• 0

[C++] Test if two files are the same?


Question

I'm not looking to test if two files are duplicates, I know you can do that by doing a byte by byte comparison, or hashing both files.

What I'm looking for is a way to test if both files are literally the same file. For example:

c:\documents and settings\bla.txt

c:\docume~1\bla.txt

When comparing the strings, those might be seen as two different files, when really they're the same file. I could convert both strings to short file names, but I'm not sure if Windows has other ways of linking files to eachother.

In brief, I need a foolproof way to test if two files are the same file or different.

Link to comment
https://www.neowin.net/forum/topic/349791-c-test-if-two-files-are-the-same/
Share on other sites

21 answers to this question

Recommended Posts

  • 0

Well i can just give you puesudo code:

Read both files and store the text inside, into two seperate strings

--> If string 1 == string 2

Do what you want to happen

You will have to check yourself, or let someone else find out how to read the files, since i haven't learned about reading files yet.

  • 0

So your question is how are you supposed to see if two files are identical without comparing contents of them!?

Btw, love your avatar - reminds me of when I was creating demos in DOS and I made effect that looked exactly as your avatar... heh..

  • 0

so let me see if i'm getting the question.

u have 1 file but have 2 different strings for the paths:

as in

Path 1 is C:\Docs\abc.txt

Path 2 is D:\Prog\Desktop\abc.txt

put the two paths in 2 string arrays. parse the arrays backwards till u reach the '\', from that point on again go forward till the end of the array and store this in 2 new arrays.

now compare these 2 arrays to chk if they are the same.

  • 0
  df_dukkar said:
so let me see if i'm getting the question.

u have 1 file but have 2 different strings for the paths:

as  in

Path 1 is C:\Docs\abc.txt

Path 2 is D:\Prog\Desktop\abc.txt

put the two paths in 2 string arrays. parse the arrays backwards till u reach the '\', from that point on again go forward till the end of the array and store this in 2 new arrays.

now compare these 2 arrays to chk if they are the same.

586278450[/snapback]

He wants to see if the files are the same, i.e. they contain the same stuff, but for some reason he doesn't want to open the file or uses hashes like an MD5sum.

  • 0

Sorry, let me reexplain :pinch:

c:\documents and settings\file.txt

c:\docume~1\file.txt

Technically, both are the same file, but doing a string comparison would say differently.

I have a function which has two parameters, inputfile and outputfile. If the outputfile is different than the inputfile, it will truncate the outputfile. But if the inputfile and outputfile are the same file, then it'll overwrite the current file.

I already mentioned that I could convert both strings to a short filename, but I'm unsure if there are other things to consider. For example, %systemroot%.

So I need a "foolproof" way of testing if the two strings both literally represent the same file. If converting to a short filename would be adequate, could someone give me a function that can do this? I was unable to find anything on Google or MSDN :blush:

And sorry for not being clearer in my first post :(

Btw, love your avatar - reminds me of when I was creating demos in DOS and I made effect that looked exactly as your avatar... heh..

My avatar is a XOR effect, (X ^ Y) ;)

Edit: Just to be absolutely sure I don't confuse anyone again...

I'm NOT looking to compare the contents of files.

I'm only looking to see if two file paths are the same.

eg. c:\docume~1\file.txt IS c:\documents and settings\file.txt. Only difference is one is the short file name and the other is the long file name.

Edited by xinok
  • 0

I dont really get why you would like to do that since they are always the same. That means instead of writing

cd "c:\documents and settings"

you can always use

cd c:\docume~1\

But if you really want to do that then it's only matter of stripping strings.

Reason that it stands docume~1 is that DOS cannot handle filenames larger than 8 characters, so "documents and settings" became "docume~1".

My recomendation is that you have some kind of translation table that translates docume~1 to its full name or use full path as input and strip it down to 6 characters and add "~1" to it.

  • 0
  xinok said:
but I'm not sure if Windows has other ways of linking files to eachother.

586278291[/snapback]

unfortunately windows does not have symlinks like in unix - this is how i understand link of similar (the same) files.

maybe i did not understand your post correctly, but if you want it not as part of some school assignment, what's the problem using 'comp' command?

i have it in the sendTo menu..

  • 0

NTFS supports both hard and soft links like ext2; these features are largely underused though.

There is an api function called GetShortPathName that will deal with 8.3 vs long format. The best way to detect all links/short/long would be to check which directory entry the directories ultimately point to. I think this approach would work only on a per-file-system basis (e.g., you need diff code for FAT32 and NTFS).

  • 0

Jayzee: I know what short file names are.

Andareed: Thanks for the GetShortPathName function

robotnic: I found this: CreateHardLink. It doesn't seem to exist in VC++ 6 though. I was hoping to create a hard link file, see what I can find out about them.

Taken from here:

A hard link to a file is indistinguishable from the original name for the file; there's no particular link that is more the "real name" for the file than any other.

I guess there isn't much I can do about hard link files.

Off Topic

Something thats just sort of bugging me, whats with all the typedef's and #define's in the C++ headers?

typedef LPCSTR LPCTSTR; typedef CONST CHAR *LPCSTR, *PCSTR; #define CONST const, typedef char CHAR; etc.

I really don't see the point. It just makes C++ harder to learn trying to memorize all these "types", and overall makes code harder to read if you don't know what a certain typedef or define is.

  • 0

I've actually written 2 apps for creating soft and hard links. If anyone wants, I can post them.

If you use CreateHardLink, you'll probably need to install the platform sdk and change the vc++ includes/libs directories. Interestingly, there is a new CreateSymbolicLink on msdn that only works with longhorn.

@xinok: these namings are generally acronyms. LPCTSTR means Long Pointer Const null-Terminating STRing. Another one is TCHAR, which is CHAR on ANSI and WCHAR on UNICODE. CHAR is char because win32 uses all caps for structures and primitives.

  • 0
  Andareed said:
I've actually written 2 apps for creating soft and hard links. If anyone wants, I can post them.

586280364[/snapback]

I'd appreciate it if I can get those apps :yes: And thanks ahead of time.
  • 0

Alright, I was able to solve this little riddle. First, creating a hard link file can be done from a command in windows:

fsutil hardlink create c:\output.txt c:\input.txt

Now testing for duplicates (I already tried this, it also locks hard link files):

We have the inputfile and outputfile

First, open the inputfile, but deny access to all other processes (lock the file)

Now try opening the outputfile. If it succeeds, the files are different. If it fails, continue...

Unlock the inputfile, and try opening the outputfile again. If it succeeds this time, then the files are the same. If it fails again, something else is wrong so return an error. :)

  • 0

Couldn't find softlink app but I based it on the code from here: http://www.codeproject.com/w2k/junctionpoints.asp

The hardlink app just uses CreateHardLink. There is also a sysinternals tool with source called junction: http://www.sysinternals.com/Utilities/Junction.html

  • 0
  df_dukkar said:
could u tell me how to lock down a file ??

586282181[/snapback]

I used the OpenFile function.

#include <windows.h>

char* file = "file.dat";

OFSTRUCT fileinfo;

long handle = OpenFile(file, &fileinfo, OF_SHARE_EXCLUSIVE);

  • 0
  Quote
PIDL's are only used in the shell.

That doesn't mean that you can still use them, if theu turn out to be usefull for your purpose.

You're right about hard and soft links tho. Maybe it's possible to use one of those Nt* API's to determine the file-block they 'link' too.

This topic is now closed to further replies.
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Posts

    • Microsoft PC Manager 3.17.4.0 (Offline Installer) by Razvan Serea With Microsoft PC Manager, users can easily perform basic computer maintenance and enhance the speed of their devices with just one click. This app offers a range of features, including disk cleanup, startup app management, virus scanning, Windows Update checks, process monitoring, and storage management. Microsoft PC Manager key features: Storage Manager- easily uninstall infrequently used apps, manage large files, perform a cleanup, and set up Storage Sense to automatically clear temporary files. Health Checkup feature -scans for potential problems, viruses, and startup programs to turn off. It helps you identify unnecessary items to remove, optimizing your system's performance. Pop-up Management - block pop-up windows from appearing in apps. Windows Update - scans your system for any pending updates. Startup Apps - enable or disable startup apps on your PC, allowing you to optimize your system's startup performance. Browser Protection - rest assured that harmful programs cannot alter your default browser. Also enables you to change your default browser. Process Management - allows you to conveniently terminate any active process, ensuring optimal system performance and resource utilization. Anti-virus protection - Fully integrated with Windows Security. Safeguard your PC anytime. Quick Steps: Download Microsoft PC Manager Offline Installer (APPX/MSIX) with Adguard Adguard serves as a third-party online service, offering a user-friendly method for directly downloading appx, appxbundle, and msixbundle files from the Microsoft Store. Official download links will be generated for both the app's various versions and its dependency packages. How to download Microsoft PC Manager Offline Installer (APPX/MSIX) 1. Initially, you must find the app URL within the Microsoft Store. Access the Microsoft Store via your browser and search for "Microsoft PC Manager". Once located, copy the app URL, which includes the product ID, either from the address bar or from the provided link below. https://apps.microsoft.com/detail/9PM860492SZD 2. Now paste the app URL into the designated area, then click the check mark button to produce a direct download link. 3. To download, right-click the relevant link and select “Save link as…” from your browser's menu. Occasionally, Microsoft Edge may flag the download as insecure. In such cases, consider utilizing alternative browsers such as Google Chrome or Firefox to successfully complete the download. Microsoft PC Manager is a completely free tool optimized exclusively for use on Windows 10 (version 1809 or newer) and Windows 11. Download: Microsoft PC Manager 3.17.4.0 | from Microsoft Store View: Microsoft PC Manager Home Page Get alerted to all of our Software updates on Twitter at @NeowinSoftware
    • You might want to update to 1TB drive.  They are not very expensive these days, there are plenty of options - simple look I would think you could find a 1TB ssd or even nvme somewhere between 50 and 100 bucks. when I have moved to larger ssds in laptop in the past, you can just connect the drive via usb - image.  Then take the old drive out, put in the new drive and there you go..  If your concerned about how much space you have left this prob your best bet..   
    • I see! Wasn’t aware of that. Even though they started off with desktop app for Mac before Windows. Should be on it’s way soon! 🤞
    • support.microsoft.com/en-us/topic/microsoft-defender-update-for-windows-operating-system-installation-images-1c89630b-61ff-00a1-04e2-2d1f3865450d
    • It's a Developer Beta 1 not even a Public or User Beta, I doubt any of the design is 100% finalized yet.
  • Recent Achievements

    • First Post
      Johnny Mrkvička earned a badge
      First Post
    • Week One Done
      viraltui earned a badge
      Week One Done
    • One Month Later
      serfegyed earned a badge
      One Month Later
    • Dedicated
      firey earned a badge
      Dedicated
    • Dedicated
      fettermanj earned a badge
      Dedicated
  • Popular Contributors

    1. 1
      +primortal
      627
    2. 2
      ATLien_0
      223
    3. 3
      Michael Scrip
      217
    4. 4
      Xenon
      149
    5. 5
      Steven P.
      139
  • Tell a friend

    Love Neowin? Tell a friend!