• 0

Java: Prevent opening duplicate dialogs


Question

I'm working on a java project that it has a menu where you can click File > Login to pop out a dialog for user to enter their login info.

My problem is, when the login dialog is present, user and focus back to the main JFrame and select File > Login to pop out another dialog. I'm searching for a way to prevent this from happening. So far I thought about two solutions but I don't know which is the best way to go about solving this kind of issue:

Solution 1: In my customzied JFrame class, declare a boolean that holds the visibility of the login dialog. Whenever the user goes File > Login, it will first check to see if it's already visible or not, then open the dialog if it's not already opened.

Solution 2: Prevent user to set focus back to the main JFrame when the dialog box is opened.

If you were me, how would you approach this problem? And which one is more effective or a common practice?

8 answers to this question

Recommended Posts

  • 0

erm... make the dialog modal. that should fix it.

if you don't want a modal dialog, you can have a private static bool isOpened=false;

that when it's opened it sets that to true and sets back to false when its closed. and on the creator of that dialog it just fails if the isOpened is true :p

i'd _really_ recommend the modal approach :p

  • 0
  Menge said:

erm... make the dialog modal. that should fix it.

if you don't want a modal dialog, you can have a private static bool isOpened=false;

that when it's opened it sets that to true and sets back to false when its closed. and on the creator of that dialog it just fails if the isOpened is true :p

i'd _really_ recommend the modal approach :p

That's not necessary. Create just one instance of it (global in your class that you're showing it in) and just have it so it hides when it closes:

myDialog.setDefaultCloseOperation(WindowConstants.HIDE_ON_CLOSE);

which is the default action.

And to make it visible:

myDialog.setVisible(true);

And if you're having to do some custom listener stuff for buttons and stuff and want to hide it after the user clicks it, put:

myDialog.setVisible(false);

in your action listener.

Edited by kjordan2001
  • 0
  kjordan2001 said:

That's not necessary. Create just one instance of it (global in your class that you're showing it in) and just have it so it hides when it closes:

myDialog.setDefaultCloseOperation(WindowConstants.HIDE_ON_CLOSE);

which is the default action.

And to make it visible:

myDialog.setVisible(true);

And if you're having to do some custom listener stuff for buttons and stuff and want to hide it after the user clicks it, put:

myDialog.setVisible(false);

in your action listener.

But if you do that, if people type info in the fields. You'll have to manually reset the fields, otherwise the next time the dialog shows, the info from the previous time the dialog was shown, will still be present.

  • 0
  Winston said:

But if you do that, if people type info in the fields. You'll have to manually reset the fields, otherwise the next time the dialog shows, the info from the previous time the dialog was shown, will still be present.

Just have it reset them in the submit action listener. Either way you'll have to do some work, question is which kind. Resetting or setting a variable.

  • 0

The best solution is to make the dialog a singleton ... ie only one instance can ever be created. Its called the singleton pattern. Its design pattern, google it

heres a quick example

public class MyFrame extends JFrame {

   public static MyFrame instance;

   private MyFrame() {
	 super(); 
   }

   public static MyFrame getInstance() {
	  if (instance = null)
		  instance = new MyFrame();
	  return instance;
   }

   main() {

	 MyFrame.getInstance().setVisbile(true);
	 ... or
	 MyFrame frame = MyFrame.getInstance();
	 frame.setVisible(true);
   }

   public void cleanup() {
	 instance = null;
  }
}

you will only ever get this one dialog only one instance can every be created. Note: you will need to free the instance yourself as the JVM will not clean it up.

This topic is now closed to further replies.
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Posts

    • Not to sound ungrateful for your continued presence on Neowin (which I prefer) 😛  But would you consider a subscription to just have all the third party ads turned off by us? It's $28 ($2.33 per month) for the ad-free subscription, but it is also there for assistance and support with all the running costs. Like everything, it is becoming increasingly harder to do this, we even try to offset it with Amazon affiliate commissions (if we could finance totally through that instead of ads, I would) 😛 
    • Honestly, I don't remember accepting or refusing cookies following a prompt, because I've accepted or refused cookies on several other sites. On the other hand, I remember seeing  ads, before the start of the available articles (on the home page), and on the right. If the trackers I've mentioned are part of the cookies I have to accept (as well as those below), trackers that are detected by my antivirus as adware during the weekly scan, they'll remain where they are. The vast majority of cookies blocked by the Host file were added by Unchecky. I'd say so, but are Doubleclick, Scorecardresearch, Opencandy, file2desktop, etc. among those that should be accepted? If not, then I'd say no.  
    • Are you suggesting Vivaldi isn't Chromium-based or that it isn't fast? In any case, Skyfrog seems more focused on customizability.
    • "They fear that this collaboration could significantly bolster China's AI capabilities" how long is this supposed to stop china?, 5 years and then become an AI giant?, china is gonna be as big as the US in AI in no time
    • yeah... I'm gonna say this aint tech news either, don't turn this site into the verge......
  • Recent Achievements

    • Week One Done
      jbatch earned a badge
      Week One Done
    • First Post
      Yianis earned a badge
      First Post
    • Rookie
      GTRoberts went up a rank
      Rookie
    • First Post
      James courage Tabla earned a badge
      First Post
    • Reacting Well
      James courage Tabla earned a badge
      Reacting Well
  • Popular Contributors

    1. 1
      +primortal
      403
    2. 2
      +FloatingFatMan
      179
    3. 3
      snowy owl
      172
    4. 4
      ATLien_0
      170
    5. 5
      Xenon
      135
  • Tell a friend

    Love Neowin? Tell a friend!