Is Linux nearing XP usability?


I prefer:  

407 members have voted

  1. 1. I prefer:

    • Windows xp
      298
    • pre xpLinux free
      64
    • Linux commercial
      45


Recommended Posts

Going for windows Xp. Unfortunetly, Linux couldn't get my ethernet modem up, and lacks support for dsl internet connections. I'll try it maybe when internet is a bit more easy to setup.

585413503[/snapback]

The only problems I've heard linux in the last few years have with any ethernet modems are winmodems.

Imo the main problem with GNU/Linux is the lack of hardware support.

Take WLAN cards. I have a 3Com Xjack card in my old laptop, which still is not supported. 2 1/2 years after I bought it. The same goes to the AirPort Extreme card in my current PowerBook!

I've heard some stories about Nvidia graphic cards as well.

That said, GNU/Linux is still my #2 operating system. :D

Going for windows Xp. Unfortunetly, Linux couldn't get my ethernet modem up, and lacks support for dsl internet connections. I'll try it maybe when internet is a bit more easy to setup.

585413503[/snapback]

what distro did you use?

i couldnt get online with 2kpro because it did not detect my nforce2 ethernet, linux on teh other hand set it up automatically.

nvidia cards work awesome. in yoper, the drivers are automatically installed and are updated with the rest of the system, no restarts, no nothing. it really doesnt get any easier than taht.

ATI on the other hand...

The only problems I've heard linux in the last few years have with any ethernet modems are winmodems.

Winmodems are old 56k dialup junkers. As for ethernet modems, yes not all of them are supported. Then again there are no "ethernet modems". There are cable, DSL and sat modems.

If you are using a usb connection between your modem and your computer (for which you have to install drivers) you are probably going to run into problems. However, if you connect the modem to your computer using the RJ45 port there are no drivers to install and the rest is a configuration issue (some DSL services).

The other problem they may be facing is with their network card. The driver may very well not be included with the distro they are using. Therefore you must find it yourself.

people reading this thread will get idea that LINUX has worst support for wireless and dsl modems..

Linux doesnt has worst support for it .. but not been given by default ( from wht i know ) . Google for NDISWRAPPER drivers and read thru thousands of success stories regarding wireless network driver support.

Well, I have a Microsoft wireless network in my home, so I'm automatically screwed. I still mess around with Knoppix and a few other LiveCDs but the lack of network/internet functionality makes it boring quick. I can always take down my network and plug my DSL straight into my server but...that's slightly unproductive.

0k ... i am adding this link for folks who wonder bout wireless networking in linux http://ndiswrapper.sourceforge.net/

Getting Your WireLess NIC Working with the NDIS Wrapper Device Driver >>> http://www.linuxelectrons.com/article.php/...104718960/print

WIKI INFO on NDIS >> http://wiki.linuxquestions.org/wiki/NDIS_Wrapper

<jim carrey> Ndis in linux... its good ... its goooooood </jim carrey>

0k ... i am adding this link for folks who wonder bout wireless networking in linux http://ndiswrapper.sourceforge.net/

Thanks, I'm gonna give it a go. Even if it feels strange to use Windows drivers in GNU/Linux. :whistle:

At least its a solution for x86 computers...

windows xp can also have 3 free browsers and 2 free office suites :huh: lame way to put it...

windows will continue to be popular mainly because it's used around the globe.

585383357[/snapback]

Microsoft software is slowly being banned in countries around the globe.

http://www.winplanet.com/article/1218-.htm

Gee, I wonder why! I still use windows, but I regret it every day.

Thanks, I'm gonna give it a go. Even if it feels strange to use Windows drivers in GNU/Linux. :whistle:

At least its a solution for x86 computers...

585418461[/snapback]

Don't forget AMD64, my Compaq R3240CA now has wireless thanks to the latest ndiswrapper.

  • 5 months later...
Hello, now that Knoppix 4.0 is almost out.. do you think Linux has achieved XP usability??

Well, I think it has. But soon Longhorn will be out and then Linux will be left behind again. This looks like a cycle of events.

586192488[/snapback]

linux has had xp usability even before xp was ever out. as for longhorn, i don't think linux will be left behind. microsoft's only releasing longhorn just so it can have something to cram onto walmart's shelves (or any other retailer). i've noticed that people complain and whine about how "linux" doesn't have good driver support. wtf people? you have the internet and a hand, look for them yourself and don't expect any distro to have perfect driver support for your camera, scanner, nic, etc made by some miniscule manufacturer that nobody knows anything about.

^ I agree with you there except for one point.

My wireless device on my laptop is the most common device period and no distro has a working driver out of the box as of yet for it. It has been a pain to get working from day 1.

586192983[/snapback]

Ahh, but you got it working in the end, right? ;)

linux has had xp usability even before xp was ever out. as for longhorn, i don't think linux will be left behind. microsoft's only releasing longhorn just so it can have something to cram onto walmart's shelves (or any other retailer). i've noticed that people complain and whine about how "linux" doesn't have good driver support. wtf people? you have the internet and a hand, look for them yourself and don't expect any distro to have perfect driver support for your camera, scanner, nic, etc made by some miniscule manufacturer that nobody knows anything about.

586192972[/snapback]

You forget that the everyday average user has no idea how to find a driver sometimes, I deal with many of these idiots all the time, but thats what they have me for ;)

Anyways these people would prefer something that worked right out of the box.

i been using gentoo linux for quite some time now and as far as applications its pretty caught up. but as far as gaming and non-clone applications to allow you to use a feature but not be the program you use in windows then no. and as far as that comment about longhorn just being a update to stock walmart shelves thats way off. its a whole new kernel. 2k was nt5 xp was 5.1 and longhorn is 6.0 so people that thought the move from 2k to xp was at all dramatic and seeing how it was only a point release. longhorn is a whole new kernel and will be totally different from other windows os's. the problem is alot of kiddies are judging the os while its just peaking into beta 1 status.

Even Windows doesn't come with "out of the box" drivers that work just great.

I recall especially graphics drivers use to be crappy for games, and it's always up to the user to update to e.g. the latest ForceWare drivers in order to get some previously bugged game to work.

It's impossible to cover all bases. But many modern Linux distros of today do come with usable (and we can't expect more, really) drivers for a whole lot of hardware, just like Windows. Some improvements can maybe be made, but it's not really too "behind" Windows anymore I think.

I prefer Linux Free (Fedora).

The only real issues I have with Linux are wireless networking (even though I figured out how to get one of the cards to work) and transferring video files from my digital camera. Maybe I'll get an SD reader to fix that error. But as for Fedora, they are missing a fair amount of vital packages (xmms, xmms-mp3, ati and nvidia drivers, etc.) and like all Linux distros, should dump Mesa in favour of a graphics library that offers greater out-of-the-box OpenGL performance.

Yet even with those few roadblocks, I'm doing well with neither PC in my possession running Windows! It's just so much more usable, stable, and speedy! :p

This topic is now closed to further replies.
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Posts

    • Tor Browser 15.0.15 by Razvan Serea Protect your privacy. Defend yourself against network surveillance and traffic analysis. Tor is a network of virtual tunnels that allows people and groups to improve their privacy and security on the Internet. The Tor software protects you by bouncing your communications around a distributed network of relays run by volunteers all around the world: it prevents somebody from watching your Internet connection and learning what sites you visit, it prevents the sites you visit from learning your physical location, and it lets you access sites which are blocked. The Tor Browser Bundle lets you use Tor on Windows, Mac OS X, or Linux without needing to install any software. It can run off a USB flash drive, comes with a pre-configured web browser to protect your anonymity, and is self-contained. Tor Browser 15.0.15 changelog: All Platforms Updated NoScript to 13.6.20.1984 Updated Tor to 0.4.9.9 Bug tor-browser#42436: Allow for multiple configured (front, reflector) domain fronting pairs in Moat module Windows + macOS + Linux Bug tor-browser#44997: Captcha doesn't work in TB desktop Linux Bug tor-browser#44886: Backport tor-browser#44361: Notify Linux i686 users that they won't receive updates anymore Download: Tor Browser (64-bit) | Tor Browser (32-bit) | 109.0 MB (Open Source) View: Tor Browser Website | Other Operating Systems Get alerted to all of our Software updates on Twitter at @NeowinSoftware
    • Less disk space means less bandwidth demands which means lower operating costs for service providers... that's where money talks. ... cuz it's not about improving video quality!... that's just marketing spin.
    • And thereby lies the rub. AV1 support is not as wide as paid analysts would have the industry believe. With AV2 around the corner, it's going cause more time backlog in adoption (how many recent purchasers will upgrade yet-again within the next 6-12 months? most would rather stay pat for another 1+ years before even thinking about upgrading their setups).
    • Microsoft OneDrive is getting a simple yet much needed feature by Sayan Sen Microsoft has been steadily expanding OneDrive’s file management capabilities over the years, including for shared content and shortcuts, although it has had its flaws, too. The cloud storage platform introduced support for folder shortcuts several years ago, allowing users to pin frequently accessed shared folders from OneDrive, SharePoint, and Teams. Now, Microsoft is refining that experience further with a new way to organize those shortcuts as revealed in a recent Microsoft 365 roadmap addition. Previously, shortcuts added through the “Add shortcut to My files” option would appear alongside all other files and folders in the root of a user's OneDrive. And although it's meant to be useful, this approach could also create clutter along the way, especially for heavy users who may have to work with large numbers of shared folders across multiple projects and teams on their systems. This is where Microsoft’s latest feature comes in, as it is looking to address this inconvenience by giving users the option to place new shortcuts inside a dedicated “Shortcuts” folder instead. The feature is designed to keep shortcut links organized into a single location instead of scattering throughout the main OneDrive directory. Hence, the idea is to make navigation and usability easier and simpler. The first time a user chooses this option, OneDrive will automatically create the folder, and to help make it stand out from the other folders, the Shortcuts folder will have a distinct visual identity featuring a unique color and a building-style icon. That being said, the new Shortcuts will behave just like any other folder in OneDrive, and as such, users will be able to move it to a different location, rename it, share it with others, or remove it entirely if they prefer a different structure. You can view the entry on the Microsoft 365 roadmap website here. Currently, the feature is in the "in development" phase, but the tech giant expects the rollout to start next month (July 2026). Do keep in mind, though, that new feature rollouts often get delayed.
    • VS Code 1.123 introduces massive upgrades for persistent AI developer workflows by Paul Hill Microsoft has just released Visual Studio Code 1.123 alongside its annual developer conference, Build 2026. This release, as always, has a heavy focus on advanced AI agent integration and making the built-in browser more robust. Notably, this update brings big sync changes that keep your AI agents persistent across sessions. With this update, VS Code now supports cross-machine syncing for chat histories, touched files, repository contexts, and related PRs via GitHub accounts, tying users even more into Microsoft’s developer ecosystem. This update also introduces the new /chronicle command that allows you to query past sessions using natural language, generate instant standup reports, and get personal productivity insights. Microsoft has also made some improvements to network-dependent operations, it explains: “When a terminal command that is run by a local agent requires access to domains that are not configured as allowed domains, the command is automatically retried inside the sandbox with unrestricted network access. After that, if it still fails, it falls back to unsandboxed execution. This allows network-dependent operations such as git fetch to finish, while keeping filesystem protections in place.” Microsoft has not stopped there; in this update, it also allows developers to drag, drop, and pin multiple agent sessions side-by-side for easy code comparisons in real-time. It also introduces the Research Agent, accessible via /research. This is a read-only, depth-optimized tool that gets data from the web, local codebase, and GitHub to give you a Markdown report on complex APIs or unfamiliar code. Now, let’s talk about the integrated browser and some security enhancements. VS Code 1.123 features enhanced screenshot capture tools that allow for targeted Area Screenshots and Full Page Screenshots to send layout context instantly to AI chat. The address bar has also been revamped, supporting favorite pages and tab management. Finally, on the security front, this update introduces a safety-first two-hour delay on third-party extension auto-updates to safeguard against compromised or buggy releases. This release is now available for Windows, Mac, and Linux. If you have VS Code, keep an eye out for the update availability notification. If you still don’t have VS Code, you can get it here.
  • Recent Achievements

    • One Month Later
      B2Proxy earned a badge
      One Month Later
    • One Year In
      MadMung0 earned a badge
      One Year In
    • Week One Done
      jefred earned a badge
      Week One Done
    • Apprentice
      JoeyNeo went up a rank
      Apprentice
    • Week One Done
      oliviaexpo earned a badge
      Week One Done
  • Popular Contributors

    1. 1
      +primortal
      482
    2. 2
      PsYcHoKiLLa
      227
    3. 3
      Skyfrog
      71
    4. 4
      FloatingFatMan
      60
    5. 5
      Nick H.
      54
  • Tell a friend

    Love Neowin? Tell a friend!