Why do LCD Computer monitors expensive?


Recommended Posts

Lately, I've been looking for an LCD computer monitor and the cheapest one I found was $220. Why are they still so expensive after they've been out for so long? LCD monitors are just so expensive that I just ordered a brand new computer instead with an LCD included. Only cost me $650 total for everything. It seems to be cheaper that way rather than buying a monitor separately.

I remember CRT monitors used to cost only $50-60. Why don't LCDs ever go that low?

Edit: A little typo on my subject. The actual subject is supposed to be "Why are LCD Computer monitors expensive?" Sorry for the mistake but I'm unable to edit it and fix it.

You must like cheap products in small sizes, I prefer to buy things that will work and have displays big enough that I can read the text or easily view a digital camera image without scrolling. Enjoy the dead pixels, large dot pitch, and poor color dithering of your $50 LCD you got there buddy.

Maybe it's just me, but I don't remember CRT's ever being that cheap except if they were used. Besides, quality CRT monitors, widescreen CRT's and CRT's larger than 17" were always relatively expensive. You can get a 19" widescreen LCD for $170, you would never find a widescreen 19" CRT for that cheap.

  Budious said:
You must like cheap products in small sizes, I prefer to buy things that will work and have displays big enough that I can read the text or easily view a digital camera image without scrolling. Enjoy the dead pixels, large dot pitch, and poor color dithering of your $50 LCD you got there buddy.

A quick example. DVD players when they first came out cost like $500. Now you can get one that has just as good of quality for less than $100. My question is: why doesn't this drop in prices happen with LCDs?

I don't know. They must frown up people buying LCDs by themselves. Like I said in my original post, I just bought a new Dell computer with a 19" widescreen LCD included. It's just more cheaper that way. By buying the LCD separately, you're pretty much paying half the cost of a computer.

Consider a piece of steak. How come steak doesn't drop to like 5 cents? Cows have been around forever! You'd think that since farmers can produce a billion cows in a year these days, steak would be dirt cheap. Yet, a decent 8oz cut still goes for 7-8 bucks.

An LCD isn't a piece of steak, but perhaps the manufacturing process of an LCD just can't get any cheaper than it already is. Just like raising a good cow still requires you to feed it something other than a blade of grass per day, which costs money. That is, until the day they can produce a Dragon Ball Z capsule thing that costs a penny to produce and provides the nutrition of a grass field the size of New Zealand and can sustain the cow for 5 yrs. Most of us on Neowin will probably not be around when that day comes. lol This was probably the dumbest analogy ever.

  steelcurtain said:

Those are not $50-60. People always encourage me to wait until LCDs do become that cheap but I can only wait for so long. All this waiting is driving me nuts so I just bought a new computer. I need a new computer anyway. Can you believe my current computer only has 256mb of RAM? Talk about ancient.

  xraffle said:
I don't know. They must frown up people buying LCDs by themselves. Like I said in my original post, I just bought a new Dell computer with a 19" widescreen LCD included. It's just more cheaper that way. By buying the LCD separately, you're pretty much paying half the cost of a computer.

Thats because

A) The hardware inside of the computer isn't the highest of quality... probably most aspects are integrated into the motherboard, which save Dell money

B) Since dell wants to sell computers, often people buying lower end Dells will want the whole package, so Dell gets the monitor at wholesale and don't mark it up by much if at all, just so they can sell a whole computer as a package and still make their money on the computer itself.

Lets say the same monitor Dell includes is 100$ from the manufacturers. Dell may only value the monitor component at 100$ as part of the package, and not make any profit on that particular part but it helps them sell the rest of the computer since its a package and thats where they make their profit.

Now Best Buy may also pay 100$ for this exact model of monitor, but they will charge 180$ (guesstimate) because thats the only thing they are selling so they need to make their profit.

It's sort of like the same idea as door crasher sales at stores. They sell mass quantities of certain special items at a loss (making no profit or even costing them a little bit) then tons of people go to the store for this item. Many of these people are now in the store and will shop around. They may buy some food or whatever else. That will make the company the money, even if they take a small loss on 1 particular item.

  Abhishek Kapoor said:
like now a days DDR2 RAM is cheaper than DDR1 so on same note why not LCD cheaper than CRT

DDR2 is more common but there is still a demand for DDR1 by those people who have computer that cannot use DDR2, so it isn't as mass produced and usually stuff that is produced less of is more expensive. As for LCDs and CRTs, well even older computers can use LCD monitors, so its not like people have computers that can only use CRTs (well maybe people on win95 or something but thats another question!).

LCD's are not expensive in my opinion. You can pick up a 19" LCD monitor for less than ?100 - and I think that's really good value.

CRT's are REALLY cheap because the technology is redundant. Nobody in their right mind should buy one.

LCDs are very cheap right now (I picked up a Dell 22" for $220 last month), the only reason CRTs got so cheap is because it's a dead technology, at one point LCDs will be like that too....but it will take a long time

  dragon2611 said:
and here was me looking at LCD's the other day and thinking How cheap they'd become.

I was thinking the same thing

  xraffle said:
Those are not $50-60. People always encourage me to wait until LCDs do become that cheap but I can only wait for so long. All this waiting is driving me nuts so I just bought a new computer. I need a new computer anyway. Can you believe my current computer only has 256mb of RAM? Talk about ancient.

No, they aren't $50-60, and would you really want a LCD so cheaply? I know DVD players are cheap, but I still don't think they have all of the connections of slighty more expensive ones, but I could be wrong. Staples had a 22 inch at $200 within the last month. I consider that almost dirt cheap.

  steelcurtain said:
I know DVD players are cheap, but I still don't think they have all of the connections of slighty more expensive ones, but I could be wrong.

My 8 year old DVD player that I bought for $300 at the time is not as good as current ones. It doesn't have any component or HDMI outputs and doesn't read any writable discs. Last year, I bought one for $75 and it has better picture, upconverts to 1080p, has both component and HDMI outputs, and reads discs of all formats. It's way better than the $300 one I paid for long time ago. I was expecting something like this to happen to LCDs, but it looks like it ain't going to happen.

  Marty2003 said:
To the OP, If you're looking for really cheap new technology, now is probably the right time to jump on the HD DVD bandwagon ;)

What's the point on getting HD DVDs if Blu-ray was the one that won. All new movies will be released on Blu-ray, not HD-DVD. Even though it's cheap, it would be a complete waste of money.

  xraffle said:
I understand that. But as time goes, usually the price of technology decreases. What's going on with LCDs?
Jeez, patience. LCD displays in such large quantities are still pretty new technology. Wait about 10 more years.
  Marty2003 said:
Maybe it's just me, but I don't remember CRT's ever being that cheap except if they were used. Besides, quality CRT monitors, widescreen CRT's and CRT's larger than 17" were always relatively expensive. You can get a 19" widescreen LCD for $170, you would never find a widescreen 19" CRT for that cheap.
I remember 14" CRTs being standard, with 15" as the "upgrade". 17" units were prohibitively expensive! I'm talking $300 for the 15" CRT, and $900 for the 17 inch models.

Kids these days who only started computing with Win9x have no sense of computing history, sometimes. At least you recall the expensive truths of the not-so-distant past. ;)

  markjensen said:
Jeez, patience. LCD displays in such large quantities are still pretty new technology. Wait about 10 more years.

I bought my current computer 7 years ago. I wanted to buy it with an LCD at the time, but didn't because they were just so expensive. Now, 7 years later, when my computer becomes ancient, the LCD prices are still sky high. And I know that when I was looking into a new computer 7 years ago, LCDs have been out for a few years already. So, how many decades do you expect me to wait? DVD players never took this long to drop in price.

  xraffle said:
I bought my current computer 7 years ago. I wanted to buy it with an LCD at the time, but didn't because they were just so expensive. Now, 7 years later, when my computer becomes ancient, the LCD prices are still sky high. And I know that when I was looking into a new computer 7 years ago, LCDs have been out for a few years already. So, how many decades do you expect me to wait? DVD players never took this long to drop in price.

My post clearly states "10 more years". That is precicely, to the day, how long you have to wait. :rolleyes:

This microwave mentality of "need it now" annoys me.

The serious answer is that you must wait for suppliers to out-produce demand. The 'per piece' price of items drops in proportion to the number produced. And technology improves, giving better yield and less scrap costs to manufacturers. Add in any new advances, and the factories producing older tech will need to pretty much give their product away at cost or just close.

And all of these things, grasshopper, take time, like water wearing away at the stone.

This topic is now closed to further replies.
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Posts

    • Yeah, I don't have RGB on my WHOLE case. Shouldn't hurt the performance.
    • There's a question mark for those that only want RGB.
    • Review: LincPlus enters the traditional NAS space with the 6-bay LincStation S1 by Steven Parker I have reviewed a couple of NAS units for LincPlus, the LincStation N1 and N2, which can only take SSDs (2.5-inch and NVMe. Now LincPlus is back with a more traditional 6-bay NAS that takes four HDDs and two NVMe. Yes, they call this a 6-bay NAS, probably because there is no limitation on how you can use the NVMe slots. The LincStation S1 started life on Kickstarter, but is now available for purchase on the official website. The specs of it are below: LincPlus LincStation S1 CPU: Intel Alder Lake-N N97, 4 cores 4 threads, up to 3.6 GHz TDP 12W Graphics: Intel UHD Graphics 24 EUs Memory: 8 GB LPDDR5 3200MT/s (replaceable) Disk Capacity: 112 TB (4x 24 TB SATA, 2x 8 TB NVMe) RAID Level RAID0, RAID1, RAID10, RAID5, RAID6 Network: 2x RJ-45 2.5 GbE (10/100/1000/2.5 GbE) Internal storage: 1x 128 GB eMMC (USB boot drive) 4x SATA 3.0 2x 2280 NVMe USB Ports (Front) 1x USB 3.2 Gen 2 Type-A (10 Gbps) 1x USB 3.2 Gen 2 Type-C (10 Gbps) USB Ports (Rear) 1x USB 3.2 Gen 2 Type-A (10 Gbps) 1x USB 3.2 Gen 2 Type-C (10 Gbps) 2x USB 2.0 Type-A HDMI 1x (HDMI 2.0) Hardware Transcoding: H.264, H.265, MPEG-4, VC-1 Maximum resolution: 4K (4096 x 2160); Maximum FPS: 60 LED: Light strip (right side) Size (H/W/D): 231x195x156mm Weight: 2.9kg Power: 20V 7A DC (External PSU) Price: $599.99 As you can see from the specs, this is no slouch; it comes with an Intel N97, which was introduced in Q1 of 2023. This means that it now supports AV1 decoding, it can also decode H.264, VP8, VP9, H.265 (8 bit), and H.265 (10 bit). Processor E-cores L3-cache Turbo clock GPU GPU-clock TDP Intel N355 8 6 MB 3.9 GHz 32 EUs 1.35 GHz 9-15 W Intel Core i3-N305 3.8 GHz 1.25 GHz Intel N350 3.9 GHz 1.35 GHz 7 W Intel Core i3-N300 3.8 GHz 1.25 GHz Intel N250 4 3.8 GHz 1.25 GHz 6 W Intel Processor N200 3.7 GHz 0.75 GHz Intel N150 3.6 GHz 24 EUs 1 GHz Intel N97 1.2 GHz 12 W Intel Processor N100 3.4 GHz 0.75 GHz 6 W The CPU is part of the Alder Lake offering and sits just above Intel's entry-level mobile processor, albeit with an impressive TDP for the features it offers. As before, we are seeing another NAS with an acceptable, if not great, amount of RAM. As a reminder, up until a couple of years ago, it was commonplace to only get 2 or 4GB max on a flagship Synology or QNAP home NAS. Ever since the likes of TerraMaster and more have entered the market with ample RAM sizes included in their NAS offerings, it has gone a long way in forcing the hands of the traditional makers to up their game a bit. First impressions The S1 (as I will be calling it) came in a big cardboard box that protected the inner cardboard box with the fancy decals. In the box LincPlus LincStation S1 Power adapter User Manual [full online guide] Unraid Starter License Card Accessories Pack (10x Screws, 1x Screwdriver and 8xHDD tray labels) Design It actually looks good. The S1 is made up of metal and plastic and is quite heavy at 2.9kg (without HDDs installed). The design looks more like something you'd proudly show off in an office rather than hiding it in a meter cabinet or storage room. In addition, each side, along with the top and bottom, serves a purpose that I will get into in more detail later. There is also a light strip on the side that is set to orange. There is no instruction in the booklet or online documentation on how this this can be changed, but from previous experience with the N1, and N2 I tried pointing to tower.local:50000 in a browser and I did get the light strip configuration page (which is in Chinese, but I auto-translated to English), however changing any of these options did not result in the light strip changing mode, brightness, or color. I have reported this to my contact at LincPlus and was told that the page does not configure the light strip on the side. This page is still public, so it does not require login credentials to configure the LED control test. On the front, and the left of the unit from top to bottom, there is a 1.77 inch touchscreen, LED indicators for network status, 4x HDD and 2x SSDs, below that there is a plastic cover that can be opened to the right to reveal the USB 3.2 Gen 2 Type C and Type A ports, and then under that is the Power Button. Around the back, from left to right, there is a barrel port, two 2.5 GbE ports, an HDMI 2.0 port, a USB 3.2 Type C (10Gbps) port, two USB 2.0 ports and a Type A USB 3.2 10Gbps port. Above that, there is a 3-stage toggle switch for LED lighting (Upper position—the front light is on, Center position—all lights are off, Lower position—the side LED strip is on). Finally, the other toggle switch controls whether the front touch-screen is on or off. There's still no Kensington Security Slot present, which is a bit of a shame, considering it's a data storage device. Left side Right side On the left side, you have the magnetic cover, which, when removed, reveals the NVMe heatsink, single SODIMM memory slot, USB flash drive, and battery (see image below). On the right, there is another array of LED indicators that does the same thing as the front one. NVMe slots USB Flash drive Upon removing the heatsink, which is kept in place by a pull spring clip system, you can find the two NVMe slots. One thing I like about these slots is that they do not use a screw or bolt to hold the drives in place. It is a pull spring clip system. So you pull the clip to the side, add the drive and let go, which clamps it into place. However, this system only works for 2280 lengths. TEAMGROUP supplied us with the MP44Q 4TB NVMe SSD that I am using here, my colleague, Chris White gifted me the 250 GB 970 Evo Plus many moons ago when he shipped me the Synology DS720+ that he reviewed for Neowin back in 2020! The USB Flash drive can be accessed rather easily, but it is real fiddly to put back in! Populating the LincStation S1 As can be seen above, this is a top-loading system of four HDDs. The sleds are toolless. The sled itself is quite innovative. On the right side, you can "pull out" the plastic side housing that clips the HDD into the sled. The second image shows how much it can be pulled to the side, just enough for the two plastic protrusions that double for screws to shift out of the way (you can see these in the third image, and what is on the left side of the HDD sled). Once you place the HDD at a 45-degree angle to the left, press down and then clip it in from the right, and it is secured. That's all there is to it! Touchscreen The touchscreen on the front of the S1 can show four different pieces of information: Product info and serial number, the system status, storage summary of all six bays, and the network status by swiping left or right on the screen. Documentation The documentation booklet's 30 pages in English, German, or French, included in the box, is quite clear on how to populate the S1, with instructions on how to activate the Unraid Basic key (with the activation code card that is included), along with how to set up a disk array and basic getting started tips. Setup BIOS The Aptio BIOS can also be accessed during boot on the S1 by mashing the DEL key. One thing to note, however, on booting, you only have a few seconds to change the boot options, for the choice to run Memtest86+, or other Unraid-related boot options. If you're too slow, then the S1 will boot to Unraid, which is the default choice. Initial Setup After pointing your web browser to http://tower.local/you are required to set a password for root. The LincStation S1 comes preinstalled with Unraid on the internal flash disk, so all you need to do is set your user account and set up a disk array. Unraid defaults to a RAID5-style array, which is perfectly fine for our use. The BASIC (or trial) license of Unraid supports up to six storage devices, which can make things a bit difficult when wanting to transfer data from an external disk to a fully populated array. A Plus license costs $59, so you would have to decide if that's worth the extra expense. The main dashboard of Unraid After logging in, you are presented with the main dashboard of Unraid, which was on version 6.12.10. I was offered to update to 7.1.4 and after checking the release notes and known issues before upgrading, and aside from ZFS storage pools not being downgradable back to 6.x (once migrated) it seemed like a painless update. For my testing, I assigned two 6TB HDDs to the array, along with the 250GB SSD for a cache device. After troubleshooting the inability to access the SMB shares, I was finally able to access the share I created on my LAN by typing \\TOWER\public in File Explorer, which enabled its visibility by clicking within Network to TOWER. The internal array check (of two disks) reported an average speed of 296 MB/sec, which is pretty decent for traditional HDDs. The OS is written to the internal flash drive, but in order to install apps, an array must be present since the /appdata/ folder is saved on the disk array. I ran a CrystalDiskMark test on a mapped network drive from within a Windows 11 24H2 PC connected over a 10 GbE hub (S1 is limited to 2.5 GbE), and as you can see, the HDD array is performing well within expected speeds. Heat As far as heat goes, the large 140mm fan is doing its work, even during and after building the array, the HDDs reported a max temp of 43C, and as I am writing now with the S1 in idle state it is reporting a max HDD temp of 38C. Unraid comes with a community app store that contains tens of thousands of apps. In some cases, there are multiple flavors of the same app, such as Plex, so do look out for the OFFICIAL stamped in the top right corner of the app to be sure you are installing the intended version, or maybe you prefer a different take on the app, it's up to you! I installed Plex, and all I had to do was assign a temp directory for Plex Transcode and add a path for my media. After copying some media files over and accessing the new Plex server from my Google TV, I could start streaming immediately. Conclusion The ups Things I like about the S1 include the newer and more efficient Alder Lake CPU, with support for AV1 decoding and dual 2.5 GbE connectivity. You are also not locked into Unraid. If you want, you can remove the eMMC flash drive, located in the left NVMe bay, and flash it with something else, like TrueNAS, Xpenology, or some other NAS OS. However, be warned that Unraid (once activated) locks to the GUID of the eMMC flash drive, so it's best to ensure you have a backup image of the flash drive's contents, and be careful not to misplace it should you opt to replace it with a different flash drive. The downs While the build is really good compared to, say, the 2023 released TerraMaster F4-423, which is a mostly plastic exterior, the S1 is still $100 more expensive with a slightly better CPU. Is it worth it? Depending on your use case, this is still a good NAS that is not locked into an OS or even the hardware that you may populate it with. If you are looking to get up and going quickly, then this ticks the boxes; however, I do question why this more expensive model went with 2.5 GbE when the cheaper (all SSD) LincStation N2 has 10 GbE. There is also a lot of community support regarding the apps you can install in Unraid on the LincStation S1, so you won't have to look far and wide to get yourself up and running. So it ain't all bad. I'd argue that this is still great value for money. Purchase options As of writing, you can get this for $559.99, which is $40 off its slightly higher MSRP pricing of $599.99. You can save an additional 5% off when you enter the coupon code NEOWIN during checkout. It is not yet available on the official LincPlus Amazon page. According to the User Manual, the LincStation S1 has a domestic warranty period of 12 months (from the date of purchase), which is not extendable and covers the basics such as build workmanship and breakdowns during normal use. As an Amazon Associat,e we earn from qualifying purchases.
    • How does having no RBG a Con? That should automatically be a Pro
  • Recent Achievements

    • Dedicated
      John Volks earned a badge
      Dedicated
    • One Month Later
      KenKay earned a badge
      One Month Later
    • Week One Done
      KenKay earned a badge
      Week One Done
    • Dedicated
      Amadou earned a badge
      Dedicated
    • One Month Later
      TheRingmaster earned a badge
      One Month Later
  • Popular Contributors

    1. 1
      +primortal
      642
    2. 2
      ATLien_0
      244
    3. 3
      Xenon
      178
    4. 4
      neufuse
      154
    5. 5
      +FloatingFatMan
      123
  • Tell a friend

    Love Neowin? Tell a friend!