• 0

[VB.NET] Deleting string from text file


Question

9 answers to this question

Recommended Posts

  • 0
  Puggsley said:
I need to search through a .txt file and remove a specific string. Anything i've found so far deletes a specific line number, but the string could appear on any line.

Ok, this answer will work, but I'm sure there are less expensive ways to achive the desired result. That said... Load the entire file into a string (oh my!) and then do a String.Replace("OLD VALUE", "") and then save the string to the file.

If the file is small, this is not a big deal, if the file is large it can take a serious chunk of memory.

If I think of something else I'll post back.

  • 0

Thanks for the prompt reply!

Thats the best solution i could come up with as well. As for the file size, there is about 10 files, varying from 20kb to 5mb so it could be a problem. Time and memory isn't too much of an issue and if it becomes one then it is something to look at in the future, but right now its more important to get something working

How much of a problem do you think it will be?

  • 0

I think the 5mb file is a LITTLE bit of an issue, but since these days (as opposed to 1995) memory is cheap and plentiful it's not something I would freak about.

If you write your code well, when you find a better solution, you'll be able to change that small chunk of code and get better performance. (hack? oh a little)

If it was me, and I was out of time, I'd go with the original idea and then at a later date do the performance gain. I've done tech work for 20 years and dev for 15. *I* find it most important to get the job done, over having it done well. Done well is nice, but not if it's NOT done. (read that sentence carefully)

  • 0

Would it be possible to read the file just one line at a time? This way only one line will have to be in memory. There may be a way to loop this method until the end of file has been reached. Just search through each line one at a time for the string to remove it. After the line has been analyzed, unload it and load the next line.

I'm not sure how you would go about coding this, but perhaps the idea will spark something. :)

  • 0

The problem with the "line by line" is that VB opens access to the file and will allocate a chunk of memory near the size of the file in either case. This is a concern and I'm sure there is a better solution that I have stated above... at the moment I don't have one. (sorry)

EDIT:

I thought I'd make a comment here: Besides the coding issues another point of development work is to know which goals to reach for... I had a friend back in San Francisco that spent a month creating a reporting engine in VB. Considering his fee and the abilities of VB the time would have been much better spent purchasing Crystal Reports or some other engine and having a large number of reports created by the end of that first month. (of course there are arguments for creating the engine, but in this case it was a serious waste of the client's cash)

SOMETIMES getting something done quickly vs writing tight, memory and CPU light code is better. It's a case by case issue based on the information at hand and the time alotted.

Just food for thought.

Peace,

James Rose

New York City

Edited by jameswjrose
  • 0

OK, so i took the plunge and went with the original suggestion but am having real difficulties getting it to work

To make sure its nothing else in the program i created a new project and put the following code on the form load event and created a text file with the contents "Hello World" in the output folder

Dim FileContents as String
Dim objReader as System.IO.StreamReader
objReader - New StreamReader(Environment.CurrentDirectory & "\test.txt")
FileContents = objReader.ReadToEnd
objReader.Close
FileContents.Replace("Hello", "")
Dim objWriter as System.IO.StreamWriter
objWriter = New StreamWriter(Environment.CurrentDirectory & "\test.txt")
objWriter.Write(FileContents)
objWriter.Close

From watching in explorer the program seems to zero byte the file and then write exactly the same contents back again.

Any ideas would be greatly appreciated!

This topic is now closed to further replies.
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Posts

    • Watchdog finds Microsoft guilty of confusing advertising when it comes to Copilot by Usama Jawad While Microsoft is advocating for Copilot usage in both personal and enterprise environments as much as possible, it arguably hasn't made as big of a splash as it wanted. Now, the U.S. watchdog National Advertising Division (NAD) has criticized Microsoft for some of its advertising practices when it comes to Copilot. In a recent blog post spotted by The Verge, NAD noted that Copilot does possess the functionalities that Microsoft expressly claims it does in enterprise use cases. This includes capabilities like summarization of content, generating text, and creating outlines for PowerPoint slide decks. While Copilot does have some limitations in this area, NAD thinks that they are pretty minor, so the lack of disclosure in this area doesn't really impact how most customers leverage Copilot. That said, the watchdog discovered some problems in Microsoft's messaging when it came to Business Chat. It believes that Redmond's universal and interchangeable use of Copilot for both the assistant and Business Chat can cause confusion among users, as they judge their functionalities. For example, NAD argues that while Copilot is quite fast at seamlessly generating documents in other applications, this is not the case with Business Chat, which requires more manual steps, and this is not abundantly clear in the advertising on Microsoft's website. Finally, NAD advised Microsoft to get rid of its claims regarding an increase in productivity and ROI because while the tech giant does have supporting studies to back its boasts, they do not provide a "good fit" for objective claims. It's also worth highlighting that the UK government recently did trial Copilot in work environments and discovered that participants did save 26 minutes per day on average. Still, it seems like this is not good enough for NAD. Interestingly, Microsoft did respond to NAD's advisory, saying that while it disagrees with some of the watchdog's findings, it has made changes to its advertising messages in order to comply with NAD's recommendations. Source: NAD via The Verge
    • My new emergency poo ticket holder
    • These are the same ignorant, gullible, cowardly fools who still believe that gods are real and that fictional White Jesus is coming back to Earth "any day now". It's a Venn-diagram of two almost perfectly concentric circles. In short, they'll buy anything you lie to them about as long as it makes them less afraid... Of things the rest of us know we don't have to be afraid of at all.
    • It isn't fair to shift all blame to the user. Yes, the user shouldn't have blindly trusted MS with all their data, but assuming the facts reported are correct, MS massively screwed up too. Both can be true.
    • How about with add up/down votes on posts instead? Then we could upvote posts that are True based on the facts and supported by evidence. And we could also downvote the ridiculous paranoid rantings of ignorant, gullible, cowardly people who still fall for ancient proven lies and obvious fearmongering scams behind such nonsense like white supremacy, Nazism, Trumpism, etc. I'm willing to give it a try. How about you?
  • Recent Achievements

    • Experienced
      dismuter went up a rank
      Experienced
    • One Month Later
      mevinyavin earned a badge
      One Month Later
    • Week One Done
      rozermack875 earned a badge
      Week One Done
    • Week One Done
      oneworldtechnologies earned a badge
      Week One Done
    • Veteran
      matthiew went up a rank
      Veteran
  • Popular Contributors

    1. 1
      +primortal
      699
    2. 2
      ATLien_0
      268
    3. 3
      Michael Scrip
      211
    4. 4
      +FloatingFatMan
      186
    5. 5
      Steven P.
      142
  • Tell a friend

    Love Neowin? Tell a friend!