Good Charlotte or Green Day?

[se7en.hu]

Green Day out of those there music is ok...

[Kriz]

I wouldnt choose either, GC have had one song that i liked but all the rest are pop-rock imo. Greendays older stuff, although i may not have liked it, i still recognise them as being a good band, but they arent my thing.

[hotdog666al]

Greenday have some alright songs (Basket case & Warning) It's a shame they are pop sell-outs now

Good Charlotte have never been good.

[....]

Mmmm...that was some good charlotte. I'll have another serving.

[Schuyler]

dude....good charlotte is the gayest garbage i've ever listened to! don't even compare them to green day!!

[.:YodaGP:.]

Greenday is the better of two evils.

[PyX]

Definately, Green Day all the way! Good CHarlotte made SOME good songs (The Click being the best of them), but they're not that good. Green Day is old school, I love their music, like their lyrics and some of their songs are masterpieces, the others are just amazingly good :p

[Xylene]

Neither Green Day nor Good Charlotte are "punk rock".

[AOXOMOXOA]

i dont really listen to this crap, but if i had to choose it would be green day

[brunok]

To be honest, I think Good Charlotte stinks....the songs are kinda dumb and boring and the singer has a terrible voice...

[Techno_Funky]

heck yes

green day anyday :punk:

[mariadelmar]

Green Day

[Terrigamer]

Out of these two, Green Day. But as been said to death by others, I hardly consider them "punk". Especially GC..lol.

[.fury]

green day by far, saw them live at milton keynes bowl yesterday, they were fantastic :yes:

[BluePhlame1337]

green day definatly, after about 1.5 minutes of listening to good charlotte, I wanted to stick a tooth pick though my own eardrums to make it stop.

[McLaren_F1]

Neiter, don't listen to punk rock :)

[Jason S. Global Moderator]

both are terrible mtv pop bands. :no:

[bukowski]

i hate both, but anything is better than good charlotte. so greenday is teh winnaer!!1

[LEATHERFACE559]

Why anyone would ask this I dont know why GREEN DAY is obviously way better than that those POP-PUNK POSERS GAY CHARLOTTE. GREEN DAY IS PUNK GAY CHARLOTTE POP-PUNK. ANYWAYS my vote goes to GREEN DAY they are much better than GAY CHARLOTTE.

[SerialStorm]

Going tto see Green Day in a few months :happy:

[dan]

While I must admit Green Day are leagues ahead of "Good" Charlotte i just thought if anyone is interested in listening to some fairly modern high quality, non sell out (ie they aint on MTV) punk bands check out the following:

NOFX

Lagwagon

Reset (Now a dead band but in their time they were amazing beyond belief)

Saves The Day

Me First And The Gimme Gimme's (the best punk cover band in the world)

Millencolin

Also here are some other bands who may be considered punk/emo spinoffs

The Get Up Kids

Bad Astronaut

But yeah none of this would be possible without bands like the Sex Pistols, Ramones, and possibly The Pixies on a modern day approach.

[KeR]

Green Day

I can't wait to go to their concert this Sptember :D

[gcrocks]

GOOD CHARLOTTE ROCKS!!!!

Green day sucks :x

They don?t wanna be american idiots? they are!!!

The persons who don?t like GC is idiot!!!!!

GOOD CHARLOTTE ROCKS!!!!

[gcrocks]

GOOD CHARLOTTE ROCKS!!!!!!

green day sucks :x

They don?t wanna be american idiots? Thry are

Who don?t like GC is an idiot

GOOD CHARLOTTE ROCKS!!!!!!

GOOD CHARLOTTE RULZZ!!!!!!!

[KoL Veteran]

Neiter :no: