

I wonder if that's a conscious choice they made, I mean, has nobody tried to do just that? Did the one(s) in charge of the vision or design for Windows 11's Start even see it? But what you mention about inadaptability also happens in other places, for example, uninstalling Windows Terminal makes their entries still appear in Win+X (only they do nothing): https://aka.ms/AAd8hie

 

If I had to hazard a guess, I'd say it's the same lack of attention to detail we've seen over the years.

On 14/08/2021 at 04:47, spacelordmaster said:

I honestly think they should have left the start menu the way it was back in Windows 98: Simple. I hate this mess they have now.

 

At least give the user the option to choose which Start Menu they want instead of shoving in our faces what THEY think is best for us.

Yeah, I know - it's like they are turning into Apple, albeit not that bad yet.  Not being able to resize the start menu is pretty messed up. You can do it in Windows 10 easily.

On 14/08/2021 at 05:34, Midge said:

First thing i did was align the start menu left.

 

Im not even oposed to what theyre trying to do, but please just give a ticky box for "open to all apps by default" as im sure 90% of users will be pressing it anyway or typing into the start menu to search the app theyre looking for

 

Also the right click on the taskbar for task manager is missed

Why remove the task manager link from the taskbar right-click menu?  Can you get to it from the right-click menu on the start button?  I would posit that most people don't know about Ctrl + Alt + ESC for bringing up the task manager.

On 14/08/2021 at 07:05, Dot Matrix said:

The Windows 11 Start Menu is the biggest piece of ######. I really cannot put to words just how much a *HATE* this thing. Poor design, absolutely no ability to customize the layout, or ability to go fullscreen like I can in Windows 10.

Good thing you can stick with Windows 10 until 2025. 

On 14/08/2021 at 07:26, cacoe said:

Opening all apps by default as an option would be welcome.

 

Here's a redesign for the people who only use search -

image.png.42e19398ccab8b015b043490259769ed.png

 

I guess this is good enough for most people and everything else is just window dressing 🤷‍♂️

 

If Windows shipped like this, there really would be an uproar lol.

I’d love that LOL. Pop! OS does this by default. 

I need groups and get rid of recommended or let us turn it off and let pinned apps use the whole page recommended is just a waste of space for heavy users ... Gawd I have at least 20 dev apps I use daily that fill up what is there alone ... at least in win 10 you could organize stuff and find it semi easily with tile organization...

On 14/08/2021 at 18:52, devHead said:

Why remove the task manager link from the taskbar right-click menu?  Can you get to it from the right-click menu on the start button?  I would posit that most people don't know about Ctrl + Alt + ESC for bringing up the task manager.

 

This is the taskbar menu:

image.png.0ce02418f00eac42591ee60c704a6c49.png

 

Right click start:

 

image.png.a34b37e291296167212bf73ba78452d5.png

Something I have done for a few years now is remove everything pinned to the Windows 10 start menu so its essentially just a list of all installed apps:

 

image.png.658639a7465e7b04ad48ef821ed2e5a6.png

 

This was back when you ended up with a rainbow of different icon backgrounds for pinned apps, which just looked terrible. I liked how I ended up a nice compact menu that could be scrolled if required.

 

I don't really seam to use the start menu anymore beyond searching now, since Windows 8 butchered the start menu I actually just got used to searching for the program I wished to launch, although historically from Windows 98 to 7 my start menu would be OCD organised with different folders for Apps, Games, Media and so on.

 

The right click start button menu is incredibly useful, I always right click > shutdown / sign out > sleep when finished on the PC, as that was the quickest way to do so on Windows 8. Likewise for device manager, so its nice to see that's relatively the same on Windows 11.

 

Right click on the task bar > task manager not been an option is going to be annoying though, that always seemed the most efficient way to access task manager, after CTRL + ALT + DEL no longer did. I could probably get used to accessing it from right clicking on the start button, that does however seem like an unnecessary change, especially how its essentially muscle memory how I access it from right clicking on the task bar.

  • Like 1
  • Thanks 1
On 16/08/2021 at 15:28, InsaneNutter said:

Something I have done for a few years now is remove everything pinned to the Windows 10 start menu so its essentially just a list of all installed apps:

 

image.png.658639a7465e7b04ad48ef821ed2e5a6.png

 

This was back when you ended up with a rainbow of different icon backgrounds for pinned apps, which just looked terrible. I liked how I ended up a nice compact menu that could be scrolled if required.

 

I don't really seam to use the start menu anymore beyond searching now, since Windows 8 butchered the start menu I actually just got used to searching for the program I wished to launch, although historically from Windows 98 to 7 my start menu would be OCD organised with different folders for Apps, Games, Media and so on.

 

The right click start button menu is incredibly useful, I always right click > shutdown / sign out > sleep when finished on the PC, as that was the quickest way to do so on Windows 8. Likewise for device manager, so its nice to see that's relatively the same on Windows 11.

 

Right click on the task bar > task manager not been an option is going to be annoying though, that always seemed the most efficient way to access task manager, after CTRL + ALT + DEL no longer did. I could probably get used to accessing it from right clicking on the start button, that does however seem like an unnecessary change, especially how its essentially muscle memory how I access it from right clicking on the task bar.

I honestly just put the most popular icons pinned on taskbar - the rest I can scroll or search 

 

It is really crappy that the put stuff like suggestions there - it is getting worse and worse 

 

I could teach my dad how to use Win 98 easily. Now, I have to spent hours customizing his new PC to acceptable usability level before he can use it.  And I don't blame him - having to do so much work to get your system to work decently - it is ridiculous. Latest buy for my Mom drove mad - it took 6 hours to get it to work the way she wants - and she would never be able to do it herself

 

I am sticking to 10 until it is no longer supported and then we will see if I move to Linux finally (I used Linux last time 20 years ago in university - I am sure it is better now LOL)

 

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Posts

    • On the topic of being locked out of a service. Recently two different friends of mine got locked out of their Google accounts. Both were hack attempts and one of them is waiting 30 days before he can get back in. He had backup codes and MFA but not a passkey. It was a browser token hack. Anyhow he has to wait 30 days for the dispute or whatever to end. The other person only had a password and is screwed losing all of the email, docs and years of photos. Google won’t help her at all. Her fault because she had no backup/recovery setup. Enable passkeys if possible. Also do NOT use browser based password managers. If using a cloud service make sure it is one you can fully sync to one of your devices so you can back it up. Like a PC or Mac with some backup drive plugged into it. Google is the worst to use IMHO. You can’t sync your photos at all. You have to use the “Take Out” service which is manual and takes days. That service strips the meta data from your photos. Also Google Docs synced to a device are useless without a Google accounts. MS Office/Libre Office is not going to open a link to a Google doc to a dead account.
    • Why you need to take back control of your synced passwords and how to go about doing that by Paul Hill Credit: Pixabay Last month, when Google decided to introduce daily and weekly caps for Gemini, it reignited an anxiety of mine, that you can’t really depend on service providers to maintain features forever, and it got me looking into free software (as in freedom) in other areas too. One app I quickly came across was KeePassXC on desktop and KeePassDX on Android as an alternative to password manager lock-in within the Chrome or Firefox ecosystems. I personally like to switch around with browsers, and using either password manager is inconvenient, so something like KeePassXC was interesting to me. The main issue with it now is syncing; I was not sure how to do that. After a bit of research, I came across Syncthing, a tool I was vaguely familiar with but had never used because it seemed complicated. However, I was completely wrong, and honestly, I think everyone should use it if they use multiple devices. It essentially lets you share folders peer to peer across all of your devices, no cloud services that you don’t control necessary! And it was fairly simple to set up, if not a bit clunky. Since setting it up, I’ve also started using Syncthing to back up other apps too, so don’t think it’s limited to just saving password databases. You can use it for pretty much anything you use Dropbox or Google Drive for. Before continuing to talk about those apps a bit more, let’s walk back a bit and talk about browser sync. Ever since the late 2000s and early 2010s, really, since we have been using smartphones, browser sync has been a necessity of life. I don’t know about you, but I have hundreds of passwords saved. For the most part, they’re all unique, so I don’t remember them and rely on software to manage them for me. Until recently, I’ve relied on password managers in Chrome and Firefox, but what I always found annoying was that it can be hard to transfer them between browsers. Sure, on Windows it is simple enough, but on Linux, exporting bookmarks has been temperamental. It works OK nowadays, but not too long ago, Chrome required you to enable exporting passwords in chrome://flags. The situation is even worse on mobile; there is no exporting or importing of passwords of any kind. You literally have to do it on a desktop, which is incredibly annoying in our mobile-first world. Sync also lets us take out bookmarks, history, tabs, and autofill data easily. To enable sync, it’s just a matter of signing into the browser once, and it handles the rest. It’s nice and easy. Obviously, all this has some issues, including those I’ve outlined above about it being hard to transfer data between browsers, but also things such as account suspension, lost account passwords, and other lock-in mechanisms, such as passkeys, being tied to a specific browser. On a sidenote, I have just removed all of my passkeys because they can make it harder to move browsers. I think the biggest threat to your synced passwords, especially if doing this with Google, is having your account suspended. I don’t ever expect mine to be suspended, but you do hear horror stories on Reddit where people lose access to their Google accounts. Imagine if you have hundreds of passwords, then suddenly lose access to them because Google froze your account, what would you do? So yes, it can be nice to use these syncing services for their convenience, but they also have risks. You may have seen me going on about free software quite a bit in my editorials. It’s essentially a concept championed by the Free Software Foundation. It’s software under particular licenses that grant you four freedoms: run the program for any purpose (0), study and change the source code (1), redistribute copies to others (2), and the freedom to distribute modified copies to others (3). For example, if there is an app I use and one day it gets abandoned by the developer, I can keep running it or even clone the software and continue developing it. Look at the myriad of cool services Google has run over the years before killing them. You can’t take the source code for those because they are proprietary, for the most part. Both KeePassXC and Syncthing are free software, so I get the freedoms listed above. In my use case where I’m syncing a database full of my passwords, I also get proper ownership over my data, there is no losing access to the database due to a frozen account, I can access the code of the tools I’m using, and I can get support from real people online if I run into issues, rather than having to consult a vague help page from an opaque company. With the KeePassXC password manager, you create a .kdbx file, which is what will be synced between devices. KeePassXC has cross-platform apps and also has browser extensions so that the browser can fetch passwords from the database once it is unlocked. Meanwhile, Syncthing is a peer-to-peer file sync tool where you can select folders to sync between your devices. Just pop files in the folders you choose, and then they will be available across your other devices whenever they come online. Syncthing is resilient as it works over both LAN and the internet and only ever sends content between your devices, never to a third-party server somewhere else. By combining these two pieces of software, you can essentially replicate the browser sync functionality. I have had a weird, conflicting issue where a new file is appearing, but it doesn’t seem to be impacting my main password database, which is updating between devices just fine. If you want to get a setup similar to what I have, you will need to go here to download KeePassXC for your computer. Once you have that, you will need to download your passwords from your web browser to a CSV file. In Chrome, you can type chrome://password-manager/settings into the URL bar, and you should see an option to download your passwords under Export Passwords. This will give you the CSV file you need for importing into KeePassXC. If you use a different browser, just use a search engine and type “browser-name export passwords” and muddle along. In KeePassXC, you’ll want to press Import File from the home screen, select the CSV file, and create a new database from it. On one of the screens of the wizard, there will be a Title field with a drop-down selected to none. Change this to Title and continue. You’ll select a name for the database, the encryption level (the defaults are fine), and then you will pick a password. I would choose four unrelated words that are easy for you to remember, as you’ll be typing them fairly often to access your passwords. When you have all your passwords in your new database, you will want to set up the browser extension so that your browser can fetch passwords from KeePassXC. Rather than explain how to do that here, refer to KeePassXC’s guide on how to set it up properly. Once you’ve got that set up, you want to install KeePassDX on Android. You can grab it on the F-Droid store and the Google Play Store. For iPhone users, there are other .kdbx-supporting apps, but I haven’t tried any of them, so have a look around and use what suits you. Once you have that done, you will want to install Syncthing on your computer and find a third-party app for your mobile device. On Android, I use an app called BasicSync; there are also options for iOS, but again, I’ve not tried these. Once you’ve got SyncThing, you’ll want to set it up and connect all of your devices together and share a folder between your gadgets. PCWorld has a good tutorial on setting up a synchronized file between your devices using SyncThing. Once you’ve set it up, congrats, you’ll never have to touch that stuff again except for adding or removing devices. I’ll be honest, I didn’t particularly like setting up Syncthing. It didn’t take me a massive amount of time, but I think I had to check online because I found it a bit confusing. That said, I’ve had it running for several weeks now and never need to touch the Syncthing settings, so that’s very nice. I also mentioned a conflicting file. I’m not sure why this is appearing, but the main .kdbx file seems to be updating and syncing just fine. What’s nice is that both KeePassXC and Syncthing are free software, so they won’t just vanish one day; you can take the code and fork the project or use a range of alternative implementations that others have made. It’s also nice that it works over LAN, so even if your ISP is having problems, your passwords will still sync. One area where you will want to be a bit more careful with this setup is if you only have one device. I am OK because I have a computer and two phones, all synced up. If you just have one device, you will probably want to store a backup of your .kdbx file somewhere else. Obviously, you’ll also want to remember your password really well, too. If you get locked out, it's game over. Overall, if you want to take back control of your computing from big tech, taking control of your passwords is an important part of this. You don’t need to immediately clear out your browser’s password manager; try running KeePassXC and the password manager concurrently for a while to see if you run into any problems. If you do try this out, let us know some other creative ways to use Syncthing. I haven’t really come up with a solution about what to do with my bookmarks, for example.
    • If the price was a dollar, someone would complain "Why isn't it free?" If it was free, someone would complain they weren't being paid to play it.
    • That lens of history will burn if you hold it at the right angle... Warn users too late: Shame, Microsoft! That extremely minor update to an obscure Control Panel widget required 2 years of warning. Warn users too early: Shame, Microsoft! We've got better things to do. Pipeline and process be damned, we'll just always be disappointed, eh?
    • Microsoft Paint used to be my favorite Windows app as a kid, and it's still pretty good by Usama Jawad I have been using Windows since the early 2000s, when I was around 10 years old or so. I vaguely remember playing around with Windows 98 and Windows 2000, but that may have been on school PCs which had old operating systems installed. My main OS on the home PC, and the one I recall spending most time with, was Windows XP. At that time, I used the home PC to create Word and PowerPoint documents for school, but a lot of the time, I simply used it to play games. My dad would bring game discs which we would try and install on the PC, sometimes unsuccessfully, and sometimes, we would rely on flash games in the browser, like Bubble Trouble on Miniclip. However, the problem with the latter approach was the internet speed. On a good day, our dial-up internet would offer us speeds of 56 kbps, but on most days, it was closer to 33 kbps. This did not facilitate online gaming as I would often have to wait minutes for a game to load or "draw" on the screen, and trying to download pirated games wasn't simple either. I remember getting tired of waiting for online games to load and just downloading simulator games from the Big Fish Games website instead, only to be disappointed after finding out that I was just being given access to trial versions of the title, and I needed to fork out money to pay for the full version. All of this is to say that it wasn't very easy to find entertainment options on the home PC when I was a kid, due to a number of reasons, mostly outside of my control. This situation pushed me towards a rather unconventional ally: Microsoft Paint. Whenever the internet wasn't working as good as I expected, I would simply spin up Paint and draw complete rubbish on the canvas. Of course, that wasn't always the intention, but it usually happened when I messed up drawing a straight line or something, and then I would give up on that particular piece and simply draw a random collection of objects. Microsoft Paint was extremely accessible and easy to use. Even if you weren't an artist, you could quickly understand the tools at your disposal and how to leverage them on a canvas. The absolute breadth on offer ensured that each painting was truly unique, as you could utilize various combinations of tools like the pencil, paint, spray paint, and more to truly personalize your creation. Since I wasn't particularly good at drawing both on digital screen or a physical screen, I remember that my main style of art would be to insert a bunch of randomly intersecting lines and then fill them with random colors through the paint can. I have trying to replicate that art style in the latest version of Paint below, and as you can see, it's truly Pablo Picasso-esque. The human imagination truly knows no bounds Microsoft Paint kept me occupied for hours and was my best friend when video games on the home PC were inaccessible for one reason or the other. There was no academic or professional reason for which I would need to use Paint, but I still loved using it in my personal time, even if what I created wasn't worth being shown to anyone. It was simply fun. Fast-forward to today, and the situation is mostly the same. Now that I am almost 29 years old, and I still have no reason to use Microsoft Paint in a professional capacity. In fact, I don't even use it in a personal capacity, except to dabble with it from time to time, just to see if core functionalities are still intact. And I'm happy to say that I think Microsoft Paint still offers the same accessibility and inviting experience that it did to me a couple of decades ago, even though its UX has been refreshed and it's been integrated with Copilot features. Interestingly, things could have been a lot different, had Microsoft had its way. Microsoft Paint was marked for deprecation with the Windows 10 Fall Creators Update in 2017, and even began displaying a product retirement alert, urging customers to shift to Paint 3D instead. Fortunately, after consumer backlash, Microsoft reversed course on this decision, and Paint continues to be a native app inside Windows installations that can also be updated quite frequently through the Microsoft Store. Instead, Paint 3D ended up on the chopping block, which is for the better, I think. I have intermittently played around with Microsoft's refreshed Paint experience in the past few years, and I do think it has received worthwhile upgrades. the UI and the UX has been modernized while retaining core functionality, and the app is still fairly easy to use. It doesn't meet any of my use-cases, but I've never really had any use-cases ever, as described previously. Of course, the elephant in the room is the Copilot integration. Personally, I believe that this is one place where Copilot does make sense, environmental concerns aside. I know that a lot of creatives use AI to generate images, and while some may be using professional alternatives, Paint still offers a decent casual experience, with the power of Copilot. Of course, you do need to have a valid Microsoft 365 Copilot license and available credits to use it, but even if you don't, you still get the big Copilot button in the toolbar, unfortunately. All in all, I am glad that Microsoft Paint continues to be a native feature in Windows 11, and a piece of software that has evolved to meet modern needs without cutting off its own roots. It's just an iconic piece of Windows history that was an essential part of my childhood, and while I don't use it anymore, I'm just glad it is still there.
  • Recent Achievements

    • Week One Done
      Supreme Spray LV earned a badge
      Week One Done
    • One Month Later
      Genuinetonerink- Dubai earned a badge
      One Month Later
    • Week One Done
      Genuinetonerink- Dubai earned a badge
      Week One Done
    • One Year In
      hhgygy earned a badge
      One Year In
    • Week One Done
      AMV earned a badge
      Week One Done
  • Popular Contributors

    1. 1
      +primortal
      513
    2. 2
      +Edouard
      163
    3. 3
      PsYcHoKiLLa
      88
    4. 4
      Steven P.
      74
    5. 5
      Michael Scrip
      73
  • Tell a friend

    Love Neowin? Tell a friend!