Good Charlotte or Green Day?

[FiREFLi]

GOOD CHARLOTTE ROCKS!!!!

Green day sucks :x

They don?t wanna be american idiots? they are!!!

The persons who don?t like GC is idiot!!!!!

GOOD CHARLOTTE ROCKS!!!!

586099599[/snapback]

GOOD CHARLOTTE ROCKS!!!!!!

green day suck:x:x

They don?t wanna be american idiots? Thry are

Who don?t like GC is an idiot

GOOD CHARLOTTE ROCKS!!!!!!

GOOD CHARLOTTE RULZZ!!!!!!!

586099606[/snapback]

Looks to me like you just signed up to post that....twi:blink:ink:

Or you're a real neowinnian who wanted to start a bit of controversy:shifty:fty:

:laug:ninja:nja: :laug:ninja:nja:

[Purple Haze]

I've loved Green Day since 1994, and I hate hate hate Good Charlotte with a passion. Can't sing, can't write songs worth a crap, the fat guitar player sits there mouthing all the words in an incredibly annoying fashion, and I doubt they could even play a Green Day song w/o messing it up.

[Memento_Mori]

really neither of them can be considered punk in the true sense, at best they're big musics watered down and marketable version of what punk is.

[giga Veteran]

Neiter  :no:

586099621[/snapback]

Agreed. :x

[TheWahbinator]

If I had to choose, I'd choose Green Day

[Alex Suraci]

Another vote for Green Day. ;) <3 Misery

[Habitat]

NETHER! you need to check out some audioslave, coldplay, or journey

[InternalStorm]

Good Charlotte are Christians, and their lyrics really inspire more than Green Day. Green Day simply is about being sacriligious and having lyrics that are obsessed with the material world they live in. The new Good Charlotte is much more mature and has some good meanings as well as being catchy. I have to go with them, they have more potential for the future, and have my ears more than the immature Green Day does.

[JustVince]

Greenday completely especially their earlier stuff like Kirplunk and Dookie... Good Charlotte sucks in my opinion.

[Ayepecks]

I listen to punk-rock, but I don't like either of them. I used to like Green Day, but I absolutely hate their new material. Good Charlotte has always been crap, though.

[Hipster]

Green Day is punk. They sound like punk so they are punk. Just because they are completely mainstream doesn't change that.

Good Charlotte on the other hand is bubble-gum pop crap.

[Tomi]

Although a few of my best friends love Good Charlotte, I'm going to have to vote for Green Day as I think they're awesome. :happy:

Don't wanna be an American Idiot...

:laugh: I love that song. :D

[Bling3k12]

Good Charlotte has to be the biggest pile of crap band I have ever heard. MAYBE In 2001 they had some good music. The Motivation Proclamation is probably the only song I could listen to, if I could get myself to hit Play. Anyone who is a fan of theirs needs their head examined, and during the examination, a "mishap" occurs, leaving them braindead.

Wait, you'd almost have to be braindead to like their music. So no worries on the mishap, that must have happened already.

Edit: Crap, I forgot they did the theme to "Undergrads", which used to be on MTV... that show was awesome. Son of a...

[CactuzJak]

Good Charlotte is so punk rock, anyone see their new Nintendo commercial...

[blush]

I listened to Good Charlotte before Green Day's "American Idiot" came around... I love American Idiot, so I tried their other songs and GD is definitely better than GC.

[Guol]

dude....good charlotte is the gayest garbage i've ever listened to! don't even compare them to green day!!

586088044[/snapback]

To be honest, I think Good Charlotte stinks....the songs are kinda dumb and boring and the singer has a terrible voice...

586088170[/snapback]

you know, what i wonder is how many good charlotte songs HAVE you listened to??? like come on, just because you hear one or two it doesnt mean the rest of their songs are crap. their latest album actually has some pretty good songs IMO.

GOOD CHARLOTTE ROCKS!!!!!!

green day sucks :x

They don?t wanna be american idiots? Thry are

Who don?t like GC is an idiot

GOOD CHARLOTTE ROCKS!!!!!!

GOOD CHARLOTTE RULZZ!!!!!!!

586099606[/snapback]

yeh, im a good charlotte fan as well....but you could be abit more mature....and btw, welcome to neowin:D:D

Good Charlotte are Christians, and their lyrics really inspire more than Green Day. Green Day simply is about being sacriligious and having lyrics that are obsessed with the material world they live in. The new Good Charlotte is much more mature and has some good meanings as well as being catchy. I have to go with them, they have more potential for the future, and have my ears more than the immature Green Day does.

586099697[/snapback]

i agree with you there.

i am a large fan of both of these bands in fact, except they cant be judged against each other. genre doesnt have much to do with this though. nobody really gives a crap if they're punk or not.

its just that greenday have had much more experience, so they can play the instruments better [although their latest album was abit disappointing].

on the other hand, good charlotte have much better and meaningful lyrics than greenday, which is also important. they have also learnt to play instruments better, and their latest album is quite a good deal.

thats why i voted neither, although i do prefer good charlotte. next time i advise that people should actually listen to more of the band before criticising the songs.:yes:s:

[Damrock2002]

Neither.

I can't stand them.

[dafinga]

I'm not big fans of either ... but most deffently I would listen to Green Day over Charlotte. Charlotte is like pretty little rock pop punk that teenagers jump on beds to and say "Moshing is rocking!"

Either or listen ... if you like these bands listen to the originals: The Clash, Stiff Little Fingers, The Modern Lovers, The Stooges, New York Dolls, Ramones, Buzzcocks, Generation X, Richard Hell, Nick Lowe, etc etc etc ...

[one321]

Green Day hands down. IMO these two bands are incomparable.

[.weir]

why don't we have a poll with some good bands? Pop music is so . . . bleh

[stezo2k]

Greenday all the way, by far the best

[kyro]

avril lavigne says good charlotte.

[Lee G. Veteran]

GreenDay is better - I'm not fans of either though :|

[dyl4n]

Good Charlotte are Christians, and their lyrics really inspire more than Green Day. Green Day simply is about being sacriligious and having lyrics that are obsessed with the material world they live in. The new Good Charlotte is much more mature and has some good meanings as well as being catchy. I have to go with them, they have more potential for the future, and have my ears more than the immature Green Day does.

586099697[/snapback]

I highly doubt that. Ever see the Punk'd episode with Good Charlotte? They're complete ######.

[TokyoKiller]

Green Day all the way, an addition to that their latest album sounds better than anything ive ever listened to. Because every song in that album makes sense and is actually good from track one to track 13.