• 0

[VB.NET] Deleting string from text file

Asked by Puggsley,

 Share

Question

9 answers to this question

Recommended Posts

  • 0
Veteran

James Rose

Posted
Posted
  Puggsley said:
I need to search through a .txt file and remove a specific string. Anything i've found so far deletes a specific line number, but the string could appear on any line.

Ok, this answer will work, but I'm sure there are less expensive ways to achive the desired result. That said... Load the entire file into a string (oh my!) and then do a String.Replace("OLD VALUE", "") and then save the string to the file.

If the file is small, this is not a big deal, if the file is large it can take a serious chunk of memory.

If I think of something else I'll post back.

  • 0
Proficient

Puggsley

Posted
  • Author
Posted

Thanks for the prompt reply!

Thats the best solution i could come up with as well. As for the file size, there is about 10 files, varying from 20kb to 5mb so it could be a problem. Time and memory isn't too much of an issue and if it becomes one then it is something to look at in the future, but right now its more important to get something working

How much of a problem do you think it will be?

  • 0
Veteran

James Rose

Posted
Posted

I think the 5mb file is a LITTLE bit of an issue, but since these days (as opposed to 1995) memory is cheap and plentiful it's not something I would freak about.

If you write your code well, when you find a better solution, you'll be able to change that small chunk of code and get better performance. (hack? oh a little)

If it was me, and I was out of time, I'd go with the original idea and then at a later date do the performance gain. I've done tech work for 20 years and dev for 15. *I* find it most important to get the job done, over having it done well. Done well is nice, but not if it's NOT done. (read that sentence carefully)

  • 0
Enthusiast

MECL

Posted
Posted

Would it be possible to read the file just one line at a time? This way only one line will have to be in memory. There may be a way to loop this method until the end of file has been reached. Just search through each line one at a time for the string to remove it. After the line has been analyzed, unload it and load the next line.

I'm not sure how you would go about coding this, but perhaps the idea will spark something. :)

  • 0
Veteran

James Rose

Posted
Posted (edited)

The problem with the "line by line" is that VB opens access to the file and will allocate a chunk of memory near the size of the file in either case. This is a concern and I'm sure there is a better solution that I have stated above... at the moment I don't have one. (sorry)

EDIT:

I thought I'd make a comment here: Besides the coding issues another point of development work is to know which goals to reach for... I had a friend back in San Francisco that spent a month creating a reporting engine in VB. Considering his fee and the abilities of VB the time would have been much better spent purchasing Crystal Reports or some other engine and having a large number of reports created by the end of that first month. (of course there are arguments for creating the engine, but in this case it was a serious waste of the client's cash)

SOMETIMES getting something done quickly vs writing tight, memory and CPU light code is better. It's a case by case issue based on the information at hand and the time alotted.

Just food for thought.

Peace,

James Rose

New York City

Edited by jameswjrose
  • 0
Proficient

Puggsley

Posted
  • Author
Posted

OK, so i took the plunge and went with the original suggestion but am having real difficulties getting it to work

To make sure its nothing else in the program i created a new project and put the following code on the form load event and created a text file with the contents "Hello World" in the output folder

Dim FileContents as String
Dim objReader as System.IO.StreamReader
objReader - New StreamReader(Environment.CurrentDirectory & "\test.txt")
FileContents = objReader.ReadToEnd
objReader.Close
FileContents.Replace("Hello", "")
Dim objWriter as System.IO.StreamWriter
objWriter = New StreamWriter(Environment.CurrentDirectory & "\test.txt")
objWriter.Write(FileContents)
objWriter.Close

From watching in explorer the program seems to zero byte the file and then write exactly the same contents back again.

Any ideas would be greatly appreciated!

This topic is now closed to further replies.
 Share
Go to question listing

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.

  • Posts

    • Microsoft and Crowdstrike announce partnership on threat actor naming

      By TheGhostPhantom · Posted

      Crowdstrike the same service provider that caused millions of in damages? I hate disliking a company for a singular failure but they really screwed up.
    • Windows 11's growth slowed down in May 2025

      By The Werewolf · Posted

      I see you subscribe to the Linux/macOS approach to winning over converts...
    • Windows 11's growth slowed down in May 2025

      By The Werewolf · Posted

      As we get closer to October 2025 and the end of Windows 10 support, Windows 11 will pick up its pace and soon become the most popular desktop operating system worldwide. That's an assertion. It's also quite possible that the only growth will come from attrition as people and companies buy new machines that only come with Win11. It's also possible that we'll get a literal repeat of Win XP and Win 7, where a large number of users just waited until Microsoft gave in and fixed the core problems that the consumers were complaining about in Win Vista and Win 8 when they released Win 7 and Win 10.
    • SteamOS falls to lowest adoption level in years as Steam on Linux use rises

      By Geezy · Posted

      It's significant growth for Linux considering the market share, so it could have had that effect I described.
    • Microsoft and Crowdstrike announce partnership on threat actor naming

      By pradeepviswav · Posted

      Microsoft and Crowdstrike announce partnership on threat actor naming by Pradeep Viswanathan Whenever a cyberattack is discovered, companies disclose it to the public and assign it a unique name based on their internal procedures. Unfortunately, this leads to inconsistencies, as each company has its own naming conventions. As a result, the same threat actor behind a cyberattack may end up with multiple names, causing delays and confusion in response efforts. For example, a threat actor that Microsoft refers to as Midnight Blizzard might be known as Cozy Bear, APT29, or UNC2452 by other security vendors. To address this issue, Microsoft and CrowdStrike are teaming up. These companies will align their individual threat actor taxonomies to help security professionals respond to cyberattacks with greater clarity and confidence. It’s important to note that Microsoft and CrowdStrike are not attempting to create a single naming standard. Instead, they are releasing a mapping that lists common threat actors tracked by both companies, matched according to their respective taxonomies. The mapping also includes corresponding aliases from each group’s naming system. You can view the joint threat actor mapping by Microsoft and CrowdStrike here. Although this threat actor taxonomy mapping is a joint effort between Microsoft and CrowdStrike, Google/Mandiant and Palo Alto Networks' Unit 42 are expected to contribute to this initiative in the future. Vasu Jakkal, Corporate Vice President of Microsoft Security, wrote the following about this collaboration with CrowdStrike: As more organizations join this initiative, the collective defense against cyber threats will undoubtedly be improved.

  • Recent Achievements

    • One Year In
      WaynesWorld earned a badge
      One Year In
    • First Post
      chriskinney317 earned a badge
      First Post
    • Week One Done
      Nullun earned a badge
      Week One Done
    • First Post
      sultangris earned a badge
      First Post
    • Reacting Well
      sultangris earned a badge
      Reacting Well

  • Popular Contributors

    1. 1
      +primortal
      173
    2. 2
      ATLien_0
      125
    3. 3
      snowy owl
      122
    4. 4
      Xenon
      116
    5. 5
      +Edouard
      93
    Show More

  • Tell a friend

    Love Neowin? Tell a friend!