[Official] Anime/Manga Thread


Recommended Posts

Do you still enjoy watching anime? It seems that when weight out, there's more negative then positive points coming from you about anime.

Now I don't mean this to call you out on anything. I'm just merely interested for the answer to this question :)

I don't think I can say I enjoy watching anime that was released in the past 2-3 years that much. It's not "me growing up" that makes me dislike most of the anime. Watching just ~250 shows and realizing how many plot devices and cliches are used makes me a dull, negative reviewer. The anime in the past two years have been rehashes of 80s or 90s anime and the sci-fi genre isn't that interesting because most of them are crazy shows like TTGL and Code Geass. I can name the number of anime series I actually enjoyed watching that were released in the past two years (Nodame Cantabile, Spice and Wolf and Ponyo just to name a few). For the past year, I've been reading more manga than watching anime and some are actually thoroughly enjoyable. There were amazing series and movies that were nothing spectacular story wise, like Summer Wars and Darker than Black. 2008 till now features amazing animation techniques that were eye candy. Too bad, I can't say the same for the stories and narration of most of them.

TL;DR: I love the anime and manga art genres. Most of the anime in the past 3 years? Not so much.

By the way, don't you think the fights in FMA:B are getting a bit too tiring and absurd? The manga so far spent the last six volumes on random fights from the mountains to Central HQ and throwing in some random transmutation circle conspiracy theories just for fun. I really wish the mangaka didn't send Ed and Al North. The manga was a 9-10/10 until that arc.

Where is FMA?

What? Fullmetal Alchemist.

Where? MangaTraders for the manga or interwebs for episodes.

Why? It's a decent shounen series with some Seinen sub plots in a cool fantasy world with art that breaks from the typical lanky, metrosexual male lead and a whiny, squirrel type female lead.

How? Read or watch it.

:rofl:

^It kinda comes over as if watching anime become a job for you, instead of watching series to have a good time while watching them.

No, I'm not getting tired of the fights in FMA:B and I'm also don't think that they're absurd. They all belong and fit well into the story. Just like those "random" transmutation circles which aren't just for fun. Why do you wish that Ed and Al didn't head up north?

Of course plots and certainly cliches will often looks similar. You don't only see this anime or manga's but also in cartoons, comics, books, films, real live series, etc, etc. There's no way around that fact.

^It kinda comes over as if watching anime become a job for you, instead of watching series to have a good time while watching them.

No, I'm not getting tired of the fights in FMA:B and I'm also don't think that they're absurd. They all belong and fit well into the story. Just like those "random" transmutation circles which aren't just for fun. Why do you wish that Ed and Al didn't head up north?

Of course plots and certainly cliches will often looks similar. You don't only see this anime or manga's but also in cartoons, comics, books, films, real live series, etc, etc. There's no way around that fact.

I don't see it as a job. If it was one, I would be spending 8 hours a day on it, analyzing anime series in alphabetical order while creating a anime wiki similar to TVTropes.

Did you not get slightly irked when all the former enemies of Ed start collaborating like one big, happy family? I mean seriously. The guy, whose race was almost entirely wiped out by State Alchemists, is now playing tea cup parties with Ed and the Flame Alchemist. Nothing got to me more when Ed was in the north and they were greeted by Sloth and somehow all the best alchemists of the State were completely blind to the fact that someone was digging a tunnel around an entire country! The whole thing capped off the absurdity when Ed's dad is revealed as a slave who was controlled by an evil gas and all of a sudden two doubles appear! Where did fair trade go in that situation?! He then turns to Jesus and the whole scene where he walks on water with alchemy while approaching Pride made me wonder whether the mangaka started to seriously get into Christianity and Abraham symbolism even though she illustrates Ed as being a strong atheist.

However, my criticisms are only about these arcs. The others were magnificent and kept me riveted.

I don't see it as a job. If it was one, I would be spending 8 hours a day on it, analyzing anime series in alphabetical order while creating a anime wiki similar to TVTropes.

Did you not get slightly irked when all the former enemies of Ed start collaborating like one big, happy family? I mean seriously. The guy, whose race was almost entirely wiped out by State Alchemists, is now playing tea cup parties with Ed and the Flame Alchemist. Nothing got to me more when Ed was in the north and they were greeted by Sloth and somehow all the best alchemists of the State were completely blind to the fact that someone was digging a tunnel around an entire country! The whole thing capped off the absurdity when Ed's dad is revealed as a slave who was controlled by an evil gas and all of a sudden two doubles appear! Where did fair trade go in that situation?! He then turns to Jesus and the whole scene where he walks on water with alchemy while approaching Pride made me wonder whether the mangaka started to seriously get into Christianity and Abraham symbolism even though she illustrates Ed as being a strong atheist.

However, my criticisms are only about these arcs. The others were magnificent and kept me riveted.

See, that bit of text underneath the spoiler tags proves you don't understand the reason why they're working together. It's one of the key things during this whole anime which you don't understand :p Even the Homonculus don't understand it. Also, Ed and the rest couldn't have known about the tunnel at all if you ask me. Someone who's digging turns up so they should come to the conclusion about some huge tunnel?

The point about Hohenheim is kinda far fetched imo. You're reading to far into things, things which don't have a deep reason by behind it :p

See, that bit of text underneath the spoiler tags proves you don't understand the reason why they're working together. It's one of the key things during this whole anime which you don't understand :p Even the Homonculus don't understand it. Also, Ed and the rest couldn't have known about the tunnel at all if you ask me. Someone who's digging turns up so they should come to the conclusion about some huge tunnel?

Too far fetched IMO. Enemies coming together to fight an enemy. I do understand why they're butt buddies but it makes me question why such a story path was chosen instead. Maybe I was expecting the same mature tone FMA had in the beginning rather the tournament style fighting it's currently featuring with each Homonculus being one stronger than the other.

Too far fetched IMO. Enemies coming together to fight an enemy. I do understand why they're butt buddies but it makes me question why such a story path was chosen instead. Maybe I was expecting the same mature tone FMA had in the beginning rather the tournament style fighting it's currently featuring with each Homonculus being one stronger than the other.

Instead of what? There's no other storyline in this or whatever.

Anyways, I just wanted to know if you still enjoyed watching anime :p

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Posts

    • Guess it's one of those things best used by devs to thoroughly test stuff.
    • is it all upside down there? traffic lights reverted too?
    • Bluesky COO warns social media regulations could destroy competition from small startups by Paul Hill Fears that increasing government control of social media risks regulatory capture by the biggest social media firms were raised again recently. Bluesky’s chief operating officer said in an interview that social media bans for children and tighter regulations for social media firms risk creating a world where there are only a few social media platforms run by companies with the deepest pockets. Regulations on social media firms have been very lax since they appeared for mainstream users in the 2000’s. This gave Meta, Snapchat, and Google time to build up their user bases and get entrenched, with Meta being the most successful. Now that Meta has succeeded, it has been attempting regulatory capture. By pushing for more regulations of social media, Meta hopes to make it more difficult for rivals to challenge it. For its part, it doesn’t need to worry about the cost of regulation because it has a lot of money to spend, whereas startups do not. Speaking to CNBC, Rose Wang, Bluesky’s chief operating officer, said: “I support the protection and the safety of youth, the question that we have then is at what cost, because essentially what I’m scared of is in the long term, we’re headed to a world where there’s about three to five platforms, and extreme heavy regulation of those platforms, and basically the whole compliance teams of these platforms are 10 times the size of our entire team. So, basically, we’re living in a world where it’s almost impossible for smaller entrants to come in and build healthier spaces. These platforms have led to a place where the bottom line is the thing that drives what they do... so I understand why governments have to step in and regulate, because the platforms have done nothing right.” She said that while she is not against regulation, there needs to be more channels between the small to mid-sized players and regulators to help protect them. She says that big tech players, on the other hand, “who we know are circumventing regulation,” need to be regulated. Essentially, the Bluesky position is one of nuance, rather than absolutes. While Bluesky’s proposal may preserve competition in the social media space, it still doesn’t address the massive privacy implications these age verification measures introduce, such as handing over sensitive identity documents to access age-gated content. Source: CNBC
  • Recent Achievements

    • One Month Later
      DJC50PLUS earned a badge
      One Month Later
    • Week One Done
      DJC50PLUS earned a badge
      Week One Done
    • Proficient
      Eric Biran went up a rank
      Proficient
    • Dedicated
      Conjor earned a badge
      Dedicated
    • Week One Done
      Windows Guy earned a badge
      Week One Done
  • Popular Contributors

    1. 1
      +primortal
      493
    2. 2
      PsYcHoKiLLa
      249
    3. 3
      Steven P.
      71
    4. 4
      +Edouard
      70
    5. 5
      ATLien_0
      69
  • Tell a friend

    Love Neowin? Tell a friend!