Allchin on Vista: "It's Not Going to Work"


Recommended Posts

This whole fuss was about the restart of the coding. The first "wave" of Longhorn Builds (the 4xxx series) was based on Windows XP SP1 I believe. With the 5048 build, Microsoft completely restarted coding (although they didn't really "lose" any work) but basing themselves on the Windows Server 2003 codebase.

It wasn't really abandoned. The PDC would not have taken place if it had been cancelled.

if that was true, MS would have charged for it

No.

586583661[/snapback]

well you entitled to you opinion, just as I am...I would have like to have seen the registry gone, once and for all, that would have been revolutionary, other than that I still say its an upgrade to XP

Edited by Kilgore Trout

[Thread from Windows Beta Discussion Merged with this one]

What I love about these articles is how they're written in the future

586583748[/snapback]

It's been Tuesday for some time in the land down under.

Now, tell me, can you hear the thunder?

why don't people notice.. that Microsoft can't live on windows XP forever.. people want change.. people want upgrades.

and this article is so old... why can't people wait till it's done, before shooting there mouth off?

Play it before you hate it.

watch... vista will come out and will best os x with all of its features, and people will still say 'vista is just xp sp3', probably the same people who had said os x was far better than windows xp.

the article talks about how allchin wanted windows to be able to have a component taken out and still have it work; that sounds like what we've been hearing about vista when it was still called longhorn. this article is probably referring to events that happened before microsoft started revealing to developers what longhorn would consist of.

a lot of talk about things being abandoned for longhorn really make no sense for people who have followed it in the news. on the surface windows might not look that different, i think people expect too much. have you all watched the downloadable videos of allchin promoting longhorn features?

nobody is saying Vista isn't coming out. the original WSJ ariticle documents the more ambitious features being jettisoned and why

586583613[/snapback]

One feature of Vista was dropped, that being of WinFS and that was ONLY dropped from shipping with Vista. It's already out in beta and will be in beta when VISTA ships, big whoop.

Geeeez guys, make this into something it's not!

Vista is not XP service pack 3, if you think that, then you will be in for a shock.

Ugh, what a terribly written "article."

It's about one of the Longhorn resets that happened well over a year ago. It's not news. There were many reasons for the Longhorn resets... A big part of the second reset was because of XP SP2 and Win2003 SP1. A lot of resources were devoted to those projects for a long time, as well as the x64 versions of Win2k3. Longhorn was reset to a new starting point working from the work done on the Win2k3 SP1 release. There were other changes... A lot was learned in the development of XP SP2 and 2003 SP1. This surely influenced the development process for Longhorn. There were other changes, too. It was determined that building an OS on top of Avalon, Indigo, and WinFS was a bad idea when those technologies wouldn't be completed until near the same time as the OS itself.

That's what I think Allchin was talking about... You can't say "Avalon and WinFS will be done in June, we'll build the Explorer shell and browser, on top of them and ship it in August." That's not enough time. The shell team would be sitting on their proverbial asses waiting for the technology to be there.

summing up: the grand plans were abandoned, and now we have Window XP second edition

586583560[/snapback]

if that was true, MS would have charged for it

well you entitled to you opinion, just as I am...I would have like to have seen the registry gone, once and for all, that would have been revolutionary, other than that I still say its an upgrade to XP

586583765[/snapback]

Vista is a bigger change than any of the following

95 -> 98

98 -> 98SE

98SE -> ME

ME -> XP is arguable since they started using the NT kernel, but I'd say it's still bigger.

Now if it's bigger than at least those first 3, why would you fcall it XP SP3 or XP second edition? That's just ridiculous.

Vista is a bigger change than any of the following

95 -> 98

98 -> 98SE

98SE -> ME

ME -> XP is arguable since they started using the NT kernel, but I'd say it's still bigger.

Now if it's bigger than at least those first 3, why would you fcall it XP SP3 or XP second edition?  That's just ridiculous.

586584911[/snapback]

The development cycle is remiscent of NT4 -> Windows 2000 (NT5).

However, I don't think it's necessarily as big a change as that. Even if it is technologically, it won't be as important... because Windows 2000 made NT useable for home users (even if it wasn't perfect for it til XP).

does anybody remember Gates saying, as big as "windows 95? its been scaled back, let's admit it, I'm not out to bash MS, but they have been working on WinFS since Cairo, I'll take a wait and see attitude

Edited by Kilgore Trout
This topic is now closed to further replies.
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Posts

    • Ford execs say they made a mistake when they replaced human engineers with AI by David Uzondu Ford recently announced that over the last three years, it's had to rehire about 350 "gray beard" engineers to mentor younger staff and reprogram diagnostic systems and AI tools that were failing to meet up to quality expectations. The company's VP of vehicle hardware engineering, Charles **** said that leaders overlooked the deep experience of veterans who survived many product cycles. **** admitted that simply replacing them with AI was a huge mistake, and that while AI is "a fantastic tool," it remains "only as good as the information you use to train it." The rehired engineers now run mandatory meetings to troubleshoot vehicles and reprogram automated engineering software and AI tools to prevent glitches before production. These technical specialists hunt for failure points before parts ever reach the plant floor, helping prevent the massive recalls and defects that previously cost the company billions as it aims to cut one billion dollars in expenses this year. In last year's JD Power Quality Survey, an annual study that measures the quality of a car during the first three months of ownership, Ford finished 10th among mainstream brands and scored below the industry average. But this year, JD Power ranked the automaker as the top mainstream brand, placing it above the likes of Toyota Motor Corp. and Honda Motor Co. Ford attributed this massive improvement directly to the expertise of these returned engineers. Ford's realization that AI cannot magically design and test quality vehicles without senior human oversight is just the tip of the iceberg. When Careerminds looked at companies that conducted AI-driven layoffs, researchers found out that 35.6% of those companies had to rehire more than half of the employees they previously fired. Another 32.7% had to rehire between 25% and 50% of them. In 2024, Sebastian Siemiatkowski, CEO of Klarna, proudly announced that its new chatbot was doing the work of 700 full-time customer service agents. As a result, the fintech company froze hiring and cut hundreds of positions. But by mid 2025, and into 2026, Klarna was scrambling to recruit human agents again because customer satisfaction had plummeted. It turns out, while AI is very good at answering basic questions like how to check an account balance, when faced with complex customer issues that require nuance, the thing usually resorts to the unhelpful, robotic corporate jargon we all know and love.
    • Free AI in IDEs is shifting to paid models Or you know, you could just learn to actually design and code apps, use frameworks to handle the repetitive parts and not use AI at all - and voila... free for life!
    • In a sane world US antitrust laws wouldn't even allow these companies to be in the position to be subjected to EU directives. As you say, better than oligarch nothing.
    • Apple reportedly has a second-generation iPhone Fold planned for 2027 Good grief, Apple hasn't even released a first folding phone and the Apple faithful is already obsessing over the sequel? Seriously people, go out and touch grass... because this level of obsession is borderline stalkery/neurotic.
    • I checked on the IPs associated with every login and they're all mine... And whenever I get a new prompt, there is no activity to show for it. 
  • Recent Achievements

    • Week One Done
      xvvxcvv earned a badge
      Week One Done
    • One Month Later
      xvvxcvv earned a badge
      One Month Later
    • Enthusiast
      Xonos went up a rank
      Enthusiast
    • Conversation Starter
      Admir earned a badge
      Conversation Starter
    • First Post
      The_Focal_Point earned a badge
      First Post
  • Popular Contributors

    1. 1
      +primortal
      405
    2. 2
      +Edouard
      169
    3. 3
      PsYcHoKiLLa
      129
    4. 4
      neufuse
      69
    5. 5
      Xenon
      68
  • Tell a friend

    Love Neowin? Tell a friend!