• 0

[VB.NET] Deleting string from text file


Question

9 answers to this question

Recommended Posts

  • 0
  Puggsley said:
I need to search through a .txt file and remove a specific string. Anything i've found so far deletes a specific line number, but the string could appear on any line.

Ok, this answer will work, but I'm sure there are less expensive ways to achive the desired result. That said... Load the entire file into a string (oh my!) and then do a String.Replace("OLD VALUE", "") and then save the string to the file.

If the file is small, this is not a big deal, if the file is large it can take a serious chunk of memory.

If I think of something else I'll post back.

  • 0

Thanks for the prompt reply!

Thats the best solution i could come up with as well. As for the file size, there is about 10 files, varying from 20kb to 5mb so it could be a problem. Time and memory isn't too much of an issue and if it becomes one then it is something to look at in the future, but right now its more important to get something working

How much of a problem do you think it will be?

  • 0

I think the 5mb file is a LITTLE bit of an issue, but since these days (as opposed to 1995) memory is cheap and plentiful it's not something I would freak about.

If you write your code well, when you find a better solution, you'll be able to change that small chunk of code and get better performance. (hack? oh a little)

If it was me, and I was out of time, I'd go with the original idea and then at a later date do the performance gain. I've done tech work for 20 years and dev for 15. *I* find it most important to get the job done, over having it done well. Done well is nice, but not if it's NOT done. (read that sentence carefully)

  • 0

Would it be possible to read the file just one line at a time? This way only one line will have to be in memory. There may be a way to loop this method until the end of file has been reached. Just search through each line one at a time for the string to remove it. After the line has been analyzed, unload it and load the next line.

I'm not sure how you would go about coding this, but perhaps the idea will spark something. :)

  • 0

The problem with the "line by line" is that VB opens access to the file and will allocate a chunk of memory near the size of the file in either case. This is a concern and I'm sure there is a better solution that I have stated above... at the moment I don't have one. (sorry)

EDIT:

I thought I'd make a comment here: Besides the coding issues another point of development work is to know which goals to reach for... I had a friend back in San Francisco that spent a month creating a reporting engine in VB. Considering his fee and the abilities of VB the time would have been much better spent purchasing Crystal Reports or some other engine and having a large number of reports created by the end of that first month. (of course there are arguments for creating the engine, but in this case it was a serious waste of the client's cash)

SOMETIMES getting something done quickly vs writing tight, memory and CPU light code is better. It's a case by case issue based on the information at hand and the time alotted.

Just food for thought.

Peace,

James Rose

New York City

Edited by jameswjrose
  • 0

OK, so i took the plunge and went with the original suggestion but am having real difficulties getting it to work

To make sure its nothing else in the program i created a new project and put the following code on the form load event and created a text file with the contents "Hello World" in the output folder

Dim FileContents as String
Dim objReader as System.IO.StreamReader
objReader - New StreamReader(Environment.CurrentDirectory & "\test.txt")
FileContents = objReader.ReadToEnd
objReader.Close
FileContents.Replace("Hello", "")
Dim objWriter as System.IO.StreamWriter
objWriter = New StreamWriter(Environment.CurrentDirectory & "\test.txt")
objWriter.Write(FileContents)
objWriter.Close

From watching in explorer the program seems to zero byte the file and then write exactly the same contents back again.

Any ideas would be greatly appreciated!

This topic is now closed to further replies.
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Posts

    • Yetis often do eat llamas. I'm not guessing.
    • Since I watch on a lot of devices and use the music service, I enjoy it. Like if I was just on PC then yeah use adblock. But I'm on watching on my phone, iPad, and TV and not always on my WiFi. The price is getting a little nuts at this point though.
    • Happens EVERY TIME a new version of WMP-HC comes out and you download it in the first few days of release. Happens a lot with other program updates that get listed in the software section here as well.
    • Hitman maker's first showcase will reveal its new James Bond game this week by Pulasthi Ariyasinghe IO Interactive is well known for its development of the Hitman series of stealth and assassination games. In a fitting twist, it was revealed back in 2020 that the studio has begun work on a James Bond game, and after years in development, it seems fans are finally getting a look at the project. Announced today, the project now has a title: 007 First Light. The brand-new game will be revealed in an exclusive showcase event. Coming in as the first ever IOI Showcase, it will be held on June 6 at 6pm PDT on the studio's own YouTube channel. "Join us for the first ever IOI SHOWCASE," said the studio in a social media post today. "Set your reminders and don't miss out on the exclusive reveals and information straight from the team!" Aside from 007 First Light information, the showcase will feature new content reveals for Hitman World of Assassination, the IO Interactive-published title MindsEye developed by Build a Rocket Boy, and more. The game is set to follow James Bond in his start as the MI6 special operative that everyone now knows him as. The origin story is said to be inspired by novels of Ian Fleming as well as the movie franchise, but it will be an original narrative by the developer. While we haven't even seen the game in action yet, IO Interactive CEO Hakan Abrak has already said that he hopes the game is successful enough to spawn a trilogy. "I don't want to speak too big about it, but I just hope we'll do a thing that will define James Bond in gaming for years to come," said Abrak last year. "And that is not only one game, but that we create a universe for gamers to own for many years to come that we can grow with that next to the Bond on the movies." While the studio hasn't revealed much more about 007 First Light since its original announcement, it has already been confirmed as coming for the Nintendo Switch 2 console. Other platforms have not been announced just yet, but it should land for PC, Xbox Series X|S, and PlayStation 5 consoles like the studio's other projects.
  • Recent Achievements

    • Week One Done
      Nullun earned a badge
      Week One Done
    • First Post
      sultangris earned a badge
      First Post
    • Reacting Well
      sultangris earned a badge
      Reacting Well
    • First Post
      ClarkB earned a badge
      First Post
    • Week One Done
      Epaminombas earned a badge
      Week One Done
  • Popular Contributors

    1. 1
      +primortal
      164
    2. 2
      ATLien_0
      125
    3. 3
      Xenon
      119
    4. 4
      snowy owl
      115
    5. 5
      +Edouard
      97
  • Tell a friend

    Love Neowin? Tell a friend!