Who is the better director

By OrangeSoul
in The Media Room

 Share

Who is the better director  

87 members have voted

  1. 1. Who is the better director

    • Alfred Hitchcock
      18
    • Stanley Kubrick
      19
    • Steven Spielberg
      33
    • James Cameron
      6
    • Quinton Tarantino
      11

Recommended Posts

Grand Master

FiREFLi

Posted
Posted

I did a null vote, I have no idea who directs what films, and have no desire to learn. I had heard all of their names before, except Kubrick. However, I only knew Speilberg as a film director, oh and Hitchcock rang a bell in the films department. If I'd have voted it would have been for Speilberg I suppose. But I didn't, nevermind eh.

Veteran

QuantumTrickery

Posted
Posted

Its like comparing apples and oranges. Sure they are both fruit, but completely different. Same with the list of directors. Each has their talents and what they excel at. But putting Tarrentino on a list with those other greats? What a waste, to be honest. So many far better directors, not to mention far better at doing what Tarrantino yanked his ideas from to begin with.

Apprentice

lifesize loudsound

Posted
Posted

You do have to admit, though, that Tarantino is pretty brilliant in the same way Beck is brilliant. He takes old things, recombines them in new ways and comes up with something fresh. We will have to give Tarantino some time, though, to find out if he can continue to be brilliant for decades, like many of those other directors have been.

I voted for Kubrick though. But all those guys are very enjoyable directors, although I'd agree that Scorcese needs a place up there. James Cameron?!?

Grand Master

AgEnTsMiTh

Posted
Posted
frank capra

george stevens

preston sturges

d w griffith

sergei eisenstein

victor fleming

martin scorcese

any of these guys will pop up if you ask tarantino, spielberg, and cameron about their influences

Very True. Let's not forget Akira Kurosawa. HE should be on that list.

Experienced

glazzz

Posted
Posted
I would put Tony Scott up there.

if you're going with Tony, you gotta add Ridley as well...

my vote went to Hitchcock, he was the man.

Hey there are so many more, its hard to remember them all. But I would have to honestly say, Kurosawa is one of the biggest influences to many of the big directors today.

(Y) good call. (Y)

Mentor

CrimsonBlur

Posted
Posted

If you're going to put someone like James Cameron or Quinton Tarantino on there you might as well include Ridley Scott as well, and it is a CRIME that Scorcese isn't on that list. I voted Speilberg. In my opinion he is the best over-all director, and Ridley Scott is very good as well. Tarantino, Hitchcock and Kubric have so much of their own style that (for me) it actually makes THEIR movies all too similarly made. Speilberg does an excellent job of making all of his movies VERY different. Think about it: Close Encounters of the Third Kind, Indiana Jones, Jurassic Park, Schindler's List, Saving Private Ryan, AI, and now The Terminal (to mention a few). All of those movies are very different except for Schindler's List and Saving Private Ryan. They all have his style mixed in, but most of his movies are radically different.

This topic is now closed to further replies.
 Share
Go to topic listing

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.